Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you why the title ‘Prince of Wales’ is an historical insult to the Welsh and shouldn’t exist anymore

943 replies

Upthebracket22 · 10/09/2022 07:19

I am Welsh. I was enraged yesterday when the new king decided to ‘bestow’ the title on Prince William, an English Prince without asking the Welsh if they wanted another English Prince of Wales.

here is some historical context from a petition going around at the moment:

The "Prince of Wales" title (Welsh: Tywysog Cymru) is a title historically used by native, Welsh princes since the 14th century. The last native Prince of Wales was Llywelyn the Last, killed by English soldiers in 1282 and his head was then paraded through the streets of London and placed on a Tower of London spike. Llywelyn's brother Dafydd was the first person of note to be hung, drawn and quartered and his head was placed next to Llywelyn's. Both their daughters were taken as infants and children and imprisoned.

But this happened centuries ago you might say. The truth is, that since the days of Llywelyn the Last and the "rebel" Prince of Wales, Owain Glyndwr, the title has been held exclusively by Englishmen as a symbol of dominance over Wales. To this day, the English "Princes of Wales" have no genuine connection to our country.

The title remains an insult to Wales and is a symbol of historical oppression. The title also implies that Wales is still a principality, undermining Wales' status as a nation and a country. In addition, the title has absolutely no constitutional role for Wales, which is now a devolved country with a national Parliament.

As Welsh actor, Michael Sheen put it;

"Make a break there. Put some things that have been the wrongs of the past right. There's an opportunity to do that at that point. Don't necessarily just because of habit and without thinking just carry on that tradition that was started as a humiliation to our country. Why not change that as we come to this moment where things will inevitably change."

I don’t think many people have any concept of Welsh history. I find it offensive and think now would have been a good moment to right a historical wrong.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
herecomesthsun · 16/09/2022 16:29

Hang on, I'm denying nothing of a Welsh culture. But I am impressing upon you that Wales is NOT really different from the rest of the UK.

Those 2 statements don't hang together.

www.itv.com/news/wales/2022-09-16/crowd-heard-booing-as-king-charles-arrives-at-cardiff-castle

I think that a tactful approach that takes into account the spectrum of opinion - the boos as well as the cheers -would be very wise.

I actually think that this would be a very inopportune time to completely dismantle the monarchy as we have so much other uncertainty and some people find the Royals reassuring, but they need to handle this carefully and to listen to the concerns of Mark Drakeford and co. Who were, you know, elected.

DownNative · 16/09/2022 16:18

herecomesthsun · 16/09/2022 16:12

That's the thing - it's been ably demonstrated that the Windsors' ancestry is not predominantly Anglo-German. not the main point, but no it hasn't

Yes, it has which is why I posted the line if descent from Brian Boru to Queen Elizabeth II, for example. Did a partial ljne for her Scottish line too. These are very extensive lines and not small ones.

Showed the Welsh line.

It amounts to Windsor ancestry not being predominantly Anglo, but British. 🤔

herecomesthsun · 16/09/2022 16:12

That's the thing - it's been ably demonstrated that the Windsors' ancestry is not predominantly Anglo-German. not the main point, but no it hasn't

DownNative · 16/09/2022 14:08

herecomesthsun · 15/09/2022 22:58

Sheeeesh

yes predominantly Anglo German, "predominantly" means "mostly", allowing for other elements (surely I don't need to say that again ?)

no, someone doesn't have to have ALL the elements of nationality I suggested, just SOME of them, so not a binary choice. I set it out like that because William doesn't seem to meet ANY of the criteria I suggested very well, he lived there years ago, with no apparent plans to move back - and apparently learnt the national anthem parrot-fashion (nice that he did that but not the same as learning the language). But most fundamentally he hasn't even expressed that he wants to be regarded primarily as Welsh as far as I know? and it would seem a bit unreasonable to ascribe the nationality to him therefore.

Yes there is genuinely a Welsh culture as I've discussed. It is a bit mean hearted that you want to deny Wales its cultural distinctiveness in order to lumber it with some Royals from Berkshire.

That's the thing - it's been ably demonstrated that the Windsors' ancestry is not predominantly Anglo-German. Their Scottish ancestry both well established and significantly sizeable. So is their Irish ancestry. Add in a good chunk of Welsh.

You'd have been more accurate in saying they're predominantly of British-German ancestry, allowing for the varying degrees of Europe wide ancestry.

William began learning Welsh in 1999 at the behest of King Charles. It's thought he's not fluent in it which is the same as most of the 29% who can speak Welsh. Remember, a whopping 70% of people in Wales cannot speak Welsh. So, it's clearly not a part of some kind of criteria you've imagined.

Neither is living in Wales. I know someone who is Welsh and hasn't lived there for about 40 years. Again, this isn't a criteria.

Who's talking about ascribing Welsh to William? The point is he has good connections to Wales!

Hang on, I'm denying nothing of a Welsh culture. But I am impressing upon you that Wales is NOT really different from the rest of the UK. Moving from one part of the UK to another isn't a culture shock by any means. British culture is found in all parts of the UK. Wales has more commonality with the rest of the UK than it does differences.

Considering 70% of people in Wales don't speak any Welsh, are you counting books written in English by Welsh authors as Welsh culture? Or songs sung in English by Welsh singers? And so on. Those would be British culture. But you cannot possibly mean cultural things solely in Welsh since 70% of people in Wales don't have any Welsh skills. A good chunk of the 29% who have some Welsh skills aren't fluent enough for 100% Welsh cultural expressions.

Welsh is a minority language. Therefore, Wales mostly has the same culture as the rest of the UK. British.

Discovereads · 16/09/2022 13:27

cakeorwine · 15/09/2022 08:01

I’ve had my DNA done and it confirmed the family tree I’d built back to 13th century

So you have traced EVERY single relative up the family tree to the 13th century?

That's 2 ^ 21 grandparents - which is a massive number.

Not every single line, that would mean over 2 million people, and there are many theads that do not have records going back that far. My ancestry is also not nobility, and the further back you go the fewer records exist for peasants/serfs so I’ve really only found the lines through my “bastard” ancestors born on wrong side of the beds of nobility back that far. My tree currently has 2300 people in it.

Some notables in my family tree from 12-13th century include Ada Delen died 1220 Dumbarton. Gilbert Drummyn 1297 Kincardineshire, four generations of Malcom Drummonds : 1150, 1210, 1239, and 1295. A Roderick Drummond in 1181 all in Kincardineshire. Non Graham 1220, Kirkwall, Orkney. Lnu Maldwin 1150 Loch Lommond. Euphemia Ross, 1257 Tain, and Beatrix Stewart 1184 Forfar.

HairyToity · 16/09/2022 11:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

HairyToity · 16/09/2022 11:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Abhannmor · 16/09/2022 09:26

Interesting word Tywysog. Cognate with Taoiseach no doubt , which also means Leader.

William might be a good Taoiseach for all I know. Charles might be a good King. If there was an election he'd likely win it

I'm sure there's people who claim descent from the last High King of Ireland. Doubt I'd vote for him / her. But it's nice to have the option.

herecomesthsun · 16/09/2022 09:22

Big step = and much more controversial - to get rid of the monarchy, relatively simple to tweak the Tywysog thing.

jrt2022 · 16/09/2022 09:16

Well boohoo. The royal family is a symbol of oppression for everyone, English people included. We’re all stuck with them. Better to get rid of them altogether than fanny around trying to convince people they need to change their stupid meaningless titles.

Abhannmor · 16/09/2022 09:13

Discovereads · 12/09/2022 17:22

Well Russia is a republic…..just saying….we could end up with a British Putin, we would have if a warmonger like Enoch Powell could have ended up in charge.

13 minutes before someone bit 😂

LuluBlakey1 · 16/09/2022 08:23

LuluBlakey1 · 16/09/2022 08:23

Quite! It is still relatively unknown by many.

PS It's 'harrying' not 'harrowing'.

LuluBlakey1 · 16/09/2022 08:23

Legrandsophie · 10/09/2022 07:32

You think Cornwall had it bad, try being from Northumberland. Read up about ‘the harrowing of the north’.

Quite! It is still relatively unknown by many.

herecomesthsun · 16/09/2022 08:08

Yeah, I think it is a bit fluid, and that personal affiliation comes into it hugely. But I think the "Welsh leader" (Tywysog Cymru) should be someone who is clear that they identify as being Welsh, rather "British", which is not the same thing.

NotAScot · 16/09/2022 07:55

@herecomesthsun I was born in Scotland. I've lived and worked here for most of my life (apart from boarding school in England and a decade working in Germany). I consider myself English, I feel no attachment to Scottish traditions, culture, etc. It's very much the same for my kids too (boarding school in England), but now working in Scotland too.

Sports can reveal a lot. I always support England in cricket, rugby, football. The one exception being I'm a long time Rangers (and Everton) supporter. Looking forward to seeing Rangers-Liverpool, but we could not get tickets for the Anfield game :(

herecomesthsun · 15/09/2022 22:58

Sheeeesh

yes predominantly Anglo German, "predominantly" means "mostly", allowing for other elements (surely I don't need to say that again ?)

no, someone doesn't have to have ALL the elements of nationality I suggested, just SOME of them, so not a binary choice. I set it out like that because William doesn't seem to meet ANY of the criteria I suggested very well, he lived there years ago, with no apparent plans to move back - and apparently learnt the national anthem parrot-fashion (nice that he did that but not the same as learning the language). But most fundamentally he hasn't even expressed that he wants to be regarded primarily as Welsh as far as I know? and it would seem a bit unreasonable to ascribe the nationality to him therefore.

Yes there is genuinely a Welsh culture as I've discussed. It is a bit mean hearted that you want to deny Wales its cultural distinctiveness in order to lumber it with some Royals from Berkshire.

DonnaHadDee · 15/09/2022 18:27

Answer the question: How you objectively quantify the "major distortion" you refer to?

Consider the "long winded" comment a bit of external construction feedback, don't take it personally.

Consider the comment on Slavic alphabets a reminder to fact check. Again very constructive feedback.

DownNative · 15/09/2022 18:14

DonnaHadDee · 15/09/2022 16:39

You must be very sensitive. Asking how you objectively quantify the "major distortion" you quote is ignoring a valid question.

Is this you seriously attempting to claim or suggest that the Prima Nocta myth isn't a part of Scottish Nationalism?

As the bit you selectively quoted refers to that. Additionally, I see you didn't touch the other examples. Probably best not to.

Now, let's have no further Ad Hominem Fallacies from you....shall we?

DownNative · 15/09/2022 18:10

herecomesthsun · 15/09/2022 15:52

Actually, I've linked to the Royal family tree previously, so I would refer you back to that. It's pretty well understood that there is a very strong connection with European royalty, that is hardly a minority opinion. Much stronger than the Welsh component.

As I said before, there are a lot more points of contact with Scotland and England for the Royals than with Wales, a sizeable chunk of Welsh people are things #not my prince and that will be to do with having someone who doesn't live in Wales, isn't planning to live in Wales, doesn't speak the language etc. They seem like a very nice, very posh, very rich family based in the South of England which is lovely, but they don't seem to have much connection with Wales.

See also the definition of ethnicity. Shared culture. Don't see much evidence of it here, beyond that they might watch Strictly too? There is a Welsh language & literature & musical traditions etc.( They both like rugby I suppose.)

Also there is nothing wrong with the Guardian, it is one of the better UK papers.

On the 11/09/2022 06:58, you asserted:

"I have, they are still predominantly of Anglo German descent, I'm afraid. "Predominantly" means "mostly", you see."

Do you still stand by that?

It has been shown the House of Windsor has extensive Scottish and Irish ancestry as well as direct descent from ancient Welsh Royalty.

That alone puts a sizeable dent in your assertion that they have mostly English and German ancestry. Remember, George I, the first Hanoverian King of England, has direct ancestry straight from the Scottish King James VI. His mother was the granddaughter of the Unionist King who unified the Crowns of England and Scotland as well as ordering the creation of the first Union Jack.

This is the first thing to deal with.

The culture in Wales is not really different from that in the rest of the UK. There is genuinely a shared British culture across many areas from politics, sport, music, art and so on. You know, 70% of people in Wales do NOT speak Welsh.

In this line "that will be to do with having someone who doesn't live in Wales, isn't planning to live in Wales, doesn't speak the language etc", you seem to be saying a person has to be all of those things in order to be considered Welsh or part of the Welsh national ancestry. You've narrowed the range of possibilities to a binary choice which then leads to a False Dilemma Fallacy.

Prince William can speak Welsh to a degree - not many of the 29% of Welsh people who speak Welsh are fluent in it either so fluency cannot be a criteria. His wife also learnt Welsh. William and his wife did make their first family home in Wales too. They did live in Anglesey for a time as well. And they both have Welsh ancestry.

It appears you've decided to arbitrarily narrow the range of possibilities as mentioned above. It seems to fit your own bias here.

DonnaHadDee · 15/09/2022 16:39

You must be very sensitive. Asking how you objectively quantify the "major distortion" you quote is ignoring a valid question.

DownNative · 15/09/2022 16:28

DonnaHadDee · 15/09/2022 16:10

You write like an intern excited to get access to Wikipedia. I'd ask you how you objectively quantify the "major distortion" you quote, but I won't bother to read your long-winded reply.

I remember your post on alphabets used for Slavic languages ... a classic :)

So, you'd rather engage in Ad Hominem nonsense (personal attacks) instead debating any given specific point?

Well, everyone can see that and this suggests immaturity on your part in terms of debate. 🙄

DonnaHadDee · 15/09/2022 16:10

You write like an intern excited to get access to Wikipedia. I'd ask you how you objectively quantify the "major distortion" you quote, but I won't bother to read your long-winded reply.

I remember your post on alphabets used for Slavic languages ... a classic :)

herecomesthsun · 15/09/2022 15:54

justasking111 · 15/09/2022 15:19

We've got a fruit cake running plaid. Gordon Brown on speed dial with the senedd, no wonder folks are a bit uptight when they've a Scot pulling their strings

Now you see, that IS a little bit racist.

DownNative · 15/09/2022 15:53

DonnaHadDee · 15/09/2022 15:31

"Nationalism is based on a distortion of history" is your own point of view.

"and has been around a very short time in human history". So what? So has the welfare state , so has safe widely available contraception, antibiotics, etc. Some are good, some are bad.

Your posts are very funny to read. You might be my neighbour :)

On the contrary, it's not difficult to evidence how Nationalism distorts history for their own ends.

Consider Scotland and Braveheart, for example. A major distortion there centres around the idea that the English practiced Prima Nocta in Scotland. It's actually a myth, but has long been part of Scottish Nationalism.

Consider the 800 years of oppression with Irish Nationalism and Republicanism myth. Completely ignores the abuses of the people by Gaelic Lords, for example. Consider the distortion that most Irish people supported and 1916 rising in Dublin - they didn't.

In each case, the distortion is intended to spread a particular political ideology. In both cases, the English cast as enemies and opponents today. A major driver of PSF/PIRA murder was Anglophobia and historical distortions.

And so on.

So, you want to compare political ideologies with government policies?

Faulty Comparison Fallacy. Your error in logic. 🤔

herecomesthsun · 15/09/2022 15:53

thinking not things