Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you why the title ‘Prince of Wales’ is an historical insult to the Welsh and shouldn’t exist anymore

943 replies

Upthebracket22 · 10/09/2022 07:19

I am Welsh. I was enraged yesterday when the new king decided to ‘bestow’ the title on Prince William, an English Prince without asking the Welsh if they wanted another English Prince of Wales.

here is some historical context from a petition going around at the moment:

The "Prince of Wales" title (Welsh: Tywysog Cymru) is a title historically used by native, Welsh princes since the 14th century. The last native Prince of Wales was Llywelyn the Last, killed by English soldiers in 1282 and his head was then paraded through the streets of London and placed on a Tower of London spike. Llywelyn's brother Dafydd was the first person of note to be hung, drawn and quartered and his head was placed next to Llywelyn's. Both their daughters were taken as infants and children and imprisoned.

But this happened centuries ago you might say. The truth is, that since the days of Llywelyn the Last and the "rebel" Prince of Wales, Owain Glyndwr, the title has been held exclusively by Englishmen as a symbol of dominance over Wales. To this day, the English "Princes of Wales" have no genuine connection to our country.

The title remains an insult to Wales and is a symbol of historical oppression. The title also implies that Wales is still a principality, undermining Wales' status as a nation and a country. In addition, the title has absolutely no constitutional role for Wales, which is now a devolved country with a national Parliament.

As Welsh actor, Michael Sheen put it;

"Make a break there. Put some things that have been the wrongs of the past right. There's an opportunity to do that at that point. Don't necessarily just because of habit and without thinking just carry on that tradition that was started as a humiliation to our country. Why not change that as we come to this moment where things will inevitably change."

I don’t think many people have any concept of Welsh history. I find it offensive and think now would have been a good moment to right a historical wrong.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
DdraigGoch · 10/09/2022 23:06

Additionally, there's been no hereditary Princess of Wales due to Male Preference Primogeniture. Hence why Queen Elizabeth II was never Princess of Wales.

However, she changed this to Absolute Primogeniture ensuring there WILL be a hereditary Princess of Wales in the future.

The title of Prince of Wales - unlike that of Duke of Cornwall - is not heritable. As the appointment was never automatic, there's no reason that a past monarch couldn't have made a female heir presumptive Princess of Wales in her own right. Indeed, Welsh politicians suggested that the then Princess Elizabeth be made Princess of Wales for her 18th birthday, though George VI decided to stick with tradition. However Princess Mary, Eldest surviving daughter of Henry VIII and future Queen Mary I was given many of the roles and responsibilities of a Princess of Wales, and indeed was unofficially known by the title, so it wouldn't have been without precedent.

MotherOfCatBoy · 10/09/2022 23:05

consoc.org.uk/the-constitution-explained/the-uk-constitution/

this is a useful explainer on the advantages and disadvantages of an unwritten constitution and the dangers of convention.

Discovereads · 10/09/2022 22:48

MotherOfCatBoy · 10/09/2022 22:45

I wasn’t suggesting the monarch would attempt to overrule Parliament, but that our democracy in itself it not that robust, because at its heart we do not have a written constitution and so certain powers exist only by tradition.
In a truly mature society, all positions would be electable or mandated by a representative power (eg as certain positions are appointed by government).
As an aside, the monarchy do currently use influence to alter or exempt themselves from laws and regulations before they come to full parliamentary scrutiny. This is obviously not as extreme as dictatorships but why should it happen at all? On a continuum, we are not perfect as a template for how to run a state. I used extreme examples to illustrate the ridiculousness and illegitimacy of the hereditary principle of government.

? We have a written constitution, it’s just not codified into a single document.

“As an aside, the monarchy do currently use influence to alter or exempt themselves from laws and regulations before they come to full parliamentary scrutiny.” Nope, they are prohibited from doing so per the constitution.

MotherOfCatBoy · 10/09/2022 22:45

I wasn’t suggesting the monarch would attempt to overrule Parliament, but that our democracy in itself it not that robust, because at its heart we do not have a written constitution and so certain powers exist only by tradition.
In a truly mature society, all positions would be electable or mandated by a representative power (eg as certain positions are appointed by government).
As an aside, the monarchy do currently use influence to alter or exempt themselves from laws and regulations before they come to full parliamentary scrutiny. This is obviously not as extreme as dictatorships but why should it happen at all? On a continuum, we are not perfect as a template for how to run a state. I used extreme examples to illustrate the ridiculousness and illegitimacy of the hereditary principle of government.

DownNative · 10/09/2022 22:32

MotherOfCatBoy · 10/09/2022 22:17

i don’t care who they’re descended from. The point is, no one elected them. The whole damn lot have no democratic mandate whatsoever. I don’t care whether they’re descended from Owain Glydwr, Julius Ceasar or Big Bird. It doesn’t matter. What matters is democratic representation, whatever system that may be. None of them is perfect but as Churchill observed, it’s the worst system of government apart from all the others. I would like a non hereditary Head of State with a fixed term limit. Otherwise what’s the difference between us and Saddam Hussein and Gaddafi who both installed their sons, or Saudi Arabia and other Gulf States run by despots? Don’t say Parliamentary democracy because that’s hanging by a thread too and can be subverted by “good chaps” anytime they like.
Once again - this is not about whether you like any of the current lot or not. It’s about how they get there, what power (soft or hard) they have, their qualification for the role and the impact (economic and political) on the rest of the U.K.
If Llewellyn himself were resurrected, I’d tell him he’d rather missed his moment and perhaps he’d better get himself on a selection shortlist.

What a load of nonsense!

The difference between the UK and Saddam Hussein era Iraq or any country with a dictator is:

  1. The Monarch has no political power over the UK. Ever heard of the Abolition and Restoration of the Monarchy?

The Westminster Parliament is Supreme in UK politics. Not the House Of Windsor. All Monarchs since the establishment of Parliamentary Sovereignty and Supremacy know they can and will be removed should they encroach upon Parliament's power.

They haven't and so they are reliant on Parliament to stay on the throne. We are a representative democracy and governed by consent.

There will be ZERO subverting of Parliament by any British Monarch. The days of the Absolute Monarch was over with the Williamite Wars which stopped James II and Louis XIV trying to reestablish their right to rule as Absolute Monarchs as they saw it.

  1. Dictatorships such as Hitler, Gaddafi and Hussein are/were the sole power of their countries. They use military force, assassinations and murder to gain and sustain their power.

You became absurd by attempting suggest the UK is anything like the aforementioned Dictatorships!

The Democracy Index proves otherwise. 🙄

KimberleyClark · 10/09/2022 22:19

i don’t care who they’re descended from. The point is, no one elected them. The whole damn lot have no democratic mandate whatsoever.

who needs a democratic mandate when you have a divine right?

MotherOfCatBoy · 10/09/2022 22:17

i don’t care who they’re descended from. The point is, no one elected them. The whole damn lot have no democratic mandate whatsoever. I don’t care whether they’re descended from Owain Glydwr, Julius Ceasar or Big Bird. It doesn’t matter. What matters is democratic representation, whatever system that may be. None of them is perfect but as Churchill observed, it’s the worst system of government apart from all the others. I would like a non hereditary Head of State with a fixed term limit. Otherwise what’s the difference between us and Saddam Hussein and Gaddafi who both installed their sons, or Saudi Arabia and other Gulf States run by despots? Don’t say Parliamentary democracy because that’s hanging by a thread too and can be subverted by “good chaps” anytime they like.
Once again - this is not about whether you like any of the current lot or not. It’s about how they get there, what power (soft or hard) they have, their qualification for the role and the impact (economic and political) on the rest of the U.K.
If Llewellyn himself were resurrected, I’d tell him he’d rather missed his moment and perhaps he’d better get himself on a selection shortlist.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 10/09/2022 22:16

Yes, we are all sisters and brothers and cousins and like any family, rich and poor, good, bad, thick, thin, bright and dim. Some rise, some are given, some thrive some shrivel.

Bottomofthepileasusual · 10/09/2022 22:12

Upthebracket22 · 10/09/2022 07:24

@Swingsarefun wales is one of the poorest countries in Europe. We are in no way better off for being governed by Westminster thanks

Don't talk shit. Wales has a lower cost of living than a lot of places so salaries are ge really lower it does not make us poor.

CPL593H · 10/09/2022 22:01

I know I get boring on this subject, but it is virtually impossible to be of predominately Brit ancestry and not directly descended from Edward III in 21-14 generations. Virtually all American Presidents are. Barack Obama isn't, but is a direct descendent of Edward I (yes, him) on another line. The truth is that the population of the British Isles (not huge already by todays standards) was decimated by the Black Death. There just weren't that many people, they married each other in a few generations from the fall from being Royal, so we are all a bit Plantagenet. All descended from Charlemagne too, like everyone in Western Europe.

I fear we are worrying the bones of old wars. Disgraceful and appalling things were done in Ireland, Scotland and Wales but apart from a few Royal relatives 20 odd generations back, I'm not sure that has much to do with my dirt poor, oppressed by their poverty family. The sins and glories of our ancestors are not ours to bear or own. If Wales and Scotland want independence, I would understand and wish them well. In the meantime, we are where we are.

PaddleBoardingMomma · 10/09/2022 21:52

What a pathetic goady thread! I for one am thrilled he and Catherine are Prince and princess of Wales!

DownNative · 10/09/2022 21:47

Line of descent from Rhys ap Gruffydd to Elizabeth II:

Rhys ap Gruffydd —> Gwenllian —> Goronwy —> Tudur Hen —> Goronwy ap Tudur —> Tudur Fychan —> Maredudd ap Tudur —> Owen Tudor —> Edmund Tudor —> Henry VII of England —> Margaret Tudor —> James V of Scotland —> Mary, Queen of Scots —> James VI and I of Scotland and England —> Elizabeth of Bohemia —> Sophia of Hanover —> George I —> George II —> Frederick, Prince of Wales —> George III —> Edward, Duke of Kent and Strathearn —> Queen Victoria —> Edward VII —> George V —> George VI —> Queen Elizabeth II

Line of descent from Llywelyn the Great to Elizabeth II:

Llywelyn the Great —> Elen —> Hawise —> John Wake —> Margaret Wake —> Joan of Kent —> Thomas, 2nd Earl of Kent —> Alianore Holland —> Anne de Mortimer —> Richard, 3rd Duke of York —> Edward IV —> Elizabeth of York —> Margaret Tudor —> James V of Scotland —> Mary, Queen of Scots —> James I and VI of England and Scotland —> Elizabeth of Bohemia —> Sophia of Hanover —> George I —> George II —> Frederick, Prince of Wales —> George III —> Edward, Duke of Kent and Strathearn —> Queen Victoria —> Edward VII —> George V —> George VI —> Queen Elizabeth II

So, the Royal Family are also descended from Welsh Royalty.

Additionally, there's been no hereditary Princess of Wales due to Male Preference Primogeniture. Hence why Queen Elizabeth II was never Princess of Wales.

However, she changed this to Absolute Primogeniture ensuring there WILL be a hereditary Princess of Wales in the future.

DownNative · 10/09/2022 21:34

Queen Elizabeth II's Scottish line of descent:

Henry VIII's sister, Queen Margaret of Scotland, the grandmother of Mary Queen of Scots

Robert The Bruce

Robert II, King of Scots (her parents' common ancestor)

James VI of Scotland (I of England)

Elizabeth Of Bohemia, daughter of James VI and I

Sir John Lyon, Thane of Glamis

Swingsarefun · 10/09/2022 21:08

speakout · 10/09/2022 08:03

Lovely piece of victim blaming.

In what way are the modern day people if Wales victims for being part of the UK? I’m just baffled. They gets lots more funding than they raise in taxes - loads - because they are part of the UK, and yet it’s a terrible place to live and things would be better with independence apparently. Just think of the poverty ordinary Welsh people would face. Does independence put food in peoples mouths? Of course not! Do you care about those in poverty? Of course not! You just want to have your nasty little nationalistic whine.

and as for William being Prince of Wales, he’s part of the British royal family, and wales is part of Britain.

Discovereads · 10/09/2022 20:50

It is an indubitable fact that the Royal Family is predominantly of English & German descent. Rubbish. Look at the genealogy instead of reading hate

DownNative · 10/09/2022 20:45

herecomesthsun · 10/09/2022 20:15

Smile

It is an indubitable fact that the Royal Family is predominantly of English & German descent.

They of course have British nationality - of course they aren't "half British".

Regarding all the history, the Tudors as you remember had no direct heirs.

Looking it up, there appears to be a very distant link through Margaret Tudor, marrying into the Stewart lineage but the other link through "Nest" appears to be possibly mythical rather than historical and lost in the mists of time. It is all so tenuous that you can't blame the popular Welsh feeling for many people of being unconvinced that the Royals are enitiled to the Welsh Prince title. It is a bit of a fudge. Certainly my Nain was of this mind.

The Royals' links to Scotland are a good deal more convincing.

In the circumstances, if the Royals were that convinced that people in Wales want another royal Prince of Wales they could have got affirmation through a consultation couldn't they? Rather than pushing this through at a time of bereavement.

I think there is no harm in discussing the matter given the element of planning that presumably went into the timing.

They chose to do it like this.

I feel no hatred at all, we should do away with this fake title and get on with living peaceably and respectfully together like the actual and spiritual descendents of princes that we all are in Wales. Smile

And again that excludes their clear ancestral links to Scotland, Wales and the island of Ireland as a whole.

Additionally, their ancestry is European as they're related to all of Europe's Royal families.

George I, Elector Of Hanover, wasn't even fully German either as his mother Elizabeth of Bohemia, was the daughter of James VI - the King of Scotland who in 1603 became also James I of England - and his Danish wife, Anne.

James was the first styled British King of the United Kingdom. All Monarchs, thereafter, are all British Monarchs rather than Scottish or English.

Their Irish ancestry is quite extensive too.

Brian Boru is the ancestor of every English monarch from Henry IV (succ 1399) to the present day.

Elizabeth I descends from Thomas Butler, 7th Earl of Ormond and hence from John Fitzgerald, 1st Earl of Kildare.

Elizabeth II descends from, among others:

Brian Boru, High King of Ireland (died 1014).

Aoife Mac Murrough, Princess of Leinster, who married Strongbow in 1170.

James Butler, 1st Duke of Ormonde (died 1688).Descent: Through Bowes-Lyon and Lyon and Stanhope from Elizabeth Butler.Elizabeth II has other descents from earlier Earls of Ormond.

Donal Reagh MacMurrough-Kavanagh, King of Leinster (died 1476).Descent: Through James Butler, 1st Duke of Ormonde.Donal Reagh descends from Art Og MacMurrough-Kavanagh, King of Leinster (died 1417).

Gildas O'Reilly, Lord of East Breifne (1300s).Descent: Through James Butler, 1st Duke of Ormonde from Sir Richard Butler and his wife.

Dermod O'Brien, 5th Baron of Inchiquin (died 1624).Descent: Through through her mother and Wellesley and Hill and Boyle.Hence descends from, among others, Murrough O'Brien, the last King of Thomond (died 1551) and Connor O'Brien, King of Thomond (died 1540) and Conor "na Suidane" O'Brien, King of Thomond (died 1268) and Domnall Mor O'Brien, King of Thomond (died 1194).

Gerald Fitzgerald, 11th Earl of Kildare (died 1585).Descent: Through Inchiquin and Nugent.Hence descends from Garret Og Fitzgerald, 9th Earl of Kildare and Garret Mor Fitzgerald, 8th Earl of Kildare and Rowland FitzEustace, Baron Portlester.Elizabeth II has other descents from earlier Earls of Kildare.

James Fitzgerald, 10th Earl of Desmond (died 1529).Descent: Through 1st Duke of Ormonde from James Butler, 9th Earl of Ormond by his wife Joan Fitzgerald, daughter of 10th Earl of Desmond.Elizabeth II has other descents from earlier Earls of Desmond.

The rebel Hugh O'Neill, Earl of Tyrone (died 1616).Descent: Through Wellesley and Hill and Stafford and MacDonnell and Magennis.Hence descends from Brian O'Neill, last High King of Ireland (died 1260).

The rebel James FitzMaurice Fitzgerald (died 1579).Descent: Through Inchiquin and Fitzgerald.

As you can see, the Royal Family's ancestral heritage is much more complex than you give them credit for.

herecomesthsun · 10/09/2022 20:26

They chose the timing.

Valeriekat · 10/09/2022 20:22

This is not the time for this. If people were so concerned it could have been done before now since the King rarely used the title anyway.

herecomesthsun · 10/09/2022 20:15
Smile

It is an indubitable fact that the Royal Family is predominantly of English & German descent.

They of course have British nationality - of course they aren't "half British".

Regarding all the history, the Tudors as you remember had no direct heirs.

Looking it up, there appears to be a very distant link through Margaret Tudor, marrying into the Stewart lineage but the other link through "Nest" appears to be possibly mythical rather than historical and lost in the mists of time. It is all so tenuous that you can't blame the popular Welsh feeling for many people of being unconvinced that the Royals are enitiled to the Welsh Prince title. It is a bit of a fudge. Certainly my Nain was of this mind.

The Royals' links to Scotland are a good deal more convincing.

In the circumstances, if the Royals were that convinced that people in Wales want another royal Prince of Wales they could have got affirmation through a consultation couldn't they? Rather than pushing this through at a time of bereavement.

I think there is no harm in discussing the matter given the element of planning that presumably went into the timing.

They chose to do it like this.

I feel no hatred at all, we should do away with this fake title and get on with living peaceably and respectfully together like the actual and spiritual descendents of princes that we all are in Wales. Smile

justasking111 · 10/09/2022 19:52

We had a councillor who stated in a meeting this June past that people were talking about burning cottages again. He's a plonker par excellence for these type of statements. Same guy said how thrilled they were to welcome Ukrainian people to Wales. The hypocrisy is unbelievable

colouringindoors · 10/09/2022 19:28

Legrandsophie · 10/09/2022 07:31

YABU- you’ve cherry picked bits of Welsh history to suit yourself. The Llywelyn was prince of Gwynedd. He and his family subjugated the other kingdoms of Wales and very briefly United them into one country. Cornwall is a much older and better established kingdom than Wales and probably has more the moan about in terms of subjugation.

If we are talking about the conquest made by Edward the First then he was a Norman. The Norman line died out when the last Plantagenet heir died in the tower- Edward Earl of Warwick.

King Charles is a direct descendant of a Welsh man- Owen Tudor.

Nationalism is a divisive disease that can only lead to bigotry and ignorance.

Awesome

Porcupineintherough · 10/09/2022 19:15

Discovereads · 10/09/2022 18:20

They’re not German! Look at the family trees. George I (Hanover)was the great grandson of James I/IV. Albert Saxe-Coburgs father was the brother of Victoria I’s mother (they were first cousins). Two marriages within your family of your cousin who is descended from a British expat who married a German over 300yrs doesn’t ethnically make you ten generations later more German than British! FGS we have British people fully considered to be ethnically British because their great grandmother married a German refugee fleeing the Nazis only last century.

Scratch a nationalist, find a racist.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 10/09/2022 19:13
Biscuit
DownNative · 10/09/2022 19:12

Discovereads · 10/09/2022 17:34

Charles III not only can trace his Welsh ancestry back over 550yrs to Owain Tudor and 1,000 yrs to Gruffyd ap Llywelyn, the last Prince of Wales but he also studied Welsh language and history at University College of Wales in Aberystwyth. In addition, since 2007 he has lived there part of every year in Mydffai in a home he bought in Wales.

The Prince of Wales title was stolen from the Welsh princes by Edward I in 1283 when the Angevin Normans conquered Wales.

But a mere two hundred years later, Henry VII, grandson of the Welsh nobleman Owain Tudor, took the throne in 1485, and since then the title has been held by a royal of noble Welsh descent. Owain Tudor was descended from Rhys ap Tewdwr (Rhys ap Tudor Mawr), king of the Deheubarth in South Wales. In addition, Charles III is also descended from Princess Nest verch Gruffyd the daughter of Gruffyd ap Llywelyn, the last Prince of Wales via James I/IV (Stuarts of Scotland who are descended from her).

Female ancestors matter as much as male.

The royal family today has English, Welsh and Scottish ancestry plus various European ancestry from the usual dynastic matches that royals in Europe commonly made with each other. Even if we’re one to saying that Charles III is only “half British” because his father Phillip was nominally Greek and Danish isn’t the whole story because Prince Phillip was descended from our Queen Victoria! Making both Charles III’s mother AND father descended from Welsh royalty.

The new Princess of Wales is also descended from Llywelyn the Great and is also distantly related to her husband, William, Prince of Wales.

Naturally, their kids are too.

Some are intent on ignoring the House Of Windsor's very British ancestry and the fact Queen Elizabeth II was the most British of all sovereigns when she ascended.

Nationalism will always attempt to distort history and ancestral lines as it requires division of the people to dismantle the UK unitary state.

Swipe left for the next trending thread