Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you why the title ‘Prince of Wales’ is an historical insult to the Welsh and shouldn’t exist anymore

943 replies

Upthebracket22 · 10/09/2022 07:19

I am Welsh. I was enraged yesterday when the new king decided to ‘bestow’ the title on Prince William, an English Prince without asking the Welsh if they wanted another English Prince of Wales.

here is some historical context from a petition going around at the moment:

The "Prince of Wales" title (Welsh: Tywysog Cymru) is a title historically used by native, Welsh princes since the 14th century. The last native Prince of Wales was Llywelyn the Last, killed by English soldiers in 1282 and his head was then paraded through the streets of London and placed on a Tower of London spike. Llywelyn's brother Dafydd was the first person of note to be hung, drawn and quartered and his head was placed next to Llywelyn's. Both their daughters were taken as infants and children and imprisoned.

But this happened centuries ago you might say. The truth is, that since the days of Llywelyn the Last and the "rebel" Prince of Wales, Owain Glyndwr, the title has been held exclusively by Englishmen as a symbol of dominance over Wales. To this day, the English "Princes of Wales" have no genuine connection to our country.

The title remains an insult to Wales and is a symbol of historical oppression. The title also implies that Wales is still a principality, undermining Wales' status as a nation and a country. In addition, the title has absolutely no constitutional role for Wales, which is now a devolved country with a national Parliament.

As Welsh actor, Michael Sheen put it;

"Make a break there. Put some things that have been the wrongs of the past right. There's an opportunity to do that at that point. Don't necessarily just because of habit and without thinking just carry on that tradition that was started as a humiliation to our country. Why not change that as we come to this moment where things will inevitably change."

I don’t think many people have any concept of Welsh history. I find it offensive and think now would have been a good moment to right a historical wrong.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
DdraigGoch · 10/09/2022 23:50

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:47

Other systems are available.

Ireland for example

Or Sweden, or Norway, or Denmark, or the Netherlands...

Oh hang on, the countries Mumsnet envies the most are all constitutional monarchies. Maybe they're on to something.

Discovereads · 10/09/2022 23:49

@MotherOfCatBoy

“the proponents of a “written constitution” would support its being brought together in one document.”
You mean a “codified constitution” as that’s what a written constitution that is consolidated into a single document is called. We have a written constitution, it’s just not codified. And no, I am not a proponent of a codified constitution. A codified constitution becomes sacrosanct and frozen in time. It is unwieldy and almost impossible to change. The US can’t impose proper gun controls because their constitution is codified and it’s this too difficult to delete “right to bear arms” bit even though it’s 300yrs out of date. The US also can’t give women their right to an abortion, because their Constitution is codified to say “right to life” but nothing about a woman’s right to terminate life…..which has led to Roe v Wade being overturned and abortion being banned in half the country, and counting. So, no, I actually prefer written but not codified because it’s easier to evolve as a society with the times.

still fail to see what any hereditary position has to do with any office of State. We wouldn’t use it for any other position. Would you want your local Councillors to be hereditary? If not, why would you want your Head of State to be?
Meh, why not? We have positions in “the State” that are hired, appointed, or elected so why not a ceremonial figurehead position that is hereditary? I’m not convinced that a popularity contest (election) is the best way to fill every function of a State.

The Crown Estates belong to the monarch, but they are not any King or Queens private property nor do they “belong to the country” in the sense of public property. They are a third type of property. So any bill talking about landowners and so on has to have separate provisions stating what bits apply or do not apply and that requires specialist legal advisors.

DdraigGoch · 10/09/2022 23:47

travellinglighter · 10/09/2022 23:39

And that level of supercilious arrogance is why the young people of wales are mostly in favour of independence. Scotland will go, Ireland will unite and then those young people will grow up and you can kiss goodbye to Wales as well. We have a £13billion deficit which won’t be £13 billion when we don’t have to pay for trident, hs2, the Elizabeth line, parliamentary refurb etc. We pay our share and they are of no benefit to us.

Trident is of no benefit to you?

I should think that the last few months are an excellent demonstration of the value of having an independent nuclear deterrent.

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:47

DdraigGoch · 10/09/2022 23:44

Like the US?

No thanks.

Other systems are available.

Ireland for example

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:46

Being chosen by God has not been a literal feature since the Abolition and Restoration of the Monarchy

You did hear the proclamation today?

"o whom we do acknowledge all Faith and Obedience, with humble affection: beseeching God, by whom Kings and Queens do reign, to bless His Majesty with long and happy years to reign over Us."

DdraigGoch · 10/09/2022 23:44

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:37

This is getting very literal and pedantic. I know we have a lot of legal documents and Acts that together as read as something like a constitution. But the point is that it’s harder to make clear exactly what is meant by successive iterations and the proponents of a “written constitution” would support its being brought together in one document

I get a bit jealous of modern countries with a proper written single document, an elected Head of State and a modern voting system.

Like the US?

No thanks.

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:44

A Monarch who refuses Royal Assent risks provoking a Constitutional crisis. Essentially, George V found with his legal advice any withholding Royal Assent would change nothing

Is it written in the Constitution that the Monarch has to give assent?
What happens if they don't give assent?

Has it actually ever been tested?

Is this all written down somewhere with clear rules? If so, then there wouldn't be a Constitutional crisis, would there?

DownNative · 10/09/2022 23:43

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:39

Our Constitutional Monarchy a good compromise between an Absolute Monarch and continuing to have a Monarchy. Our Monarchy is a massive part of our global soft power. It makes us second only to the United States

Being chosen by God and having that pass down the family is not a modern way to run a country.

Two things:

  1. Being chosen by God has not been a literal feature since the Abolition and Restoration of the Monarchy.

  2. The Monarch does NOT run the country. The Westminster Parliament is Supreme and the devolved administrations have devolved responsibility whilst being subject to Westminster.

justasking111 · 10/09/2022 23:42

travellinglighter · 10/09/2022 23:39

And that level of supercilious arrogance is why the young people of wales are mostly in favour of independence. Scotland will go, Ireland will unite and then those young people will grow up and you can kiss goodbye to Wales as well. We have a £13billion deficit which won’t be £13 billion when we don’t have to pay for trident, hs2, the Elizabeth line, parliamentary refurb etc. We pay our share and they are of no benefit to us.

Your grasp of Welsh economics is tenuous

DownNative · 10/09/2022 23:40

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:34

Westminster is Supreme. Not the Monarch and no Monarch has refused Royal Assent since Mary, Queen of Scots

Interesting.

"In 1914, George V took legal advice on withholding royal assent from the Government of Ireland Bill; then highly contentious legislation that the Liberal government intended to push through Parliament by means of the Parliament Act 1911. He decided to not withhold assent without "convincing evidence that it would avert a national disaster, or at least have a tranquillising effect on the distracting conditions of the time".[28]"

So it's not a given that Royal Assent is automatically given.

Does it contradict my point?

Absolutely not.

A Monarch who refuses Royal Assent risks provoking a Constitutional crisis. Essentially, George V found with his legal advice any withholding Royal Assent would change nothing.

Certainly wouldn't have averted a national disaster or calmed tensions. This was the era of the divisive Home Rule Bill. That sane year, partition was included in the amendment.

travellinglighter · 10/09/2022 23:39

Swingsarefun · 10/09/2022 07:23

i don’t mean to be rude but you just sound like the worst of the Scottish nationalists we get around here. Yada yada yada. Get the chip off your shoulders. Stand up straight. Stop whining. You’re in the UK now. This is a good thing. They country is much richer for it, has more tools to alleviate poverty because of it. This doesn’t eradicate your Welsh history.

And that level of supercilious arrogance is why the young people of wales are mostly in favour of independence. Scotland will go, Ireland will unite and then those young people will grow up and you can kiss goodbye to Wales as well. We have a £13billion deficit which won’t be £13 billion when we don’t have to pay for trident, hs2, the Elizabeth line, parliamentary refurb etc. We pay our share and they are of no benefit to us.

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:39

Our Constitutional Monarchy a good compromise between an Absolute Monarch and continuing to have a Monarchy. Our Monarchy is a massive part of our global soft power. It makes us second only to the United States

Being chosen by God and having that pass down the family is not a modern way to run a country.

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:37

This is getting very literal and pedantic. I know we have a lot of legal documents and Acts that together as read as something like a constitution. But the point is that it’s harder to make clear exactly what is meant by successive iterations and the proponents of a “written constitution” would support its being brought together in one document

I get a bit jealous of modern countries with a proper written single document, an elected Head of State and a modern voting system.

justasking111 · 10/09/2022 23:37

MotherOfCatBoy · 10/09/2022 23:25

This is getting very literal and pedantic. I know we have a lot of legal documents and Acts that together as read as something like a constitution. But the point is that it’s harder to make clear exactly what is meant by successive iterations and the proponents of a “written constitution” would support its being brought together in one document.

As for what the monarchy can and can’t do (which isn’t crystal clear - please provide exact wording and sources) - if they’re so irrelevant, why do we need them at all? I still fail to see what any hereditary position has to do with any office of State. We wouldn’t use it for any other position. Would you want your local Councillors to be hereditary? If not, why would you want your Head of State to be?

(Lastly @Discovereads you’ve confused me about Crown land - when you say it’s neither public nor private, what is it? What does the Land Registry say? Who has rights to it and over it? Who collects revenue from it? Who benefits from it? It may be the State or it may be the private landowner in the form of a member of the Royal Family, but I want to know if it’s not public, nor private, what exactly is it? And why? As I understand it, Crown Estates actually belong to the country, but the Duchies and other private holdings are private.)

@MotherOfCatBoy Google is your friend re crown estate

DownNative · 10/09/2022 23:35

MotherOfCatBoy · 10/09/2022 23:25

This is getting very literal and pedantic. I know we have a lot of legal documents and Acts that together as read as something like a constitution. But the point is that it’s harder to make clear exactly what is meant by successive iterations and the proponents of a “written constitution” would support its being brought together in one document.

As for what the monarchy can and can’t do (which isn’t crystal clear - please provide exact wording and sources) - if they’re so irrelevant, why do we need them at all? I still fail to see what any hereditary position has to do with any office of State. We wouldn’t use it for any other position. Would you want your local Councillors to be hereditary? If not, why would you want your Head of State to be?

(Lastly @Discovereads you’ve confused me about Crown land - when you say it’s neither public nor private, what is it? What does the Land Registry say? Who has rights to it and over it? Who collects revenue from it? Who benefits from it? It may be the State or it may be the private landowner in the form of a member of the Royal Family, but I want to know if it’s not public, nor private, what exactly is it? And why? As I understand it, Crown Estates actually belong to the country, but the Duchies and other private holdings are private.)

Ah, I see you're Shifting The Goalposts now which is a logical fallacy!

@MotherOfCatBoy you previously stated "at its heart we do not have a written constitution and so certain powers exist only by tradition."

Now, you're trying to claim "I know we have a lot of legal documents and Acts that together as read as something like a constitution."

Contradictory.

Ours don't read as something like a constitution. They ARE a constitution!

The British Monarch has the same powers as the Irish President. Ceremonial and subject to their Parliaments which retains Supreme Authority in their respective jurisdictions.

Our Constitutional Monarchy a good compromise between an Absolute Monarch and continuing to have a Monarchy. Our Monarchy is a massive part of our global soft power. It makes us second only to the United States.

Absurd comparing a town council with a Head Of State! 🙄 Non-sequitur Fallacy.

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:34

Westminster is Supreme. Not the Monarch and no Monarch has refused Royal Assent since Mary, Queen of Scots

Interesting.

"In 1914, George V took legal advice on withholding royal assent from the Government of Ireland Bill; then highly contentious legislation that the Liberal government intended to push through Parliament by means of the Parliament Act 1911. He decided to not withhold assent without "convincing evidence that it would avert a national disaster, or at least have a tranquillising effect on the distracting conditions of the time".[28]"

So it's not a given that Royal Assent is automatically given.

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:31

DownNative · 10/09/2022 20:45

And again that excludes their clear ancestral links to Scotland, Wales and the island of Ireland as a whole.

Additionally, their ancestry is European as they're related to all of Europe's Royal families.

George I, Elector Of Hanover, wasn't even fully German either as his mother Elizabeth of Bohemia, was the daughter of James VI - the King of Scotland who in 1603 became also James I of England - and his Danish wife, Anne.

James was the first styled British King of the United Kingdom. All Monarchs, thereafter, are all British Monarchs rather than Scottish or English.

Their Irish ancestry is quite extensive too.

Brian Boru is the ancestor of every English monarch from Henry IV (succ 1399) to the present day.

Elizabeth I descends from Thomas Butler, 7th Earl of Ormond and hence from John Fitzgerald, 1st Earl of Kildare.

Elizabeth II descends from, among others:

Brian Boru, High King of Ireland (died 1014).

Aoife Mac Murrough, Princess of Leinster, who married Strongbow in 1170.

James Butler, 1st Duke of Ormonde (died 1688).Descent: Through Bowes-Lyon and Lyon and Stanhope from Elizabeth Butler.Elizabeth II has other descents from earlier Earls of Ormond.

Donal Reagh MacMurrough-Kavanagh, King of Leinster (died 1476).Descent: Through James Butler, 1st Duke of Ormonde.Donal Reagh descends from Art Og MacMurrough-Kavanagh, King of Leinster (died 1417).

Gildas O'Reilly, Lord of East Breifne (1300s).Descent: Through James Butler, 1st Duke of Ormonde from Sir Richard Butler and his wife.

Dermod O'Brien, 5th Baron of Inchiquin (died 1624).Descent: Through through her mother and Wellesley and Hill and Boyle.Hence descends from, among others, Murrough O'Brien, the last King of Thomond (died 1551) and Connor O'Brien, King of Thomond (died 1540) and Conor "na Suidane" O'Brien, King of Thomond (died 1268) and Domnall Mor O'Brien, King of Thomond (died 1194).

Gerald Fitzgerald, 11th Earl of Kildare (died 1585).Descent: Through Inchiquin and Nugent.Hence descends from Garret Og Fitzgerald, 9th Earl of Kildare and Garret Mor Fitzgerald, 8th Earl of Kildare and Rowland FitzEustace, Baron Portlester.Elizabeth II has other descents from earlier Earls of Kildare.

James Fitzgerald, 10th Earl of Desmond (died 1529).Descent: Through 1st Duke of Ormonde from James Butler, 9th Earl of Ormond by his wife Joan Fitzgerald, daughter of 10th Earl of Desmond.Elizabeth II has other descents from earlier Earls of Desmond.

The rebel Hugh O'Neill, Earl of Tyrone (died 1616).Descent: Through Wellesley and Hill and Stafford and MacDonnell and Magennis.Hence descends from Brian O'Neill, last High King of Ireland (died 1260).

The rebel James FitzMaurice Fitzgerald (died 1579).Descent: Through Inchiquin and Fitzgerald.

As you can see, the Royal Family's ancestral heritage is much more complex than you give them credit for.

You do realise that we ARE ALL related to each other if you go back far enough. Because people alive a long time ago have many many many ancestors alive today.

DownNative · 10/09/2022 23:27

Guardian? Pfft.

"The royal household can be consulted on bills in order to ensure the technical accuracy and consistency of the application of the bill to the crown, a complex legal principle governed by statute and common law. This process does not change the nature of any such bill."

Literally a formality.

Westminster is Supreme. Not the Monarch and no Monarch has refused Royal Assent since Mary, Queen of Scots.

MotherOfCatBoy · 10/09/2022 23:25

This is getting very literal and pedantic. I know we have a lot of legal documents and Acts that together as read as something like a constitution. But the point is that it’s harder to make clear exactly what is meant by successive iterations and the proponents of a “written constitution” would support its being brought together in one document.

As for what the monarchy can and can’t do (which isn’t crystal clear - please provide exact wording and sources) - if they’re so irrelevant, why do we need them at all? I still fail to see what any hereditary position has to do with any office of State. We wouldn’t use it for any other position. Would you want your local Councillors to be hereditary? If not, why would you want your Head of State to be?

(Lastly @Discovereads you’ve confused me about Crown land - when you say it’s neither public nor private, what is it? What does the Land Registry say? Who has rights to it and over it? Who collects revenue from it? Who benefits from it? It may be the State or it may be the private landowner in the form of a member of the Royal Family, but I want to know if it’s not public, nor private, what exactly is it? And why? As I understand it, Crown Estates actually belong to the country, but the Duchies and other private holdings are private.)

Discovereads · 10/09/2022 23:19

@DownNative
It's clear you don't understand much about the political history of the UK State or how we came to have a Constitutional Monarchy. That's why you make ridiculous comparisons with Dictatorships. 🙄

Yep. Spot on.

DownNative · 10/09/2022 23:17

MotherOfCatBoy · 10/09/2022 23:05

consoc.org.uk/the-constitution-explained/the-uk-constitution/

this is a useful explainer on the advantages and disadvantages of an unwritten constitution and the dangers of convention.

You have failed to understand your own link as it makes it very clear the UK does have a written constitution. It's in various sources listed in the link.

Ours is just uncodified which does NOT mean unwritten.

You're incorrect in thinking the UK operates by convention. Sure, convention plays a part, but we operate more from legislation and so on. Things are clearly set down in written form and we follow those.

Discovereads · 10/09/2022 23:15

MotherOfCatBoy · 10/09/2022 23:05

consoc.org.uk/the-constitution-explained/the-uk-constitution/

this is a useful explainer on the advantages and disadvantages of an unwritten constitution and the dangers of convention.

Yes, and if you read past the “It is often noted that the UK does not have a ‘written’ or ‘codified’ constitution.”

It goes on to explain that while we don’t have a constitution codified into a single legal document, it’s sources ARE in other WRITTEN legal documents…

“It is true that most countries have a document with special legal status that contains some of the key features of their constitution. This text is usually upheld by the courts and cannot be changed except through an especially demanding process. The UK, however, does not possess a single constitutional document of this nature. Nevertheless, it does have a constitution. The UK’s constitution is spread across a number of places. This dispersal can make it more difficult to identify and understand. It is found in places including some specific Acts of Parliament; particular understandings of how the system should operate (known as constitutional conventions); and various decisions made by judges that help determine how the system works.”

  • Acts of Parliament= WRITTEN
  • Case Law= WRITTEN
DownNative · 10/09/2022 23:11

MotherOfCatBoy · 10/09/2022 22:45

I wasn’t suggesting the monarch would attempt to overrule Parliament, but that our democracy in itself it not that robust, because at its heart we do not have a written constitution and so certain powers exist only by tradition.
In a truly mature society, all positions would be electable or mandated by a representative power (eg as certain positions are appointed by government).
As an aside, the monarchy do currently use influence to alter or exempt themselves from laws and regulations before they come to full parliamentary scrutiny. This is obviously not as extreme as dictatorships but why should it happen at all? On a continuum, we are not perfect as a template for how to run a state. I used extreme examples to illustrate the ridiculousness and illegitimacy of the hereditary principle of government.

Uh.....yes you WERE suggesting exactly that in this crackers part of your post @MotherOfCatBoy:

"Otherwise what’s the difference between us and Saddam Hussein and Gaddafi who both installed their sons, or Saudi Arabia and other Gulf States run by despots? Don’t say Parliamentary democracy because that’s hanging by a thread too and can be subverted by “good chaps” anytime they like."

The Royals are clearly in your "subverted by "good chaps" anytime they like" line and the UK State is stupidly compared to Dictatorships by you as well.

Your extreme examples simply undermines your attempted argument since it bears zero reflection on a Constitutional Monarchy or the British State.

The Monarchy is NOT a hereditary principle of government. It is only a hereditary principle of....the Monarchy's line of succession. Again, Parliament is Supreme and the Sovereign power. Not the Monarch.

The Williamite war against James II and Louis XIV settled that one.

Only the Monarch is exempt from laws and only because of Parliamentary Sovereignty, Representative Democracy and Government By Consent principles. All other Royals are subject to it.

You're incorrect in asserting that the UK doesn't have a written constitution. We, in fact, DO have a written document which is simply not all in one place.

We have an uncodified one, but it's literally written down. Acts Of Parliament, Devolution Settlement and the Northern Ireland Belfast Agreement are just some examples of the UK's written constitution.

To reemphasise, the UK has a written uncodified constitution. And written constitutions can also be perverted, so aren't the safeguard against tyranny like you think.

Mature societies come in various shapes. A Constitutional Monarchy is just one example and we're far from the only one too.

It's clear you don't understand much about the political history of the UK State or how we came to have a Constitutional Monarchy. That's why you make ridiculous comparisons with Dictatorships. 🙄

DdraigGoch · 10/09/2022 23:11

MotherOfCatBoy · 10/09/2022 22:17

i don’t care who they’re descended from. The point is, no one elected them. The whole damn lot have no democratic mandate whatsoever. I don’t care whether they’re descended from Owain Glydwr, Julius Ceasar or Big Bird. It doesn’t matter. What matters is democratic representation, whatever system that may be. None of them is perfect but as Churchill observed, it’s the worst system of government apart from all the others. I would like a non hereditary Head of State with a fixed term limit. Otherwise what’s the difference between us and Saddam Hussein and Gaddafi who both installed their sons, or Saudi Arabia and other Gulf States run by despots? Don’t say Parliamentary democracy because that’s hanging by a thread too and can be subverted by “good chaps” anytime they like.
Once again - this is not about whether you like any of the current lot or not. It’s about how they get there, what power (soft or hard) they have, their qualification for the role and the impact (economic and political) on the rest of the U.K.
If Llewellyn himself were resurrected, I’d tell him he’d rather missed his moment and perhaps he’d better get himself on a selection shortlist.

Just wait for Boaty McBoatface to be elected UK President...

Discovereads · 10/09/2022 23:10

Pffft. A lot of nasty speculation that is. The royal assent function can’t be used to change bills, or reject them if the ministers (Parliament) have passed them.

As far as a “secret back channel” speculation…the official stated ““The royal household can be consulted on bills in order to ensure the technical accuracy and consistency of the application of the bill to the crown, a complex legal principle governed by statute and common law. This process does not change the nature of any such bill.”

Which means they don’t change the bills other than to ensure they are accurate in terms of what they apply to. Much of the land that is Crown land is neither public land nor private land and so it’s not cut and dry which laws regarding property apply to crown land or not. That’s why the lawyers have to look at the constitution and case law, when a Bill comes through. But again, this isn’t the Queen or any RF member personally asking for tweaks or influencing things.