Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you why the title ‘Prince of Wales’ is an historical insult to the Welsh and shouldn’t exist anymore

943 replies

Upthebracket22 · 10/09/2022 07:19

I am Welsh. I was enraged yesterday when the new king decided to ‘bestow’ the title on Prince William, an English Prince without asking the Welsh if they wanted another English Prince of Wales.

here is some historical context from a petition going around at the moment:

The "Prince of Wales" title (Welsh: Tywysog Cymru) is a title historically used by native, Welsh princes since the 14th century. The last native Prince of Wales was Llywelyn the Last, killed by English soldiers in 1282 and his head was then paraded through the streets of London and placed on a Tower of London spike. Llywelyn's brother Dafydd was the first person of note to be hung, drawn and quartered and his head was placed next to Llywelyn's. Both their daughters were taken as infants and children and imprisoned.

But this happened centuries ago you might say. The truth is, that since the days of Llywelyn the Last and the "rebel" Prince of Wales, Owain Glyndwr, the title has been held exclusively by Englishmen as a symbol of dominance over Wales. To this day, the English "Princes of Wales" have no genuine connection to our country.

The title remains an insult to Wales and is a symbol of historical oppression. The title also implies that Wales is still a principality, undermining Wales' status as a nation and a country. In addition, the title has absolutely no constitutional role for Wales, which is now a devolved country with a national Parliament.

As Welsh actor, Michael Sheen put it;

"Make a break there. Put some things that have been the wrongs of the past right. There's an opportunity to do that at that point. Don't necessarily just because of habit and without thinking just carry on that tradition that was started as a humiliation to our country. Why not change that as we come to this moment where things will inevitably change."

I don’t think many people have any concept of Welsh history. I find it offensive and think now would have been a good moment to right a historical wrong.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Discovereads · 11/09/2022 00:26

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:12

Is saying that the first born child of the Monarch should be the Head of State of a country of 80 million people really the best we can come up with in the 21st Century?

William and young George have their future mapped out.

Best for us imho. Look at the government we’ve had the past decade and the harm they have done to the country, if anything that proves that elections (popularity contests) where politicians can lie with no consequence is not the best way to run a country. Having an elected head of state would just be more of that shit.

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:24

You keep ignoring that some of the most successful and democratic countries in Europe are monarchies

And some aren't. And are also successful and democratic.

And we would carry on fine without a Monarch.

DdraigGoch · 11/09/2022 00:18

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:15

Other than Greece, how well do you think those countries have done since

You seem to have missed out many countries in Europe that don't have a Monarch and are doing quite well.

Do you think we would not do well because we didn't have a Monarch? Where's your pride in Britain, the UK and its people?

You keep ignoring that some of the most successful and democratic countries in Europe are monarchies.

Where's my pride in Britain? I'm not the one who keeps saying that it needs to change.

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:18

DownNative · 11/09/2022 00:15

80 million?

Not the UK. 66 million.

Constitutional Monarchies work.

For some people.

Not for all.

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:17

DownNative · 11/09/2022 00:13

I see you're just blatantly ignoring your obvious bias in ignoring facts you must've read to pluck that out about George V. No problem as you lost credibility doing that.

A Monarch resigning? It's called Abdication which a certain Edward did to marry an American in 1936.

Parliament is Supreme and Sovereign.

So what would happen if a Monarch refused to sign a bill?

Would it become law or would they have to wait until a Monarch was appointed who would sign it?

What if no Monarch signed it?

DownNative · 11/09/2022 00:15

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:12

Is saying that the first born child of the Monarch should be the Head of State of a country of 80 million people really the best we can come up with in the 21st Century?

William and young George have their future mapped out.

80 million?

Not the UK. 66 million.

Constitutional Monarchies work.

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:15

Other than Greece, how well do you think those countries have done since

You seem to have missed out many countries in Europe that don't have a Monarch and are doing quite well.

Do you think we would not do well because we didn't have a Monarch? Where's your pride in Britain, the UK and its people?

DownNative · 11/09/2022 00:13

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:06

Wouldn't that be interesting...

If a Monarch did refuse to give assent, then they would be removed.

I do wonder if one would resign on principle. If they really didn't agree with it

I see you're just blatantly ignoring your obvious bias in ignoring facts you must've read to pluck that out about George V. No problem as you lost credibility doing that.

A Monarch resigning? It's called Abdication which a certain Edward did to marry an American in 1936.

Parliament is Supreme and Sovereign.

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:12

Discovereads · 11/09/2022 00:09

Sorry, but I can’t help but call ridiculous statements for what they are…

Well, technically “the past” also includes Athens and their pure democracy, and Rome and their republic thousands of years ago. Having a hereditary figurehead of state is no more “in the past” than having a republic. Is it progress to regress all the way back to something that we had two thousand years ago as part of the Roman Republican Empire?

Is saying that the first born child of the Monarch should be the Head of State of a country of 80 million people really the best we can come up with in the 21st Century?

William and young George have their future mapped out.

DdraigGoch · 11/09/2022 00:11

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:58

And no, we are not “stuck in the past” don’t be ridiculous

Calling people ridiculous does not help win people over.

We are stuck in the past. A Head of State who is there because of birthright.

That's the past.

A head of state who only remains there because Parliament decreed he should. As they did as part of the Glorious Revolution, with the Act of Settlement, and most recently with the Succession to the Crown Act 2013. The monarch would not be the monarch if parliament didn't want him to be.

In the 70 years in which Queen Elizabeth II reigned, the following monarchies (in their own right, I'm not including former colonies who became independent) became republics: Afghanistan, Burundi, Egypt, Ethiopia, Greece, Iraq, Iran, Laos, Libya, Nepal, Rwanda, Tunisia, Vietnam, Yemen.

Other than Greece, how well do you think those countries have done since?

DownNative · 11/09/2022 00:10

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:52

@Discovereads

And yet many countries seem to cope with having a written Constitution that adapts to changes.

Meanwhile, we are stuck in the past.

The Royal Family are basically the Truman Show. At least Harry saw this and got out. William and his family have their life planned out. They only get 1 life and this is what it is. Kept in a gilded cage for the masses.

Most written codified constitutions are very slow to change. For example, it took a really long time for the Republic of Ireland to cease all territorial claims over Northern Ireland. 62 years if we go by the 1937 version. It's very slow and requires more political processes. The US Constitution has barely changed since it was written by the Framers!

In contrast, an uncodified constitution can adapt rapidly without requiring amendments or referendums. The UK's constitution has seen more change and at a faster rate than the USA or ROI.

Both approaches have pros and cons.

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:09

DownNative · 11/09/2022 00:04

Again, does it change my point the House Of Windsor is not merely Anglo-German which was the point I was making in response to someone?

Well, no, it doesn't.

Rather it supports my point ancestry is complex, not simple. As does yours. 🤦‍♂️

The Windsors are just another bunch of people who just happened to get 'lucky' with being the first born, in some cases, with a line back to previous Monarchs.

No Royal Blood.

Discovereads · 11/09/2022 00:09

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:58

And no, we are not “stuck in the past” don’t be ridiculous

Calling people ridiculous does not help win people over.

We are stuck in the past. A Head of State who is there because of birthright.

That's the past.

Sorry, but I can’t help but call ridiculous statements for what they are…

Well, technically “the past” also includes Athens and their pure democracy, and Rome and their republic thousands of years ago. Having a hereditary figurehead of state is no more “in the past” than having a republic. Is it progress to regress all the way back to something that we had two thousand years ago as part of the Roman Republican Empire?

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:06

DownNative · 11/09/2022 00:01

I had a look on Wikipedia where you took the George V information from and noticed you blatantly ignored these sections that came just before it as well as after:

"Hence, in modern practice, the issue has never arisen, and royal assent has not been withheld."

And:

"Thus, as the concept of ministerial responsibility has evolved, the power to withhold royal assent has fallen into disuse, both in the United Kingdom and in the other Commonwealth realms."

The fact it is not withheld is due to the concept of Parliamentary Sovereignty. Parliament can and has removed Monarchs. Parliament can and has restored Monarchs.

Monarchs are subject to Parliament and not the other way round. Ever seen the State Opening Of Parliament where the door is slammed shut to Black Rod?

The Monarch isn't allowed to step into the Commons itself as a demonstration Parliament is Supreme and Sovereign.

Constitutional crisis can occur with written constitutions as well. We have a Supreme Court - how do you think they would rule if a Monarch encroaches upon Parliament's power? They'll rule in favour of Parliament for the reasons I've already stated.

Doctrine of Parliamentary Sovereignty
Representative Democracy
Government By Consent

A Monarch would face removal if they persisted in pushing against it. A condition of the restoration.

Wouldn't that be interesting...

If a Monarch did refuse to give assent, then they would be removed.

I do wonder if one would resign on principle. If they really didn't agree with it

DownNative · 11/09/2022 00:04

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:31

You do realise that we ARE ALL related to each other if you go back far enough. Because people alive a long time ago have many many many ancestors alive today.

Again, does it change my point the House Of Windsor is not merely Anglo-German which was the point I was making in response to someone?

Well, no, it doesn't.

Rather it supports my point ancestry is complex, not simple. As does yours. 🤦‍♂️

Joshanddonna · 11/09/2022 00:02

Oh get a grip.

DownNative · 11/09/2022 00:01

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:44

A Monarch who refuses Royal Assent risks provoking a Constitutional crisis. Essentially, George V found with his legal advice any withholding Royal Assent would change nothing

Is it written in the Constitution that the Monarch has to give assent?
What happens if they don't give assent?

Has it actually ever been tested?

Is this all written down somewhere with clear rules? If so, then there wouldn't be a Constitutional crisis, would there?

I had a look on Wikipedia where you took the George V information from and noticed you blatantly ignored these sections that came just before it as well as after:

"Hence, in modern practice, the issue has never arisen, and royal assent has not been withheld."

And:

"Thus, as the concept of ministerial responsibility has evolved, the power to withhold royal assent has fallen into disuse, both in the United Kingdom and in the other Commonwealth realms."

The fact it is not withheld is due to the concept of Parliamentary Sovereignty. Parliament can and has removed Monarchs. Parliament can and has restored Monarchs.

Monarchs are subject to Parliament and not the other way round. Ever seen the State Opening Of Parliament where the door is slammed shut to Black Rod?

The Monarch isn't allowed to step into the Commons itself as a demonstration Parliament is Supreme and Sovereign.

Constitutional crisis can occur with written constitutions as well. We have a Supreme Court - how do you think they would rule if a Monarch encroaches upon Parliament's power? They'll rule in favour of Parliament for the reasons I've already stated.

Doctrine of Parliamentary Sovereignty
Representative Democracy
Government By Consent

A Monarch would face removal if they persisted in pushing against it. A condition of the restoration.

Discovereads · 11/09/2022 00:00

The Royal Family are basically the Truman Show. At least Harry saw this and got out. William and his family have their life planned out. They only get 1 life and this is what it is. Kept in a gilded cage for the masses.

To a certain extent, yes they are symbolic and we own them as living history. But Harry didn’t see anything or get out. He’s 5th in line for the Throne. Only if his brother William and all his children die would Harry have a chance. And that’s not going to happen. So Harry is literally is surplus to requirements and not needed to be an active royal. He’s been pushed out.

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:58

And no, we are not “stuck in the past” don’t be ridiculous

Calling people ridiculous does not help win people over.

We are stuck in the past. A Head of State who is there because of birthright.

That's the past.

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:56

Don’t be, because that exactly what the US has and it’s codified constitution is the reason why Roe v. Wade was overturned and abortion is banned in half the country. Codified constitutions don’t tend to keep up with the times, so recent things like womens rights are more fragile

All depends how it's written.

Other modern countries seem to do ok.

Discovereads · 10/09/2022 23:55

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:52

@Discovereads

And yet many countries seem to cope with having a written Constitution that adapts to changes.

Meanwhile, we are stuck in the past.

The Royal Family are basically the Truman Show. At least Harry saw this and got out. William and his family have their life planned out. They only get 1 life and this is what it is. Kept in a gilded cage for the masses.

Many countries do not cope with a codified constitution. Meanwhile we have a written constitution (don’t know how many times we have to correct you). And no, we are not “stuck in the past” don’t be ridiculous. The fact that an Act of Parliament can amend our constitution means we have and do adapt and move forward MUCH faster than all the countries with codified constitutions.

Discovereads · 10/09/2022 23:53

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:37

This is getting very literal and pedantic. I know we have a lot of legal documents and Acts that together as read as something like a constitution. But the point is that it’s harder to make clear exactly what is meant by successive iterations and the proponents of a “written constitution” would support its being brought together in one document

I get a bit jealous of modern countries with a proper written single document, an elected Head of State and a modern voting system.

Don’t be, because that exactly what the US has and it’s codified constitution is the reason why Roe v. Wade was overturned and abortion is banned in half the country. Codified constitutions don’t tend to keep up with the times, so recent things like womens rights are more fragile.

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:52

@Discovereads

And yet many countries seem to cope with having a written Constitution that adapts to changes.

Meanwhile, we are stuck in the past.

The Royal Family are basically the Truman Show. At least Harry saw this and got out. William and his family have their life planned out. They only get 1 life and this is what it is. Kept in a gilded cage for the masses.

DownNative · 10/09/2022 23:51

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:46

Being chosen by God has not been a literal feature since the Abolition and Restoration of the Monarchy

You did hear the proclamation today?

"o whom we do acknowledge all Faith and Obedience, with humble affection: beseeching God, by whom Kings and Queens do reign, to bless His Majesty with long and happy years to reign over Us."

As I said, it is not literal and a Monarch only sits on the throne due Parliamentary Sovereignty.

It was Parliament who restored the Monarchy on the understanding of that basis.

You're taking a bit of traditional text as part of a ceremony and trying to present it as what it is not.

DownNative · 10/09/2022 23:51

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 23:46

Being chosen by God has not been a literal feature since the Abolition and Restoration of the Monarchy

You did hear the proclamation today?

"o whom we do acknowledge all Faith and Obedience, with humble affection: beseeching God, by whom Kings and Queens do reign, to bless His Majesty with long and happy years to reign over Us."

As I said, it is not literal and a Monarch only sits on the throne due Parliamentary Sovereignty.

It was Parliament who restored the Monarchy on the understanding of that basis.

You're taking a bit of traditional text as part of a ceremony and trying to present it as what it is not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread