Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you why the title ‘Prince of Wales’ is an historical insult to the Welsh and shouldn’t exist anymore

943 replies

Upthebracket22 · 10/09/2022 07:19

I am Welsh. I was enraged yesterday when the new king decided to ‘bestow’ the title on Prince William, an English Prince without asking the Welsh if they wanted another English Prince of Wales.

here is some historical context from a petition going around at the moment:

The "Prince of Wales" title (Welsh: Tywysog Cymru) is a title historically used by native, Welsh princes since the 14th century. The last native Prince of Wales was Llywelyn the Last, killed by English soldiers in 1282 and his head was then paraded through the streets of London and placed on a Tower of London spike. Llywelyn's brother Dafydd was the first person of note to be hung, drawn and quartered and his head was placed next to Llywelyn's. Both their daughters were taken as infants and children and imprisoned.

But this happened centuries ago you might say. The truth is, that since the days of Llywelyn the Last and the "rebel" Prince of Wales, Owain Glyndwr, the title has been held exclusively by Englishmen as a symbol of dominance over Wales. To this day, the English "Princes of Wales" have no genuine connection to our country.

The title remains an insult to Wales and is a symbol of historical oppression. The title also implies that Wales is still a principality, undermining Wales' status as a nation and a country. In addition, the title has absolutely no constitutional role for Wales, which is now a devolved country with a national Parliament.

As Welsh actor, Michael Sheen put it;

"Make a break there. Put some things that have been the wrongs of the past right. There's an opportunity to do that at that point. Don't necessarily just because of habit and without thinking just carry on that tradition that was started as a humiliation to our country. Why not change that as we come to this moment where things will inevitably change."

I don’t think many people have any concept of Welsh history. I find it offensive and think now would have been a good moment to right a historical wrong.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Legrandsophie · 11/09/2022 09:18

And I would suggest what people haven’t forgotten is all the half true nationalistic facts spouted by Plaid Cymru.

Legrandsophie · 11/09/2022 09:14

@herecomesthsun

I’m well aware that history isn’t just in books. I’ve spent the last two years travelling all over Wales tracing Welsh history. So thanks for the condescending tone.

By your reasoning Charles is also Welsh. He speaks Welsh, has a house in wales and is descended from the last Welsh prince defeated by Edward I.

There is something poetic about him being descended from them both. A very traditional approach to unifying two fighting forces through blood and marriage.

People spouting Welsh nationalism need to be aware how bigoted and exclusionary they sound. Especially to people like me who essentially the children of three of the home nations but are being made to feel like filthy English pigs by drum banging nationalistic rhetoric. I can’t imagine what those on the borders feel like now the ‘no true Welshman’ line is being rolled out again.

The Welsh border hasn’t been contested by two nations since the late 13th century. When Offa’s Dyke was built in the 700s there was no single kingdom of Wales. He was contesting the border against the king of Powys.

DingleyDel · 11/09/2022 09:10

I can’t believe people are trying to blame ‘retired English people ‘ for Wales (and other regions who have completely screwed themselves over with their leave vote) voting for Brexit! How many retired English people live in Wales? Enough to sway the vote? Surely the stats by region speak for themselves. The South East out of all the regions wanted leave the least. How does the ‘home county toffs’ theory square up with those stats? Are we really suggesting they’ve all moved to Wales? The North? This all sounds like some pretty extreme mental gymnastics to me.

herecomesthsun · 11/09/2022 08:59

Also, if we are claiming to have a consideration of history here, there was fierce fighting over the Welsh/ English border for many centuries - and people haven't forgotten. Many people haven't forgotten the attempts to stop children speaking Welsh in school or mining disasters or Welsh children being in service to English houses or Capel Celyn or Aberfan, all in living memory.

I wouldn't say that is about hate, but it is about national memory, which is precious; And national memory includes the stories about the Tywysog title being appropriated from the Welsh people. That appropriation shouldn't endure without consultation.

History, you know is not just in books or in (partly mythological) lineages.

herecomesthsun · 11/09/2022 08:50

well neither gate nor hate is very appropriate really

herecomesthsun · 11/09/2022 08:49

Legrandsophie · 11/09/2022 08:36

@herecomesthsun

It comes across as gate because it is the approach that considers ‘one drop’ to rules someone out as British. Remind me again who was in favour of denying national status to people with one drop of foreign blood?

It comes across as bigoted.

Charles was born in Britain
Elizabeth was born in Britain
George VI was born in Britain
Edward VII was born in Britain
Victoria was born in Britain

The last king to be born in a Germanic state was George the second.

How many generations before you consider them not Anglo-German? My mum’s family came from Ireland in the 1850s yet I have never considered myself Irish. Yet according to you I should!

But, I completely agree, and have written all over this thread, that they are British British Nationality Smile but mainly English / German descent. I am only writing about the ethnicity because people keep querying it and raising it. It doesn't bother me one jot.

If the British people as a majority are happy with the Royal family, and they ? probably are, then lets stick with that (for now).

If 30-40% Welsh people - and maybe more? -- have reservations about having a Prince of Wales, given the history of the title and the family etc, then maybe some consultation would have been a good idea. And maybe the family's timing on this was poor.

Legrandsophie · 11/09/2022 08:36

Hate! Not gate. Typing too fast.

Legrandsophie · 11/09/2022 08:36

@herecomesthsun

It comes across as gate because it is the approach that considers ‘one drop’ to rules someone out as British. Remind me again who was in favour of denying national status to people with one drop of foreign blood?

It comes across as bigoted.

Charles was born in Britain
Elizabeth was born in Britain
George VI was born in Britain
Edward VII was born in Britain
Victoria was born in Britain

The last king to be born in a Germanic state was George the second.

How many generations before you consider them not Anglo-German? My mum’s family came from Ireland in the 1850s yet I have never considered myself Irish. Yet according to you I should!

Legrandsophie · 11/09/2022 08:29

I love it. The Passport to Pimlico approach.

We were all separate kingdoms once. Why do we just devolve to that. But how far are we going back? Are we talking Anglo-Saxon heptarchy or Brythonic Celtic tribes?

Will happily become a Silures or a Mercian.

absolutelyanythingwilldo · 11/09/2022 08:20

Joshanddonna · 11/09/2022 08:03

The sooner London breaks away from the rest of the country the better. Free London. Liberate London. Vive la Peckham.
We can do a deal to get through Kent and rejoin the EU. Then we will have a labour/ Lib Dem coalition with Charles as King. Everyone will get a free puppy or pony and chicken tikka and apple crumble will be our national London dish.

Wimbledon won't put up with being ruled over by London. We want independence from the oppressive London regime.

Though I fear once we do have independence, it may embolden the Worple Road separatists to revolt.

fuckfuckfuck2021 · 11/09/2022 08:14

I'm welsh and I was happy when he was given the prince of wales title. Not because I don't know the history but because I don't feel we are oppressed by the royal family!

herecomesthsun · 11/09/2022 08:13

But this thread was not originally about Welsh independence (which would be a more complicated issue) but about whether the King's son should have the Wales title; also we don't have to "make up" Welsh culture as Welsh history, traditions, food and even an ancient language and literature already exist.

Joshanddonna · 11/09/2022 08:03

The sooner London breaks away from the rest of the country the better. Free London. Liberate London. Vive la Peckham.
We can do a deal to get through Kent and rejoin the EU. Then we will have a labour/ Lib Dem coalition with Charles as King. Everyone will get a free puppy or pony and chicken tikka and apple crumble will be our national London dish.

herecomesthsun · 11/09/2022 07:07

That should read "pro European" not "pre European". I'm fairly mature, but not that old.

herecomesthsun · 11/09/2022 06:58

Discovereads · 10/09/2022 20:50

It is an indubitable fact that the Royal Family is predominantly of English & German descent. Rubbish. Look at the genealogy instead of reading hate

I have, they are still predominantly of Anglo German descent, I'm afraid. "Predominantly" means "mostly", you see.

It is not "reading hate", at all, as I don't hate either English or German people (I am very pre European in fact), and so I can respect and even admire their heritage. Which is minimally Welsh, even you must agree.

As regards the extremely tenuous links to Welsh ancestry, as I have said before, going that far back, huge numbers of ethnic Welsh will be connected by lines of descent to Llewelyn and Owain Glyndwr and the princes of old. If we could do DNA analysis we would find that random Welsh people walking the streets of Wrexham and Chirk had more connection with these old princes than William.

So I would say (which is a very positive and love-filled statement) that we are all princes by descent in Wales. And we don't need a (predominantly) English bugger thanks.

TomPinch · 11/09/2022 01:14

The whole thing is like the Truman show with people just obsessed with the clothes Kate wears, the pictures of their children and the antics of William and Harry. Sycophancy at its worst. Or opium for the masses.

OK then. I guess you want to abolish organized sport and pop music because a lot of people have a prurient interest in the private lives of the people who do it.

DdraigGoch · 11/09/2022 01:03

TomPinch · 11/09/2022 00:57

You may have a problem with that. But that is my opinion.

I understand that. But remember that opinions are like arseholes: everyone has one. So whether it's worth anything depends on how good it is.

My opinion is that well-intentioned iconoclasm isn't a good thing. The UK / Canada / NZ / Australia etc constitutional systems aren't broken and shouldn't be broken. The events of the last few years round the world show clearly why this matters. That's my opinion and that's why it's a better one than yours.

Hear hear, just look at how bitter things are in the US these days. Elections fought in court, storming of the Capitol, vested interests able to prevent the removal of the Second Amendment...

If it ain't broke, don't fix it.

user1473878824 · 11/09/2022 01:01

What date would you like history that’s actually meaningful to start?

DdraigGoch · 11/09/2022 00:59

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:45

Wanting a better democracy is the opposite of pride?

Really?

It's not democratic that our Head of State is there by birth right. I would not acknowledge him as King nor curtsey to him. I am a citizen, not a subject.

You may have a problem with that. But that is my opinion. The whole thing is like the Truman show with people just obsessed with the clothes Kate wears, the pictures of their children and the antics of William and Harry. Sycophancy at its worst. Or opium for the masses.

Replacing the King with an elected president would do nothing to improve the democratic governance of the country. You disagree? Do tell me just how replacing the monarchy with a republic will improve the amount of representation you have where it really matters - in the day-to-day running of the country.

Ten of the twenty most democratic countries in the world are constitutional monarchies, which considering that republics account for three quarters of all countries is pretty good going.

TomPinch · 11/09/2022 00:57

You may have a problem with that. But that is my opinion.

I understand that. But remember that opinions are like arseholes: everyone has one. So whether it's worth anything depends on how good it is.

My opinion is that well-intentioned iconoclasm isn't a good thing. The UK / Canada / NZ / Australia etc constitutional systems aren't broken and shouldn't be broken. The events of the last few years round the world show clearly why this matters. That's my opinion and that's why it's a better one than yours.

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:45

Discovereads · 11/09/2022 00:37

Where’s your pride? You’re the one that wants to tear down the monarchy which has last for over a thousand years. It’s a keystone of our heritage and culture, and you just want to bin it like it’s nothing. And even if you’re right that a monarchy has neither helped nor hindered us, then there’s no good reason to get rid of it except for the fact you’d rather change Britain to be like some foreign country…that’s not pride in your country. That’s the opposite of pride.

Wanting a better democracy is the opposite of pride?

Really?

It's not democratic that our Head of State is there by birth right. I would not acknowledge him as King nor curtsey to him. I am a citizen, not a subject.

You may have a problem with that. But that is my opinion. The whole thing is like the Truman show with people just obsessed with the clothes Kate wears, the pictures of their children and the antics of William and Harry. Sycophancy at its worst. Or opium for the masses.

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:41

Discovereads · 11/09/2022 00:29

The Monarch doesnt sign bills! They don’t even personally give assent! That’s been delegated to the Lords Comissioners since 1541! 😆😆😆

So in that case, what was the King George V case about if they don't personally give assent?

I am just going from Parliamentary procedure
guidetoprocedure.parliament.uk/collections/rdnwhrzS/royal-assent

Although apparently there was a BBC drama a while ago where a future King Charles refused to give assent to a bill which provoked a constitutional crisis

www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p04z0n7s

Prince Charles has waited his entire life to ascend to the British throne. But after the Queen's death, he immediately finds himself wrestling his conscience over a bill to sign into law. His hesitation detonates a constitutional and political crisis, and his family start to worry, with William and Kate becoming aware his actions may threaten their future. Meanwhile, an unhappy and frustrated Prince Harry starts a relationship with a 'commoner', just at the moment that the press is looking for a way to attack. With the future of the monarchy under threat, protests on the streets and his family in disarray, Charles must grapple with his own identity and purpose to decide whether, in the 21st century, the British crown still has any real power.

Discovereads · 11/09/2022 00:37

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:15

Other than Greece, how well do you think those countries have done since

You seem to have missed out many countries in Europe that don't have a Monarch and are doing quite well.

Do you think we would not do well because we didn't have a Monarch? Where's your pride in Britain, the UK and its people?

Where’s your pride? You’re the one that wants to tear down the monarchy which has last for over a thousand years. It’s a keystone of our heritage and culture, and you just want to bin it like it’s nothing. And even if you’re right that a monarchy has neither helped nor hindered us, then there’s no good reason to get rid of it except for the fact you’d rather change Britain to be like some foreign country…that’s not pride in your country. That’s the opposite of pride.

TheUsualChaos · 11/09/2022 00:30

Tell you what, go fully independent and be shot of the UK completely. And we'll the billions that funds your country's deficit. Ta.

Discovereads · 11/09/2022 00:29

cakeorwine · 11/09/2022 00:17

So what would happen if a Monarch refused to sign a bill?

Would it become law or would they have to wait until a Monarch was appointed who would sign it?

What if no Monarch signed it?

The Monarch doesnt sign bills! They don’t even personally give assent! That’s been delegated to the Lords Comissioners since 1541! 😆😆😆