Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you why the title ‘Prince of Wales’ is an historical insult to the Welsh and shouldn’t exist anymore

943 replies

Upthebracket22 · 10/09/2022 07:19

I am Welsh. I was enraged yesterday when the new king decided to ‘bestow’ the title on Prince William, an English Prince without asking the Welsh if they wanted another English Prince of Wales.

here is some historical context from a petition going around at the moment:

The "Prince of Wales" title (Welsh: Tywysog Cymru) is a title historically used by native, Welsh princes since the 14th century. The last native Prince of Wales was Llywelyn the Last, killed by English soldiers in 1282 and his head was then paraded through the streets of London and placed on a Tower of London spike. Llywelyn's brother Dafydd was the first person of note to be hung, drawn and quartered and his head was placed next to Llywelyn's. Both their daughters were taken as infants and children and imprisoned.

But this happened centuries ago you might say. The truth is, that since the days of Llywelyn the Last and the "rebel" Prince of Wales, Owain Glyndwr, the title has been held exclusively by Englishmen as a symbol of dominance over Wales. To this day, the English "Princes of Wales" have no genuine connection to our country.

The title remains an insult to Wales and is a symbol of historical oppression. The title also implies that Wales is still a principality, undermining Wales' status as a nation and a country. In addition, the title has absolutely no constitutional role for Wales, which is now a devolved country with a national Parliament.

As Welsh actor, Michael Sheen put it;

"Make a break there. Put some things that have been the wrongs of the past right. There's an opportunity to do that at that point. Don't necessarily just because of habit and without thinking just carry on that tradition that was started as a humiliation to our country. Why not change that as we come to this moment where things will inevitably change."

I don’t think many people have any concept of Welsh history. I find it offensive and think now would have been a good moment to right a historical wrong.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
herecomesthsun · 14/12/2022 15:39

On the other hand standing your ground and taking back power is usually a pretty good way to empower yourself. And this is one possible way.

justasking111 · 12/12/2022 22:35

Ireland exports a huge amount of food that puts us to shame

It's tax break for companies make huge sums for them. They're more tech savvy than us, more travelled, certainly better known on the world stage than us.

www.worldstopexports.com/irelands-top-10-exports/

Vaccine001 · 12/12/2022 22:19

Hate the English much? Get a life

travellinglighter · 12/12/2022 22:01

DdraigGoch · 12/12/2022 20:37

You're not seriously suggesting that Wales can be the world leader in water, are you?

Food exports won't get you far, not when the WAG are encouraging the selling off of farmland for forestry at a considerable rate.

HS2 certainly benefits those of us in North Wales.

What I’m saying is that we have advantages that Ireland didn’t have. We are self sufficient in water, power and food. We have exportable commodities. We would not have to pay for things that don’t particularly benefit us. HS2 knocks an hour off the travel time to Manchester and at that point you have to catch a second train that travels at snails pace to north wales. So essentially you might just as well get on the London to Holyhead train because it won’t make much difference to your travel time.

justasking111 · 12/12/2022 21:58

The present Senedd are like ferrets in a sack plaid impatient with labour for not being radical enough. Labour not supporting farming. Arguing about second homes, they're nibbling at the edges to avoid more serious concerns.

We seem to be in limbo

DdraigGoch · 12/12/2022 20:37

travellinglighter · 12/12/2022 20:16

I did say it wouldn’t be easy but we do have some advantages that Ireland didn’t have. We’re a net exporter of water, power and food. I read somewhere that Wales is the third largest exporter of green electricity on the planet. We essentially supply a large part of the northwest and central England with water. We are net exporter of food largely because we are an agricultural economy.

Bear in mind, the power/water companies don’t pay their taxes directly to the Welsh government, any benefit we received is filtered through Westminster and can be withdrawn.

A further issue is we pay for national infrastructure projects that do not benefit us. Wales’ share of HS2 comes in at £5billion, we pay a similar proportion for cross rail, trident, parliamentary refurbishment that give little or no direct benefit to Wales.

The point is very simple. We have had policies, costs and governance imposed on us by a government we would never elect and seems to see us as an afterthought.

It might be painful but it might be time to go through the pain to decide our destiny.

You're not seriously suggesting that Wales can be the world leader in water, are you?

Food exports won't get you far, not when the WAG are encouraging the selling off of farmland for forestry at a considerable rate.

HS2 certainly benefits those of us in North Wales.

travellinglighter · 12/12/2022 20:16

DdraigGoch · 11/12/2022 13:49

Ireland struggled for decades, it had to become a tax haven to get to where it is today. Would Wales really offer a 12% corporation tax rate?

I did say it wouldn’t be easy but we do have some advantages that Ireland didn’t have. We’re a net exporter of water, power and food. I read somewhere that Wales is the third largest exporter of green electricity on the planet. We essentially supply a large part of the northwest and central England with water. We are net exporter of food largely because we are an agricultural economy.

Bear in mind, the power/water companies don’t pay their taxes directly to the Welsh government, any benefit we received is filtered through Westminster and can be withdrawn.

A further issue is we pay for national infrastructure projects that do not benefit us. Wales’ share of HS2 comes in at £5billion, we pay a similar proportion for cross rail, trident, parliamentary refurbishment that give little or no direct benefit to Wales.

The point is very simple. We have had policies, costs and governance imposed on us by a government we would never elect and seems to see us as an afterthought.

It might be painful but it might be time to go through the pain to decide our destiny.

justasking111 · 11/12/2022 23:10

I don't think Westminster, Holyrood, Senedd , NI assembly give a stuff about most of us. This has trickled down to our councils. Greed is good. Corruption rife. They're dismantling all our cultures to create something quite different imo.

DuchessDandelion · 11/12/2022 23:01

Eleganz · 11/12/2022 17:18

You have far more autonomy than those in the North or Midlands of England who are treated with just as much distain as the Welsh, Scottish and Northern Irish by the Westminster elite.

Worrying about royal titles that are just for show anyway is utterly pointless. The fight is to wrestle power away from the Eton boys in Westminster. At least you have the Senedd in Wales, all we get is the suggestion of super county councils that will put more power in the hands of regional Tories, rather than true devolution.

Not just the Midlands and North. Having moved about quite a bit, it's the same in many southern areas too. Basically, if you don't live in the Home Counties or a notably prosperous town.

Eleganz · 11/12/2022 17:18

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 10/12/2022 15:04

I totally agree with you. Ditto the Duke of Edinburgh. I think a lot of English people do not know their history. Wales, Scotland and Ireland are treated like second class satellite regions, with very little of the benefits that the south of England has, yet any talk of independence is poo pooed.

You have far more autonomy than those in the North or Midlands of England who are treated with just as much distain as the Welsh, Scottish and Northern Irish by the Westminster elite.

Worrying about royal titles that are just for show anyway is utterly pointless. The fight is to wrestle power away from the Eton boys in Westminster. At least you have the Senedd in Wales, all we get is the suggestion of super county councils that will put more power in the hands of regional Tories, rather than true devolution.

SnackSizeRaisin · 11/12/2022 16:45

The whole royal family needs getting rid of, together with inherited titles. The prince of Wales is just a title and doesn't have any particular role in Wales, surely?
I'm of mixed heritage so don't really see the point of independence (didn't vote for Brexit either) although I do think that Welsh culture is something special.
The Westminster government has been terrible for northern England too. I live near some of the most deprived areas in Europe. Our whole country is in a depressing state. It's weird that British people are so nationalist. They moan constantly about all the problems of living in Britain but still somehow think it's better than anywhere else

DuchessDandelion · 11/12/2022 16:34

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 10/12/2022 17:55

@Untitledsquatboulder You mean James, who was made king as his mother Mary Queen of Scots was deposed for being catholic? And then beheaded. Yup

She wasn't deposed by the English

DdraigGoch · 11/12/2022 13:49

travellinglighter · 11/12/2022 10:24

It’s hardly likely that a broadly socialist wales with a population of 3 million is likely to go down the Jack boot, flag waving route. Welsh independence is simply about the right to make our own decisions about our own country. I was a soldier, I swore oaths to the queen and I’ve met King Charles when he was prince Charles. I like the guy. I think he cares but as much as it upsets him, I’d drop him in a heartbeat.

No one says independence would be easy. Ireland suffered years of poverty but it makes its own way in the world now and Wales would do the same.

Ireland struggled for decades, it had to become a tax haven to get to where it is today. Would Wales really offer a 12% corporation tax rate?

DdraigGoch · 11/12/2022 13:45

Redbushteaforme · 10/12/2022 08:19

Nationalism is a divisive disease that can only lead to bigotry and ignorance.

English nationalism is a divisive disease that has led to bigotry and ignorance.

Civic nationalism in Scotland and Wales aspires to creating better, fairer countries which look after their citizens.

HTH.

No. They're just the same.

travellinglighter · 11/12/2022 10:24

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 14/09/2022 22:39

I think if you analysed the DNA of a lot of people living in Wales you would find a heady mix of many European cultures.

Nationalism is a path to fascism and we should fight it because we are on a slippy path.

It’s hardly likely that a broadly socialist wales with a population of 3 million is likely to go down the Jack boot, flag waving route. Welsh independence is simply about the right to make our own decisions about our own country. I was a soldier, I swore oaths to the queen and I’ve met King Charles when he was prince Charles. I like the guy. I think he cares but as much as it upsets him, I’d drop him in a heartbeat.

No one says independence would be easy. Ireland suffered years of poverty but it makes its own way in the world now and Wales would do the same.

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 10/12/2022 17:55

@Untitledsquatboulder You mean James, who was made king as his mother Mary Queen of Scots was deposed for being catholic? And then beheaded. Yup

Untitledsquatboulder · 10/12/2022 15:08

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 10/12/2022 15:04

I totally agree with you. Ditto the Duke of Edinburgh. I think a lot of English people do not know their history. Wales, Scotland and Ireland are treated like second class satellite regions, with very little of the benefits that the south of England has, yet any talk of independence is poo pooed.

I was taught that the reason that there is a union bw England and Scotland is because the Scottish King took the English throne. What were you taught?

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 10/12/2022 15:04

I totally agree with you. Ditto the Duke of Edinburgh. I think a lot of English people do not know their history. Wales, Scotland and Ireland are treated like second class satellite regions, with very little of the benefits that the south of England has, yet any talk of independence is poo pooed.

KimberleyClark · 10/12/2022 15:02

justasking111 · 10/12/2022 12:58

Friend works in a Welsh medium school. Many books etc need to be translated that costs more. Children come from further afield so transport costs. I could go on

Translation of books also creates employment which benefits the economy.

TroysMammy · 10/12/2022 14:59

@justasking111 same as Prince Michael of Kent and his wife Princess Michael of Kent.

TroysMammy · 10/12/2022 14:32

@justasking111 on Wikipedia under Titles, Styles he was originally called His Royal Highness Prince Henry of Wales. This was until he was given the Dukedom on marriage. He was known as Captain Harry Wales in the military. I'm hoping they will be Mountbatten-Windsor instead which is the surname of his children. Unless of course that will be a bone of contention for Windsor.

justasking111 · 10/12/2022 14:19

TroysMammy · 10/12/2022 14:04

I'm Welsh and I also like having a Prince and Princess but what I don't like that if the Duke and Duchess of Sussex are stripped of the Dukedom then they will be titled Prince and Princess Henry of Wales. If that happens I will be disgusted.

Where did you hear that from?

TroysMammy · 10/12/2022 14:04

I'm Welsh and I also like having a Prince and Princess but what I don't like that if the Duke and Duchess of Sussex are stripped of the Dukedom then they will be titled Prince and Princess Henry of Wales. If that happens I will be disgusted.

Siarabang · 10/12/2022 13:56

strawberriesplease · 10/12/2022 10:28

Going down the route of being a victim will not lead to empowerment.

It just leads to a fake victim culture where you try to stand alongside genuinely oppressed groups and look ridiculous

While I agree helpless victim mentalities are unhelpful, on the subject of being anti-oppression, not sure dictating which people can and can't talk about their lived experience serves that. People are always free not to listen if they don't think certain people's experiences should be prioritised.

The poverty in vast areas of Wales is fairly tangible if you look at the stats around unemployment and wages. Victimhood would be to say nothing and just accept it. The 'there's worse off people you know' argument while inevitably true of everything isn't a particularly helpful argument when people are struggling for even minimum wage work. It's like telling starving Irish people during the famine, 'well, that's nothing compared to the shit going down across the water'. It may well be true but they'll be no less malnourished.

To many Welsh people, its culture and language is very important because it's a symbol of still being here despite conquest and being ruled by somewhere else. Welsh was described in Westminster as 'barbaric' and its teaching was outlawed for many years to the extent that within just the last hundred years kids were systematically being beaten at school for speaking their first language. In my school years, Westminster decreed that parts of our history were not to be taught at all in case it incited nationalism.

Acts like the forced drowning of a Welsh village to provide water for Liverpool despite an almost unanimous vote against it by Welsh MPs does stick in people's psyche.

People asking for the Prince of Wales title to be revoked might seem petty but just like devolution, it's a symbolic act asking for Wales to have some say over its own autonomy, which is anything but victimhood. It's a passionate will to restore some sense of self determination for its own good.

justasking111 · 10/12/2022 12:58

CardiffMam · 10/12/2022 10:49

Can someone please explain why Welsh language schools are seen as an extra cost? Children need educating, it doesn't cost anymore to educate some of them in Welsh medium schools.

Friend works in a Welsh medium school. Many books etc need to be translated that costs more. Children come from further afield so transport costs. I could go on