Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Changing for PE

132 replies

Flymetothezoom · 09/09/2022 18:14

My 7 year old son used to wear his PE kit to school on PE days. Now the school has said they want children to change in the classroom again. Parents have complained that their kids don’t want to do this. The head has sent a letter saying that:

”I understand that some parents and children are a little worried about changing into their PE kits in front of their peers. As this is something that we regularly did prior to Covid, we would like to bring back this process as part of a normal school activity.”

Why should children have to get used to changing in front of each other and their teachers? This isn’t a life skill. It is archaic and weird. As an adult I have never had to change with 26 men and women, in a room with many uncovered windows. Would I be wrong to write to the head and complain about this?

YABU: kids should change in front of each other and the teacher
YANBU: it is odd that it was ever allowed even before covid.

OP posts:
jeaux90 · 10/09/2022 12:17

Girls are getting their periods younger now. This is a fact.

I find the mixed sex changing thing utterly bizarre and boundary breaking.

They should go in in their kit or change in private areas.

twoshedsjackson · 10/09/2022 12:10

After my retirement, I did a stint of long-term supply in another nearby school, and they already had this system in place; this was before Covid. I remember thinking, I wish my old school had done that! The teaching time we could have saved, not to mention the growing heaps of lost property!
I was a pupil myself a long time ago, and we changed together, but I think times have changed, and over my career it was obvious that the onset of puberty was becoming earlier; it was a great rarity when I was Y6, but a lot of the girls I taught in my later years were well on the way to being young women. I would guess that, rather than arguing the odds about when it became inappropriate, it was more straightforward to have a whole school policy.

zingally · 10/09/2022 12:10

I'm a primary supply teacher, and yes, most schools are now phasing back in to changing at school. For the younger ones, it's a life skill.

Personally, I don't have an opinion either way.

I remember changing in the classroom in front of the boys and our male teacher in Year 6! I don't remember it being a big deal, but I remember my best friends mum not liking it. She raised it with the school IIRC, and just got a metaphorical shrug in response. This was the better part of 30 years ago though.

ThanksItHasPockets · 10/09/2022 11:34

prescribingmum · 09/09/2022 21:49

@SeeSawDaw they are also told not to show their underpants to others and to keep them covered with their clothes

Could you please point me towards the part of the PANTS guidance which says this? Like PP I am frankly alarmed that your child's school has so fundamentally misinterpreted the campaign and is using it to teach your child that it is her responsibility to protect herself from abuse.

PANTS is supposed to be an age-appropriate introduction to bodily autonomy and consent and it sounds like the staff at your child's school need a refresher on its principles.

TeaAndBiscuitsAndWine · 10/09/2022 00:57

The posters saying it’s ok because the children are young are missing some important points:

  1. A number of the girls will be hitting puberty from Year 3 (aged 7/8) onwards, it’s far more common than it used to be.
  2. Even before reaching menarche, a lot of girls will be developing differently to the boys, developing breasts for instance.
  3. Boys from that age onwards, especially those with older male brothers, cousins etc., can be very well aware of the bodily differences and can be vile to the girls about their bodies, happened at our school.
  4. Except in winter, a lot of children don’t wear vests these days. So it does mean stripping to their knickers in front of a class full of other children, roughly half of whom are the opposite sex. Once they are old enough to be disturbed by this, just don’t make them do this!

I understand the argument re: seeing bruises, but just make them wear shorts and T shirts for PE, and let them then put on joggers and hoodies if they get cold.

Iamnotthe1 · 09/09/2022 22:45

GreenIsle · 09/09/2022 22:37

Surely the boys and girls change separately. When I was in primary school about 20 years ago the boys were sent out to change on the toilets and girls changed in the classroom even then.

Also regards to hygiene how is doing 50 minutes of PE any different from them running around at break time and lunchtime. They are hardly doing HIT workouts etc.

It's very different. At lunch, children will be eating for half the time and will be on the playground for half. It's rare that a child will spend their whole time outside being active and will mix doing various things, including just walking around having a chat or playing low energy games like throwing a ball around.

High quality P.E. lessons are typically an hour long with the children being active for over 90% of the lesson. They even do things like jogging on the spot whilst teachers give instructions so that any time "waiting" or standing around is minimised. Whilst it does depend on the specific focus on the P.E. lesson, it's not unusual for children to get incredibly sweaty by the end of the lesson, definitely more so than during break or lunch.

marlowe5 · 09/09/2022 22:37

ImSoMagical · 09/09/2022 18:34

I agree with wearing pe kit on pe days. It must save time and no faffing about changing clothes. Also, the amount of stuff that goes missing or goes into lost property must be massively reduced! As a mum I find it much easier to send them in pe kit.

This!

GreenIsle · 09/09/2022 22:37

Surely the boys and girls change separately. When I was in primary school about 20 years ago the boys were sent out to change on the toilets and girls changed in the classroom even then.

Also regards to hygiene how is doing 50 minutes of PE any different from them running around at break time and lunchtime. They are hardly doing HIT workouts etc.

fallfallfall · 09/09/2022 22:31

it's no longer appropriate. please do write to the appropriate people. some kids will care. and some will also be made fun of. totally unnecessary to see this many people's underwear all at once.

YellowHouze · 09/09/2022 22:26

My DD’s wear navy shorts under their dresses everyday anyway ( like cycling shorts but shorter). They both asked for these as they wanted to do cartwheels and play outside without any one seeing their pants. I think this is fair enough so I bought them several pairs each. They wear body tops as well, which are comfortable. This means that getting changed in front of others is less stressful for them.

Cece92 · 09/09/2022 22:24

My daughters school done this pre covid however they now go to school in their p.e kit. They have kept it in place and it saves so much time for me and DD. She is 9 in a couple weeks and starting to go through changes. She won't change in front of me so there's not a chance in hell she would in class either xxx

WestIsWest · 09/09/2022 22:21

noclothesinbed · 09/09/2022 18:45

They arnt adults though are they. Honestly I really feel for teachers these days why do parents have to object to everything it must Make their job so difficult having to battle every rule. Just do what the school tell you to do it's not hard. Your child is not that precious

All children are precious and should be treated that way!

WestIsWest · 09/09/2022 22:21

DreamingofItaly2023 · 09/09/2022 18:28

DS has struggled with this as the school rightly drummed the PANTS rule into all the children and now he feels confused. He feels that his pants are private and doesn’t like others seeing him in just his pants. He doesn’t want me to speak to the school however.

I was so disappointed about the change, I thought going in in your PE kit would be the one good thing to come out of COVID.

This is exactly what I was thinking. It’s giving them mixed messages and is totally unnecessary.

WestIsWest · 09/09/2022 22:19

half of them surely spend their days out of school running about in knickers anyway.

What the fuck???

ellieboolou · 09/09/2022 22:12

My year 6 dd would hate to return to mixed changing on PE days, luckily our school still allows the kids to go in kit in PE day.

People saying it's a life skill it is indeed - one that a parent can teach daily to their kids, those who can't change quickly either have kids with needs (my eldest is asd and struggles) or are the parents can't be bothered.

Pinkflipflop85 · 09/09/2022 22:08

@sponsabillaries said it better than me.

Properly indeed...

Pinkflipflop85 · 09/09/2022 22:07

prescribingmum · 09/09/2022 21:31

DD's school has placed a huge emphasis on the pants rule since Reception and regularly reinforces how their underwear is private and not to be shown to others. They place emphasis on sitting properly in their dresses and making sure they do not reveal their knickers.

I would be fuming if they also felt it appropriate to make them take off their clothes and reveal their underwear to the rest of the class on a regular basis. Total contradiction of everything they have just been taught.

Fortunately they still wear PE kit on their PE days and only need to change occasionally such as when photo day falls on PE day. In those cases they separate girls and boys (including Reception).

The sweating argument is void in primary school - they spend their entire lunchbreak running around more than they do in a PE lesson!

The school has spectacularly missed the point.

The pants rule is about private parts and has nothing to do with people seeing your pants.

Pretty disappointing that they are giving the message, to girls in particular, that there is something wrong with an everyday item of clothing being seen.

sponsabillaries · 09/09/2022 21:58

prescribingmum · 09/09/2022 21:31

DD's school has placed a huge emphasis on the pants rule since Reception and regularly reinforces how their underwear is private and not to be shown to others. They place emphasis on sitting properly in their dresses and making sure they do not reveal their knickers.

I would be fuming if they also felt it appropriate to make them take off their clothes and reveal their underwear to the rest of the class on a regular basis. Total contradiction of everything they have just been taught.

Fortunately they still wear PE kit on their PE days and only need to change occasionally such as when photo day falls on PE day. In those cases they separate girls and boys (including Reception).

The sweating argument is void in primary school - they spend their entire lunchbreak running around more than they do in a PE lesson!

That’s a total misinterpretation of the PANTS initiative. It teaches that the parts of your body covered by your pants are private and no one should ask to see or touch them without clearly explaining why, eg a doctor or nurse.

It is not there to teach little girls that it is their responsibility to sit modestly and I would be fucking livid if my DD’s school was peddling that kind of victim-blaming nonsense.

‘Properly’. What the fuck.

SeeSawDaw · 09/09/2022 21:55

@prescribingmum Then that's not part of NSPCC PANTS guidelines as I understand them. We do however tell kids how to sit properly when sitting on the carpet, which has nothing to do with sexual abuse.

prescribingmum · 09/09/2022 21:49

@SeeSawDaw they are also told not to show their underpants to others and to keep them covered with their clothes

MerryMarigold · 09/09/2022 21:49

It's not a life skill to get changed in front of other people but it is a life skill to be able to dress yourself. You'd be surprised at how many kids are dressed by their parents! P.e clothes and shoes change is a life skill!

SeeSawDaw · 09/09/2022 21:46

prescribingmum · 09/09/2022 21:31

DD's school has placed a huge emphasis on the pants rule since Reception and regularly reinforces how their underwear is private and not to be shown to others. They place emphasis on sitting properly in their dresses and making sure they do not reveal their knickers.

I would be fuming if they also felt it appropriate to make them take off their clothes and reveal their underwear to the rest of the class on a regular basis. Total contradiction of everything they have just been taught.

Fortunately they still wear PE kit on their PE days and only need to change occasionally such as when photo day falls on PE day. In those cases they separate girls and boys (including Reception).

The sweating argument is void in primary school - they spend their entire lunchbreak running around more than they do in a PE lesson!

The PANTS rule for kids is about keeping their privates private, not about not showing your pants.

prescribingmum · 09/09/2022 21:31

DD's school has placed a huge emphasis on the pants rule since Reception and regularly reinforces how their underwear is private and not to be shown to others. They place emphasis on sitting properly in their dresses and making sure they do not reveal their knickers.

I would be fuming if they also felt it appropriate to make them take off their clothes and reveal their underwear to the rest of the class on a regular basis. Total contradiction of everything they have just been taught.

Fortunately they still wear PE kit on their PE days and only need to change occasionally such as when photo day falls on PE day. In those cases they separate girls and boys (including Reception).

The sweating argument is void in primary school - they spend their entire lunchbreak running around more than they do in a PE lesson!

Iamnotthe1 · 09/09/2022 21:29

There are arguments on both sides.

Coming in P.E. kit makes things quicker and means you get the full hour for the lesson rather than changing, which, of course, improves the effectiveness of P.E. lessons. It also increases privacy for the child on an individual level. P.E. kits are also much cooler in during the summer months.

However, changing for P.E. reinforces the idea message that we change for sport, in part, due to the hygiene implications. By the time primary children are in Y5 and Y6, if you aren't having P.E. at the end of the day (and aren't changing), the classroom definitely has a distinct aroma for the later afternoon. P.E. kits might also not be warm enough during winter, particularly if schools end up having to limit heating.

There are also safeguarding implications: one of the messages to come out of many school safeguarding courses is that teaching staff are one of the few people outside of the home that see children in a state of partial dress and so are the most likely people to detect hidden physical abuse.

FabFitFifties · 09/09/2022 21:21

The primary school which my son has just left, have sensibly, in my opinion, allowed children to continue to come dressed in PE kit. They have introduced a smarter, more practical version, complete with hoodie. They also provided the first set, during change over, free of charge.