Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Meanwhile....energy bills and the cost of living crisis

39 replies

cakeorwine · 09/09/2022 07:15

Announced yesterday - a freezing of the unit price of energy (for 2 years) for households and 4 months for businesses. Paid for by borrowing.

Unit price to be announced soon

4 months for business is not a long time. And the price of gas is not going down

There is also high inflation affecting fuel and food prices.

I hope the Queen's passing does not distract people from this real issue - which is only a few weeks away

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Alexandra2001 · 10/09/2022 13:57

Getoff · 09/09/2022 11:24

The energy companies aren't benefiting. If they weren't being given taxpayer money, they'd be getting consumers money. They aren't getting money for nothing, they're getting money for energy.

The winners in this scheme are people on below average incomes, who will receive more subsidy than they pay back through tax. The losers are people who pay more than an average amount of tax.

Thats not really true.

With no help, the well off would easily afford a 3 or 4k increase, meanwhile at the bottom end (around 8m households) people wouldn't be able to pay, the energy companies wouldn't be getting their money, the courts would be overwhelmed & hardly anyone forced to have a key meter.

So, the price cap is of huge benefit to the energy companies.

Also, whilst the low paid (thats anyone under 30k) pay less income tax, they still pay a host of other taxes, far more than the wealthy in proportion to income & we'll all be paying for this stupid catch all policy for decades to come.

cakeorwine · 10/09/2022 11:45

It's only a few weeks to go to the new price cap.

I hope that stuff is being fleshed out on this. The Bank of England delayed announcing interest rate changes.

Inflation is still high. Food is getting expensive. Petrol is high.

But we have paused this discussion

OP posts:
Getoff · 09/09/2022 11:30

(Actually I'm not sure about business, I forgot their rates could be different.)

Getoff · 09/09/2022 11:27

People won't be encouraged to reduce their use of gas - which is a problem when there is a limited supply of gas.

This was my objection to this type of scheme. I wanted them to pay a flat amount of cash into each electricity account, and still have electricity and gas at market prices, so people had a big incentive to economise. But in fairness, prices are still going to be historically high, so people do still have a higher than ever incentive to economise. And I suppose this scheme does also help business, and help keep down the general level of inflation.

MarshaBradyo · 09/09/2022 11:26

Getoff · 09/09/2022 11:24

The energy companies aren't benefiting. If they weren't being given taxpayer money, they'd be getting consumers money. They aren't getting money for nothing, they're getting money for energy.

The winners in this scheme are people on below average incomes, who will receive more subsidy than they pay back through tax. The losers are people who pay more than an average amount of tax.

Yes it’s odd how people are framing this

The benefit is to us as we get lower bills. We’re not paying the real rate but getting a subsidy

Getoff · 09/09/2022 11:24

carefullycourageous · 09/09/2022 07:17

Handing billions & billions of taxpayers' money to the energy companies is still making me Angry

The energy companies aren't benefiting. If they weren't being given taxpayer money, they'd be getting consumers money. They aren't getting money for nothing, they're getting money for energy.

The winners in this scheme are people on below average incomes, who will receive more subsidy than they pay back through tax. The losers are people who pay more than an average amount of tax.

nachoavocado · 09/09/2022 11:22

cakeorwine · 09/09/2022 07:46

People won't be encouraged to reduce their use of gas - which is a problem when there is a limited supply of gas.

At least we haven't got headlines about Liz saves the energy crisis. Fuel bills to be capped at £2500.

So people won't get confused by this

Yes they will! It will still be bloody expensive just not as ridiculously high as expected. No one is going to look at their energy bill this winter and think ooh look that's really affordable, not unless they reduce their energy consumption.

MarshaBradyo · 09/09/2022 11:21

It is still twice the cost of last year - unless you received cash payment which bridges the gap for an average user.

Usage will fall due to this.

AndSoFinally · 09/09/2022 11:18

The main driver of your energy costs is how big your house is and how many people live in it.

High costs could therefore apply to the rich and poor equally.

I'm a high earner but my one wage supports 8 people and out bills are high. There's no fair way to account for that so the help will have to be a blunt tool

wonkylegs · 09/09/2022 10:17

@ancientgran the problem with this solution is that many poorer people will have greater energy needs than wealthier people as richer people can afford to insulate their homes, buy double/triple glazing, buy energy efficient appliances, buy solar panels and batteries and generally do things that reduce their energy consumption.
I have solar panels and a battery, have made my formerly leaky Victorian house much more energy efficient, have a super insulated extension but I'm under no illusions that my lower consumption is because I could afford to pay up front and save over time.

mibbelucieachwell · 09/09/2022 09:35

This is the modus operandi of recent conservative governments. They faff about ineffectually with minor issues such as a few dozen vibrant, energetic young people crossing the English Channel, returning to imperial units of measurement, covering up their corruption and lies and having endless photos taken while economists, scientists, mayors, charitable organisations etc desperately cry for help and suggest sensible, workable measures. Finally at the eleventh hour, when thousands and thousands of people are sick with worry they slap out a crude, eye-wateringly expensive plaster on the problem.

Their response to covid was the same. Having previously ignored pandemic planning they downgraded covid as a threat and reduced testing in February 2020, didn't update their models, which were clearly two weeks out of date, frittered away a ton of taxpayers money on illegally awarded contracts for expensive and ineffective PPE and Nightingale hospitals. Then hastily set up the blanket furlough scheme with little scope to guard against fraud, and nothing for freelancers who didn't have enough years of tax returns. The. The east out to help out scheme....

And Brexit. Remember how the negotiators were met with incredulity at their lack of detail and organisation? Queues at Dover, unworkable endless paperwork for businesses: these were predicted.

They could have capped only the first percentage of household energy costs and left excess use at the current rate to discourage excessive energy consumption even by more well off households (obviously use of medical equipment in homes and extra heating for vulnerable people would be exempt). They could have levvied an extra windfall tax to cover some of the cost and used it to help fund energy efficiency measures such as insulation, triple glazing, solar panels, heat pumps etc.

But no. They chose to keep big businesses and their shareholders happy at the expense of taxpayers in the most expensive possible way with no plan for paying it back that they'll admit to while they gad about in private planes and petrol cars while they impose more and more authoritarian laws that reduce the independence of the electoral commission, reduce the right to protest, make it harder for journalists to criticise the government and allow privatised water companies to pump sewage onto our beaches. Next on their list is reducing workers rights.

Alexandra2001 · 09/09/2022 09:32

Flockbee · 09/09/2022 09:26

It'd be really challenging though to target those who need adidtional help beyond how they have already (those receiving additional payments will rightfully still get them to help). Some people on fairly decent wages will have cut their cloth accordingly but now be struggling, those who are super wealthy and won't be feeling the pinch will be in the minority.

Just set the cost per unit at x for average consumption, that unit cost could be lower than the price freeze cap with the money saved - then market rate above that.
Caveats for exceptional cases, disabled & other genuine hi users.

It would also encourage lower use, its not my idea, its Germany's, they are having to borrow less too.

Agree, higher earners often have higher outgoings, esp mortgage costs.

Alexandra2001 · 09/09/2022 09:28

Flockbee · 09/09/2022 09:21

Ironically it's because fuel has been cheap to now considering that many people haven't had to consider their usage or understand their bills.

Its not the OP, its the Government and the regulator... If someone says "i will cap the the price of the 4 tyres i'll fit to your car to £400" .. what would most people think?
£400 is the max i will pay for 4 new tyres.

Its deliberate use of language to confuse and allow folk to think the Govt/regulator is on their side... whilst also giving the authorities a way out to charge far more.

Flockbee · 09/09/2022 09:26

It'd be really challenging though to target those who need adidtional help beyond how they have already (those receiving additional payments will rightfully still get them to help). Some people on fairly decent wages will have cut their cloth accordingly but now be struggling, those who are super wealthy and won't be feeling the pinch will be in the minority.

Bubblebubblebah · 09/09/2022 09:25

Just an FYI there is a cost of living topic here with some good threads on so the fact AIBU isn't full of it at this point is because there is a designated space not that people forget about it. Most can concentrate on two things at once

Alexandra2001 · 09/09/2022 09:23

FourTeaFallOut · 09/09/2022 07:43

It's a tough balance to crack. Some people wouldn't be happy unless Truss walked into their homes and wiped their arse for them personally, meanwhile others would happily watch the poor freeze to ice just to maintain the free market spirit. Dizzyingly, these extremes seem to hail from both sides of the commons.

Not really seen that from either side tbh, all Tories see the need for help & no one from Labour is saying freeze prices at last years cap for 5 years.

As for a "tough nut to crack" why isn't the support targeted? i'm sure many of us know folk who are extremely well off and fair play to them but in a national crisis, why should tax payers money be used to help people who don't need it? yet at the same time, the less well off, even with this price cap freeze, will see avg bills double from just a few months ago, they could barely afford the previous cap.

Then there is the little fact that in 18 months time, we will be in exactly the same position.

Truss wont be able to change global commodity prices.

Flockbee · 09/09/2022 09:21

PeekAtYou · 09/09/2022 09:17

Please be careful with your wording OP.

Fuel bills aren't being capped at £2500. The average bill will be about £2500. Some households will pay more and some will pay less. There are people online who believe that they can use unlimited energy for £2500pa which isn't the case.

Businesses are getting 6 months support. Is this because Liz is going to see what the January figures are and reassess?

Ironically it's because fuel has been cheap to now considering that many people haven't had to consider their usage or understand their bills.

Flockbee · 09/09/2022 09:20

Allegedly they have renegotiated a lot of the agreements so its not just propping them up, but to be honest it's not the suppliers that have driven prices up its the producers. They are businesses and will go where the money is, if we won't pay above £x they will sell in a country that will. There's also the long game to consider, windfall tax has implications beyond the here and now but I'm sure it has been considered. Its not ideal to have so much debt but as we rely on companies to provide utilities they aren't doing it out of the kindness of their hearts and supply and demand means they can line their coffers; a government can't intervene too much in that (people usually moan about government interference with things so presumably this is a good thing).

PeekAtYou · 09/09/2022 09:17

Please be careful with your wording OP.

Fuel bills aren't being capped at £2500. The average bill will be about £2500. Some households will pay more and some will pay less. There are people online who believe that they can use unlimited energy for £2500pa which isn't the case.

Businesses are getting 6 months support. Is this because Liz is going to see what the January figures are and reassess?

Mybeautifulfriend22 · 09/09/2022 09:16

justaladyLOL · 09/09/2022 09:11

Really??
Another thread about the same thing?
The world has changed
We have it easy for many years
Now it is going to be hard for ever

yes our monarch has died but so will normal people because of the cost of living crisis. It doesn’t go away for the mourning period. People are very worried. Even with the government help we still have high fuel, high foods, low wages not rising anywhere near inflation, mortgage rates rising and so on.

it’s a huge talking point. You can see what it is from the title so you can just scroll on….

Mybeautifulfriend22 · 09/09/2022 09:14

The Tory party came in twelve years ago saying labour had borrowed too much and we had to stomach Austerity. It’s been twelve years and we are in a state.

Im actually furious that there’s no windfall tax on the high profits that are occurs g through which would help pay for this. But many of the government party have their dirty fingers in so many lies that they can’t hurt their business interests now can they?

justaladyLOL · 09/09/2022 09:11

"And some people say they vote Tory for economic reasons."
As a business owner I would never ever trust Labour with business.

justaladyLOL · 09/09/2022 09:11

Really??
Another thread about the same thing?
The world has changed
We have it easy for many years
Now it is going to be hard for ever

ancientgran · 09/09/2022 09:08

cakeorwine · 09/09/2022 07:46

People won't be encouraged to reduce their use of gas - which is a problem when there is a limited supply of gas.

At least we haven't got headlines about Liz saves the energy crisis. Fuel bills to be capped at £2500.

So people won't get confused by this

Madness isn't it. I think there should be two prices, you get a certain basic amount of gas/electricity at a low price and then for anything above that you pay more. People won't have to go without power but will still try to cut back.

Mumoblue · 09/09/2022 09:02

No windfall tax, just more borrowing. And some people say they vote Tory for economic reasons. Fuck me sideways.