Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Question over friend hating children

93 replies

Lemondrizzle77 · 08/09/2022 11:44

I have a friend who doesn't have any children. In fact I have many friends who are not mothers. All of which are pleasant enough about and towards my own. However this one friend says she 'hates' all babies and small children. Fine. But she gives my children dirty looks whenever she sees them says all babies are vile and disgusting and is always negative when my children or someone else's children are mentioned in the group chat or in passing. It is starting to grate. I accept children are not for her but her hostility is starting to make me question if our values are aligning or not.

Anyway at dinner last night the topic of pregnancy somehow came up and she said she has never once used contraception in her life (and I know she is very sexually active) and I thought this was quite unusual as she quote un quote 'hates kids' so in my mind surely you would ensure you are protected. So I asked her what she would do if she got pregnant and she said 'oh have an abortion'

AIBU to think this odd. I don't want to jump on the whole 'every women secretly wants kids' bandwagon because they don't but I'm inclined to think there might be more behind why she detests children so much.

Only reason I am posting is because I have been tempted to pull back from the relationship recently but now I wonder if I should try and be more supportive and just ignore her unkind comments.

OP posts:
Mascia · 08/09/2022 13:08

Hillrunning · 08/09/2022 11:49

I'm constantly amazed by these stories, I'm friendly, kind, interested in others and don't smell bad and yet I have very very few people who want to hang out with me but somehow these vile people seem to have people like you who are willing to be their friends and only question it when it gets really really bad. Why is this?

She can dislike babies, she shouldn't be rude though and she is just plain stupid to not use contraception.

Ah, I know what you mean 🙂
It’s like those people who say how they’re constantly invited to places and how others always want to hang out with them - and they really need to learn to say “no” to people.
Or the ones who claimed they actually quite enjoyed lockdowns, because they didn’t need to meet anyone.
I always wondered how much fun these people actually are.

Tabbouleh · 08/09/2022 13:05

HikingBoots · 08/09/2022 12:57

*whumpthereitis · Today 12:23

She’s probably performative as a defense against ‘you’ll change your mind!’, or ‘I bet you secretly do!’. Any positive interaction with children leading to ‘you’d be such a good mother, you do want children really.*

Definitely this. As a childfree woman it's really hard to coo over someone's baby without people thinking you want one really, or saying "oh you'll be next", or saying what a good mother you'd be. People are so unnuanced. It becomes easier not to bother.

I don't like other people's kids and I have never cooed over them. But I have managed to restrain myself from making derogatory comments or giving them dirty looks because I am not 14..

Mascia · 08/09/2022 13:00

10HailMarys · 08/09/2022 11:49

It sounds to me as if she is being deliberately obnoxious to provoke a reaction. I don't really like kids either, but some people are really performative and weird about it. She sounds really irritating. Oh, and I don't believe for one second that she's never used contraception, by the way (unless what she actually meant was hormonal contraception). I think she's just trying to be outrageous and edgy. She's an attention-seeker.

This. I wouldn’t want to be friends with her, she sounds obnoxious.

HikingBoots · 08/09/2022 12:57

*whumpthereitis · Today 12:23

She’s probably performative as a defense against ‘you’ll change your mind!’, or ‘I bet you secretly do!’. Any positive interaction with children leading to ‘you’d be such a good mother, you do want children really.*

Definitely this. As a childfree woman it's really hard to coo over someone's baby without people thinking you want one really, or saying "oh you'll be next", or saying what a good mother you'd be. People are so unnuanced. It becomes easier not to bother.

dockspider · 08/09/2022 12:54

You’re friends with someone who gives your kids dirty looks? Why?!

InsertPunHere · 08/09/2022 12:52

She sounds a grandstanding butthead.

It is fine not to want kids, it’s fine not to want to be around children. To go on about it is obnoxious showboating.

HikingBoots · 08/09/2022 12:50

I'm childfree by choice, 38, happily married, and I'd say your friend is either not comfortable with her decision, or not comfortable with society's judgement of her decision.
To proclaim that you hate all babies and children is as odd as proclaiming that you hate all pensioners.
However, I can see how I might have come across like this in my early 20s - when everyone was talking about babies, having babies, asking me awkward questions about babies - and I was trying to figure out my own position on the subject. Saying I hated kids was my way of saying "oh, just fuck off" to the world for constantly making me feel so uncomfortable and 'othered'.
However, your point on contraception is far of the mark I'd say. DH and I have used the withdrawal method for more than a decade and I would genuinely have an abortion if I got pregnant. It simply isn't a big deal to me.

roarfeckingroarr · 08/09/2022 12:49

Anyone who critiques my son - without good reason! - would see their friendship terminated.

cont · 08/09/2022 12:47

whumpthereitis · 08/09/2022 12:23

She’s probably performative as a defense against ‘you’ll change your mind!’, or ‘I bet you secretly do!’. Any positive interaction with children leading to ‘you’d be such a good mother, you do want children really’.

Women that don’t want children often do get a lot of pressure placed on them, are disbelieved, and considered poor authorities on themselves and patronized. It can be incredibly frustrating, so some feel a need to prove their stance. Of course then it’s often taken as ‘I bet she does but secretly can’t!’, which just increases the frustration and hostility.

I don’t think she’s wrong about the abortion thing. No idea why she doesn’t use contraception, but that’s her business.

She's still a dick and she's definitely wrong about the abortion thing. She can use a barrier, hormonal, non hormonal or possibly permanent contraception if she's so sure she hates children.

Truly, people will defend anything. There's no need to play devils advocate, she's just an arse

WoodlandMummy · 08/09/2022 12:47

Hmm. The lady doth protest too much, methinks. V odd behaviour to not use protection when you ‘hate’ kids…unless….

A lot of women who want children but have fertility issues use self protection deflection methods, such as your friend. Although hers is a v extreme method, granted.

I would say if she’s not using protection and never has, she isn’t able to have children. The whole OTT manner in which she expresses her hatred combined with not using protection is indicative of this method.

When I didn’t want children prior to wanting them I took contraception v seriously. And I didn’t hate children, I just didn’t want them at the time! If your friend really hates children so much, there is no way she would risk getting pregnant.

Tabbouleh · 08/09/2022 12:46

Sorry. Posted too soon. Where people have the most awful and yet popular friends.

Peashoots · 08/09/2022 12:46

10HailMarys · 08/09/2022 11:49

It sounds to me as if she is being deliberately obnoxious to provoke a reaction. I don't really like kids either, but some people are really performative and weird about it. She sounds really irritating. Oh, and I don't believe for one second that she's never used contraception, by the way (unless what she actually meant was hormonal contraception). I think she's just trying to be outrageous and edgy. She's an attention-seeker.

This.
I don’t really like kids on the whole (bar my own most of the time 😆 and a select few family and friends kids) but I’d never be so vile and rude. She’s an attention seeker for sure. I don’t think I would continue to invest in this friendship personally.

Tabbouleh · 08/09/2022 12:45

MzHz · 08/09/2022 12:41

I could have written this too

it always amazes me how other frankly unpleasant people seem to have loads of friends and I have so few

Am often amazed by this too. MN is full of posts like these where peopl

Lippyass · 08/09/2022 12:44

It's probably easier to say you hate kids than admit to everyone, including yourself, that you can't have kids.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 08/09/2022 12:42

I had a friend like this.....I pulled her up on it by saying I get this is the topic she's picked to.show how ' edgy 'she is but she's just making herself look like a dickhead. The resulting silence from everyone else in the group was very telling.

MzHz · 08/09/2022 12:41

Hillrunning · 08/09/2022 11:49

I'm constantly amazed by these stories, I'm friendly, kind, interested in others and don't smell bad and yet I have very very few people who want to hang out with me but somehow these vile people seem to have people like you who are willing to be their friends and only question it when it gets really really bad. Why is this?

She can dislike babies, she shouldn't be rude though and she is just plain stupid to not use contraception.

I could have written this too

it always amazes me how other frankly unpleasant people seem to have loads of friends and I have so few

Rapidtango · 08/09/2022 12:40

She just doesn't sound like a particularly nice person, whether she likes kids or not (there's plenty on Mumsnet who like their own children but aren't keen on other people's). I'd bin her off.

rainbowmilk · 08/09/2022 12:39

I voted YABU but only because I’ve no idea why you’re asking MN why a woman could dislike kids rather than just not hanging out with her anymore. She sounds unpleasant and fair enough that you don’t seem to like her… but you can't have imagined that this thread wouldn’t just be outraged mums calling her names. Just ditch her?

Mumspair1 · 08/09/2022 12:38

More fool you for being friends with someone who gives your DC dirty looks.

Tabbouleh · 08/09/2022 12:37

Edgelord yes. I had a friend like this. I dropped her.

OriginalUsername2 · 08/09/2022 12:33

I would find the way she reacts to actual children quite uncomfortable.

nachoavocado · 08/09/2022 12:32

But she gives my children dirty looks whenever she sees them says all babies are vile and disgusting and is always negative when my children or someone else's children are mentioned in the group chat or in passing. I would ditch her for this. Children are people too.

CrunchyCarrot · 08/09/2022 12:31

I had a friend who hated children - she eventually told me it was because her sister tried to smother her in bed a few times when they were kids. As a result she looks on all children as capable of evil. I don't think it's entirely rational and I do think she needed help for those feelings - and I suggested she should get it, but I sort of understood her perspective after that, even though I didn't agree with it.

WhoWasMark · 08/09/2022 12:25

I have a relative just like this. She’s awful about kids, really hates them. She has three and is okish about her own kids but won’t have birthday parties, play dates or anything like that because of how much she hates kids. She’s been like it since she was a kid herself, no idea why she chose to have kids because it’s rude to ask but I think your friend is doing the right thing not having them if she doesn’t like them.

whumpthereitis · 08/09/2022 12:23

She’s probably performative as a defense against ‘you’ll change your mind!’, or ‘I bet you secretly do!’. Any positive interaction with children leading to ‘you’d be such a good mother, you do want children really’.

Women that don’t want children often do get a lot of pressure placed on them, are disbelieved, and considered poor authorities on themselves and patronized. It can be incredibly frustrating, so some feel a need to prove their stance. Of course then it’s often taken as ‘I bet she does but secretly can’t!’, which just increases the frustration and hostility.

I don’t think she’s wrong about the abortion thing. No idea why she doesn’t use contraception, but that’s her business.

Swipe left for the next trending thread