Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To rehome my puppy or stick it out

85 replies

Boujisboo · 08/09/2022 09:00

I got a second puppy (already have a 2 year old)
I absolutely adore him to pieces but he’s very hard and different to my first. He isn’t taking to toilet training well, he’s eating his own poo, plus I’m working And have recently broken my hand which makes it harder. He’s 16 weeks and lovely but I’m finding myself getting angry with him for doing puppy things because it’s so hard with my hand.
mow my 2 year old is starting to just puss in then house too!
my ds will be distraught and probably never forgive me but I just don’t know if I can do it anymore even though I know I’ll miss him terribly

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GetThatHelmetOn · 27/12/2022 09:16

Moneymoneymoney1979 · 08/09/2022 09:09

Still early days for toilet training. Eating poo indicates boredom, something lacking nutritionally or an unclean breeder.

… or pup “hidding” it’s sins to avoid being told off.

Get these 2 books:

  • How to house break your dog in a week
  • The Gina Ford guide to potty training.

The first one, I swear by it, have trained several dogs including problematic rescues and different ages and they all were clean in less than a week.

The second one, as controversial as Gina Ford might be, she is certainly right on how to identify when your kid is ready for the potty.

Whatever you do, don’t try both at the same time. Start with the dog to remove a lot of the stress quickly and then try again with your child.

Flat04 · 10/09/2022 19:11

I saw that you mentioned struggling financially, so I can understand not feeling in a position to shell out for a crate. Can you make the pen more crate-like by sectioning it off so he doesn't have the run of the whole thing?

hedgehogscrossing · 10/09/2022 18:24

You could try crate training now, I don't think its too late. Our 13 week terrier cross actually likes her crate, she knows that mid morning she goes in and naps for at least an hour and a half. It means I can get on with stuff and I know she's safe. I actually wanted to have her sleep on my bed now she's a bit bigger but she jumps off and goes in crate. Maybe try literally 2/3 min with a treat and build up. I leave toys in there if I am downstairs but take everything out at night.

Frances658 · 10/09/2022 18:01

And as lots of people get a crate for their puppies, which they then grow out of, there must be loads knocking about 2nd hand.

Frances658 · 10/09/2022 17:57

Yes I agree with the PPs, I'd just bite the bullet and crate train him. I think it will really help with the toilet training, they don't like to go in their "den". I don't think a pen will help very much with that, there's too much space, he'll just decide that one end of it is his toilet, and it will be more difficult for him to understand that he can't go to the toilet inside. I agree with @Flat04 , I'd get a crate that's just big enough for him to stretch out in. It will encourage him to sleep (my puppy sleeps much better when he's actually shut in his crate, he's far less distracted), and puppies are supposed to sleep for most of the day.

Flat04 · 10/09/2022 16:22

I'm sorry things are difficult. We have a 3 year old dog and 4.5 month puppy who's actually a really easy puppy, but the relentlessness of even easy puppies is hard work. I feel like I've barely been able to relax for a second since we brought her home, and I have a husband and teens to share the burden and no broken hand, so I can totally understand why you're at the end of your rope. I think it's great that you recognise you're overwhelmed and are reaching out for suggestions. You're doing amazingly at taking the advice on board, but one thing that jumped out at me is this.

iv brought a little puppy pad thing for indoors for when I’m at work (I work school hours but lots of working home so rarely left with my other dog for more than 2 hours) iv decided to put their toys and things in the kitchen which is small when im gone,

I honestly think leaving a 16 week-old puppy alone for 2 hours if not in a crate is almost guaranteeing much harder work for yourself. If you can't be right there with him, I think he needs to be confined to a very small space, and preferably sleeping. Otherwise he has way too much freedom to form bad habits, which can be very hard to break. If you're going to be out, I think you need to make sure he's been tired out, give him a frozen kong and put him in a crate or pen. I'm another person who believes puppy pads are confusing, especially if he's already developed the habit of going in the house.

Good luck OP. Keep at it and won't be long before you all have a great companion!

autienotnaughty · 09/09/2022 22:57

The 'teen' months are tough!! My lab ate his poo 🤢 he grew out of that after a few months but I also made sure his food was good quality. He's 18m now and still mouthing/chewing tho he has improved.

Boujisboo · 09/09/2022 22:45

romdowa · 09/09/2022 21:47

I've a 15 week old cockerpoo and I'm right there with you. Between the toilet training being impossible and the nipping, we are tearing our hair out and have threatened to rehome ddog several times an hour 🤣

i sympathise! So badly. I think it’s ok to vent it’s what’s bloody got me through.

OP posts:
Boujisboo · 09/09/2022 22:43

He just did a poo outside (took am hour) but he didn’t even try and eat it! I’m so so so happy and proud of him! The fact he didn’t try and eat it is amazing to me he was so happy with himself too

OP posts:
romdowa · 09/09/2022 21:47

I've a 15 week old cockerpoo and I'm right there with you. Between the toilet training being impossible and the nipping, we are tearing our hair out and have threatened to rehome ddog several times an hour 🤣

ZuzuSusu · 09/09/2022 21:42

You're doing great OP. Puppy blues are so normal, can I ask what breed? We have a two year old dog of a known to be very stupid breed and she is just now fully potty trained. We do a puppy pad for her at night because she has a tiny bladder and we praise her for using it, she tries very hard to be good and use the pad. I'm so glad we stuck with it, when she went through her terror phase I was having mobility issues and all the training just went tits up, so very similar to your situation, it's sounds like you're doing a lot of fantastic and practical stuff to make things better.

Brigante9 · 09/09/2022 21:26

Get rid of the puppy pads, allowing and encouraging peeing in the house just means he’ll be even harder to toilet train.

Crate train, it’s been great for my two, one of whom is destructive. You have to pick up poo immediately. One of mine really likes the older dog’s poo, it’s hideous! Try to get into a routine of morning toileting then picking up, crating him then supervise play time so you can prevent accidents/pick up poo asap. One of mine was 5 months before he was properly toilet trained (excited puppy pee pants, used to sprinkle with excitement, thank god it stopped!)

Puppy blues are awful. I’ve known so many people give away young puppies. Some are just so hard. Mine have finally decided that they’ll stay in bed quietly until I get up at 6.30 rather than squeak at 5, they’re a year old now. 🙈

Boujisboo · 09/09/2022 20:49

I did know what I was taking on I thoight for. Year before o got another one but I never expected to split with my partner and break my hand. Iv got some great advice from people who have understood this anf it’s really given me the stregnth to reset today and go at it with a fresh attitude. Iv taken him everywhere with me today and he’s had accidents of course but I feel these are in control and I’m on it and we are both progressing. He’s a lovely little thing and I could cry about how I felt yesterday.
but onwards and upwards and in realising it’s better for me if I have boundaries

OP posts:
Cw112 · 09/09/2022 13:08

They are still so little and only learning. You need to preserve, you took this responsibility on when you decided to get the puppy. It's really hard going at the start our dog is really high energy breed who just turned 1 and it was tough at the start but now he's great. Things we found helped: crate training, keeping a bag of kibble always to hand to reward all positive behaviour, spend time training in quiet areas and then build up background distractions gradually, attend puppy and adolescent training classes, avoid losing your temper or scolding as gentle correction and positive reinforcement will serve better in the long run.

KarmaStar · 09/09/2022 11:16

The puppy blues is common,if you are usually a loving,responsible,caring owner then stick with it.if you arent,or can't be,re home the poor pup.
these are very important weeks for your pup,he's learning all the time so you need to get rid of the taking your pain out on the pup for immediate starters.He won't forget any good turns or any bad ones.
bond with him.put time into his training,get a routine going for both dogs ,they love routine,and this includes back to basics with both about toilet training.pup will copy older dog so toilet training now is essential,after food,drinks,sleeps,games,out you go into the garden,see them circle and sniff indoors,out you go..
it is hard work but so worth it.

HairyMothballs · 09/09/2022 08:43

When you got the puppy (I presume at 12 weeks?), you must have known how long he's likely to live, and what his needs are? And you're fed-up with his behaviour already? Could you get a trainer?

Just remember - you've got a partner/friends/relatives/workmates/neighbours/social media/tv, etc., etc. The puppy has been taken from his mum and siblings, and only has YOU

Fearneyox · 09/09/2022 08:32

Sounds great, do what YOU want to do regarding the crate/pen - it’s your sanity at the end of the day. A question you asked earlier - I’d only crate when you are not with him personally, if you’re in the kitchen I’d let him mooch about with you so he has some stimulation and so you can jump on him with the pooping if necessary x

Boujisboo · 09/09/2022 08:25

Fearneyox · 09/09/2022 08:15

I always caution again puppy pads, they’re very confusing for a puppy as they’re being constantly told to not go inside the house, but suddenly they can go on this soft piece of floor? But not the rest of the floor? It can sometimes make things harder and more confusing for them. If you have wipeable floors I’d bin the puppy pads and stick it out, obviously if you want to save your carpets though that’s fair enough 😅 good luck x

I know but a friend suggested one in the same place all the time I won’t be upset if it doesn’t work as Kitcgen is laminate

OP posts:
Boujisboo · 09/09/2022 08:24

Fearneyox · 09/09/2022 08:17

Also there is nothing wrong with crate training. A lot of puppies actually see the crate as their safe space and grow to love it. Lots of mental stimulation (snuffle mats etc) and play before you crate and a few toys inside it and most puppies will settle nicely in them x

I did it with my elder one and he was very good with toilet training I think this one really needs it. I have a dog pen and can’t really afford a crate right now so will use that it’s just open wired will make it all nice for him x

OP posts:
Fearneyox · 09/09/2022 08:17

Also there is nothing wrong with crate training. A lot of puppies actually see the crate as their safe space and grow to love it. Lots of mental stimulation (snuffle mats etc) and play before you crate and a few toys inside it and most puppies will settle nicely in them x

Fearneyox · 09/09/2022 08:15

I always caution again puppy pads, they’re very confusing for a puppy as they’re being constantly told to not go inside the house, but suddenly they can go on this soft piece of floor? But not the rest of the floor? It can sometimes make things harder and more confusing for them. If you have wipeable floors I’d bin the puppy pads and stick it out, obviously if you want to save your carpets though that’s fair enough 😅 good luck x

Boujisboo · 09/09/2022 08:04

Will set the big play pen up but by bit throughout today to put him in when I’m even in kitchen for mow.
do you think I should just do this through the day (as sleep in hallway with my big dog is working well

OP posts:
Boujisboo · 09/09/2022 08:00

Subaru4336 · 08/09/2022 20:51

Is he crate trained? If so, if you're not able to supervise him, e.g., when you're on calls, crate him. He'll likely sleep as he's so young, and pups sleep the majority of a 24hr period. Then you can take him outside when you're done. Anytime you can't watch him, put him in the crate, otherwise you're just setting him up to fail.

He’s not I got heavily criticise for it by my family and gave in! Regretting it now

OP posts:
Boujisboo · 09/09/2022 07:59

Update

so last night I kept then
in the upstairs hall with a stair gate as that’s quite enclosed and I couldn’t put the gate up.

took them out first thing and they both weed which was so good and gave them loads of praise and sweets! Came in done their breakfast and looked and saw a big poo on sofa. He did go to eat it I said no and he walked off so I could pick it up.

whilst doing so big wee on the floor. I just cleared it up.
will get pen out today and keep going!

OP posts:
takemetomars · 08/09/2022 20:58

TheHumanExperience · 08/09/2022 09:54

I house trained my puppy in week. 7 years later and she's never had an accident in the house.

What did I do? I treated the task like a full time job.
Puppy was crate trained into a crate not too big. This way she had her safe space where she was happy.

Nighttime: Every time she came out of her crate (overnight) she was picked up and carried to the garden. This didn't allow accidents en route. Any noise during the night from pup, I immediately shot up (no matter how tired, raining etc), quickly downstairs (no words to pup), carried pup to the garden and waited in silence. No other interaction just a calm good girl when toileted, nothing more and back into her crate until morning. Unless of course she barked again. Then it was up again. The investment was worth it.

Daytime: I turned into a hawk. Tied to me with an indoor training lead a puppy will ALWAYS give sign they need to go.

Daytime: After ever drink and every meal, straight out into the garden. No words, just wait and watch until the deed is done. Then crazy praise and a tiny treat STRAIGHT after.

Then moving forward, when she was toileting I add a word.... we used wee wee, or quickly, every time she went. Followed by the praise and infrequent treat reward.

She now goes on command.

A second dog especially a puppy, is a little like having a second child. Sounds like a great idea, but in reality is so much harder than you thought. You must have evaluated this before buying a new puppy. It's only fair to put the required work in, to give the pup the very best chance of having a loving secure home for life.

This is the effort we have put in to both of ours (18 months old and 7 months old). I really don't understand anyone who doesn't tbh