Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I could not be funded by a man" - Really?

978 replies

aokii · 08/09/2022 08:59

I have noticed that this line, " I could not be funded by a man" is often trotted out on here. Frequently, it is directed at SAHMs.

I take issue with this for two reasons -

  1. Unless you are in the type of marriage where you have totally separate funds, you are inevitably being "funded by a man" to a greater or lesser extent anyway - particularly if you are the lower earner or you work part-time.

  2. Unlike in families where there are two working parents, a family with a SAHM is not going to be paying childcare costs. So although the SAHM is obviously not doing paid work, her role is still a direct and significant saving.

No doubt people will come on now and talk about "financial vulnerability," re- SAHMs and this is a fair point. However, it is far from a given that SAHMs are any more financially vulnerable than the next woman. Nobody should ever just assume this.

I'm aware that there will be many women who earn more than their husbands and have separate finances. There will be couples who both work flexibly around each other and will argue a SAHP would not be a saving for them as they don't need to use childcare anyway, etc etc. But I less interested in personal anecdotes. I'm talking more generally about the vast majority of families with parents who both work and have shared finances. Could they honestly say they could maintain the same lifestyle without their DH's income coming into the household? If "no," then they are at least part-funded by a man surely?

AIBU to say that before tossing out the line, "I could not be funded by a man," people on here should look at themselves.

OP posts:
Waferbiscuit · 16/09/2022 23:38

I have mostly been single throughout my life so am pretty self funded. It's hard.

What baffles me is that there are women who have never worked or worked part time who get a house, car, holidays, clothes etc just through the transaction of marriage with a man. Wow! Many of them could never afford close to the lifestyle they're living and I often wonder if they think 'I work 2days a week but got this lifestyle that is far better than my salary allows'.

What's off putting is some women have a sense of entitlement as if maybe just by being a woman one deserves someone to pay one's way. All the work that goes into presenting oneself deserves a reward in the end, right?

Thereisnolight · 16/09/2022 22:47

TokidokiBarbie · 15/09/2022 23:08

And given feminism is the reason I can vote, own property

Not really. It was more the end of the war, during which women had stepped up and taken over many men's duties, and the fact that other countries like Australia had already given women the vote, making Britain look behind the times. The average man didn't have the vote until women did.

Only rich men and those who had fought in the war could vote previously. I'm not even convinced many of the suffragettes really cared whether their maids got the vote as many seemed to be rich women who wanted what their husbands had. Some historians even believe they hindered the cause by attempting to set bombs off in churches etc and blinding innocent postal workers with letter bombs.

I'm not sure I see them as heroes tbh. Anyone who attempts to bomb the innocent public is morally equivalent to Al Queda really.

Completely agree.

TokidokiBarbie · 15/09/2022 23:08

And given feminism is the reason I can vote, own property

Not really. It was more the end of the war, during which women had stepped up and taken over many men's duties, and the fact that other countries like Australia had already given women the vote, making Britain look behind the times. The average man didn't have the vote until women did.

Only rich men and those who had fought in the war could vote previously. I'm not even convinced many of the suffragettes really cared whether their maids got the vote as many seemed to be rich women who wanted what their husbands had. Some historians even believe they hindered the cause by attempting to set bombs off in churches etc and blinding innocent postal workers with letter bombs.

I'm not sure I see them as heroes tbh. Anyone who attempts to bomb the innocent public is morally equivalent to Al Queda really.

User112 · 15/09/2022 22:44

MingeofDeath · 15/09/2022 07:58

I don't think that it is "being funded by a man" that is the actual issue. Many women who are sahp and post on here complaining about their situation have no way to be financially independent. Nothing wrong with being a sahp but they should always have the ability to support themselves in case something happens.

Exactly!

5128gap · 15/09/2022 22:31

TokidokiBarbie · 15/09/2022 21:04

I reject feminism based on my observation of feminists. 😂 Sadly, it's become a bit like the men's rights scene.

At face value who wouldn't support men's rights, but in reality it's become overrun with incels and misogynists, just like how feminism harbors a lot of embittered negative women that just don't seem to like men.

Most of us want equality but also want a partner and to get on with men, not elope to some feminist utopia free of all those with a penis.

I'm not sure you can really liken women telling other women to get men to do more childcare to men telling other men to rape and murder women. Yes some women dont like men and are vocal about it on this women centred forum. But truly, what risk does that pose to men, their safety and their 'rights'?
And given feminism is the reason I can vote, own property, now have at least a level of protection from some of the worst discrimination I encountered at work when I was younger, and actually have the choice whether to work or stay home in the first place...if the odd woman wants to criticise my domestics or disapprove of my lipstick, it's a small price to pay. I can always argue my corner if I think she's wrong.

TokidokiBarbie · 15/09/2022 21:04

5128gap · 15/09/2022 17:27

Its a bit daft those saying they reject feminism on the basis of some strident disagreement about being funded by a man. Talk about throwing the baby out with the bath water!
I've been on the wrong side of the feminist debate about cosmetic surgery, make up and so forth, many times. But that's fine, I'm comfortable with my choices where that's concerned and know that I can be supportive of an ideology that strives to improve things for women without being a poster child for every single feminist ideal.

I reject feminism based on my observation of feminists. 😂 Sadly, it's become a bit like the men's rights scene.

At face value who wouldn't support men's rights, but in reality it's become overrun with incels and misogynists, just like how feminism harbors a lot of embittered negative women that just don't seem to like men.

Most of us want equality but also want a partner and to get on with men, not elope to some feminist utopia free of all those with a penis.

murderousbiscuits · 15/09/2022 18:11

Topgub · 15/09/2022 17:09

Did you name change just to say that?

😬

😂 as if!

5128gap · 15/09/2022 17:27

Its a bit daft those saying they reject feminism on the basis of some strident disagreement about being funded by a man. Talk about throwing the baby out with the bath water!
I've been on the wrong side of the feminist debate about cosmetic surgery, make up and so forth, many times. But that's fine, I'm comfortable with my choices where that's concerned and know that I can be supportive of an ideology that strives to improve things for women without being a poster child for every single feminist ideal.

Topgub · 15/09/2022 17:09

Did you name change just to say that?

😬

murderousbiscuits · 15/09/2022 16:52

It's is rather, thanks.

Topgub · 15/09/2022 16:34

@murderousbiscuits

Good for you?

murderousbiscuits · 15/09/2022 16:30

The difference is obvious. To me anyway
Predictable. I'm not offended though so your wrong.

aokii · 15/09/2022 16:02

People are very patient with you to be honest Topgub and you only really have one point, so not much to debate.

OP posts:
Topgub · 15/09/2022 15:57

@aokii

I'm crushed.

🤣

You're not the first to criticise me abd I doubt you'll be the last. Its common when people can't debate the actual points.

Good job I dont care either way eh?

Topgub · 15/09/2022 15:55

Why do people name change so often on this site?

Its weird.

@murderousbiscuits

Yes, that's correct.

The difference is obvious. To me anyway

murderousbiscuits · 15/09/2022 15:47

I dont judge women who don't want to work personally. That's their choice to make. But even if I did, so what?! Why would they even care?

People judge working mothers all the time in far worse ways than sahms ever are.

Do I care? Not even a tiny bit. I mean I'll argue to the death they're taking shite but I don't care or feel judged on a personal level

It really baffles me the pure utter absolute offence that sahms take to their role being criticised.

When SAHMs reply to you, you always accuse them of being offended. Yet when you reply it's just you arguing 'they're talking shite'.

Kennykenkencat · 15/09/2022 15:42

How does this work when as a male/female couple you get a mortgage.
If a man out earns you, do you not take account of his income and get a smaller mortgage/place because living in a bigger house would mean your husband was supporting you to have a larger house.

What happens if you split up and have to sell?
Do you only take the percentage increase of what you could have afforded on your own. Or do you split the larger amount 50/50

If you are married or in a ltr you are a team.
I would find it odd that someone would be so rigid in not taking any support.
I would think someone didn’t want a ltr relationship and was putting boundaries up.
It comes across as separating yourself from the team.

If you are in a ltr whether married or not there are times when your partner/husband needs your support and there are times when you need support from him.

I would say if you never want to be supported by a man then don’t get into a relationship. Life can throw some real hard times at you even if you have planned and put everything in place to cover all possible outcomes. Not to accept help at any point from the person you share your life with will just make a shitty situation needlessly worse

aokii · 15/09/2022 15:35

I am critical if your posting style yes, because you badger people with inane questions and the same set phrases over and over. I don't think you even realise when you're insulting people and there is never any nuance or development to your arguments.

OP posts:
Topgub · 15/09/2022 15:29

Huh.

And you have the cheek to say Your logic process and the way you interpret what people say to you seems to be slightly different about me?

🤣

I didnt say anyone criticised my family set up. I said they criticised me.

aokii · 15/09/2022 15:25

How could I possibly criticise you or your family set-up Topgub. What is there to even say? "I'm Toogub and I work and so does my DH but at different times and we have some family help." Er, ok. Why on earth would anyone have an issue with that?

OP posts:
Topgub · 15/09/2022 15:24

No one has criticised you

Yes they have

Well it's your own fault, we don't like what you say or how you say it!

🤣

aokii · 15/09/2022 15:22

You (and some others to be fair) have twisted the thread to a different thread altogether. My point in the OP was what it was.

Its not the fact you disagree. Not at all. It's the way you disagree. Your logic process and the way you interpret what people say to you seems to be slightly different, let's just say that.

OP posts:
Topgub · 15/09/2022 15:16

And you and others have repeatedly criticised me so don't act all coy now.

Topgub · 15/09/2022 15:15

Ummm.

One of the first comments on this thread (now deleted) was someone saying that women who worked couldn't get someone to fund them and I very obviously meant in general. Not just on your thread

If you didn't want discuss your op, why post it?

aokii · 15/09/2022 15:05

Nobody is criticising you or you family set-up Topgub. Not one iota. Not one person has criticised you or your family or any family with working parents on this thread.

Yet you have been here persistently pontificating about SAHMs for five days.

Can you really not see the difference?

OP posts: