Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I could not be funded by a man" - Really?

978 replies

aokii · 08/09/2022 08:59

I have noticed that this line, " I could not be funded by a man" is often trotted out on here. Frequently, it is directed at SAHMs.

I take issue with this for two reasons -

  1. Unless you are in the type of marriage where you have totally separate funds, you are inevitably being "funded by a man" to a greater or lesser extent anyway - particularly if you are the lower earner or you work part-time.

  2. Unlike in families where there are two working parents, a family with a SAHM is not going to be paying childcare costs. So although the SAHM is obviously not doing paid work, her role is still a direct and significant saving.

No doubt people will come on now and talk about "financial vulnerability," re- SAHMs and this is a fair point. However, it is far from a given that SAHMs are any more financially vulnerable than the next woman. Nobody should ever just assume this.

I'm aware that there will be many women who earn more than their husbands and have separate finances. There will be couples who both work flexibly around each other and will argue a SAHP would not be a saving for them as they don't need to use childcare anyway, etc etc. But I less interested in personal anecdotes. I'm talking more generally about the vast majority of families with parents who both work and have shared finances. Could they honestly say they could maintain the same lifestyle without their DH's income coming into the household? If "no," then they are at least part-funded by a man surely?

AIBU to say that before tossing out the line, "I could not be funded by a man," people on here should look at themselves.

OP posts:
Topgub · 11/09/2022 00:46

My son was described as a metrosexual as a 3 yo. By adult women

Because he liked dolls, hoovering, kitchens and cleaning. He's been 'accused' of being gay his whole life.

My dad, born in the 50s (just) parent in the 70s was an equal parent. My fil, with no mil, watched my kids in his 70s and still does almost 90
Age isn't an excuse.

My own set up is shared childcare from birth. Dh has been as equally responsible for his children as I have been since they were born

There's really no excuse for it to be any other way

AprilRae91 · 11/09/2022 00:44

I wonder if OP is embarrassed that they don’t have a decent career and their husbands/partners eclipses theirs, and that’s why they felt the need to post this thread.

Sidonien · 11/09/2022 00:27

Topgub · 10/09/2022 19:59

@KateColumbo

Am I teaching boys?

Yes, I'm teaching my boy to be a feminist

That's great to hear top. I think the attitude change has really got to start with boys in childhood. Their fathers need to model the role they want their boys to take, being more involved in childcare themselves. Little boys need to be encouraged to be nurturing and gentle, playing with dolls, kitchens, ironing, helping out around the house and with younger siblings from toddler age.

We need to stop accepting more aggressive behaviour from boys than girls (no more 'boys will be boys'). These things are changing. If I think of the role my grandfathers played in childcare and at home compared to the role my DH plays, there is a huge difference in attitude between them towards the role of fatherhood. I know lots of dads our age who have changed their working patterns to let them be home more, and a few who stay at home with the kids full time, or work part-time while wife is FT.

What's your own childcare set up, if you feel able to say?

Topgub · 10/09/2022 20:33

@KateColumbo

Sure

KateColumbo · 10/09/2022 20:06

@Topgub
So higher taxes than?

Topgub · 10/09/2022 20:00

Paid for by the govt

Not, sure. Sweden?

Topgub · 10/09/2022 19:59

@KateColumbo

Am I teaching boys?

Yes, I'm teaching my boy to be a feminist

KateColumbo · 10/09/2022 19:50

By not teaching girls they should be the default parent or to accept that their male ohs career is always more important than theirs
Are you teaching boys that mothers don't have to be the default parent or that their career isn't more important than their OH's? Or is this just the girls responsibility?

By making mat and pat pay equal. By not having women taking 1 year mat leave as standard (not actually sure it is standard outside of mc)
I had my first before the statutory 52 weeks mat leave was introduced. It wasn't great for lots of reasons IMO. Nobody has to take the full 52 but women in the UK are fortunate to have the option.

By teaching couples to discuss childcare before they decide to have kids.
Many do and it's obviously prudent to but how would you enforce it though.
Even if you could the best laid plans can have a spanner in the works.

By providing fully subsidised childcare
Paid for by?

Following more of a Scandinavian model.
Which parts?
I think it's Denmark who have recently changed parental leave policy as despite it being generous for both parents fewer fathers were taking advantage.
Sweden gets longer parental leave than the UK at 16 months.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 10/09/2022 18:30

The oh sahms all devote their time to volunteering and communities only gets trotted out when it suits. And contradicts all the I chose to be a sahm to devote myself to my children's needs pish

I think they're different demographics for the most part. Of my social group of sahms, the women who do the most volunteering tend to be the ones who had children later in life (late 30s/40s), who had careers before hand and who are perhaps trailing spouses, have husbands who work away for weeks or months at a time or like me, were very ill after childbirth. Our local home start volunteers for example are mostly comprised of these with a few women who took early retirement.

Of the women I've met in person who insist they had to be sahms for their children, they tend to be younger or at least younger when they had kids and do less outside the house. Less likely to be degree educated and less likely to have had a career previously.

Topgub · 10/09/2022 17:13

@Sidonien

By not teaching girls they should be the default parent or to accept that their male ohs career is always more important than theirs

By making mat and pat pay equal. By not having women taking 1 year mat leave as standard (not actually sure it is standard outside of mc)

By teaching couples to discuss childcare before they decide to have kids.

By providing fully subsidised childcare

Following more of a Scandinavian model.

Topgub · 10/09/2022 17:08

@5128gap

Yeah sorry, I was rushing.

The implications being you have to not ever have anything else as your focus.

The oh sahms all devote their time to volunteering and communities only gets trotted out when it suits. And contradicts all the I chose to be a sahm to devote myself to my children's needs pish.

Much like dad's can work and be around for their children but working mums some how can't

StarCourt · 10/09/2022 11:51

I'm 55 and never been financially dependent on anyone and never had a joint account. It did mean I had to pay somebody to look after DD from a very early age though and have always had to use full wraparound school care too.

Sidonien · 10/09/2022 11:46

@Topgub

*Your post said you wanted to see men taking equal leave and going part time /working flexibly.

How do we achieve that?*

Well more companies need to offer equal leave to men. If it's not available to them then they can't take it. That would be a good start! Perhaps it should be made a legal requirement if companies are not willing to offer it. Separate and equal, not shared leave.

Men in the workplace should support and encourage other men who want to do part time hours, particularly those in management positions, they should also take the lead and model flexible working, leaving early to pick up children etc. That would help too.

What do you think could be done to achieve it (if you do think it is desirable too) ?

5128gap · 10/09/2022 11:39

Topgub · 10/09/2022 11:34

@5128gap

Except the argument was how can you be around for your children if you're not physically with them?

Well in the examples I gave the volunteer could be physically with their children.

aokii · 10/09/2022 11:36

Oh dear.

OP posts:
Topgub · 10/09/2022 11:34

@5128gap

Except the argument was how can you be around for your children if you're not physically with them?

rainbowmilk · 10/09/2022 11:29

Topgub · 10/09/2022 11:12

I'd be tempted to remove the recovery time for the mum from the mat leave to a separate leave but I know that would result in women being penalised so that wouldn't work

Pps or physical issue post birth really aren't about childcare

Yeah, I wouldn’t recommend that. I had a medical issue which I won’t go into in detail but essentially it was pretty much identical to carrying a full term baby and then having major abdominal surgery to remove it, plus associated complications due to blood loss etc. I couldn’t (obviously) be classed as someone requiring maternity leave to recover but because it was sick leave, I was under intense pressure to return, and I was quickly unpaid. I took 3.5 months off and went back far before I was ready, because I had no choice. The absence of protection from pregnancy was what left me in that position, and it’s what would happen to others if you separated them out.

(That being said, a year is in my view too generous. Where I am, most women take the full year then their accrued leave on top, so 13 months off. Most also have at least 3 kids, so you can imagine the staffing issues if we added men to it.)

Sidonien · 10/09/2022 11:28

@Topgub

I'd prefer to see equal leave for both parents. Paid equally.

That is exactly what I was describing and advocating for in my post!

Winederlust · 10/09/2022 11:26

aokii · 08/09/2022 09:56

"I have zero respect for anyone using marriage/relationships as a meal ticket"

So in your marriage (if you're in one) I assume you keep totally separate finances - do your own food shopping etc. Divide every bill to the penny? I hope you don't have a joint mortgage? Heaven forbid!

This makes no sense.
You can have an imbalance of earnings or financial contributions in a relationship without one being 'dependent' on the other.
The point is, regardless of relative income, if you were to separate, would you be able to support yourself?

Everyone and everyone's relationship is different. My DH contributes more overall financially but I'm certainly not 'dependent' on him. I have ensured that my own financial position means I could quite easily have a comfortable life without him.

5128gap · 10/09/2022 11:22

Topgub · 10/09/2022 09:52

Hang on.

I thought it was being argued that sahms chose to be sahms so the could be around for their children?

How can they be around for them if they're off volunteering and studying? Who's watching your kids?!

The idea that all sahms nobly give up all their time for others is laughable. A large proportion of sahms are forced into it through lack of childcare. They're not volunteering or studying

Volunteering carries no obligation and is flexible. I guarantee there will be a voluntary role of one type or another that doesnt take time away from childcare, unless the SAHM is literally chained to her child 24 hours a day.
Examples I personally know of are:
A woman coaching a sports team for girls in a deprived neighbourhood 2 hours a week after her partner gets home.
A woman who logs in and answers a telephone helpline from home, as and when she's available to do so.
A woman who gives lifts to people for hospital appointments and takes her toddler with her.
A man who walks the dog of a disabled woman for an hour a week, which could easily be done with a child in tow.
Im not for a moment suggesting that all SAHMs volunteer. Merely that it's a way they can contribute beyond their immediate family if they choose to.

aokii · 10/09/2022 11:21

User112 - is that you, Andrew Tate?

OP posts:
User112 · 10/09/2022 11:19

Topgub · 10/09/2022 09:52

Hang on.

I thought it was being argued that sahms chose to be sahms so the could be around for their children?

How can they be around for them if they're off volunteering and studying? Who's watching your kids?!

The idea that all sahms nobly give up all their time for others is laughable. A large proportion of sahms are forced into it through lack of childcare. They're not volunteering or studying

And when kids are off to school, they find utterly ridiculous excuses to continue to sit at home.

These women expect the partner to “help” with chores while they do nothing to “help” put food on the table!!

Wait till these hypocrites to start complaining when their darling sons end up with women just like them!

Sidonien · 10/09/2022 11:15

Topgub · 10/09/2022 10:56

@Sidonien

Why does the mother need the first year?!

Why doesn't the dad get the first year to bond?

Most women don't take a year to recover and most don't breastfeed past 6 weeks.

They could do it the other way round if they chose, but physically it probably makes most sense for the mother to go first. Conventionally it would be a year, so the point I was making was that the mother could take the first year and then the father the second year. Some of that would be unpaid though, and like I said, the rest would be half pay. So either of them could take less than a year if they wanted to.

aokii · 10/09/2022 11:12

I also agree that parental leave should be more flexible for dads. Definitely. Whether they take it or not is another matter.

OP posts:
Topgub · 10/09/2022 11:12

I'd be tempted to remove the recovery time for the mum from the mat leave to a separate leave but I know that would result in women being penalised so that wouldn't work

Pps or physical issue post birth really aren't about childcare

Swipe left for the next trending thread