Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a windfall tax would prevent investment in renewables at a time when we need them most

63 replies

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 08:59

This may be an unpopular view, but people need to hear it. The vast profits being made by our energy companies look disgusting but are a once-in-a-generation opportunity for them to invest in alternatives to fossil fuels. They are building wind farms etc, and investing in future technologies such as modern nuclear power stations and fusion. This investment is the only way to wean us off fossil fuels such as gas. If Government takes the profits as a windfall tax, it would be a populist act that many would approve of, but they would then have to hand the money back to the same companies to subsidise their investment activities.

Disclaimer: I've never voted Conservative in my life, but I am objective and open to seeing the logic in some Conservative policies.

OP posts:
allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:21

NanooCov · 08/09/2022 09:18

Their annual reports are heavily greenwashed.

Windfall profits will (in the majority) be going to shareholders not to reinvestment.

You have been heavily red-washed by your social media feed. Putting false info into annual reports is a serious offence and companies wouldn't last long if they did it. (Marketing is different, and sometimes does stray into greenwashing, or at least has in the past).

OP posts:
GonnaNeedABiggerGoat · 08/09/2022 09:18

profits aren't invested back into the companies

I don't think it's anywhere near that clear cut.

www.niesr.ac.uk/blog/windfall-tax-good-idea

NanooCov · 08/09/2022 09:18

Their annual reports are heavily greenwashed.

Windfall profits will (in the majority) be going to shareholders not to reinvestment.

Anothernamechangeplease · 08/09/2022 09:17

So are you proposing that we should legislate to force the energy companies to invest their excess profits in this way, or are you just hoping that they'll do the right thing?

What proportion of their profits would you be expecting them to invest?

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:13

Brefugee · 08/09/2022 09:10

What evidence do we have that the energy companies would use their excess (and excessive) profits to reinvest. The lesson of the Water Companies not investing in infrastructure should be a lesson here.

Read their annual reports. The evidence is there.

OP posts:
allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:12

We've never needed gas storage before now, and its not a sensible investment for the future as gas is going to run out soon..We need investment in alternatives to gas.

OP posts:
Brefugee · 08/09/2022 09:10

What evidence do we have that the energy companies would use their excess (and excessive) profits to reinvest. The lesson of the Water Companies not investing in infrastructure should be a lesson here.

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:10

Less money = slower change.

OP posts:
MostlyHappyMummy · 08/09/2022 09:10

profits aren't invested back into the companies
if they were, we'd still have gas storage in this country so wouldn't need to buy gas on open market
and we wouldn't have water pipes leaking out more than a third of our water supply
nor have raw sewage being dumped into our waterways
the gaslighting my the government and energy companies is shocking
but more shocking is how the public just fall for it all

Randomword6 · 08/09/2022 09:09

It's not a case of either or. The profits can be partially channeled into funding renewables.

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:08

@Flammkuchen your reply makes no sense.

The energy firms need the money to build the wind farms, nuclear power stations, etc. This increases the supply of alternative energy, therefore brings the overall cost of energy down.

OP posts:
Flammkuchen · 08/09/2022 09:05

Totally disagree. Let’s say wind power costs £10 per KwH, and renewables companies invested expecting a price of £20 per KwH. If the price is now £100 due to gas shortages, it is a pure windfall gain.

If the price cap limits the price to say £30 per KWH, it’s still an amazing investment.

Conversely, a price of £100 doesn’t encourage extra investment if prices are expected to fall back in the future if the Russia-Ukraine war ends.