Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a windfall tax would prevent investment in renewables at a time when we need them most

63 replies

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 08:59

This may be an unpopular view, but people need to hear it. The vast profits being made by our energy companies look disgusting but are a once-in-a-generation opportunity for them to invest in alternatives to fossil fuels. They are building wind farms etc, and investing in future technologies such as modern nuclear power stations and fusion. This investment is the only way to wean us off fossil fuels such as gas. If Government takes the profits as a windfall tax, it would be a populist act that many would approve of, but they would then have to hand the money back to the same companies to subsidise their investment activities.

Disclaimer: I've never voted Conservative in my life, but I am objective and open to seeing the logic in some Conservative policies.

OP posts:
SleeplessInEngland · 08/09/2022 09:43

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:28

I'm not talking about water companies, They aren't suppliers of oil and gas. I'm talking about energy companies.

Again, the grasp of basic general knowledge is seriously lacking!

It's adorable you think energy companies would act so differently to water companies.

SafeMove · 08/09/2022 09:41

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:30

Rubbish. They are investing in building infrastructure because they know the future is in alternative energy and they want to be the dominant suppliers of that when the oil/gas runs out. They are completely transforming their business models.

Why, exactly, do they want to be dominant future suppliers? You casting around the term 'naivety' looks a bit silly when you say respond with points like this.

MasterBeth · 08/09/2022 09:40

MarshaBradyo · 08/09/2022 09:37

We’ll need this and renewables though?

We need all types full speed

No. We don't need new sources of fossil fuel extraction that will cause irreversible catastrophic climate change. We need to vastly accelerate the transition into renewables. Every pound we spend on fossil fuels and every ton of new carbon we release into the atmosphere is inching us closer to disaster.

All investement should be put into a massive programme of energy conservation and insulation, local sustainable production (solar, air source heat pumps etc), public transport, wind, tidal etc etc, not opening up more gas fields!

MarshaBradyo · 08/09/2022 09:37

We’ll need this and renewables though?

We need all types full speed

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:36

I SPECIFICALLY compared the investment that you think the energy companies will make with the investment the water companies haven't made

Why compare apples and pears? No logic there.

OP posts:
allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:34

The gradually in your reply is the problem. We do';t have time for gardually

Agree. That's why they need the windfall!

OP posts:
Brefugee · 08/09/2022 09:34

I'm not talking about water companies, They aren't suppliers of oil and gas. I'm talking about energy companies.
Again, the grasp of basic general knowledge is seriously lacking!

FFS op don't be an idiot. I SPECIFICALLY compared the investment that you think the energy companies will make with the investment the water companies haven't made. Your basic reading comprehension skills are seriously lacking.

FWIW: I believe that energy (and water) should be nationalised industries. But they need to be run professionally and properly with proper investment. I'm not entirely sure i trust any UK goverment to ensure that.

MarshaBradyo · 08/09/2022 09:33

I thought we needed all energy supplies to have a hope of security

So it will see investment in off shore / renewables etc

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:32

midgetastic · 08/09/2022 09:30

I would excempt anything actually spent directly on renewables but they would need pretty strong evidence

Go an read their company reports They are literally building wind farms and investing in developing fusion technologies and much more.

OP posts:
MasterBeth · 08/09/2022 09:32

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:26

They're not leaving the market. They are transforming themselves to be the alternative energy companies of the future.

The naivity here is seriously worrying - do people honestly believe the likes of BP and Shell are only interested in oil and gas? They've been investing in alternatives for years and are gradually moving away from fossil fuels.

The gradually in your reply is the problem. We do';t have time for gardually. The fossil fuel giants are still investing in new gas and oil fields. Only through legislation and financial penalty will they move at the speed they need to into renewables.

JustTheOneSwan · 08/09/2022 09:30

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:26

They're not leaving the market. They are transforming themselves to be the alternative energy companies of the future.

The naivity here is seriously worrying - do people honestly believe the likes of BP and Shell are only interested in oil and gas? They've been investing in alternatives for years and are gradually moving away from fossil fuels.

I'm all for that but let them pay for the transformation with their substantial profit.
we could go crazy and spend the money we save with a tax on national power companies but instead we are allowing fracking?
how are we going to benefit there, how do we force these fracking companies to sell us gas much lower than market rates?

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:30

Flammkuchen · 08/09/2022 09:27

Investment is made based on the long-term future expected price, not what it is in the next 2 years.

If prices are expected to be temporarily high, and then reduce again, investment will only be made if it is economic at the expected future price, not the short-term high price.

That is why a one-off windfall tax does not deter investment if it is set at a sensible level and is not arbitrary.

Rubbish. They are investing in building infrastructure because they know the future is in alternative energy and they want to be the dominant suppliers of that when the oil/gas runs out. They are completely transforming their business models.

OP posts:
midgetastic · 08/09/2022 09:30

I would excempt anything actually spent directly on renewables but they would need pretty strong evidence

MarshaBradyo · 08/09/2022 09:29

Flammkuchen · 08/09/2022 09:27

Investment is made based on the long-term future expected price, not what it is in the next 2 years.

If prices are expected to be temporarily high, and then reduce again, investment will only be made if it is economic at the expected future price, not the short-term high price.

That is why a one-off windfall tax does not deter investment if it is set at a sensible level and is not arbitrary.

Do you mean the windfall tax that has already happened? So that one off is ok but not again

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:28

Brefugee · 08/09/2022 09:26

Read their annual reports. The evidence is there.

you are Liz Truss and i claim my fiver. There is zero evidence that water companies are investing properly otherwise you wouldn't have shit in your rivers and the sea. The dividend payments show this.

I'm not talking about water companies, They aren't suppliers of oil and gas. I'm talking about energy companies.

Again, the grasp of basic general knowledge is seriously lacking!

OP posts:
Flammkuchen · 08/09/2022 09:27

Investment is made based on the long-term future expected price, not what it is in the next 2 years.

If prices are expected to be temporarily high, and then reduce again, investment will only be made if it is economic at the expected future price, not the short-term high price.

That is why a one-off windfall tax does not deter investment if it is set at a sensible level and is not arbitrary.

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:26

JustTheOneSwan · 08/09/2022 09:22

If you think a corporate juggernaut like Shell would leave the UK power market open for another company or competitors you aren't thinking straight.
Tax or restrictions isn't a deterrent when money can be made the issue is Tories prioritising their business chums and investments before their electorate plebs who get mugged.

They're not leaving the market. They are transforming themselves to be the alternative energy companies of the future.

The naivity here is seriously worrying - do people honestly believe the likes of BP and Shell are only interested in oil and gas? They've been investing in alternatives for years and are gradually moving away from fossil fuels.

OP posts:
Brefugee · 08/09/2022 09:26

Read their annual reports. The evidence is there.

you are Liz Truss and i claim my fiver. There is zero evidence that water companies are investing properly otherwise you wouldn't have shit in your rivers and the sea. The dividend payments show this.

MarshaBradyo · 08/09/2022 09:24

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:23

You're missing the point - there was already investment, but it wasn't enough, and the change was happening too slowly. We need an energy revolution, and if the Government plays its cards rights Putin may inadvertently help to fund one.

Yes we do

We need vast investment in U.K. energy security

Anothernamechangeplease · 08/09/2022 09:24

PestorPeston · 08/09/2022 09:21

If companies reinvest their income in the company there is less profit to tax.

If companies choose to extract vast profits as share dividends and bonuses, then they are choosing to pay tax.

Maybe a certain amount of focus should be placed on the energy market traders and hedgers. When Nordstrom closed wholesale gas prices dropped by 40%.

That's a very good point. Any investment in renewable can be deducted pre-tax, and we can then apply a windfall tax to whatever is left over.

allatwonce · 08/09/2022 09:23

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 08/09/2022 09:21

Power bills already have significant levies enforced for green power investment. These will not be affected by the windfall tax. I have no problems whatsoever with a windfall tax.

You're missing the point - there was already investment, but it wasn't enough, and the change was happening too slowly. We need an energy revolution, and if the Government plays its cards rights Putin may inadvertently help to fund one.

OP posts:
JustTheOneSwan · 08/09/2022 09:22

If you think a corporate juggernaut like Shell would leave the UK power market open for another company or competitors you aren't thinking straight.
Tax or restrictions isn't a deterrent when money can be made the issue is Tories prioritising their business chums and investments before their electorate plebs who get mugged.

PestorPeston · 08/09/2022 09:21

If companies reinvest their income in the company there is less profit to tax.

If companies choose to extract vast profits as share dividends and bonuses, then they are choosing to pay tax.

Maybe a certain amount of focus should be placed on the energy market traders and hedgers. When Nordstrom closed wholesale gas prices dropped by 40%.

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 08/09/2022 09:21

Power bills already have significant levies enforced for green power investment. These will not be affected by the windfall tax. I have no problems whatsoever with a windfall tax.