Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect her to pay?

64 replies

Lavender14 · 08/09/2022 08:40

So a woman on my street who I've previously got on really well with has hit my car and caused a bit of damage. She was annoyed at the time but she backed into my car and there were witnesses so she couldn't really deny blame. Initially she said she would pay for it and said she had a relative who could do the work, however the relative hasn't shown up after weeks of back and forth and now I'm starting to doubt the relative exists. I took the car to get a quote and told her the cost and now she's not replying. How long do I give her to come up with the money? The last thing I want is to make it awkward with someone I live a few doors down from and I know money is probably tight for her especially at the minute so want to be fair, but at the same time I would like the car fixed. Its not off the road with the damage or anything but just has a big dent at the front and green paint scrapes all over it. What would you do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheMatriarchy · 11/04/2023 14:36

I would not have informed her you were going to your insurers as that gives her an opportunity to counter claim and concoct some nonsense about how it was your fault. Call them asap and explain exactly what happened how you were trying to be neighbourly but now realise that was the wrong thing to do. Have some names of witnesses and any other evidence to hand. You are supposed to inform them no matter what btw.

ReadersD1gest · 11/04/2023 13:51

ReadersD1gest · 11/04/2023 13:48

I'm fascinated at the posters declaring that the scuzzy article paying half is reasonable.

This is making it half op's problem, as she can hardly buy half a duvet / mattress / set of bedding.
Why the fuck should op be left with any portion of the replacement bill?

Blush. Think I might be on the wrong thread...

ReadersD1gest · 11/04/2023 13:48

I'm fascinated at the posters declaring that the scuzzy article paying half is reasonable.

This is making it half op's problem, as she can hardly buy half a duvet / mattress / set of bedding.
Why the fuck should op be left with any portion of the replacement bill?

Cherrysoup · 19/02/2023 10:44

She’s taking you for a fool. Stop messing with dates/ultimatums, just tell her you’ve reported it to your insurance as of yesterday.

heretohelpGB · 19/02/2023 10:42

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

hekissedmybottom · 19/02/2023 10:34

I wouldn't expect a skint person to buy anything for obvious reasons.

Beautiful3 · 10/09/2022 21:04

It's gone on too long. Just ring up your insurance with her reg, name and address. Stop chasing her. Do it now, while you still have witnesses, in case she starts denying it.

Honeyroar · 10/09/2022 20:34

Don’t let it drag out any longer. This happened to a friend of mine. I can’t remember the ins and outs, but it was too late to claim through the insurance and she ended up footing the bill herself.

Shinytaps · 10/09/2022 20:30

Phone your insurance asap. I had a dent on my car and I didn’t tell my insurer. I pranged it in a car park. When I phoned to claim for something else they told me I should have informed them of any damage to the car within 24 hours (even if I didn’t intend to claim).

PoshHorseyBird · 10/09/2022 20:16

Are you sure she has insurance? Obviously its illegal not to but people do it. I'd just message her saying you think it's best to go through insurance as shes not paid you and you'll pass the details to your insurance company. Then see if she contacts you. If not go ahead and let your insurance sort it.

Caroffee · 10/09/2022 19:06

She needs to pay up. Go via your insurer as others have said.

Lavender14 · 10/09/2022 18:06

Thanks everyone, I've taken the advice on board and given her a deadline and let her know I'll be informing my insurance if she doesn't pay the quote I've already got. I checked my insurance they don't seem to have a set time to notify them by thank god so fingers crossed we'll get a resolution one way or another. Deffo done with the friendship now I feel like she's really messing me around.

OP posts:
Trytreytray · 10/09/2022 14:24

@Lavender14
You can check on the insurance data base if her car is insured.. you're only supposed to check your own vehicle but I know that people use it free (to check cars they're not responsible for)
Otherwise you can pay a small admin fee to legally check.
Google motor insurance data base England.

Goldbar · 08/09/2022 13:56

Go through insurance. And I would never have someone's 'relative' fix my car unless they operate a reputable car repair business and are prepared to enter into a formal contract with me - as otherwise you have no recourse if the work is badly done.

VictoriaConcordiaCrescit · 08/09/2022 13:37

Through insurance, call today

She's clearly giving you the run around with no intention of paying

Electricstar · 08/09/2022 13:24

You’ve tried to be nice by asking her to pay up before going through insurance. I scratched someone’s car at my old workplace (luckily he fixed cars for a living on weekends lol) and he gave me costs which were minor and I paid him direct and it was sorted within days. It seems easier that way which is why I understand why you didn’t call insures straight away

I think now is time to call insurance though if I’m honest the whole “they’ve got a relative who can fix car” I’ve seen people use that before and nothing come of it. I think you should text her and say look it’s been weeks, I’m going to have to get insurance company involved” or, you don’t have to even tell her to be honest whatever you prefer

abovedecknotbelow · 08/09/2022 13:19

I'm guessing she doesn't have insurance

Lavender14 · 08/09/2022 12:55

Bookworm20 · 08/09/2022 12:17

Just go and see her and say, you want to get it sorted and if she can't sort it by end of next week you'll just have to contact your insurance.

Perhaps she doesn't think the damage was that bad and the quote is now something she can't afford. Either way she needs to let you know and to try and keep things as amicable as possible, give her the deadline type scenario.

I am confused though. If she backed into it and it has a 'big dent at the front' How is there green paint scraps all over the rest of the car? I'm wondering if you're a bit like my dp when it comes to the car, she'd of had to back into it at a fair speed to cause a big dent. Only asking as mine and my partners idea of a big dent is very different. His car had what I would describe as a tiny ding, no bigger than a 1p piece, but he thought it was huge and insisted on getting it all fixed and resprayed. It really makes no difference though, its your car and she damaged it, so regardless she is responsible for paying either through insurance or her own pocket.

I was parked and stationary and she reversed into the front of my car coming out of her drive. She just didn't check if there was another car there when she started reversing. I just mean some of the paint from her car is now scratched onto where the dent is on mine. Its not all over the car, its just over the dent sorry that wasn't very clear. Dent is about the size of a football I think because her car is much bigger and higher than mine. Thanks everyone who's commented i absolutely hate any sort of confrontation and really wanted to work with her but you're right. I'll give her notice and then go through insurance anyways.

OP posts:
PicaK · 08/09/2022 12:38

Check your insurance cover. You may find it's invalid if you don't report accidents. And then that cam be what you tell her

Bookworm20 · 08/09/2022 12:17

Just go and see her and say, you want to get it sorted and if she can't sort it by end of next week you'll just have to contact your insurance.

Perhaps she doesn't think the damage was that bad and the quote is now something she can't afford. Either way she needs to let you know and to try and keep things as amicable as possible, give her the deadline type scenario.

I am confused though. If she backed into it and it has a 'big dent at the front' How is there green paint scraps all over the rest of the car? I'm wondering if you're a bit like my dp when it comes to the car, she'd of had to back into it at a fair speed to cause a big dent. Only asking as mine and my partners idea of a big dent is very different. His car had what I would describe as a tiny ding, no bigger than a 1p piece, but he thought it was huge and insisted on getting it all fixed and resprayed. It really makes no difference though, its your car and she damaged it, so regardless she is responsible for paying either through insurance or her own pocket.

SarahSissions · 08/09/2022 12:03

If she’s at fault your insurance won’t go up. I would write her a letter and say has 2 days to contact you else you will have to contact your insurer

DillonPanthersTexas · 08/09/2022 12:01

I think whatever happens now this friendship is somewhat damaged if not over. Friends don't try and rip you off over damage they have caused to your property.

Notify your insurance company and in the meantime I would make the effort to keep the witnesses engaged and on side as they are the ones who will ensure liability is with this woman alone rather then a contested accident.

Even if this elusive relative does exist are they actually a qualified car bodywork specialist with access to a proper garage and spray shop or some have a go hero bloke from the pub whose work is crap and not guaranteed.

MaggieFS · 08/09/2022 11:50

Well she's not being friendly back is she! Remind her that as she requested you've not gone to your insurers, but you can't wait any longer so you'll be passing it on to your insurers tomorrow.

TrashPandas · 08/09/2022 11:38

Question im stuck on is how long would you give her to come up with the money?

I'd have given her about three days.

Go through insurance.

Trudij123 · 08/09/2022 10:58

I’ve gone YABU PURELY because you should have gone through insurance. Get them on the case ( if you haven’t already - I’ve not RTFT yet) they can chase it.

what a cow for ignoring this!

Swipe left for the next trending thread