Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family won't respect our no screen policy foe DS

343 replies

MoMuM7 · 08/09/2022 07:19

I have a no screen policy for DS (1 yo). Everyone who watches him ie family, childcare knows this. I've recently discovered that my sister has been letting him watch TV for HOURS when he goes over to hers. She loves him to bits but why won't she abide by my rules? Is it really that hard to entertain a child? BTW she's single, lives alone and as far as I can tell has no other responsibilities/distractions that would cause her to plonk DD infront of the telly.
I have now decided she can only see him when I'm around. She's very upset. Family thinks im over reacting. AIBU?

OP posts:
DemelzaandRoss · 08/09/2022 12:11

Sighs..
Your child your rules.
Wherever you go your rules may be difficult to keep. Good luck.
Most of us here have DC. Quite a few will be able to reassure you that nothing awful will happen to your DC if they watch a screen for a bit. Some of them even grow up to be nice people.
Maybe moderation in all things.

CatsandFish · 08/09/2022 12:11

KettrickenSmiled · 08/09/2022 12:08

Your post is so unhinged and ridiculous it says far more about you than me.
What does it say about me?
That I've tried to help OP with constructive advice, which undermines you so you decided to invent a "position" that I hold about TV?
I'm not the one inventing stuff here @CatsandFish so be wary where you cast your kneejerk & unoriginal "unhinged" lest it makes you look a bit silly & lacking in comprehension skills.

The defensiveness for your choice is quite obvious, you are so wrong
What defensiveness?
What choice?
Do enlighten us.

and I think you know it hence your overwrought language, that really ads nothing to the discussion
It's up to OP whether she feels any specific PP has added to her discussion.
Who died & made you Thread Monitor? Also, do you get a special badge?

and doesn't help the OP at all.
What "help" have you offered OP?
What practical advice?
What constructive advice for how to approach her sister?
Yeah, that's right - fuck all.
Whereas if you'd bothered to actually read anything I've written to her ...

If you had any sense you'd withdraw from the thread.
😂😂😂
This is such a delightfully odd mixture of pomposity & feebleness I'm not sure where to start ... so I'll just leave it there for others to rock with laughter at.

That's all I have to say.
Bet you a fiver it isn't.

Biscuit

Some people just really show themselves up. 😂

LuckySantangelo35 · 08/09/2022 12:08

@CatsandFish

noone had to spend every second with a kid when they’re looking after them

KettrickenSmiled · 08/09/2022 12:08

Your post is so unhinged and ridiculous it says far more about you than me.
What does it say about me?
That I've tried to help OP with constructive advice, which undermines you so you decided to invent a "position" that I hold about TV?
I'm not the one inventing stuff here @CatsandFish so be wary where you cast your kneejerk & unoriginal "unhinged" lest it makes you look a bit silly & lacking in comprehension skills.

The defensiveness for your choice is quite obvious, you are so wrong
What defensiveness?
What choice?
Do enlighten us.

and I think you know it hence your overwrought language, that really ads nothing to the discussion
It's up to OP whether she feels any specific PP has added to her discussion.
Who died & made you Thread Monitor? Also, do you get a special badge?

and doesn't help the OP at all.
What "help" have you offered OP?
What practical advice?
What constructive advice for how to approach her sister?
Yeah, that's right - fuck all.
Whereas if you'd bothered to actually read anything I've written to her ...

If you had any sense you'd withdraw from the thread.
😂😂😂
This is such a delightfully odd mixture of pomposity & feebleness I'm not sure where to start ... so I'll just leave it there for others to rock with laughter at.

That's all I have to say.
Bet you a fiver it isn't.

MeridianB · 08/09/2022 12:06

Your sister should respect your decision. But she doesn’t. So I’d suggest no more time at her flat. If she wants to spend time with him, she can come with your house or to the park or activities or take him herself. But sitting in a flat watching TV is not quality time.

CatsandFish · 08/09/2022 12:05

Authenticity2020 · 08/09/2022 12:04

YANBU to supervise visits if someone is being untrustworthy, doesn’t matter who it is. It is a matter of respect for you as a parent, it’s no one else’s right to pass judgment on your personal parenting boundaries. Your sister may be happy for her child to have lots of screen time one day (if she goes on to have kiddos), my DS has much more screen time than I thought I’d ever give him before I became a mum, but hey, I respect the fact that some people have strict rules and that’s up to them. As a sister, or friend, or in whatever capacity I am to them, I would respect their rules. It’s not unreasonable to have those looking after your child, to respect your rules.

Well said. And that, is what this topic is about. Not any poster's beliefs on screen time or their guilty consciences, but the OP being respected as a parent and her wishes respected.

Authenticity2020 · 08/09/2022 12:04

YANBU to supervise visits if someone is being untrustworthy, doesn’t matter who it is. It is a matter of respect for you as a parent, it’s no one else’s right to pass judgment on your personal parenting boundaries. Your sister may be happy for her child to have lots of screen time one day (if she goes on to have kiddos), my DS has much more screen time than I thought I’d ever give him before I became a mum, but hey, I respect the fact that some people have strict rules and that’s up to them. As a sister, or friend, or in whatever capacity I am to them, I would respect their rules. It’s not unreasonable to have those looking after your child, to respect your rules.

Bpdqueen · 08/09/2022 11:58

So your telling your sister she can't turn her own TV on in her own house

Calphurnia88 · 08/09/2022 11:58

Grooooovy · 08/09/2022 11:48

I have a baby.

Yes I've also had one. As have probably most people on this thread.

Yes I'm not trying to win a medal for being the second person on this thread to have birthed a child.

I'm just providing some personal background to explain my opinion. Much as you did with your story about snuggling up on the sofa with your little boy. Am I not allowed to do that?

CatsandFish · 08/09/2022 11:57

KettrickenSmiled · 08/09/2022 11:53

You're so wrong it's laughable.
Come along to some of the domestic abuse threads & learn about what a victim actually is you absolute melt.

I've been giving OP constructive advice to help her get what she needs while reconciling with her sister & getting to a place of mutual understanding between them.

YOU, however ... have just been a wind-up merchant, & are sewing more discord with your black & white thinking.
Also - anyone who bangs on about parent's boundaries is inevitably thinking of themselves rather than their child. "It's my way or the highway!" "I will forbid you to see my child" "Mother knows best!!"
Fucking ridiculous.

Your post is so unhinged and ridiculous it says far more about you than me. The defensiveness for your choice is quite obvious, you are so wrong and I think you know it hence your overwrought language, that really ads nothing to the discussion and doesn't help the OP at all. If you had any sense you'd withdraw from the thread. That's all I have to say.

Authenticity2020 · 08/09/2022 11:57

I’m clearly in the minority! If I am afforded the privilege of looking after my nephew, paid or not, I am absolutely respecting the parents rules on screen time. It’s not like this kid is 7 years old and watching a couple of hours, he’s only ONE years old. Sure I’d be asking the parents to bring some toys, books or something (if I’m single I’m unlikely to have this) and hopefully be making some attempt to go for a walk or to the playground or something. Sure TV for 20 mins or half an hour here or there won’t hurts to break up the day, but if the parent is adamant that it’s a no then I would stick to that and if I couldn’t then I wouldn’t offer to babysit for a lengthy period. There are lots of ways to bond with a baby without using a screen.

CatsandFish · 08/09/2022 11:55

Grooooovy · 08/09/2022 11:50

OP asked for opinions on her boundaries though so people are giving them.

If my colleague told me they had a no screen rule for their child then fair enough I'd not comment but OP literally asked if she were unreasonable so what are we supposed to say?

Oh no we couldn't possibly comment OP because we must respect your parental boundaries.

She asked and we answered.

I think, although it's up to OP to clarify, that she was asking opinions on if she was being unreasonable to have only supervised visitation because her sister wouldn't abide by her boundaries and lied to her. She didn't ask for opinions on her no screen policy. People on here, out of guilt it seems, are lashing out at her over her no screen rule. Whereas if it was a MIL ignoring the no chocolate or no lactose or only go on walks if he's on a leash wishes, most people would say an OP wasn't being unreasonable. It's the blatant hypocrisy from the clearly pro-screen posters, that are basically trying to justify their own choices, that gets me.

KettrickenSmiled · 08/09/2022 11:53

CatsandFish · 08/09/2022 11:40

How are my statements that a parents wishes should be respected are 'ridiculous' and 'hyperbolic'? As I've said before on this thread, it is those like yourself who are being hyperbolic, ridiculous and courting drama instead of respect a parents boundaries. And that's because of a guilty conscience that parents on here who use screens, have. The abuse and attacks of the OP are absolutely ridiculous, hyperbolic and quite unhinged.

You're so wrong it's laughable.
Come along to some of the domestic abuse threads & learn about what a victim actually is you absolute melt.

I've been giving OP constructive advice to help her get what she needs while reconciling with her sister & getting to a place of mutual understanding between them.

YOU, however ... have just been a wind-up merchant, & are sewing more discord with your black & white thinking.
Also - anyone who bangs on about parent's boundaries is inevitably thinking of themselves rather than their child. "It's my way or the highway!" "I will forbid you to see my child" "Mother knows best!!"
Fucking ridiculous.

Hermione101 · 08/09/2022 11:52

When my son was your DD's age, we had a no tv rule at home, but my son LOVED cuddling up with his grandparents to watch cartoons together at their home. Made me happy to see it.

You need to relax and be grateful for your sister.

Also, "BTW she's single, lives alone and as far as I can tell has no other responsibilities/distractions that would cause her to plonk DD infront of the telly."

Yes, now that you are an ALL IMPORTANT parent, no one has as many responsibilities/distractions as you do. 🙄🙄

Grooooovy · 08/09/2022 11:50

CatsandFish · 08/09/2022 11:40

How are my statements that a parents wishes should be respected are 'ridiculous' and 'hyperbolic'? As I've said before on this thread, it is those like yourself who are being hyperbolic, ridiculous and courting drama instead of respect a parents boundaries. And that's because of a guilty conscience that parents on here who use screens, have. The abuse and attacks of the OP are absolutely ridiculous, hyperbolic and quite unhinged.

OP asked for opinions on her boundaries though so people are giving them.

If my colleague told me they had a no screen rule for their child then fair enough I'd not comment but OP literally asked if she were unreasonable so what are we supposed to say?

Oh no we couldn't possibly comment OP because we must respect your parental boundaries.

She asked and we answered.

Thehop · 08/09/2022 11:48

At first I was ready to say you were wrong but actually, coco melon has been proven to be really shit for children. Like visual cocaine! And one of mine couldn’t cope with screens as a toddler. So, it sounds like she just wants to borrow him, toy like and unsupervised, rather than actually put any effort in with him so…..no. I’d stop it too and tell her she can visit or take him to parks and that’s it.

Grooooovy · 08/09/2022 11:48

I have a baby.

Yes I've also had one. As have probably most people on this thread.

Grooooovy · 08/09/2022 11:47

Calphurnia88 · 08/09/2022 11:44

I have a baby. If a family member - grandparent/auntie/whatever - said they wanted to spend quality time with them, but used this time to watch hours of children's television (OP has clarified that DSis said that is all they did, despite everyone downplaying this) I would find it a little strange and actually be a bit disappointed for my baby. I want my baby to have opportunities to bond with their family members, but this isn't the way to do it.

I wouldn't ban visits but I would consider how much time my baby spent unsupervised with them if they can't think of anything better to do than watch television.

I don't know any baby who just sits and watches hours of television.

The reality is probably more like the TV's just on and she's still interacting with him throughout those hours whilst he watches then plays then watches then plays and so on.

I'd bet my house actually that the child isn't just sat there staring at a TV unmoving for hours.

KettrickenSmiled · 08/09/2022 11:47

And I disagree that TV can't be quality time as well. It depends on the mood obviously but me and my son love snuggling on the sofa and watching a film when he's a bit sleepy and I stroke his hair. It definitely is quality time. Not entirely the same as a 1 year old but tbh I don't know any 1 year old who'll just sit and stare at a telly for hours on end so I actually imagine she's probably playing and interacting with him at stages throughout anyway.

She's not taping his eyes open and sitting his high chair in front of the TV for 4 hours for goodness sake.

OP, I think this is a very reasonable & balanced way of looking at it - does it help you feel a little more relaxed? That DS is unlikely to be 100% absorbed by the TV?
Does DS, like many people, usually have the TV on as 'background', but is also chatting & playing with DS?

If you want this great relationship between DS & DC, & you want to breech the rift between you & DS, have a think about how you can re-jig the visits. And intersperse them with playtime at yours, so you can (without actually issuing 'instructions') show your sister what games & fun DS enjoys.

WrongWayApricot · 08/09/2022 11:46

also my personal preference based on professional opinion

Does this mean you help make something you believe is harmful for children? Why would you continue to do that...?

Grooooovy · 08/09/2022 11:45

BeanieTeen · 08/09/2022 11:38

Sorry I haven't read every post here but I saw you say that they're watching Cocomelon. This sends my daughter loopy - I noticed she was having meltdowns after we'd watched it (more so than normal) so Cocomelon is now 'broken' in our house. I later read an article that described how the way it is produced is extremely overstimulating, changes of 'shot' every few seconds, etc. We have far fewer issues now that we stick to CBeebies.

I think the main problem is that a lot of little kids are watching shows on streaming services, so there isn’t that variety that you have on tv (despite there being hundreds of shows to choose from). I doubt one episode of Cocomelon followed by something else will cause any problems. But one Cocomelon after another - and the same goes for watching 20 episodes of anything really after another - is enough to send anyone a bit loopy. Adults love a ‘box set binge’ but I really don’t think it’s good for kids - not sure how good it is for adults actually. I never intend to ‘binge’ on anything really, it just becomes a bit of a compulsion when it happens! Dare I say it brings out some addictive traits and tendencies… maybe that was influencing the meltdowns?
I agree just having a tv channel like Cbeebies on is probably a lot better.

Perhaps OP could suggest this then.

Just say it seems cocomelon isn't for him so could she mix it up a bit if she uses the TV.

Insisting on supervised contact and all the rest is ridiculous though and I honestly think it just deprives her son more than anything else.

There is so much to be said for positive family relations between your family and your children. You have to look at things as a whole, not just an individual situation imo. What's worse? A relatively small amount of TV but getting to spend time and build a bond with OPs sister which will likely continue as he gets older or severing that to avoid a minimal amount of screen time which is unlikely to have any real impact on her son?

I roll my eyes sometimes when my mum and dad tell me he's had ice-cream AND chocolate with them that day but you know what? In the grand scheme of things it's not a big deal. He's not having it every single day, he eats healthily 99% of the time at home and the relationship he has with my parents is just worth so much more than fretting over a big of ice cream and chocolate.

If it were daily then that's different but it's not.

Calphurnia88 · 08/09/2022 11:44

Grooooovy · 08/09/2022 11:34

I wouldn't call sitting in front of the TV together having 'quality time', particularly for a one year old. It's pretty lazy IMO, and you don't need to be an expert in childcare to know that very young children need and benefit from other forms of stimulation e.g. playing, reading, going to the park, even going to the local coffee shop is an adventure for a little one.

They do yes. Not 24/7 though. Surely it's ridiculous to suggest a couple of hours of TV here and there will stunt a 1 year olds brain development. I'm sure OP provides plenty of other forms of stimulation. Its not going to harm her son because he watches the odd bit of telly at his aunt's house.

And I disagree that TV can't be quality time as well. It depends on the mood obviously but me and my son love snuggling on the sofa and watching a film when he's a bit sleepy and I stroke his hair. It definitely is quality time. Not entirely the same as a 1 year old but tbh I don't know any 1 year old who'll just sit and stare at a telly for hours on end so I actually imagine she's probably playing and interacting with him at stages throughout anyway.

She's not taping his eyes open and sitting his high chair in front of the TV for 4 hours for goodness sake.

I have a baby. If a family member - grandparent/auntie/whatever - said they wanted to spend quality time with them, but used this time to watch hours of children's television (OP has clarified that DSis said that is all they did, despite everyone downplaying this) I would find it a little strange and actually be a bit disappointed for my baby. I want my baby to have opportunities to bond with their family members, but this isn't the way to do it.

I wouldn't ban visits but I would consider how much time my baby spent unsupervised with them if they can't think of anything better to do than watch television.

alwaysdarkestbeforedawn · 08/09/2022 11:44

MoistBandana · 08/09/2022 11:25

I know right.

Almost as weird as the assumption that a bit of telly for a kid will turn them into some uncommunicative dribbling imbecile that can't make friends and is destined for a life of yelling at cars by the M6.

😂🤣 Are you projecting this belief onto the OP?! Because that’s not even remotely what she said. Or what anyone else has said that I can see… What a bizarre world of extremes you must live in.

CatsandFish · 08/09/2022 11:40

KettrickenSmiled · 08/09/2022 11:28

The sister is the one causing the rift by not respecting the wishes of the mother (regardless of if she feels OP is unreasonable or batshit or whatever). This sister has caused all of this by simply not being honest and by disrespecting OP's wishes and boundaries. Please stop victim-blaming.

Show me the victim & I won't blame them @CatsandFish
Please stop creating melodrama out of a situation that has an easy fix.
All you are doing is driving a wedge between OP, her sister, & the rest of her family with your hyperbolic & frankly ridiculous statements.

How are my statements that a parents wishes should be respected are 'ridiculous' and 'hyperbolic'? As I've said before on this thread, it is those like yourself who are being hyperbolic, ridiculous and courting drama instead of respect a parents boundaries. And that's because of a guilty conscience that parents on here who use screens, have. The abuse and attacks of the OP are absolutely ridiculous, hyperbolic and quite unhinged.

KettrickenSmiled · 08/09/2022 11:39

Grooooovy · 08/09/2022 11:27

I just think you need to unclench a bit.

If she was looking after him daily and was watching TV with him for 8 hours a day then fair enough but going to hers every now and then and watching a bit of TV with his auntie is hardly a huge deal.

I don't give my son many things like chocolate at home unless there's a reason like Easter or Christmas but I know my parents give him a few treats when he sees them. So what? He's lived to tell the tale and he has a beautiful relationship with my parents.

By all means stop your sister from seeing your son if you like. He's your son at the end of the day but I really think all you're doing is depriving your son of a relationship he clearly enjoys for the sake of something which doesn't actually really matter.

Great post @Grooooovy - OP I hope you found it helpful, & can reconcile with a bit of compromise?
"Hi Sis, I've been thinking a lot about this & while I still have reservations about screentime, I've been a bit PFB & don't want this to fester between us. Do you want to come over for a cuppa/glass & spend some time with us? I'd love you to learn [XYZ clapping game] because you should see his little face when he (XYZ action].
You know I was upset because he's been coming home too overstimulated to sleep, & that messes his whole routine, but some of that is probably just because he's so loves spending time with you.
So I've got a plan that will help him settle down after being at yours, if you want to hear it, & want to keep having him? It will mean I have to re-jig the hours & timings, but come over & we can talk it though?"

Not telling you that you ought to do this OP, as it's your kid, your choices - but can you see yourself offering that kind of olive branch?