Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family won't respect our no screen policy foe DS

343 replies

MoMuM7 · 08/09/2022 07:19

I have a no screen policy for DS (1 yo). Everyone who watches him ie family, childcare knows this. I've recently discovered that my sister has been letting him watch TV for HOURS when he goes over to hers. She loves him to bits but why won't she abide by my rules? Is it really that hard to entertain a child? BTW she's single, lives alone and as far as I can tell has no other responsibilities/distractions that would cause her to plonk DD infront of the telly.
I have now decided she can only see him when I'm around. She's very upset. Family thinks im over reacting. AIBU?

OP posts:
OhWelllWhatever · 08/09/2022 09:00

Thread has probably moved on by now but your averageone year old is not spending hours watching tv.

If it's on in the background they will occasionally look when something catches thier attention, then go back discovering thier surroundings/messing with anything and everything - which is far more fun.

mountainsunsets · 08/09/2022 08:55

Well I am shocked most think YABU- there is no way a TV for hours is healthy for a baby.

There's also no way a one year old will just sit and watch TV for hours either though.

AhNowTed · 08/09/2022 08:54

Well if she's nothing better to do, it's like you're doing HER a favour. 🙄

Hyacinth2 · 08/09/2022 08:54

If you aren't used to children 'amusing' them for a day is hard.
You can have a roomful of toys but all they want is the dogs bowl/ to climb on furniture/ to whinge for the biscuit tin.

Apart from strapping them in a buggy for a long walk and putting them down for a looong sleep it's hard.

I would provide DSis with the buggy and some new toys which they might at least spend half an hour playing with.

NerrSnerr · 08/09/2022 08:49

If the OP's sister was caring for the baby so often that this will affect the baby in any way then she should be paid and proper boundaries in place. If it's not regular then does it matter?

Does any of the 'research' people always mention suggest that occasional (once, twice a week) screen time episodes make a difference?

NKFell · 08/09/2022 08:49

YABVU and will be ruining relationships over nothing in the scheme of things.

Put it this way, your sister is "very upset" that her nephew isn't going to be with her as often. To me, this means it's unlikely that all she does it plonk him in front of the TV all day- if that was the case, what would their be to miss?

Relax!

MRex · 08/09/2022 08:48

You've got to stop asking for family childcare if you want to be fussy about what they do. Just pay for a nursery or childminder.

Luredbyapomegranate · 08/09/2022 08:47

Are you paying her as a childminder if he’s over there for hours??

If not, then you are being unreasonable in complaining about the screen and dismissing the idea your sister might not have anything else to do while babysitting for you.

Assuming he’s not there all the time, it’s not going to do him any harm, so chill out.

NerrSnerr · 08/09/2022 08:47

I'm in my 40s and definitely had screen time. I had some toy keys that I called 'Richard Keys'. The telly was definitely on all morning before we went out anywhere (and then as a child and a teen we watched the whole CBBC program and then Neighbours and Home and Away.

Most friends did the same. It isn't a new thing. It's just different as people have iPads and YouTube.

theremustonlybeone · 08/09/2022 08:46

Well I am shocked most think YABU- there is no way a TV for hours is healthy for a baby. Babies like play, park, ducks, interactive games . Your not developing an inquisitive brain by sitting watching TV. Also your sister is ignoring your boundaries so if she is seeing your nephew through choice then until she accepts your boundaries then she needs to stop having him and if your using her for childcare you either accept it or send him to nursery

bakewellbride · 08/09/2022 08:45

My 5 month old catches the odd bit of her big brother's tv op, I suppose I should be handed in to social services now!

brookstar · 08/09/2022 08:42

I am also astonished that so few people take the research behind the no screens under 2 rule seriously.

Have you read that research? The issue is with screens replacing all other interaction.
As long as children are able to interact with the real world and with humans who speak to them and play with them then its fine.

Weemummykay · 08/09/2022 08:39

If it wasn’t for tv I would b screwed. My 3yr old is a riot and would have my house looking like a tip constantly. Although when he is watching tv it’s blippi or other educational programs and when he’s at nursery it’s baby sensory on YouTube for my nosey 3month so I can tidy 3yr olds toys away get dinner prepared etc as he doesn’t nap much through the day. A little tv doesn’t hurt so u can do other things that needs doing. As long as it’s limited and not for long periods of time I don’t there is any harm in it at all

Culldesack · 08/09/2022 08:37

RedRobyn2021 · 08/09/2022 08:32

I'm surprised at the responses on this thread, I think if your sister knew your feelings about television then it's incredibly disrespectful to plonk your child in front of a TV.

I'm saying this as someone who does let my DD 18 months watch TV. It's not about the TV it's about your decisions as a parent and it's about trust, if you can't trust her to follow something as simple as no TV then what else will she disregard.

Also the comments about the OP ruining the relationship between Aunty and the child, she's not saying they don't see each other, she's saying no unsupervised visits. Which is very reasonable.

I remember before I had kids someone telling me they took their vegetarian nephew to McDonalds and gave them a cheese burger every time they took care of them. As a child free person, I thought this was amusing. As a mother I now see how disrespectful and unnecessary this was.

How old was the veggie nephew, out of interest?

gatehouseoffleet · 08/09/2022 08:36

CatsandFish · 08/09/2022 08:34

YANBU she disrespected your wishes. If she loves him so much, as you say, WHY isn't she spending time with him? Why bother sending your son to her if she is just going to put the tv on? What a lazy person she is. She's a lousy babysitter and clearly doesn't love him that much imo. Your family are being unreasonable too. Stick to your guns, you are 100% right.

You are completely wrong.

gatehouseoffleet · 08/09/2022 08:36

The television won't do any harm to the child but the OP has asked that there is no television when others are looking after the child. How difficult would it be to follow that request for a few hours

It isn't about boundaries.

It's much easier to adhere to a no sweets rule when looking after someone else's baby than it is to adhere to no screens for hours. It's not easy to entertain a small child. I can't really see the issue with a bit of Cbeebies.

And as for screens being damaging, eg eyes, I've always had jobs where I've done lots of reading and use of screens and at 50 am only just really needing reading glasses - ie exactly the same sort of age as my mother who grew up with no screens at all. I'd be concerned about content, but presumably the OP's sister isn't letting the baby watch reruns of Taggart!

CatsandFish · 08/09/2022 08:34

YANBU she disrespected your wishes. If she loves him so much, as you say, WHY isn't she spending time with him? Why bother sending your son to her if she is just going to put the tv on? What a lazy person she is. She's a lousy babysitter and clearly doesn't love him that much imo. Your family are being unreasonable too. Stick to your guns, you are 100% right.

Rapidtango · 08/09/2022 08:34

How do you know your sister sat DC in front of TV for hours? And tbh, looking after a 1 yo for hours, even your own child, is boring - if it's not your own child it's deathly.

Are you coming back to your thread?

MajorCarolDanvers · 08/09/2022 08:32

Idontdoyoga · 08/09/2022 08:15

How on earth did our mothers manage without wretched screens?
Im with OP! Baby is a baby & babies don’t need screens!
(Where’s my hard hat?)

I don't know what age you are but we had a tv when I was young and I'm late 40s.

You have to go back a few generations now now to not have screens.

RedRobyn2021 · 08/09/2022 08:32

I'm surprised at the responses on this thread, I think if your sister knew your feelings about television then it's incredibly disrespectful to plonk your child in front of a TV.

I'm saying this as someone who does let my DD 18 months watch TV. It's not about the TV it's about your decisions as a parent and it's about trust, if you can't trust her to follow something as simple as no TV then what else will she disregard.

Also the comments about the OP ruining the relationship between Aunty and the child, she's not saying they don't see each other, she's saying no unsupervised visits. Which is very reasonable.

I remember before I had kids someone telling me they took their vegetarian nephew to McDonalds and gave them a cheese burger every time they took care of them. As a child free person, I thought this was amusing. As a mother I now see how disrespectful and unnecessary this was.

Whatafustercluck · 08/09/2022 08:32

How on earth did our mothers manage without wretched screens?

A much higher proportion would have been stay at home mums and it was just accepted that was the way of the world and their role in life was to raise the kids. Nowhere near the same competing pressures of work v home, running around madly in the evenings trying to prepare for the following day, cramming all housework into evenings and weekends. Times have changed.

carefullycourageous · 08/09/2022 08:30

We were screen free but would not have expected anyone caring for free to follow this.

Alliswells · 08/09/2022 08:29

None of your family are going to want to look after your child if you keep this up!

This is honesty not worth causing bad feelings in the family and you could destroy the potential of your little one having relationships with your family.

Quveas · 08/09/2022 08:29

I am not surprised your sister is upset. I am astonished that you need to ask why! You have pretty much ruined your future relationship with your sister, and this won't be easily forgotten. Your family think you are being ridiculous, and the longer this goes on the more they will be angry at you for upsetting your sister over such a silly thing. And you are potentially ruining any relationship between your child and his aunt. She loves the child, spends a lot of time supporting you as parents whilst also getting to spend time with a much loved nephew, and does this for no better reason than she is your sister and this is what families do. Good luck ever getting a favour from her in the future.

LookItsMeAgain · 08/09/2022 08:28

I think all of those that have told the OP to unclench, or relax about this, seem to have forgotten or have chosen not to realise that this could easily have been about the OP saying "Don't give our child sweets" and the OP's sister wants to be the fun aunt and subsequently gives the child sweets.

This isn't really about the television, it's about a boundary that the OP and her partner/husband has set down and want to be adhered to, for their child.

The television won't do any harm to the child but the OP has asked that there is no television when others are looking after the child. How difficult would it be to follow that request for a few hours?

Swipe left for the next trending thread