Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

130 billion debt - Truss

170 replies

Stephthegreat · 08/09/2022 06:36

Truss, misguided as she is, has announced a 130 billion bailout for the energy companies. Why saddle our dcs with this enormous debt because, let’s face it, it will be paid back down the line.

Truss completely ruled out a windfall tax.

What next? I fear for our country, we have just had one clown and now we have this no hoper.

OP posts:
BluOcty · 09/09/2022 07:58

Oh sorry wrong study - it's this one about higher risks of childhood leukaemia that was out last week -

www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/aug/17/young-children-fracking-wells-leukemia-study

FarFromHome2 · 09/09/2022 07:57

BluOcty · 09/09/2022 07:54

Fracking puts toxic chemicals into the air and water. This study was out just last week www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/jan/27/people-living-closer-us-oil-and-gas-wells-higher-risk-dying-prematurely-study

No, that’s posited to be from the oil and gas itself, not from fracking materials.

I don’t actually care if we frack or not, I’m fine with us being a bit cold for a few years while we bring more nuclear plants online. It’s a price worth paying to reduce our carbon production.

Alexandra2001 · 09/09/2022 07:56

FarFromHome2 · 09/09/2022 07:49

No, that’s not how it works. The wholesale price would not be affected.

Of course it can, thats the main advantage of a privatised industry... there would be no compulsion to sell NS gas as a global commodity.

There may be many valid and varied reasons why privatisation would not work but saying UK PLC would not be able to set the price is rubbish.

BluOcty · 09/09/2022 07:54

Fracking puts toxic chemicals into the air and water. This study was out just last week www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/jan/27/people-living-closer-us-oil-and-gas-wells-higher-risk-dying-prematurely-study

sst1234 · 09/09/2022 07:54

Didn’t hear anyone asking why Furlough money was thrown around like confetti when healthy people were locked down unnecessarily. The wholesale shutdown of the economy is a bigger contributor to the costing living crisis than Ukraine.

But the double standards from people here and everywhere are staggering. It’s ok if free money printed so you can sit at home and watch Netflix. But not ok if private businesses charge market rates and make profit based on market rate.

For those that don’t understand inflation, £450bn printed to pay for Covid did far far more damage to our economy than borrowing this amount to pay energy cap will.

FarFromHome2 · 09/09/2022 07:54

Alexandra2001 · 09/09/2022 07:52

NS oil gas sector is making far more than 8 billion (28m households) so i suggest you look again ...
Plus help should be targeted, no need to give all households money.

Excess profits are not going back into investment, as these decisions are long term, not based on 2 or 3 years of extra monies.

Shell is using 7 billion to buy back shares.

Look again how? £8bn divided by 28m homes is £250-300 per household, as claimed.

FarFromHome2 · 09/09/2022 07:52

carefullycourageous · 09/09/2022 07:08

Fracking does poison the ground, due to the vast amounts of chemicals. It gets into the water supply.

It’s water and sand. Yes, these are “chemicals” (everything is) but they aren’t poison.

Alexandra2001 · 09/09/2022 07:52

forinborin · 09/09/2022 07:35

For all people quoting numbers on the energy companies revenues, do you realise that these refer to the worldwide profits of the sector, and that the UK has no legal or moral right to tax companies that are domiciled and operating in other countries?

Last time I calculated, a 100% windfall tax on UK energy companies will bring something like £250-£300 per household per year.

NS oil gas sector is making far more than 8 billion (28m households) so i suggest you look again ...
Plus help should be targeted, no need to give all households money.

Excess profits are not going back into investment, as these decisions are long term, not based on 2 or 3 years of extra monies.

Shell is using 7 billion to buy back shares.

FarFromHome2 · 09/09/2022 07:51

carefullycourageous · 09/09/2022 07:10

Fuel companies pay duties to governments in each country/state.

Yes, but so what? That doesn’t let us tax a foreign country’s overseas profits, it doesn’t let us get energy for below the wholesale price.

FarFromHome2 · 09/09/2022 07:49

Alexandra2001 · 09/09/2022 07:00

Nationalised UK energy production would mean the UK Govt could set the price for around 67% of our energy needs across the year.

Plus, when the crisis is over, those companies are privatised again, so we get that money back.

i don't think you understand the difference between supply companies and production companies.

No, that’s not how it works. The wholesale price would not be affected.

forinborin · 09/09/2022 07:35

For all people quoting numbers on the energy companies revenues, do you realise that these refer to the worldwide profits of the sector, and that the UK has no legal or moral right to tax companies that are domiciled and operating in other countries?

Last time I calculated, a 100% windfall tax on UK energy companies will bring something like £250-£300 per household per year.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 09/09/2022 07:31

To all the people complaining. Why don't you become an MP and show how it should be done instead of just sitting there moaning?

No I thought not.

It is much easier to keep on moaning.

Endlesssummer2022 · 09/09/2022 07:24

YANBU. The death of the Queen has also heightened my anxiety over the stability of this country. I genuinely feel as though her passing is significant in more than one way including signalling the end of the U.K.

I’ve been feeling this iteration on the Tories since Johnson was going to finish us off and yesterday cemented this feeling. With her gone and these freaks in charge we will continue to tumble down the list of Richest countries.

Game Over dudes.

Sunnyqueen · 09/09/2022 07:16

It's just a plot. As we all know torys are the only party capable of paying debts back and managing the economy apparently so that will just be rammed down everyone's throats before any general election and hey presto another tory government!

Dealing with the absolutely disgusting profits of the energy companies must be to obvious a solution and doesn't provide them enough long term security... Probably some backhanders going on as well.

carefullycourageous · 09/09/2022 07:10

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 16:54

How can the UK government tax companies which are not based in the UK?

Fuel companies pay duties to governments in each country/state.

Alexandra2001 · 09/09/2022 07:09

Rinatinabina · 08/09/2022 09:49

I think that was the point on re-negotiating contracts with renewable companies, basically trying to reduce per kwh cost by fixed pricing over 15 years and re-starting fracking etc.

I assume this is a stop gap while they find a longer term solutions.

Given that they have already had these conversations and it’s the first few days of a Truss government I assume there are other ideas in the pipeline too (this may be a generous assessment, who knows).

Renewables are around 17% (across the year of UK energy needs) why would a private companies that can charge at global rates agree a price cut?

Unless fracking is nationalised, the gas will be priced at global rates and the small print is fracking will only go ahead IF locals support it.....

The new NS licenses wont bring in any new gas for many years and again, priced at global rates, as it is now.
One NS expert said it takes 28 years from licence to gas appearing in your home.... thats disputed but gives an idea of timescales.

Unless she plans on privatising production, we'll be back again in 18 months time... borrowing even more.

Truss is playing for time and hopes the Ukraine war will be over soon, Putin gone & a pro west leader in the Kremlin... my solution to rising energy costs is to buy a scratch card.

carefullycourageous · 09/09/2022 07:08

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 16:55

Poison the ground how?

Fracking does poison the ground, due to the vast amounts of chemicals. It gets into the water supply.

Alexandra2001 · 09/09/2022 07:00

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 13:36

Well for one thing nationalizing them wouldn’t reduce peoples energy bills by more than a few pounds a year, so it makes no sense to compare that plan with one that makes a real difference.

Nationalised UK energy production would mean the UK Govt could set the price for around 67% of our energy needs across the year.

Plus, when the crisis is over, those companies are privatised again, so we get that money back.

i don't think you understand the difference between supply companies and production companies.

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 16:55

Lasttraintolondon · 08/09/2022 12:22

We'll be paying this back forever. It's a disaster. There were other ways to do this. Windfall tax etc.

With regards to fracking - brilliant, we'll poison the ground and then sell the oil and gas to other countries and it'll make no difference to our energy bills at all. More profit to the fossil fuel companies.

Poison the ground how?

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 16:54

WatchoRulo · 08/09/2022 16:18

I have never voted Tory and I agree the costs should fall on the vast windfall profits BUT all this cack about credits cards and debts left to children is frankly arse. Not how a nation's finances work, although it's a hackneyed soundbite started by Thatcher.

How can the UK government tax companies which are not based in the UK?

ghostyslovesheets · 08/09/2022 16:24

They are planning that - if they fail at the next election they can blame the debt and economic hardship on the new government

WatchoRulo · 08/09/2022 16:18

I have never voted Tory and I agree the costs should fall on the vast windfall profits BUT all this cack about credits cards and debts left to children is frankly arse. Not how a nation's finances work, although it's a hackneyed soundbite started by Thatcher.

Zilla1 · 08/09/2022 13:52

For PPs certain that windfall taxes would sort this, what % of UK energy uses domestic production/windfall-taxable production and what involves buying on the international commodity markets?

Zilla1 · 08/09/2022 13:50

My understanding is that the per customer revenue from UK energy retailers is c£60 per annum so nationalising these won't have much effect given the majority of UK energy consumption is from energy purchased in international commodity markets. Domestic production of renewables has a range of subsidies and guarantees required to support the historical investment so nationalising these might not save much. My understanding is that more of France's energy production is from domestic nuclear so nationalising by buying the remaining 16% of EdFe that the French state doesn't own might make sense. Where the UK market wholesale price seems to be set by marginal pricing might bear some scrutiny though where is e riches those providers with lower generation costs.

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 13:36

SleeplessInEngland · 08/09/2022 12:19

I read that nationalising energy companies would cost £55 billion, so I'd be (genuinely) interested to know what the downside of that is in light of this short-term fix that'll cost almost three times as much.

Well for one thing nationalizing them wouldn’t reduce peoples energy bills by more than a few pounds a year, so it makes no sense to compare that plan with one that makes a real difference.

Swipe left for the next trending thread