Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think skin colour matters WAY more than people like to admit

454 replies

daysayso · 07/09/2022 22:22

I am involved in marketing campaigns - I won't say what because it's outing but let's say I recently worked on a campaign where the service being provided had absolutely nothing to do with race (so it wasn't makeup or hair for example).

Yet the vast majority that responded were people of colour (Same as the person featured in the ad) and it made me think how much your life chances are still dictated by your skin colour.

People like to consider race more than they like to admit even in spaces where it has nothing to do with anything, people just seem to feel more 'comfortable' with their own.

I felt for the first time in a long time my success will in part depend on my skin colour because for whatever reason the majority of white people that saw this ad decided it wasn't for them on the basis I'm someone of colour.

Please no arguments I'm looking for a mature conversation and if you find the topic sensitive you need not respond

Just looking for others experiences really

OP posts:
eldora · 08/09/2022 00:03

Sarah0611 · 08/09/2022 00:01

How so?

I suspect you know, Miss Butter Wouldn’t Melt Smile

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 08/09/2022 00:02

OK but I understand it is wrong to label people. If I referred to someone as black ( simply using black as an example) then I would be seen to be wrong /rude / racist. We hear all the time that people shouldn't be labelled, yet from reading this thread it appears (to me) that people who are not white, do in fact wish to be 'labelled' This is not easy is it

This is what I genuinely don't understand either. Of course people 'see' that somebody is a certain colour, in the same way they notice if they are tall or short, their hair colour, sex etc. And of course all rational people acknowledge that racism has existed throughout history, does still exist and is a nasty, shameful thing.

However, if you then say that you don't really care what colour people are - i.e. you are NOT a racist and you treat people as individuals instead of treating all black/Asian/white people the same way - you are told by some people that you SHOULD care and treat people with different skin colours differently and that you are naive/unpleasant/racist not to do so.

I truly don't understand why having a non-racist attitude and treating folk as individuals, according to their character, personality, behaviour or whatever and not as 'a black woman' or 'an Asian man' - whilst never denying that racism is still very much a current scourge on society - is actually considered racist.

The only takeaway I can get from that is that non-white people WANT to be treated differently because of their skin colour and thus considered victims of racism inherently (i.e. as a part of their own character), rather than as a result of their historic and current treatment by racists - which seems to me to almost be taking the blame away from the racists and claiming that it is an innate part of your identity - that you somehow should be a victim of racism. Now, I realise that this last paragraph is absolutely 100% NOT the case at all - so I too am very confused.

Would you prefer somebody to refer to you as 'my colleague Sharon, who is black' rather than just 'my colleague/friend, Sharon' - and then, when the person to whom you were mentioned is introduced to you in person, for them to be thinking "Ah, this is black Sharon" rather than "Ah, so this is Sharon" and, whilst obviously noticing that you are black, wanting to know far more interesting information about you as a person and your life rather than just what colour your skin happens to be?

No right-thinking person is denying the very real existence and horror of racism; but surely the ideal would be, as far as possible, for race not to be seen as the main significant thing that defines you? How is it somehow naive/racist/a bad thing for many people to behave in this way - to obviously know what race/sex/height you are but to see it as incidental rather than the main thing that they should dwell on?

I know it's not the same thing, but by way of a (hopefully not crass) analogy, if you were female and a builder, would you want people to think and refer to you as Claire the builder - and maybe highlight the jobs that you've done for them; or would you prefer them to obsess that "You'll never believe this, but this is Claire the female builder; yes, she's a woman and a builder; fancy that, eh, who would have thought that a woman would want to be a builder - and have the ability to do it as well?!?! Ooh, isn't she ambitious?!" Who in their right mind would want that rather than just "This is Claire - she's building our new extension for us" ?

It would be just as irrelevant, insulting and tedious if you were a competent, experienced male builder and happened to be only 5'2" tall and to have everybody constantly banging on about 'Little Tim' as if that were his full name, "Ooh, he's only small, but he still does a good job, nevertheless!" and "Do you specialise in skirting boards and leave the ceilings to the others?!"

Back on topic, I genuinely would love an answer to this. Do people of black, Asian and mixed-race origin want their colour to be pointed out and/or the main/a significant thing that defines them throughout their interactions with others or not? Surely the answer has to be 'no'; so then, why does it appear, for many, not to be?

JubileeTissues · 08/09/2022 00:02

"I actually find the term ‘white privilege’ racist."

Ey up Nige

Sarah0611 · 08/09/2022 00:01

eldora · 08/09/2022 00:00

And here the mask starts to slip…

How so?

eldora · 08/09/2022 00:00

Sarah0611 · 07/09/2022 23:56

I actually find the term ‘white privilege’ racist.

And here the mask starts to slip…

JubileeTissues · 08/09/2022 00:00

"Oblomov22
Colourblind?
What like Darius? Colourblind 

😂😂😝"

Oh yeah, hilarious. You want to have a look at your "sense of humour"

Sarah0611 · 08/09/2022 00:00

Lunar270 · 07/09/2022 23:57

What, when you claim to not know what it means?

That's interesting.

After an explanation I do. Quick learner.
Still quite offensive though don’t you think?

bellac11 · 07/09/2022 23:59

CraggyIslandTouristBoard · 07/09/2022 23:56

And yet I know a number of people from ethnic minorities - black and Asian (of Pakistani descent) who are actively involved in campaigning on diversity (so this is a subject particularly close to their hearts), and whose preferred term to describe themselves is as “people of colour” 🤷‍♀️

Yes I know. I also know black people who still use the term coloured.

No one gets to police my language and I dont police others.

LemonSwan · 07/09/2022 23:59

I am white and not up to date on the woke. So have no idea whether POC is still in or out.

But I did always find it weird. It basically lumps all non whites together. Which when I compare to feminism (which I am vested in being a member of the female sex); is akin to calling women non-men.

So I have always referred to someone as black, white, Asian or mixed etc. Because the only time I ever use it is as a descriptor usually in a specific circumstance.

Perhaps POC is more useful to everyone else when they are specifically grouping themselves as non white in an organisational manner but it’s not really of use to me as a white individual.

Not the question you asked I know sorry

eldora · 07/09/2022 23:58

@Lunar270 it’s like they follow a script…

Lunar270 · 07/09/2022 23:57

Sarah0611 · 07/09/2022 23:56

I actually find the term ‘white privilege’ racist.

What, when you claim to not know what it means?

That's interesting.

99redballoonsgobyy · 07/09/2022 23:57

@Countingdowntodecember I don't think babies of 3 months old are aware of their own race it's probably more likely a case of babies prefer people that mostly resemble their primary carer (usually mother/father) which are the usually the same race to them.
But then again what about the studies on mixed race babies??

CraggyIslandTouristBoard · 07/09/2022 23:56

bellac11 · 07/09/2022 23:29

And this is the problem with that terminology

Its completely othering, its putting people into literally 2 groups, - white, and then 'people of colour' - the others

I dont use 'people of colour' in the way that I never used the term 'coloured'.

I dont care if its the new name to refer to people who are not white, its not accurate, not representative and fairly hostile

And yet I know a number of people from ethnic minorities - black and Asian (of Pakistani descent) who are actively involved in campaigning on diversity (so this is a subject particularly close to their hearts), and whose preferred term to describe themselves is as “people of colour” 🤷‍♀️

Sarah0611 · 07/09/2022 23:56

I actually find the term ‘white privilege’ racist.

bellac11 · 07/09/2022 23:56

Sarah0611 · 07/09/2022 23:45

what is white privilege? I’m white. I’ve certainly not had a life of privilege

It refers to the fact that in a predominately white country, someone who is white wont have the other inherent prejudices shown to them, that people who are not white will have. White people who wont have had to overcome racism.

However, its not without some controversy because its a term from largely the middle classes,, the white saviour middle classes and completely neglects the experiences of the white working class or white underclass in this country. Hence it has caused offence at some levels

A small example is that white working class boys now have the worst outcomes of all students at secondary schools in the UK

So you have reacted in the way that a lot of people who havent experienced privilege would react, in that its a meaningless phrase

eldora · 07/09/2022 23:55

FarFromHome2 · 07/09/2022 23:50

That’s a strange thing to say. What makes you think that black people are not contributing, let alone thinking that you know why?

Because black posters said so, Farfromhome. Why is that so strange?

Or do you expect black people to be a rapt audience to your protestations of colour blindness?

Sarah0611 · 07/09/2022 23:54

Cw112 · 07/09/2022 23:53

Have you experienced daily racism @Sarah0611 ? If the answer to that question is no then that is your privilege. This has been explained a few times already in this thread maybe have a look back through.

Not daily. But when I was younger.

Cw112 · 07/09/2022 23:53

Sarah0611 · 07/09/2022 23:45

what is white privilege? I’m white. I’ve certainly not had a life of privilege

Have you experienced daily racism @Sarah0611 ? If the answer to that question is no then that is your privilege. This has been explained a few times already in this thread maybe have a look back through.

Lunar270 · 07/09/2022 23:52

Sarah0611 · 07/09/2022 23:45

what is white privilege? I’m white. I’ve certainly not had a life of privilege

Privilege is a bit misleading but you certainly have it as a white person. In the same way that I have male privilege.

Privilege should really be replaced with another word that means advantage, benefit or similar. Simply because a lot of people say exactly what you have when they hear it for the first time.

It's worth googling, if you have the time and inclination to understand the dynamics between races and sexes etc.

Sarah0611 · 07/09/2022 23:50

eldora · 07/09/2022 23:47

😂

Oh please! Is it laughable? Really?

FarFromHome2 · 07/09/2022 23:50

eldora · 07/09/2022 23:29

This is why so many black people don’t contribute to threads on race on MN.

Posts like these are just so frustrating,

That’s a strange thing to say. What makes you think that black people are not contributing, let alone thinking that you know why?

Throwawaytoday · 07/09/2022 23:49

As PP have said, representation is important. People feel a natural affinity to other people who appear 'like them'.

A colleague of mine uses the phrase "you can't be what you can't see" - and there is some truth to that (sure, you CAN be what you can't see, but it's a much more difficult pathway).

The challenge I have with people dismissing that they have unconscious bias, or refuting that practically everyone makes assumptions based on the colour of a person's skin is that it also dismisses the experience of the person.

"I don't treat people any differently based on their skin" has implications of "I don't believe you are systemically treated different based on the colour of your skin".

Ditto people who put 'white privilege' in inverted commas as if it's a fallacy, don't understand that the only reason that privilege is invisible to them, is because they have that privilege. It's the optimum in "if it doesn't affect me, it doesn't exist".

This is a subject I'm particularly passionate about, sorry if it's a bit soap boxy.

FarFromHome2 · 07/09/2022 23:49

bellac11 · 07/09/2022 23:18

And theres no difference between 'coloured person' and 'person of colour'

Its the emperors new clothes

Yes, this one’s a particularly egregious example. No semantic difference worth worrying about, it’s just operating as a shibboleth to show who’s in the know and who’s not.

eldora · 07/09/2022 23:47

😂

Sarah0611 · 07/09/2022 23:45

witchesbubblebath · 07/09/2022 23:44

I believe in white privilege and I say that as a white person.

what is white privilege? I’m white. I’ve certainly not had a life of privilege