Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think skin colour matters WAY more than people like to admit

454 replies

daysayso · 07/09/2022 22:22

I am involved in marketing campaigns - I won't say what because it's outing but let's say I recently worked on a campaign where the service being provided had absolutely nothing to do with race (so it wasn't makeup or hair for example).

Yet the vast majority that responded were people of colour (Same as the person featured in the ad) and it made me think how much your life chances are still dictated by your skin colour.

People like to consider race more than they like to admit even in spaces where it has nothing to do with anything, people just seem to feel more 'comfortable' with their own.

I felt for the first time in a long time my success will in part depend on my skin colour because for whatever reason the majority of white people that saw this ad decided it wasn't for them on the basis I'm someone of colour.

Please no arguments I'm looking for a mature conversation and if you find the topic sensitive you need not respond

Just looking for others experiences really

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 08/09/2022 02:04

I agree that it matters OP.

I think a lot of the effect you witnessed is down to entrenched habit and can be broken reasonably easily. The last 4ish years of US TV and film have seen a sudden explosion of people of colour playing characters that previously would have defaulted to white and making up crowd scenes and supporting characters that previously would have been expected to be white (especially in historical dramas). And it hasn’t caused the world to collapse or even messed with viewers’ suspension of disbelief. It’s just made the stories look more diverse. This is down, in part, to the inclusion riders that McDermond was talking up at the Oscars in 2018.

I think in advertising there’s something similar - a bit of a language with skin colour. And people are used to the message that advertising with people of colour is for things not aimed at white people. But if established brands with a large white customer base start to use more diverse people in their advertising, like many of the media programs have started to, that’s going to fall away.

Hopefully that will be part of a virtuous spiral that feeds into many other ways people can consciously evaluate messages, situations and people on the basis of skin colour and will be a part of destroying racism in the West. Obviously it’s only one small bit and pretty superficial in many ways, but the lack of people of colour in things aimed at white people sets up significant barriers where white people think they aren’t being racist but still act in ways that make race matter when it shouldn’t. So breaking that down could be significant.

pollyglot · 08/09/2022 01:55

Look, humans are tribal..we form tribes instinctively. It's really very few generations ago that we jealously guarded our tribal territories against "The Other". Anyone different was by definition a threat. Coulrophobia (fear of clowns, apparently common among young children), is part of the same instinct - "The Other", wearing some kind of disguise, or threatening marking - just as our instinct is to fear brightly-coloured snakes. Different, unfamiliar appearance has always triggered defence mode in humans, be it colour, disability, disfigurement. Hence poor old women, with the marks of age and poverty could easily be seen as witches. Traditionally, even men with less than perfect bodies were forbidden from being ordained into the church. We have to overcome this instinct to live in a multi-cultural, multi-human-in-all-its-forms society.

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 01:46

Lunar270 · 08/09/2022 01:41

Simply put CRT presents the idea that all inequalities experienced by POC are down to their skin colour and all white people no matter what desperate circumstances they live in are privileged and will always be elevated in some way because of the colour of their skin.

Unfortunately that's where your assessment/interpretation falls apart. There's no wonder why you don't agree with it but is typical and quite common.

Privilege doesn't literally mean that white people are privileged in the sense that you're elevated above every race, irrespective of your social status. It simply means that there is a hierarchy of races and as the default (white) you won't be subjected to the same racial experiences. There are aspects of life that you won't have to think about. This puts you (racially) in a more beneficial situation.

We can get into the rich black man vs poor white man but like for like, the black person will generally be worse off. It's not a difficult concept to understand and is independent of UK or USA attitudes to racism.

You believe that there is a hierarchy of races?

I’ve heard it all now. Tell me, though, in this hierarchy of yours, who do you personally place at the top?

Lunar270 · 08/09/2022 01:41

Simply put CRT presents the idea that all inequalities experienced by POC are down to their skin colour and all white people no matter what desperate circumstances they live in are privileged and will always be elevated in some way because of the colour of their skin.

Unfortunately that's where your assessment/interpretation falls apart. There's no wonder why you don't agree with it but is typical and quite common.

Privilege doesn't literally mean that white people are privileged in the sense that you're elevated above every race, irrespective of your social status. It simply means that there is a hierarchy of races and as the default (white) you won't be subjected to the same racial experiences. There are aspects of life that you won't have to think about. This puts you (racially) in a more beneficial situation.

We can get into the rich black man vs poor white man but like for like, the black person will generally be worse off. It's not a difficult concept to understand and is independent of UK or USA attitudes to racism.

Cw112 · 08/09/2022 01:25

LondonWolf · 08/09/2022 01:04

The definitions of racism - white privilege etc - on this thread are that of CRT - Critical Race Theory. Concepts which came out of American universities back in the 70s/80s I believe. So relatively new definitions. It is what it says it is - a theory and as such you don't have to believe in it. Personally I find it a divisive and damaging concept which goes doesn't really fit with ideas around race in the UK - after all we do not have the same historical social attitudes towards race as the US. They have been embraced here though and as we can see by this thread and generally on MN are presented as the only way to think about race.

Simply put CRT presents the idea that all inequalities experienced by POC are down to their skin colour and all white people no matter what desperate circumstances they live in are privileged and will always be elevated in some way because of the colour of their skin.

It's a personal choice whether or not to believe these ideas but personally for me I do not believe myself or my disabled children to be "privileged" and I do not feel any shame for behaviours carried out by people from centuries ago just because they happen to look like me.

I'm aware these are not popular opinions but I really think it is important to understand where these ideas come from and not just swallow them without thinking.

For further reading pretty much anything by Thomas Sowell is brilliant and "Woke Racism" by John McWhorter is excellent and accessible - both are black men.

I don't think it's about feeling shame, at the end of the day our ancestors are not us. But it is important to recognise that white people have directly benefitted from exploitation of non white people over the years and we still benefit from certain privileges now in the workplace, in social settings, in health care etc etc that's not to say that white people can't have challenges and difficulties in life but we also can't say we all have it equally hard. To me there's different layers of discrimination and some people will be impacted by more of those layers than others. So for example a straight white young person will have less discrimination than a straight white young person with a disability, a straight white young person with a disability will have less discrimination than a black young person with a disability, who may face less discrimination than a lesbian black young person with a disability. It doesn't necessarily all have to boil down to race alone, but that is one particular area where white people will not have to struggle regardless of the other challenges in their lives at least that's how I understand it.

eldora · 08/09/2022 01:22

SnowDear · 08/09/2022 00:59

West Indian but also half West Indian but also somehow white. we’ve found a scientific marvel

And the brave man who fought bigots with his white partner has now been demoted to an ‘absent dad’… It’s a tragedy too.

Daydreamsinsantafe · 08/09/2022 01:15

@LondonWolf the point is that your hardships are not because of your race. You of course can experience difficulties but they are not because you are white.
You also aren’t expected to feel shame. Only to acknowledge that you, as a race, still benefit from slavery.

eldora · 08/09/2022 01:15

Daydreamsinsantafe · 08/09/2022 01:06

@Sarah0611 So you do have issues. Whilst you work out whatever you need to please refrain from speaking ‘as a mixed raced woman’ until your discomfort takes you to ‘a white woman’.

Delicious!

marvellousmaple · 08/09/2022 01:09

LondonWolf · 08/09/2022 01:04

The definitions of racism - white privilege etc - on this thread are that of CRT - Critical Race Theory. Concepts which came out of American universities back in the 70s/80s I believe. So relatively new definitions. It is what it says it is - a theory and as such you don't have to believe in it. Personally I find it a divisive and damaging concept which goes doesn't really fit with ideas around race in the UK - after all we do not have the same historical social attitudes towards race as the US. They have been embraced here though and as we can see by this thread and generally on MN are presented as the only way to think about race.

Simply put CRT presents the idea that all inequalities experienced by POC are down to their skin colour and all white people no matter what desperate circumstances they live in are privileged and will always be elevated in some way because of the colour of their skin.

It's a personal choice whether or not to believe these ideas but personally for me I do not believe myself or my disabled children to be "privileged" and I do not feel any shame for behaviours carried out by people from centuries ago just because they happen to look like me.

I'm aware these are not popular opinions but I really think it is important to understand where these ideas come from and not just swallow them without thinking.

For further reading pretty much anything by Thomas Sowell is brilliant and "Woke Racism" by John McWhorter is excellent and accessible - both are black men.

Needs to be repeated. Completely agree.

Sarah0611 · 08/09/2022 01:07

Daydreamsinsantafe · 08/09/2022 01:06

@Sarah0611 So you do have issues. Whilst you work out whatever you need to please refrain from speaking ‘as a mixed raced woman’ until your discomfort takes you to ‘a white woman’.

I’ll take that on board. Thank you so much for educating me Aristotle.

Sarah0611 · 08/09/2022 01:06

Sarah0611 · 08/09/2022 01:01

You are actually really horrid aren’t you? Trying to catch people out. Like they are telling fibs. How silly.

Goodnight to you. I hope you are far more pleasant in real life than you are on here otherwise I do despair for you!
Regards, scientific marvel, white, black, green. Blue, mixed race person! 😂

Daydreamsinsantafe · 08/09/2022 01:06

@Sarah0611 So you do have issues. Whilst you work out whatever you need to please refrain from speaking ‘as a mixed raced woman’ until your discomfort takes you to ‘a white woman’.

LondonWolf · 08/09/2022 01:04

The definitions of racism - white privilege etc - on this thread are that of CRT - Critical Race Theory. Concepts which came out of American universities back in the 70s/80s I believe. So relatively new definitions. It is what it says it is - a theory and as such you don't have to believe in it. Personally I find it a divisive and damaging concept which goes doesn't really fit with ideas around race in the UK - after all we do not have the same historical social attitudes towards race as the US. They have been embraced here though and as we can see by this thread and generally on MN are presented as the only way to think about race.

Simply put CRT presents the idea that all inequalities experienced by POC are down to their skin colour and all white people no matter what desperate circumstances they live in are privileged and will always be elevated in some way because of the colour of their skin.

It's a personal choice whether or not to believe these ideas but personally for me I do not believe myself or my disabled children to be "privileged" and I do not feel any shame for behaviours carried out by people from centuries ago just because they happen to look like me.

I'm aware these are not popular opinions but I really think it is important to understand where these ideas come from and not just swallow them without thinking.

For further reading pretty much anything by Thomas Sowell is brilliant and "Woke Racism" by John McWhorter is excellent and accessible - both are black men.

SnowDear · 08/09/2022 01:04

Sarah0611 · 08/09/2022 01:01

You are actually really horrid aren’t you? Trying to catch people out. Like they are telling fibs. How silly.

“like” they’re telling fibs! sure yeh

Sarah0611 · 08/09/2022 01:01

SnowDear · 08/09/2022 00:59

West Indian but also half West Indian but also somehow white. we’ve found a scientific marvel

You are actually really horrid aren’t you? Trying to catch people out. Like they are telling fibs. How silly.

SnowDear · 08/09/2022 01:01

Sarah0611 · 08/09/2022 01:00

Ah thank you. I do love a bit of patronising before bed! Have you considered maybe that I’ve been brought up with white parentage yet my absent father is mixed race? No i thought not.

maybe have you considered I may be stuck in between knowing who I am? No I thought not.

maybe. You could just be kind? Ummm no I thought not.

goodnight.

oh I thought you said you don’t have any issues to examine regarding your racial identity? Silly me getting your posts mixed up again! It’s hard to keep up you see

hellom · 08/09/2022 01:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Sarah0611 · 08/09/2022 01:00

SnowDear · 08/09/2022 00:51

I don’t think you understand your own messages to be honest. In some you’re white, in some you’re mixed, you insist white privilege doesn’t exist but I suspect you haven’t quite managed to grasp the concept of it. Who knows. Bed time maybe?

Ah thank you. I do love a bit of patronising before bed! Have you considered maybe that I’ve been brought up with white parentage yet my absent father is mixed race? No i thought not.

maybe have you considered I may be stuck in between knowing who I am? No I thought not.

maybe. You could just be kind? Ummm no I thought not.

goodnight.

SnowDear · 08/09/2022 00:59

eldora · 08/09/2022 00:55

Now dad has gone from West Indian to half West Indian…

And her experience of racism has gone from zero to medium.

West Indian but also half West Indian but also somehow white. we’ve found a scientific marvel

Cw112 · 08/09/2022 00:58

eldora · 08/09/2022 00:55

Now dad has gone from West Indian to half West Indian…

And her experience of racism has gone from zero to medium.

I feel like I should have brought snacks and a chair for how this is unravelling...

hellom · 08/09/2022 00:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Daydreamsinsantafe · 08/09/2022 00:57

@Sarah0611 plot twist!

Petrar · 08/09/2022 00:56

Unconscious bias is definitely a thing - if you think you aren’t susceptible to it then you’re kidding yourself. Accepting that you are susceptible i think is necessary to addressing the issues.

eldora · 08/09/2022 00:55

SnowDear · 08/09/2022 00:51

I don’t think you understand your own messages to be honest. In some you’re white, in some you’re mixed, you insist white privilege doesn’t exist but I suspect you haven’t quite managed to grasp the concept of it. Who knows. Bed time maybe?

Now dad has gone from West Indian to half West Indian…

And her experience of racism has gone from zero to medium.

hellom · 08/09/2022 00:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.