Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For the way I described HIV to my daughter?

245 replies

maloofshoof · 07/09/2022 18:23

I met with my daughters dad today (we had some childcare issues to sort out). My daughter is 9, and last night she asked me what HIV was. I asked her where she had heard about that but she wouldn't tell me, kept saying she was unsure but had heard about it.

I was on the spot, we were driving to an after school club and so I said something along the lines of that it was a virus that erupted in the 80s and that they thought it started from gay men having sex but it turned out that it was a virus that could be spread by blood etc and so women, needle users etc could get it too. I said that in the 80s if someone had it they would die but now there is medicine that allows people with it to live a relatively normal life (bearing in mind I am no expert and was put on the spot with this question). Perhaps I should have said I'll explain later and done a bit of research but I didn't.

When I told my ex today he was really 'appalled'. He said he can't believe I taught our daughter that HIV was spread between only gay men when that was only propaganda and how the media portrayed it. He said I really messed up an educational opportunity with homophobic undercurrents (not homophobic in the slightest, in fact I have been with women and two of my close friends are gay).

I was taken aback and tried to explain myself but he was really upset and left on quite unpleasant terms.

Did I totally fuck up?

OP posts:
milkyaqua · 08/09/2022 14:57

limitedperiodonly · 08/09/2022 14:43

Just think about what you've done OP.

What she's done is given the history. Do you want her to think about that?!

It is not a homophobic association with gay sex; it is a historical fact that there was stigma towards gay men back in the 80s when it was a new and frightening disease spreading amongst gay men in western society. It is not homophobic, also, to acknowledge the fact that the vast majority of new infections in western society nowadays are still in men who have sex with men.

PlumPudd · 08/09/2022 14:50

BeanieTeen · 08/09/2022 11:01

The slavery analogy works - but it’s the other way round, surely? It’s like a child asking “what is slavery?” and your answer being “forcing someone to work for you and treating them like a possession”, without mentioning at all the fact that through history it was black people who were overwhelmingly the victims of it. And it’s not really a full explanation without it, certainly not if a child has been reading about something in the news because they won’t then understand what they were asking about in the first place.

I think generally the best way to explain a new word or concept is to do so in the context of something the children already understand.
I personally wouldn’t start talking about the Atlantic slave trade if five minutes ago my child didn’t even know what slavery was. My child has been learning about Roman Britain in school and so I’d probably talk about it in that context if I did go into any historical detail. The Atlantic slave trade and the racist attitudes involved with this are significant aspects in understanding slavery for sure, but probably not as a beginner if you have literally no understanding of that era in history - or the geography - already. It’s just information overload in my opinion that actually I think will just create more confusion and misconceptions.
Same with explaining HIV - a child can understand what a disease is, they may understand what an immune system is and they understand contagion so you can explain that it can be passed on via blood to blood contact and that it makes you more vulnerable to other illnesses. They probably won’t have a clue about the 80s, have a very basic understanding of sex at best (straight sex probably, gay less so) or STIs and how they are spread. It’s just going to cause confusion. And also probably some misunderstandings.
I think both of these are actually good examples of how we associate things that are happening now with the past. HIV still exists and so does slavery. So I personally do find it odd to explain either of those via the means of a history anecdote.

Agree with the point about adjusting to the child’s level of knowledge and not plunging into the Atlantic slave trade if they weren’t even familiar with the concept of slavery.

I think schools often will explain new concepts like slavery or disease by using anecdotes or context though, as it’s easier for children to understand something if given a real world example. E.g. the concept of human rights might come up as part of a history lesson about WW1 where a teacher explains what the Geneva Convention is and how is was put in place to make sure POWs we’re treated better. I think historical examples probably also get used more (like your Roman Britain one) because they are in the past, so probably a bit easier for kids to handle the concepts behind them and less scary. If you started off a conversation about slavery by talking about sweatshops, modern slaves dying in the back of lorries and Chinese labour camps, the kid would probably be too scared and shocked to understand the concept you were trying to teach.

You see something quite similar in children books and fairy tales where much younger kids are introduced to ideas about bad people, tricks, not always trusting strangers, fear, lying etc. but because it’s safely between the covers of a book they can learn a bit about it and about how fictional characters dealt with it without being too scared and overwhelmed, and then be better prepared for encountering some of these things in real life.

limitedperiodonly · 08/09/2022 14:43

BadNomad · 08/09/2022 13:32

History is important, yes, but I don't think it's right for your daughter first introduction to HIV to be its homophobic association with gay sex. That is what her first impression of it is now. This is how homophobia, racism, sexism etc gets passed down through the generations. Association.

Just think about what you've done OP.

Nursingistoostressful2022 · 08/09/2022 14:29

The 9-year-old child didn't ask about the epidemiology of HIV she asked what HIV is.

OP your husband was out of line for replying so vehemently in relation to what you said it is hard when a parent is put into a difficult position while on the go. You should continue being so open with your child when answering her questions. None of us feels we get it right all the time honestly, most of my non-clinical friends would never parent their children the way I parent mine.

BeanieTeen · 08/09/2022 13:32

I don’t like the attitude of “kids don’t need to know” though; if they ask questions, it’s a good opportunity to discuss some of these issues with them. Take the HIV example. Saying “it’s a virus” might make them equate it to Covid and be worried about something unnecessarily.

@WimpoleHat Yes of course, I didn’t mean at all that these things shouldn’t be discussed. In your example it makes perfect sense given the context. But if the question comes up somewhat randomly, it might just be a word they heard on the radio or said by a child at school, I think giving a simple definition of the word initially makes the most sense to me. Because of the huge scope of the subject matter, I think in some cases it can just be an overwhelming amount of information and the meaning of the word can get lost in it, or maybe associated with that one thing. I think how HIV affected the gay community and how slavery affected black people is certainly a vital part of further discussion and understanding - just not as a first port of call in terms of an explanation. I think you are then in danger of confusing a child into things like initially associating HIV with homosexuality or slavery with just the Atlantic slave trade. I’m not saying ‘kids don’t need to know’. I’m just conscious of brain overload. Especially if it might create misconceptions rather than aid explanations. Let the idea of what HIV actually is sink in, then add historical context another time.

BadNomad · 08/09/2022 13:32

History is important, yes, but I don't think it's right for your daughter first introduction to HIV to be its homophobic association with gay sex. That is what her first impression of it is now. This is how homophobia, racism, sexism etc gets passed down through the generations. Association.

LuftBalloons · 08/09/2022 13:25

No you really didn’t fuck up. Probably a bit too much information for a young child to absorb (the history of the disease) , but the substance of what you said is correct.

WimpoleHat · 08/09/2022 13:11

I think both of these are actually good examples of how we associate things that are happening now with the past. HIV still exists and so does slavery. So I personally do find it odd to explain either of those via the means of a history anecdote.

That’s a good point, actually - as is the question of “how far back do you go?” if you’re putting things into an historical context. I suppose that’s my point about needing to know the context of the child’s original question, really; in my kids’ case, the prompt for asking about HIV was someone from the Terence Higgins trust discussing AIDS and talking about Freddie Mercury, so it absolutely made sense to explain the context of the 1980s. Similarly, most if my conversations about slavery were prompted by the Edward Colston statue in Bristol being pulled down, but in a different context, if might have made more sense to talk about the Romans.

I don’t like the attitude of “kids don’t need to know” though; if they ask questions, it’s a good opportunity to discuss some of these issues with them. Take the HIV example. Saying “it’s a virus” might make them equate it to Covid and be worried about something unnecessarily.

BeanieTeen · 08/09/2022 11:01

The slavery analogy works - but it’s the other way round, surely? It’s like a child asking “what is slavery?” and your answer being “forcing someone to work for you and treating them like a possession”, without mentioning at all the fact that through history it was black people who were overwhelmingly the victims of it. And it’s not really a full explanation without it, certainly not if a child has been reading about something in the news because they won’t then understand what they were asking about in the first place.

I think generally the best way to explain a new word or concept is to do so in the context of something the children already understand.
I personally wouldn’t start talking about the Atlantic slave trade if five minutes ago my child didn’t even know what slavery was. My child has been learning about Roman Britain in school and so I’d probably talk about it in that context if I did go into any historical detail. The Atlantic slave trade and the racist attitudes involved with this are significant aspects in understanding slavery for sure, but probably not as a beginner if you have literally no understanding of that era in history - or the geography - already. It’s just information overload in my opinion that actually I think will just create more confusion and misconceptions.
Same with explaining HIV - a child can understand what a disease is, they may understand what an immune system is and they understand contagion so you can explain that it can be passed on via blood to blood contact and that it makes you more vulnerable to other illnesses. They probably won’t have a clue about the 80s, have a very basic understanding of sex at best (straight sex probably, gay less so) or STIs and how they are spread. It’s just going to cause confusion. And also probably some misunderstandings.
I think both of these are actually good examples of how we associate things that are happening now with the past. HIV still exists and so does slavery. So I personally do find it odd to explain either of those via the means of a history anecdote.

PlumPudd · 08/09/2022 09:31

WimpoleHat · 08/09/2022 08:45

It's like saying what are black people, "they were lesser humans brought over from Africa to serve the white". Why not say HIV is a sad disease that is now manageable?

The slavery analogy works - but it’s the other way round, surely? It’s like a child asking “what is slavery?” and your answer being “forcing someone to work for you and treating them like a possession”, without mentioning at all the fact that through history it was black people who were overwhelmingly the victims of it. And it’s not really a full explanation without it, certainly not if a child has been reading about something in the news because they won’t then understand what they were asking about in the first place.

I guess it’s difficult to know how much to give to kids though when they do ask questions that come with complicated sociopolitical context. To use your slavery example. Would you explain to a 9 year old asking about slavery a bit about the Atlantic slave trade, probably yes. Would you also point to the t shirt they were wearing and say “oh and darling, the cotton in that T shirt was probably partly picked by Uyghurs in forced labour camps, and there are probably slaves working in that nail bar over there,” probably not because I doubt they’d be able to handle it at 9

dianthus101 · 08/09/2022 09:28

WimpoleHat · 08/09/2022 08:45

It's like saying what are black people, "they were lesser humans brought over from Africa to serve the white". Why not say HIV is a sad disease that is now manageable?

The slavery analogy works - but it’s the other way round, surely? It’s like a child asking “what is slavery?” and your answer being “forcing someone to work for you and treating them like a possession”, without mentioning at all the fact that through history it was black people who were overwhelmingly the victims of it. And it’s not really a full explanation without it, certainly not if a child has been reading about something in the news because they won’t then understand what they were asking about in the first place.

There is no need to go into the history of it for a 9 year old and if you did it's not true that black people have overwhelmingly been the victims
throughout history. That would be more recent history.

WimpoleHat · 08/09/2022 08:45

It's like saying what are black people, "they were lesser humans brought over from Africa to serve the white". Why not say HIV is a sad disease that is now manageable?

The slavery analogy works - but it’s the other way round, surely? It’s like a child asking “what is slavery?” and your answer being “forcing someone to work for you and treating them like a possession”, without mentioning at all the fact that through history it was black people who were overwhelmingly the victims of it. And it’s not really a full explanation without it, certainly not if a child has been reading about something in the news because they won’t then understand what they were asking about in the first place.

WimpoleHat · 08/09/2022 08:34

I asked her where she had heard about that but she wouldn't tell me, kept saying she was unsure but had heard about it.

Context is always king in these scenarios - and the OP’s daughter wouldn’t give her any. FWIW, I gave a very similar explanation to my (slightly older) kids when we were listening to the news and someone from an AIDS charity was being interviewed and was discussing Freddie Mercury’s illness. Sometimes the history and context is hugely relevant and a pap one line answer causes more confusion than it solves. So I think she was quite right to give the child a longer explanation when the child hadn’t told her how or where she’d heard about it and why she was asking.

milkyaqua · 08/09/2022 08:20

Also, both 40 years ago, and now, HIV is more prevalent in the gay male population, in the west.

I would think a more pertinent question is why is a young girl asking about it. Rather than blaming the OP for her reply.

georgarina · 08/09/2022 08:18

redbigbananafeet · 08/09/2022 00:08

Why give the history that was wrong? It's like saying what are black people, "they were lesser humans brought over from Africa to serve the white". Why not say HIV is a sad disease that is now manageable?

Wtf are you talking about? It's nothing like what she said.
To say HIV spread through the gay male community initially and is still more prevalent there is just a basic fact that no gay person I know would dispute.

What you're arguing for on the other hand, to use your slavery example, is like saying slavery didn't primarily affect black people, it affected everyone the same.

milkyaqua · 08/09/2022 08:15

redbigbananafeet · 08/09/2022 07:15

Milkyaqua I don't think anyone is denying that it used to be more prevalent in gay guys, but I'm not sure why 40 odd years later that's how you'd introduce the disease to a 9 year old.

I don't know why you'd feel the need to lie about or fudge the history of a disease. If a nine year old is asking questions, then it is better to hear the facts.

BY the way, I am the sixth person to agree with and quote that pp, perhaps you want to have a stern word with them too?

redbigbananafeet · 08/09/2022 07:15

Milkyaqua I don't think anyone is denying that it used to be more prevalent in gay guys, but I'm not sure why 40 odd years later that's how you'd introduce the disease to a 9 year old.

Ilovelurchers · 08/09/2022 07:13

MissyCooperismyShero · 07/09/2022 21:30

Are these gay sex aware nine year olds the same kids that Mumsnet always claim still believe in Santa?

That's quite funny! Mine certainly doesn't (believe in Santa). Indeed I have always struggled to see how any child with any awareness of reality could sustain that belief beyond the age of about 4. Nor why it is considered especially desirable.

Am also struggling to know how a 9 year old could not be aware of sex. Unless they only watch C-Beebies. Don't people's kids watch films and stuff? And soap.operas? And, I dunno, the news. Documentaries, etc. Sex is q big part of life and frequently referred to in a wide range of contexts.

And the vast majority of kids will surely be aware that some people are gay. Having met gay people.

So if they know sex exists and what it is, and know gay people exist, ergo they will be aware of gay sex..... I struggle to see how anyone raises a child who isn't, unless they put extreme effort into sheltering them from his awareness (and why would you?)

milkyaqua · 08/09/2022 00:22

WorkingItOutAsIGo · 07/09/2022 18:46

I am genuinely confused by some of these responses. You seem to be falling over yourselves to deny that it was ever a disease which featured strongly on the gay community? Is that fact seen as homophobic now? Because I was a young adult in the 1980s and it was very clearly running rampantly though the gay community. Of course - even then - it was known that other people got it too, depending on their risk profile. But to deny the tragic experience of the gay community in this way seems very strange.

At one point in the early 1990s I counted up that I had lost 17 friends to AIDS. All were gay men. Thank goodness for better medicine now.

Can someone kindly explain why stating this history is wrong?

Exactly.

This is the history, both public and personal, that I know.

redbigbananafeet · 08/09/2022 00:11

x2boys · 07/09/2022 18:31

Well.its true it was believed that only gay men could get it at first ,It was originally named GRIDS ,but it became apparent that anyone could get it ,it did remain more prevalent though with iv drug users, sex workers ,people with haemophilia and gay men that's not untrue

And same sex relationships were illegal and punishable by imprisonment and castration, some countries death by stoning? So if a kid asks you what gay is, is that the point in history you start? Or do you say it's two people of the same sex that are attracted to each other?

redbigbananafeet · 08/09/2022 00:08

Why give the history that was wrong? It's like saying what are black people, "they were lesser humans brought over from Africa to serve the white". Why not say HIV is a sad disease that is now manageable?

dianthus101 · 08/09/2022 00:06

GreenestValley · 07/09/2022 19:52

The reason it was thought to be only passed through gay sex was because 99% of the people who had it were gay men. And they knew little or nothing about it for years after it emerged.

there was definitely homophobia in the way it was handled and stigma for those suffering but its not homophobic to explain the origins of the disease and the fact it affected gay communities worst. If anything it’s respectful to their memories vs pretending that for instance, straight women were as likely to carry or contract it.

It wasn't thought to be only passed on through gay sex though. I was a teenager at the time (mid 80s) and the public health message was very clear that it wasn't just passed on through gay sex and that anyone could get it (although gay men were at higher risk). It wasn't initially clear that men who only had sex with women were actually at very low risk unless they shared needles.

Boujisboo · 07/09/2022 22:10

maloofshoof · 07/09/2022 18:28

You're right. I just felt really put on the spot and that I had to give her an explanation but looking back, you're right, she didn't need that.

You’ll know for the future just to give a factual answer. Having said that my 11 year old asked about it and had heard about Freddie Mercury. It opened up a conversation that I think was positive w for her to know the shit that gay people and people with hiv had to go through.
i don’t think you have messed up just probably have her a bit too much info at that age!

GreenestValley · 07/09/2022 22:09

GreenestValley · 07/09/2022 21:15

source?
www.tht.org.uk/news/heterosexual-hiv-diagnoses-overtake-those-gay-men-first-time-decade
even in 2020 half of all new cases are gay men, which is the lowest it’s ever been.
back in the 80s it was much much higher. I’ll look for the stats later.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2870809/
three quarters of people diagnosed with aids in 2004 were gay men

wheel back 20 years before that and it will have been 90% +

So it is denying gay experience to deny the link between LGBT communities and this awful disease in the first few dreadful decades of its existence before it became a non terminal illness. Its genuinely like saying the holocaust didnt disproportionately affect jewish people. Just a misguided and offensive reading of the past.

right ill shut up now.

OnTheBoardwalk · 07/09/2022 22:06

it's a virus and it stops your body fighting off other diseases. When it was first discovered, ages ago, it was very serious because no one knew how to treat it. But now, scientists have found medicines to stop it making people ill.
does that answer your question?

this for me. There are so many drugs now available daily like the pill to help stop transmission as well as the HIV treatments to lower the count

the biggest wake up call for me was the NHS mixing gallons and gallons of blood transfusions mixed with blood given to hemopilliacs .