Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think that at some point people will have to say that Brexit was never a good idea

213 replies

heatissweet · 07/09/2022 16:34

We are sinking as a country and only a very few people are better off since Brexit. It seems to me like an experiment that hasn't worked. AIBU to think that it's odd that it's hardly mentioned as one of the reasons why everything is so bleak right now? Even Liz Truss thought it was a bad idea at the time.

OP posts:
UnnecessaryFennel · 07/09/2022 19:48

And all the signs are that levelling up has effectively been shelved by our new PM. No minister for it, and IDS apparently has 'never been sure what it meant'.

But yeah, everything's totally fine and dandy in brexitland.

SofiaSoFar · 07/09/2022 19:43

feedyourheed · 07/09/2022 17:44

For those of us who wanted to be free of EU law, free of the destruction of our industries (too late sadly) and increasing federalisation then it will never have been a bad idea to leave.

All remain voters care about is easy transit through the EU, not having to fill out forms etc. So many remainers don't understand what they were REALLY voting for if you ask me. Very few knew much about the EU, other than that they were besieged by media outlets telling them we depended upon it for our very survival.

"Free of the destruction of our industries..." ???

Are you serious?! Have you seen the news at all since Brexit?

Forget Covid and Ukraine, even without those it was already catastrophic for many industries.

And now with the utterly laughable 'trade deals' - including the New Zealand one our heroic new leader eulogised but which NZ farmers actually thought was a joke as it's so heavily weighted in their favour(!) - more industries will be brought down in the near future.

I can barely believe what I'm reading from some people in this thread. Is there a parallel universe some of you are living in?

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 19:41

Florenz · 07/09/2022 19:10

The benefits of Britain being in the EU were not spread around equally. Middle-class/rich people benefitted from us being in the EU, working-class people did not. Middle-class/rich people are more likely to be highly educated and have the money and connections to be able to work in foreign countries, because they have skills that are in demand, they benefit from having more opportunities, being able to have more employers competing for them. Working-class people do not benefit from any of this, instead they suffer as they have to compete with immigrant workers who will "work harder for lower wages". This is why Brexit won. Why people can't accept that is beyond me.

That is your perception @Florenz, it is far from reality. The EU funded infrastructure such as community centres and many programmes for deprived areas, disabled people and the elderly and provided grants to many charities. When we were in the EU, working class and poor kids could travel to Spain/Greece etc and get a job for less than the cost of a train fare from London to Manchester. Many of them did.

PM Johnson's Leveling Up policy was supposed to replace the money deprived areas lost when we left the EU. It isn't even close to what we had before. Lower middle class and working class kids have been shafted by the removal of FOM. The rich are fine by dint of being rich.

Antarcticant · 07/09/2022 19:37

TotallyScouting · 07/09/2022 18:42

Not yet 40 not 49! 49 is a bit ancient 😂🙈

49 'ancient' ? I should hope you rethink that in 9 years' time otherwise you'll be in for a dreary middle-age.

Flutterbybudget · 07/09/2022 19:36

The Brexit espousing campaigners started off with “it’ll be wonderful”, £350 million to the NHS, freedom to control our own borders, freedom to create our own laws, no one can tell us what to do, we hold all the cards etc
It then became, “we survived the Blitz”, “the EU are being awkward” etc
Now it’s “none of our woes are anything to do with Brexit at all” “there’s a war” “Covid” etc
Heck, even Nigel Farage is complaining that “this is not the Brexit I voted for”, except it IS the Brexit that he and millions of others voted for, it’s the Brexit that “project fear” predicted, it’s the Brexit that those who voted against it feared.

So basically, no, I don’t think the majority of people who voted for Brexit will ever admit that they made a mistake, there will always be someone or something else that they will blame for the complete and utter clusterfuck that is Brexit

ZaphodDent · 07/09/2022 19:25

UWhatNow · 07/09/2022 17:11

You can’t possibly say that brexit has failed - we are still going through the process. Turning the ship will take time. The final analysis won’t be able to be judged for at least another 5-10 years.

This is so annoying. We were told Brexit would be so great that we could immediately start giving the NHS £350M a week. Sunlit uplands, we were told. Have our cake and eat it, we were told.

The next ten years will see my 2 DC starting their career and hopefully settling down. A vital time in their lives. Wish someone had warned me about this in 2016!

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 19:20

Among the Left leaning Leave voters some don't regret it. Others regret it because of what has happened since, Covid, war etc.

heatissweet · 07/09/2022 19:17

The benefits of Britain being in the EU were not spread around equally. Middle-class/rich people benefitted from us being in the EU, working-class people did not.

I think that's too simplistic, because of things like EU subsidies to certain areas, sometimes deprived areas. And anyway, one thing is certain is that working class and poorer people have definitely not benefitted since we left!

OP posts:
bellac11 · 07/09/2022 19:11

Exactly, the issues for NI and the Republic havent even been touched on yet

There is a huge reason why the vast vast majority of business owners voted and campaigned to remain. Brexit has not been good for business.

Florenz · 07/09/2022 19:10

The benefits of Britain being in the EU were not spread around equally. Middle-class/rich people benefitted from us being in the EU, working-class people did not. Middle-class/rich people are more likely to be highly educated and have the money and connections to be able to work in foreign countries, because they have skills that are in demand, they benefit from having more opportunities, being able to have more employers competing for them. Working-class people do not benefit from any of this, instead they suffer as they have to compete with immigrant workers who will "work harder for lower wages". This is why Brexit won. Why people can't accept that is beyond me.

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 19:08

Where I live:
Most NI Unionist Leave voters regret it. It's made business more difficult and destabilised the Union. The ones who don't regret voting Leave are a lot more wary about what it will actually mean. Brexit is not Done!
The paramilitaries and Ex paramilitaries who voted Leave do not regret it. It has destabilised the Union and provided smuggling opportunities.
The racist Leave voters are raging.😆😆😆
My Leave voting SiL doesn't regret it. She disappeared down the Qanon/anti-vax rabbit hole during lockdown and has yet to emerge so we don't discuss politics much.

Starfishswimmer · 07/09/2022 19:04

I blame the media Brexit

HakuSansTan · 07/09/2022 19:03

Florenz · 07/09/2022 18:52

So tired of people going on about Brexit. Being in the EU wasn't of benefit to enough British people, if it was, remain would have won. For all the people going on about losing the freedom to study, work all over the EU, the amount of people that actually did that is very small, far less than the amount of people negatively affected by downward pressure on wages due to unfettered EU immigration, plus all the pressure on housing, public services etc.

Maybe just maybe, if remainers had cared more about people outside of their immediate social circle, they'd have realised that a hell of a lot of people did not like being in the EU at all, there probably wouldn't have been referendum though if that was the case. Cameron only had the referendum became he thought it was a certainty that remain would win.

You are tired yet pop up with your usual trite and bilge.

What is it this time? Remainers should have looked outside their social circle to realise most people didn't like being in the EU and Cameron only called the referendum because he though remain would win.

I prefer my average Brexiter not to hide behind posts like yours. It is something you always do. It is transparent and cowardly. Own your Brexit badge.

heatissweet · 07/09/2022 19:03

I agree we need to move beyond 'sides' or who did what, and try to look at the actual reality and what it will all mean for our future. It has been rubbish so far and there's no sign that we are getting any benefits. So at some point we will have to put the past behind us and face up to reality.

OP posts:
bellac11 · 07/09/2022 19:02

TokidokiBarbie · 07/09/2022 18:59

Tbh I doubt people who voted leave really give a shit about the opinions of those that didn't. They got what they wanted and that was that.

Its true and Ive heard people say that they actually dont care if the country is at a disadvantage as long as we are no longer members so the price is different

balalake · 07/09/2022 19:02

What people think privately and what they will say publicly may be different. I think that no-one expected it to be anything other than a Remain vote, and never thought it would be a Leave vote. Denial will continue for a long time I expect.

The very few benefits there are from Brexit are not going to be those that we get in reality, at least whilst there is a Tory government.

UnnecessaryFennel · 07/09/2022 19:01

TokidokiBarbie · 07/09/2022 18:57

At some point people might also stop making these fucking threads every few days. And they might even manage to post them in the dedicated Brexit topic.

Wouldn't it be brilliant if you had the freedom and ability to ignore threads you didn't like or weren't interested in? That would be so cool, wouldn't it? Maybe MN should get onto that.

HoneyIShrunkThePizza · 07/09/2022 18:59

I wish we could have conversations about this without calling people morons. I understand the anger, I cried when the Brexit vote happened, but when we continue to make it tribal both sides just dig their heels in and no valuable conversation can happen about how on earth this happened.

TokidokiBarbie · 07/09/2022 18:59

HakuSansTan · 07/09/2022 18:54

But @MarshaBradyo it has been 6 years. We left the European Union and all that came with it (good and bad as wasn't perfect)

It is now demonstrably bad as a result. How do you suppose those of us so appalled by it remain silent on the off chance we can hear the leavers speak?

Do tell me and I will take it on board.

They were loud and proud post Brexit and up until fairly recently tbf.

Can you not concede it is because they can't defend it anymore... Can't produce any tangible benefits, if a single one at all?

I don't think anyone should quieten down so we can listen to 'put off' posters. Many of them bathed in their 'win' and told us all to get over it.

I for one won't get over it or shut up.

Tbh I doubt people who voted leave really give a shit about the opinions of those that didn't. They got what they wanted and that was that.

MarshaBradyo · 07/09/2022 18:58

HakuSansTan · 07/09/2022 18:54

But @MarshaBradyo it has been 6 years. We left the European Union and all that came with it (good and bad as wasn't perfect)

It is now demonstrably bad as a result. How do you suppose those of us so appalled by it remain silent on the off chance we can hear the leavers speak?

Do tell me and I will take it on board.

They were loud and proud post Brexit and up until fairly recently tbf.

Can you not concede it is because they can't defend it anymore... Can't produce any tangible benefits, if a single one at all?

I don't think anyone should quieten down so we can listen to 'put off' posters. Many of them bathed in their 'win' and told us all to get over it.

I for one won't get over it or shut up.

I don’t think I’ve said that anyone has to be silent, the opposite debate is ok

I do think that responses such as stupid etc can be why these threads are more one sided than the vote

Anyway mn agreed and have deleted posts and posted that people are more civil so I guess they have same view

TokidokiBarbie · 07/09/2022 18:57

At some point people might also stop making these fucking threads every few days. And they might even manage to post them in the dedicated Brexit topic.

bellac11 · 07/09/2022 18:56

Florenz · 07/09/2022 18:52

So tired of people going on about Brexit. Being in the EU wasn't of benefit to enough British people, if it was, remain would have won. For all the people going on about losing the freedom to study, work all over the EU, the amount of people that actually did that is very small, far less than the amount of people negatively affected by downward pressure on wages due to unfettered EU immigration, plus all the pressure on housing, public services etc.

Maybe just maybe, if remainers had cared more about people outside of their immediate social circle, they'd have realised that a hell of a lot of people did not like being in the EU at all, there probably wouldn't have been referendum though if that was the case. Cameron only had the referendum became he thought it was a certainty that remain would win.

Heres another example of what I was talking about

The complete lack of understanding (although the information was very freely available and discussed) of what EU funding brought into deprived areas, the same areas that voted to leave.

Being part of and a hugely influential member of the EU was enormously beneficial to British people, large numbers of social activities, new roads, educational facilities, work/employment/rights issues, safety issues, cleaner environments, cheaper products, quicker access to goods. The list is endless.

Only the deliberately obtuse refuse to see this

HakuSansTan · 07/09/2022 18:54

MarshaBradyo · 07/09/2022 18:23

I’m assuming this post is to me no sure so maybe not

Imo people get put off posting as they just get so much flack back - stupid etc. there’s so much anger it becomes a pile on. So these threads are more one sided than the actual vote

I don’t know if majority leave voters regret it or not because they probably just avoid mn on this topic

But @MarshaBradyo it has been 6 years. We left the European Union and all that came with it (good and bad as wasn't perfect)

It is now demonstrably bad as a result. How do you suppose those of us so appalled by it remain silent on the off chance we can hear the leavers speak?

Do tell me and I will take it on board.

They were loud and proud post Brexit and up until fairly recently tbf.

Can you not concede it is because they can't defend it anymore... Can't produce any tangible benefits, if a single one at all?

I don't think anyone should quieten down so we can listen to 'put off' posters. Many of them bathed in their 'win' and told us all to get over it.

I for one won't get over it or shut up.

heatissweet · 07/09/2022 18:52

But who else would you like to see accept it? Do you mean leave voters or more media or politicians

They can look around them and see actual evidence that it was a bad idea. I'm saying we can't as a country keep ignoring reality

OP posts:
Florenz · 07/09/2022 18:52

So tired of people going on about Brexit. Being in the EU wasn't of benefit to enough British people, if it was, remain would have won. For all the people going on about losing the freedom to study, work all over the EU, the amount of people that actually did that is very small, far less than the amount of people negatively affected by downward pressure on wages due to unfettered EU immigration, plus all the pressure on housing, public services etc.

Maybe just maybe, if remainers had cared more about people outside of their immediate social circle, they'd have realised that a hell of a lot of people did not like being in the EU at all, there probably wouldn't have been referendum though if that was the case. Cameron only had the referendum became he thought it was a certainty that remain would win.

Swipe left for the next trending thread