Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think that at some point people will have to say that Brexit was never a good idea

213 replies

heatissweet · 07/09/2022 16:34

We are sinking as a country and only a very few people are better off since Brexit. It seems to me like an experiment that hasn't worked. AIBU to think that it's odd that it's hardly mentioned as one of the reasons why everything is so bleak right now? Even Liz Truss thought it was a bad idea at the time.

OP posts:
bellinisurge · 08/09/2022 06:40

No one likes to admit they were lied to.

HRTQueen · 08/09/2022 00:41

I think it’s better it’s not such a spoken about political issue as people have become tired of the subject

give a few years and we can work towards re joining at the moment there would be too many responding like Brenda ‘what another one I can’t stand this’

KenAdams · 08/09/2022 00:27

Not sure if this has been posted yet but this FT article was an interesting read - on.ft.com/3cRSfvw

mamabear715 · 07/09/2022 23:55

It happened. Move on.

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 23:52

Thing is @SunscreenCentral a lot of them do admit it. Maybe not as vocally as they proclaimed Leave and few Mnetters will, but IRL they are. And they, like PP are looking at how they were lied to and are rightfully pissed off about it.

jcyclops · 07/09/2022 23:19

heatissweet · 07/09/2022 17:49

How many years were we a country outside of the European Union? I know it happened in my lifetime. I don’t understand why so many people act as though we were never a country that stood alone.

Just googled and it said talks started to join the EU in 1970 and we joined in 1973? so for many MNers like me we have always been in -but am not sure why that is relevant anyway? the world has moved on since the 60s Confused

We joined the EEC (later EC) on 1st January 1973 under Heath, and held a referendum on it under Wilson on 5th June 1975. The EEC was a very different organisation to the EU.

We signed up to join the EU on 7th February 1992 under John Major's government. It had to be ratified by parliament, and this proved impossible for many months. Labour under John Smith was against it, and a large number of Tory Eurosceptics also persistently voted against. Major eventually got it through in July 1993 by threatening to dissolve parliament and hold a general election, thus bringing the Tory rebels onside. The treaty became effective on 1st November 1993. Incidentally, the French only ratified it after a referendum with a Yes vote of 50.8%, so the EU was very close to never existing!

TokidokiBarbie · 07/09/2022 23:09

I once had a leave voter explain it to me as below (paraphrased).

'Which would you prefer? To be married to a rich man and have loads of resources but have to relinquish your independence and have him govern your actions? Or would you prefer to be independent and self sufficient but poorer in the short term?'

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 23:06

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 07/09/2022 21:48

@Florenz

So tired of people going on about Brexit. Being in the EU wasn't of benefit to enough British people, if it was, remain would have won. For all the people going on about losing the freedom to study, work all over the EU, the amount of people that actually did that is very small, far less than the amount of people negatively affected by downward pressure on wages due to unfettered EU immigration, plus all the pressure on housing, public services etc

Maybe just maybe, if remainers had cared more about people outside of their immediate social circle, they'd have realised that a hell of a lot of people did not like being in the EU at all, there probably wouldn't have been referendum though if that was the case. Cameron only had the referendum became he thought it was a certainty that remain would win.

Brilliant post!!! You will of course get shouted down on here however, for not slathering all over the EU and singing their non-existent praises. Because the remainers (the type you see on threads like this anyway,) cannot stand ANY point of view except their own, and will just not accept that a massive amount of people wanted to leave the EU for very bloody good reasons!!!... People from all walks of life, all classes, all careers, all colours and creeds, and all education levels.

Because they got absolutely NO benefit from it whatsoever, they realised we don't need to be in it, and that the EU has outlived its usefulness and is nothing but a big boys club for the elite. A LOT of people agree with your point of view, but don't post/won't post because of the usual boring and predictable 'racist, gammon, bigot, thick, low-class brexit scum' type posts that the champagne socialists always trot out.

This is why LEAVE won, even though most people expected REMAIN would, because the leave voters were shouted down so often by the vile far left wokies and their toxic bile, that they just stopped saying anything. The silent majority won.

The same thing happened with the general elections.

The left control the media, they control the message forums, they control magazines, they control TV and film, they control twitter and facebook and instagram and social media in general...

They do NOT control the ballot boxes.

The UK press is predominately right wing: The Times, The Mail, The Sun, Express etc. Many of them opposed Brexit.

Brexit was far from a Left vs Right issue.

SunscreenCentral · 07/09/2022 22:58

They will never admit it. How could they?

A great harm was done to the people of the nations of the UK whilst the Rees Mogg nightmare slendermen coined it all in and moved their corporate entities to Europe.

Even that pathetic troll that takes money for saying what you pay him to (Farage - took me that long to come up with his name, sorry..) got his family EU passports immediately through his wife god love her. As he always knew he would.

We are all Europeans. But the UK is some kind of weird Arkansas now.

heatissweet · 07/09/2022 22:44

It's called empathy but I'm guessing you might not be too familiar with it, given the forcing of your Brexit whinges on people who don't seem too keen to read them.

Hmm
OP posts:
TokidokiBarbie · 07/09/2022 22:40

heatissweet · 07/09/2022 22:29

Two conflicting posts, about how you've both made a fortune now from truck driving, and at the same time are not enamoured with Brexit and people shouldn't start threads on it. But if we hadn't had the thread we wouldn't have found out about the big boost it has given truck drivers so there's that.

Well, I'm not making a fortune yet. Just making £45k rather than £35k. But the huge deficit of competition will no doubt make it much easier to get started as a Ltd company - main contractor are so desperate for drivers they've been helping some of them with the initial outlay involved in hiring the vehicles and maintaining them - in the long run it's better for them to cut out the middlemen like my bosses.

And there's nothing conflicting about me recognising that what's good for me isn't necessarily good for the country as a whole. It's called empathy but I'm guessing you might not be too familiar with it, given the forcing of your Brexit whinges on people who don't seem too keen to read them.

bellinisurge · 07/09/2022 22:33

I'm not crying over it. I'm bored of people pretending it's not having a negative impact on our economy. And I'm as concerned as I was before the wretched vote about Northern Ireland.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 07/09/2022 22:31

TokidokiBarbie · 07/09/2022 22:24

Piss off.

The reason there's a Brexit section (and a gender section now) is because people were getting sick of reading these threads. It takes a certain type of arrogance/attention seeking to deliberately ignore the hint and continue posting in the highest traffic areas to 'force' people to see your threads.

The only people who are still crying over it are people like you, so you may as well go and have a group sniffle in your special section.

I'm not enamoured with Brexit overall despite the massive personal benefits to myself, but it's happened and it's time to stop being a massive crybaby/sore loser. We live in a thing called a democracy and the majority have spoken.

If only I could LIKE this post 100 X over!

Wisper10 · 07/09/2022 22:29

TokidokiBarbie · 07/09/2022 22:24

Piss off.

The reason there's a Brexit section (and a gender section now) is because people were getting sick of reading these threads. It takes a certain type of arrogance/attention seeking to deliberately ignore the hint and continue posting in the highest traffic areas to 'force' people to see your threads.

The only people who are still crying over it are people like you, so you may as well go and have a group sniffle in your special section.

I'm not enamoured with Brexit overall despite the massive personal benefits to myself, but it's happened and it's time to stop being a massive crybaby/sore loser. We live in a thing called a democracy and the majority have spoken.

Well said, my thinking exactly.

heatissweet · 07/09/2022 22:29

Two conflicting posts, about how you've both made a fortune now from truck driving, and at the same time are not enamoured with Brexit and people shouldn't start threads on it. But if we hadn't had the thread we wouldn't have found out about the big boost it has given truck drivers so there's that.

OP posts:
TokidokiBarbie · 07/09/2022 22:24

UnnecessaryFennel · 07/09/2022 22:10

It's so annoying how you're forced to read and comment too, isn't it? Such a waste of your time. If only there was a way of ignoring threads you're not interested in.

Piss off.

The reason there's a Brexit section (and a gender section now) is because people were getting sick of reading these threads. It takes a certain type of arrogance/attention seeking to deliberately ignore the hint and continue posting in the highest traffic areas to 'force' people to see your threads.

The only people who are still crying over it are people like you, so you may as well go and have a group sniffle in your special section.

I'm not enamoured with Brexit overall despite the massive personal benefits to myself, but it's happened and it's time to stop being a massive crybaby/sore loser. We live in a thing called a democracy and the majority have spoken.

TokidokiBarbie · 07/09/2022 22:13

Florenz · 07/09/2022 19:10

The benefits of Britain being in the EU were not spread around equally. Middle-class/rich people benefitted from us being in the EU, working-class people did not. Middle-class/rich people are more likely to be highly educated and have the money and connections to be able to work in foreign countries, because they have skills that are in demand, they benefit from having more opportunities, being able to have more employers competing for them. Working-class people do not benefit from any of this, instead they suffer as they have to compete with immigrant workers who will "work harder for lower wages". This is why Brexit won. Why people can't accept that is beyond me.

My anecdotal (but probably quite common) experience as a truck driver supports this.

My empoyer subcontracts for a large (household name) building company on the aggregates side. They very much position themselves as an 'ethical' company but much of what goes on around the periphery is anything but.

One of the main logistics providers apparently used to pay their drivers almost £300 a day, going back a good few years. They certainly earned it, being on the road all week doing long hours and sleeping in the truck, but still a decent salary. However, the boss started slowly replacing his drivers with Romanian drivers who were happy to do the job for £90 a day. Every time a new one joined he'd get rid of an English driver a couple months later it seemed.

The main client started using them almost exclusively and I must admit I was doubtful my contract would be renewed. They were only charging a day rate of £600 per truck compared to the £800 the rest were charging (obv the gaffer could afford to do this as he was saving £200 day on each drivers wage).

Well, it's all been shaken up now! The abovementioned contractor has now had to raise salaries from £90 to £200 due to all his Romanians either going home or jumping to one of the many other better paid jobs created by the driver deficit. And nobody sleeps in the truck anymore or works for longer than 10 hours.

I'm making over £10k more a year and will be able to absolutely rake it in once I finish my operator's license and can work direct (can just hire a truck and continue with my job as normal, but I'll be making £600 a day rather than £200 - realistically £300-400 a day after diesel and other expenses).

No way would I be in this situation if there were still loads of Romanians happy to drive for £90 a day.

UnnecessaryFennel · 07/09/2022 22:10

Kitkatcatflap · 07/09/2022 22:05

Every bloody week the same question in a different form ..... It's getting really tiresome.

It's so annoying how you're forced to read and comment too, isn't it? Such a waste of your time. If only there was a way of ignoring threads you're not interested in.

Kitkatcatflap · 07/09/2022 22:05

Every bloody week the same question in a different form ..... It's getting really tiresome.

UnnecessaryFennel · 07/09/2022 22:04

the leave voters were shouted down so often by the vile far left wokies

Much of the 'far left' supported (and still support) Brexit. Have you never heard of Lexit?

And as for the rubbish about the left owning the media - give me a break. Honestly, you can't be serious? The Mail, the Sun, the Express, the Telegraph, the BBC? Left wing??

echt · 07/09/2022 21:57

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 07/09/2022 21:48

@Florenz

So tired of people going on about Brexit. Being in the EU wasn't of benefit to enough British people, if it was, remain would have won. For all the people going on about losing the freedom to study, work all over the EU, the amount of people that actually did that is very small, far less than the amount of people negatively affected by downward pressure on wages due to unfettered EU immigration, plus all the pressure on housing, public services etc

Maybe just maybe, if remainers had cared more about people outside of their immediate social circle, they'd have realised that a hell of a lot of people did not like being in the EU at all, there probably wouldn't have been referendum though if that was the case. Cameron only had the referendum became he thought it was a certainty that remain would win.

Brilliant post!!! You will of course get shouted down on here however, for not slathering all over the EU and singing their non-existent praises. Because the remainers (the type you see on threads like this anyway,) cannot stand ANY point of view except their own, and will just not accept that a massive amount of people wanted to leave the EU for very bloody good reasons!!!... People from all walks of life, all classes, all careers, all colours and creeds, and all education levels.

Because they got absolutely NO benefit from it whatsoever, they realised we don't need to be in it, and that the EU has outlived its usefulness and is nothing but a big boys club for the elite. A LOT of people agree with your point of view, but don't post/won't post because of the usual boring and predictable 'racist, gammon, bigot, thick, low-class brexit scum' type posts that the champagne socialists always trot out.

This is why LEAVE won, even though most people expected REMAIN would, because the leave voters were shouted down so often by the vile far left wokies and their toxic bile, that they just stopped saying anything. The silent majority won.

The same thing happened with the general elections.

The left control the media, they control the message forums, they control magazines, they control TV and film, they control twitter and facebook and instagram and social media in general...

They do NOT control the ballot boxes.

The left control the media? On what planet?

heatissweet · 07/09/2022 21:55

The left control the media, they control the message forums, they control magazines, they control TV and film, they control twitter and facebook and instagram and social media in general...

Like that popular left wing publication the Daily Mail

OP posts:
WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 07/09/2022 21:48

@Florenz

So tired of people going on about Brexit. Being in the EU wasn't of benefit to enough British people, if it was, remain would have won. For all the people going on about losing the freedom to study, work all over the EU, the amount of people that actually did that is very small, far less than the amount of people negatively affected by downward pressure on wages due to unfettered EU immigration, plus all the pressure on housing, public services etc

Maybe just maybe, if remainers had cared more about people outside of their immediate social circle, they'd have realised that a hell of a lot of people did not like being in the EU at all, there probably wouldn't have been referendum though if that was the case. Cameron only had the referendum became he thought it was a certainty that remain would win.

Brilliant post!!! You will of course get shouted down on here however, for not slathering all over the EU and singing their non-existent praises. Because the remainers (the type you see on threads like this anyway,) cannot stand ANY point of view except their own, and will just not accept that a massive amount of people wanted to leave the EU for very bloody good reasons!!!... People from all walks of life, all classes, all careers, all colours and creeds, and all education levels.

Because they got absolutely NO benefit from it whatsoever, they realised we don't need to be in it, and that the EU has outlived its usefulness and is nothing but a big boys club for the elite. A LOT of people agree with your point of view, but don't post/won't post because of the usual boring and predictable 'racist, gammon, bigot, thick, low-class brexit scum' type posts that the champagne socialists always trot out.

This is why LEAVE won, even though most people expected REMAIN would, because the leave voters were shouted down so often by the vile far left wokies and their toxic bile, that they just stopped saying anything. The silent majority won.

The same thing happened with the general elections.

The left control the media, they control the message forums, they control magazines, they control TV and film, they control twitter and facebook and instagram and social media in general...

They do NOT control the ballot boxes.

Wisper10 · 07/09/2022 21:29

Chevyimpala67 · 07/09/2022 16:58

The facts are that we are now below India and are the world's 7th largest economy- down from 5th in 2016.

We have the lowest growth of all G7 nations.

Once the ukraine war is over and the global recession recedes the true damage to the UK will be clear

Whatever you do, don't let the fact that the population of India is 21 times that of the UK cloud your argument.

Exasperatednow · 07/09/2022 21:22

HakuSansTan · 07/09/2022 18:10

👏

People should read 'why great nations fail' Paul Kennedy - looking at 100s of years of history.

Biggest most fundamental reason, is that they isolate themselves.

Guess what we've done?