Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why people vote Tory?

596 replies

Tierne · 07/09/2022 14:25

It has to be said that life in the UK on low or middle income is much harder than it seemingly is in other western countries of similar wealth. I dont think the Tory party is making this country a nice place to live in at all. But they keep getting voted in.

So if you vote Tory:
Why do you vote for them?
Would you ever change your vote and for what reason?
Do you feel uncomfortable at how Tory policies batter the most vulnerable in our society? For example making it impossible for people to get on the housing ladder, high rents and low tenant protections, no energy bill caps, etc?

NB: I dont want this to turn into a Tory bashing thread. I'd just like to hear how Tory supporters feel about their party.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 09/09/2022 16:29

We’ll never know will we @Culldesack? It’s pointless to speculate.

Culldesack · 09/09/2022 16:26

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2022 15:55

Labour has historically been a high spending, high taxation party

It’s not now. The Tory government has levied the highest taxes for 70 odd years. 🤷‍♀️

I'm not surprised, after Covid. I dread to think how the Labour Party would have handled it.

hop321 · 09/09/2022 16:19

That’s pure speculation.

But it's not, it's based on their previous time on power. Either way, I'm not going to keep debating the point. Not many people would view Labour as a lower tax party than the Conservatives. If you do, that's your call.

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2022 16:13

Labour would have looked to raise tax further, not least to have more spending power.

That’s pure speculation. The current government hasn’t even costed its plans and it’s borrowing to fund them. Every single expenditure in the last Labour manifesto was costed. This government is spending like a drunken sailor on shore leave with no clue as to how or who will pay for it.

MarshaBradyo · 09/09/2022 16:05

wigywhoo · 09/09/2022 15:56

Pretty exceptional circumstances, unprecedented global pandemic in the modern era...,

And then war.

this is a good resource for energy security and why windfall tax undermines it

oeuk.org.uk

and view on WFT

oeuk.org.uk/a-windfall-tax-on-the-uks-energy-providers-risks-adding-a-uk-supply-crisis-to-a-global-price-crisis-warns-oeuk-chief-executive/

Starmer is playing to the crowd but he is looking at it on what goes down well level. Easier if you have zero chance to implement something which has negative impact.

hop321 · 09/09/2022 16:02

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2022 15:57

Still true.

So you think Labour would have reduced tax? I highly doubt it unless they did a u-turn on their policies when they were in government.

Labour would have looked to raise tax further, not least to have more spending power.

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2022 15:57

Still true.

wigywhoo · 09/09/2022 15:56

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2022 15:55

Labour has historically been a high spending, high taxation party

It’s not now. The Tory government has levied the highest taxes for 70 odd years. 🤷‍♀️

Pretty exceptional circumstances, unprecedented global pandemic in the modern era...,

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2022 15:55

Labour has historically been a high spending, high taxation party

It’s not now. The Tory government has levied the highest taxes for 70 odd years. 🤷‍♀️

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2022 15:53

wigywhoo · 09/09/2022 15:28

This is where, surprise surprise labour are being dishonest. The 170bn represents worldwide profits, and it will already be heavily taxed. There comes a point where additional taxation is counterproductive as it deters economic activity. Further, as I say upthread these profits are vital for many private pension schemes- which benefit pensioners in all walks of life; it doesn't equal profits for some laughing mr Burns character!

Why did the BP CEO describe his business as a “cash machine”? Even the companies themselves are amenable to higher taxation on the profits.

news.sky.com/story/cash-machine-bp-more-than-doubles-bosss-pay-to-4-46m-as-energy-prices-surge-12569227

hop321 · 09/09/2022 15:35

I don’t know what Labour’s tax policy is because they haven’t yet announced it but I’m pretty sure their spending priorities will benefit public services that have been decimated in the last 12 years.

But I'm not talking about spending priorities, I'm talking about taxation. Labour has historically been a high spending, high taxation party.

MarshaBradyo · 09/09/2022 15:33

wigywhoo · 09/09/2022 15:28

This is where, surprise surprise labour are being dishonest. The 170bn represents worldwide profits, and it will already be heavily taxed. There comes a point where additional taxation is counterproductive as it deters economic activity. Further, as I say upthread these profits are vital for many private pension schemes- which benefit pensioners in all walks of life; it doesn't equal profits for some laughing mr Burns character!

It’s a good line for Labour as they can hammer it without acknowledging the long term consequences but I agree with you

Their next proposed windfall tax was only raising £8bn anyway which is a huge gap from what is required.

OEUK are against, speaking for more than just BP

wigywhoo · 09/09/2022 15:28

This is where, surprise surprise labour are being dishonest. The 170bn represents worldwide profits, and it will already be heavily taxed. There comes a point where additional taxation is counterproductive as it deters economic activity. Further, as I say upthread these profits are vital for many private pension schemes- which benefit pensioners in all walks of life; it doesn't equal profits for some laughing mr Burns character!

ddl1 · 09/09/2022 15:25

Culldesack · 09/09/2022 12:50

Funny how these replies always purport to be from non Labour voters. The amount of abuse the left receives, is nothing compared to what they dish out.

Perhaps because most people actually aren't members of either the Labour Party or any other party? And often not consistent voters for any one party?

Because you are (I presume) a Tory supporter, you notice when Tories are called 'thick and selfish', but not when people on the left are called 'crybaby losers', 'envious scroungers' or 'virtue-signalling hypocrites'. I can assure you that all these things happen! Often.

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2022 15:18

hop321 · 09/09/2022 15:10

That is true (not helped by having to fund the pandemic measures) but you can't tell me that Labour would be looking to lower tax?

Labour wants to tax the £170 billion excess profits the energy companies have made so far this financial year. Truss is putting the cost of the energy price freeze on the nation’s credit card. I don’t think that’s a sign of fiscal probity at any time, let alone when interest rates are rising. I don’t know what Labour’s tax policy is because they haven’t yet announced it but I’m pretty sure their spending priorities will benefit public services that have been decimated in the last 12 years.

hop321 · 09/09/2022 15:10

That is true (not helped by having to fund the pandemic measures) but you can't tell me that Labour would be looking to lower tax?

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2022 15:09

I wouldn't ever vote for Labour as they're essentially a higher taxation party

We currently have the highest level of taxation ever in peace time and Truss’ refusal to tax to fund the freeze on energy prices will see us paying the price for a decade. Meanwhile the CEO of BP says his company had the highest profits ever.

We’re reconciled to paying for our future healthcare because we’d be waiting for ever otherwise. I’d rather pay more tax and have a properly functioning NHS.

hop321 · 09/09/2022 15:03

I get it, you want other people’s money to be used to make your life easier. The reason that people vote Conservative is that they don’t agree, they expect you to provide for your own family.

I wouldn't have put it quite like this but it's not a million miles away from why I vote Conservative. As a household, we pay around 50% of our income in income tax/NI (and more when you add in other taxes). I genuinely believe that's enough and I don't want to pay more tax.

I know it's a controversial point but we also pay for private healthcare and education which means the government isn't having to fund those costs for us.

I wouldn't ever vote for Labour as they're essentially a higher taxation party and I don't like some of their race to the bottom type policies. Anyone that votes Conservative is vilified on MN but millions of people voted for them at the last election.

I also dislike some of Labour's magic money tree type policies. Great, let's squeeze the MNCs and increase corporation tax. Except you risk them moving their HQ/operations out of the U.K. so it's not a net gain when you lose their corporation tax revenue and income tax revenue from the employment they create in the U.K. Ditto for high earners who are often internationally mobile.

BuenoSucia · 09/09/2022 13:28

What personal experience do you have of being poor overseas? I only ask because despite having a “professiona job” in one of the countries ALWAYS suggested on mn as somewhere utopian to live… when I came back to the UK as a single mum on benefits I was waaaaaay better off. I cried when I realised my meagre possessions contained a (literally) dog chewed plastic ladle - and on benefits I could afford to replace it.

qpmz · 09/09/2022 13:07

It has to be said that life in the UK on low or middle income is much harder than it seemingly is in other western countries of similar wealth.

Seemingly but is it actually true?

It's been bad times globally with Covid, war and climate change issues. Many people would give anything to live here though. There's only a handful of countries I'd live in if it wasn't here.

I think most people vote for the party that they think is best out the (small) bunch. Not because they fiercely agree or condone with everything they do.

Culldesack · 09/09/2022 12:50

ddl1 · 09/09/2022 12:14

What was said of anything like a similar nature about Liz Truss? Maybe you are referring to the attempts to deselect her for having an affair with another MP? I DID think that was unfair and hypocritical, especially as no one was trying to deselect him, But whatever was said about her was said about her actions as an adult. To attack someone for 'not keeping her legs closed' as a teenager is the absolute lowest of the low; and yes, I'd say the same if it was said about a Tory.

I am not a Labourite, or a member of any party, and have most often voted LibDem, though sometimes Labour. But I can assure you that there are just as many attacks on the left and even centrists as on Tories. Those from disadvantaged backgrounds are accused of being lazy and envious 'losers', who want to sponge on hardworking taxpayers. Those from better-off backgrounds are accused of being insincere 'virtue signallers', who can't possibly genuinely hold their views. All are accused of that modern cardinal sin of being 'woke'.

Funny how these replies always purport to be from non Labour voters. The amount of abuse the left receives, is nothing compared to what they dish out.

Kashmirsilver · 09/09/2022 12:28

Thesinisterdiagram · 09/09/2022 11:29

You’ve completely ignored the point @Kendodd was making. Saying ‘get a better job or a promotion’ only works on an individual level and not a societal one. Yes it might make life better for that one person, but someone else will have to fill the low paid job they left and the problem is just passed on. It ignores that some of the lowest paid jobs are the most important to the functioning of our society. Care workers, healthcare assistants, retail and warehouse workers etc etc. Or do you think no one should do those jobs? Do you honestly believe there are enough well paid jobs out there for everyone that wants one?

Do you realize the jobs/employment market is cyclical? So as groups of people enter one sector others leave. Usually up-skilling.
Now if a person can't for whatever reason then there will be a wealth gap, however, there's nothing wrong with wealth gaps. Consumer markets have goods and services for all levels.

For example, I have customers who pay £70 or one who was happy to pay £3850 for a set of bath taps.

Now the other issue is IQ and personal motivations, we're all different, and people have various reasons for being where they are.

ddl1 · 09/09/2022 12:14

Culldesack · 08/09/2022 22:58

Similar things, and worse, were said about Liz Truss, on here, so what's good for the goose. I know Labourites aren't used to receiving the insults, because you're usually too busy dishing them out. Therefore, I can see why you're outraged.

What was said of anything like a similar nature about Liz Truss? Maybe you are referring to the attempts to deselect her for having an affair with another MP? I DID think that was unfair and hypocritical, especially as no one was trying to deselect him, But whatever was said about her was said about her actions as an adult. To attack someone for 'not keeping her legs closed' as a teenager is the absolute lowest of the low; and yes, I'd say the same if it was said about a Tory.

I am not a Labourite, or a member of any party, and have most often voted LibDem, though sometimes Labour. But I can assure you that there are just as many attacks on the left and even centrists as on Tories. Those from disadvantaged backgrounds are accused of being lazy and envious 'losers', who want to sponge on hardworking taxpayers. Those from better-off backgrounds are accused of being insincere 'virtue signallers', who can't possibly genuinely hold their views. All are accused of that modern cardinal sin of being 'woke'.

Thesinisterdiagram · 09/09/2022 11:29

FarFromHome2 · 09/09/2022 08:44

No, I agree, you don’t understand.

It seems a real blind-spot with many on the left, the whole idea of increasing your skills if you want to earn more.

Look at it this way, you have two choices if you want to earn more. The one I suggest, which is changing career, getting promoted, running a business at the weekends and so-on, or yours, which is to do nothing except sit at a keyboard typing “It’s not fair! It’s not right!”

Which do you think is more likely to make a difference in your life?

You’ve completely ignored the point @Kendodd was making. Saying ‘get a better job or a promotion’ only works on an individual level and not a societal one. Yes it might make life better for that one person, but someone else will have to fill the low paid job they left and the problem is just passed on. It ignores that some of the lowest paid jobs are the most important to the functioning of our society. Care workers, healthcare assistants, retail and warehouse workers etc etc. Or do you think no one should do those jobs? Do you honestly believe there are enough well paid jobs out there for everyone that wants one?

Culldesack · 09/09/2022 11:13

MoistBandana · 09/09/2022 10:55

"It's what Labour do; never look forward, only backwards"

And yet the Tories and their supporters continually blame labour for the current issues in the country.

Labour, who have not been in power for over a decade.

What does it say about the Tories if they can't fix the supposed issues that labour made 12+ years ago in the time they have been in power?
Only yesterday did Truss, during her #TrussTax speech, blame labour..

If you moved into a house 12years ago that had a leaky roof and you didn't fix it, would you be blaming previous owners or admitting it's your fault your knicker drawer is soaked..

Well I can see why you've used the knicker draw analogy, given your user name.