Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why people vote Tory?

596 replies

Tierne · 07/09/2022 14:25

It has to be said that life in the UK on low or middle income is much harder than it seemingly is in other western countries of similar wealth. I dont think the Tory party is making this country a nice place to live in at all. But they keep getting voted in.

So if you vote Tory:
Why do you vote for them?
Would you ever change your vote and for what reason?
Do you feel uncomfortable at how Tory policies batter the most vulnerable in our society? For example making it impossible for people to get on the housing ladder, high rents and low tenant protections, no energy bill caps, etc?

NB: I dont want this to turn into a Tory bashing thread. I'd just like to hear how Tory supporters feel about their party.

OP posts:
PostmortemNow · 07/09/2022 16:57

Freedomfighters · Today 16:26
"KassandraOfSparta name calling does often seem to be a feature of left. They mark themselves out as people not worth listening to."

According to Stewart Lee latest "guardian" rant, it goes
like this:

'Boris Johnson’s “victory tour” is the insane peacock parade of a monster of a man who has ruined everything, trolling the entire country, rubbing the noses of those whose lives he has destroyed in the filth he has wall-spaffed into their faces.

The fact is that Johnson, something of a vile jelly himself if the truth be told, is a massive psychopathic bastard. And if you support him, or voted for him, you must be either evil or ignorant.'

Whoever even dared to vote Tory or God forbid Brexit
for whatever reason can only be one of the two.
Simple.

Take your pick and feel for yourself the gentler
and also the kinder side of politics.

(Personally, I can't vote for any of the available lots.
Voted Labour for years until JC the messiah
entered the stage...)

LateSummerLobelia · 07/09/2022 16:52

Okay I will bite. I voted tory last time because I am Jewish and jeremy Corbyn and Momentum truly frightened me. I have grandparents and great grandparents who died in the Holocaust and believe me we can read the signs. I was honestly scared. DH and I had an actual plan about what we would do if Corbyn came to power. It involved me taking the Dcs and leaving to go to my home country and DH sorting out the animals and our house and then following. I am genuinely not joking and I was by no means unusual among my community. People dismiss the anit semitism as nonsence but it was not nonsense by any stretch of the imagination.

anything seemed better than that. I have been a Labour voter my entire life until Corbyn. I am not going to say who I might vote for next time but I think labour have not stamped out anit semitism by any stretch, and their record on women's rights currently is fucking woeful.

I am angry with Boris and the Tories. They have let us all down. And I am angry with Kier Starmer and the Labour party for not proivding a viable opposition. They have let us all down.

FreddyHG · 07/09/2022 16:51

SirCharlesRainier · 07/09/2022 16:47

Yes, god forbid any tax should be due on the land and property values that have ballooned as a result of, er, your hard work.

Actually I would tax capital gains at ones marginal income tax rate. Unearned growth from asset price inflation should be the first to be hit.

FreddyHG · 07/09/2022 16:49

For me Labour is the party of the liberal metropolitan elites. I am a rural dweller so much of labours focus is on the inner cities we are often forgotten about and our concerns ignored. I can't vote lib Dems over Brexit reaction and house building and how they did tuition fees an electoral reform in coalition.

Skt20 · 07/09/2022 16:48

I think the "no credible alternative" argument infuriating. The Conservatives haven't been credible for years. The are inept, immoral and incompetent. Literally anyone else could give it a go and odds are they wouldn't be as terrible. That's how low the bar is.

So I can only presume anyone who votes Tory only cares about themselves...

SirCharlesRainier · 07/09/2022 16:47

hattie43 · 07/09/2022 15:19

For all these people slating Tory voters let's not forget they got in this time with huge swathes of support from red wall voters so what does that say of any credible opposition.
When I was growing up it was very simple in my house , Tories were the party of aspiration and Labour the nerdowells . That was the sum of my political learning . It never leaves you , do well at school and make something of yourself . I hated school but got in at the bottom of a good company and following a good career i now have wealth .
I would absolutely never vote Labour because as someone else alluded to I don't want the remote chance they would introduce punitive taxes on land value or capital gains . I also have nothing in common with kaftan wearing yellow haired lefties spouting nonsense .

Yes, god forbid any tax should be due on the land and property values that have ballooned as a result of, er, your hard work.

AntlerRose · 07/09/2022 16:44

The people I know who vote tory are small c conservative and believe in personal responsibility in a big way. They dont generally think the state runs things well and prefers market forces to run things and for people to chose how they spend their money.

They all actually do charitable things like hearing readers at school, mentoring youth, taking in refugees, add to foodbanks - even run them. They arent heartless.

maddy68 · 07/09/2022 16:44

Because the majority of "news" is from right wing press so information is biased and constant sound bites , and social media make it hard to navigate to the truth.

feedyourheed · 07/09/2022 16:43

I always vote independent. It doesn't matter anyway, I live in a strong Labour area with no hope of people voting anything but.

I personally don't understand why people vote Labour. They are nasty and determined to focus on matters that don't matter or don't affect the vast majority.
They offer nothing for the working classes, or any other class for that matter. Too busy (in my area) greasing their own palms and spitting nasty words at tories and tory voters, with no real solutions and offering no hope.
They come across as wanting to drag everyone down to their level (well not their level - like the Soviets before them, they want the voters hopeless, dependent on the state and in permanent despair whilst they continue quaffing champagne and laughing that people think they care about them).

It's not a popular opinion on Mumsnet but the vast majority of the population are aspirational, want a strong economy and jobs, and understand that a fit for purpose NHS and public sector depend on those things. Labour are too busy on their knees wondering what a woman is to be trusted with the economy or the country in general.
The last Labour government saddled the NHS with unrepayable debts via PFI and made tons of middle class people rich with the BTL boom that helped crash the economy and left millions unable to get on the ladder but people cannot and will not see what's in front of them. It's the tories fault!

Not that the tories are angels. They've done some mindboggling things over recent years, including crashing the economy again, lockdowns, destroying what was left of the NHS and printing so much money that 2010-2020 austerity will seem like breeze compared to what is coming in terms of inflation, currency collapse and probably economic collapse.

KassandraOfSparta · 07/09/2022 16:43

We had a referendum on proportional representation in 2011.

Rejected. And not just by the skin of your teeth, 68% against electoral reform.

mansviewpoint · 07/09/2022 16:42

Gettingbythanks · 07/09/2022 16:33

I didn’t say they do. But until I have a party I want to vote for again, I won’t be voting 🤷‍♀️

Although I agree with the sentiment, unfortunately the logic doesn't work, because unless you vote you aren't heard and the politicians / parties all either think that you can't be bothered (your problem) OR "they didn't vote against us"..If there was a tick box for "None of the above" then I would happily vote and tick that box in many of the elections we have. I personally feel that it should be the law that you must vote (postal / online / person) but that your vote could be a protest of note wanting any of them. (A Protest vote if I may use that term).
Now, if we all marked our vote papers to make them invalid then that would be the only way to be heard... but I also don't feel that's a great way of protesting, because the same people will get into power.

Of course the rules of elections should be changed, The whole point of our "representation" by a member of parliment is completely outdated and from a time, (13th Century) where our MP should have been saying our greviences and voting in a manner that we as the people of that land wanted. MPs don't even do that now. They vote for what they want in our name. It's a very poor solution to a system which technology can easily solve.

Thedogscollar · 07/09/2022 16:42

Hyperion100 · 07/09/2022 15:29

The good news is that "most" people dont vote tory.

Remember that Johnson won his 80 seat majority after winning only 44% of the vote.

"Most" votes went to centre left parties.

This is why we desperately need electoral reform and to ditch FPTP in favour of PR.

Absolutely.
The voting system in this country is ridiculous.

FreddyHG · 07/09/2022 16:41

izimbra · 07/09/2022 16:08

"don't like living in a high tax environment and don't like having woke issues rammed down ones throat."

We've had a Conservative government for 12 years and the personal tax burden is the highest it's been in decades.

Can you also explain what you mean by 'woke issues' and how Labour are responsible for the Tory obsession with them?

That photo of Angela Raynor and Keir taking a knee spoke volumes. Plus Sadiqs handling of the recent met police chief. Labour made this an issue by playing the race card against anyone concerned about immigration from Gordon browns bigoted woman quite to the stuff sprouted from Abbott and Lammy. Like some most Mumsnet users twist everything into a feminist issue and blame misogyny labour have a track record in trying to silence others by claiming xenophobia or racism. Personally I was a kemi fan and she came out top of their early polls for the conservative leadership.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 07/09/2022 16:40

Tierne · 07/09/2022 14:40

Considering their track record with voters has been so good for so long, maybe the key to improving life in the UK isnt to try and piece together a new left out of the ruins of all our fragmented left wing parties. Maybe instead we have to understand what causes the majority to vote Tory, and then create a centre party like Macron's in France that responds to those needs while also being kinder to those who are struggling

But British politics are mostly clustered around the centre in any case. Comparing the US is like apples and oranges: their democrats are more akin to small 'c' conservatives. In the UK, Labour hasn't been left wing - really left wing - since the 70s. And as for Blair and his 'New Labour' soundbite, you couldn't even get a Rizzla between New Labour and Old Tory. Both concepts are strongly rooted in the kind of destructive neo-Liberalism that's decimated our economy since Thatcherism and possibly long before that. The boom that shattered in 2008 was nothing more than an inflated debt bubble, followed by a long, slow, steady period of deflation.

Whatever you've voted in the UK for the past 30 years, you got pretty much the same. The public sector, education and health are possibly slightly worse off under the Tories (it was Labour introduced HE tuition fees though), the economy, worse under Labour. As for 'why vote Tory?' question, there are many women would like to give Labour, the Greens and Lib Dems a bloody nose by showing them exactly what they think of the way they've thrown females under the bus. I can sympathize with that view and would have joined them, were it not for the fact that as a lecturer in the Humanities voting Tory is akin to voting myself out of a job.

Not that it matters how I vote. With our inadequate first past the post system where outcomes are decided by swing constituencies, I'll get a Tory MP no matter which X I cast.

The system - I'd go as far as to say the entire UK constitution - is fucked. It is anachronistic, designed for times that are gone and not coming back, and unfit for the 21st-century world. If we want radical change it's going to take a lot more than another General Election.

feedyourheed · 07/09/2022 16:39

I always vote independent. It doesn't matter anyway, I live in a strong Labour area with no hope of people voting anything but.

I personally don't understand why people vote Labour. They come across as nasty and determined to focus on matters that don't matter or don't affect the vast majority. They offer nothing for the working classes, or any other class for that matter. Too busy (in my area) greasing their own palms and spitting nasty words at tories and tory voters, with no real solutions and offering no hope. They come across as wanting to drag everyone down to their level.

It's not a popular opinion on Mumsnet but the vast majority of the population are aspirational, want a strong economy and jobs, and understand that a fit for purpose NHS and public sector depend on those things. Labour are too busy on their knees wondering what a woman is to be trusted with the economy or the country in general. The last Labour government saddled the NHS with unrepayable debts via PFI and made tons of people rich with the BTL boom that helped crash the economy but people are totally blind to the realities.

PurplePansy05 · 07/09/2022 16:39

The thread is getting derailed, but with reference to a couple of excellent earlier posts, Truss appointed Nadhim Zahawi as a Minister for Equalities, a male, and dropped Women from his title. Her press office had yo answer questions from journalists asking this morning if women were still included.

That's for those of you still thinking to vote Con on the basis of women's rights views.

Tabitha005 · 07/09/2022 16:36

Butterflyfluff · 07/09/2022 14:28

Because there’s no credible opposition

@Butterflyfluff I think this is more pertinent now than at any time in the past 12 years.

Juniperberries25 · 07/09/2022 16:35

KassandraOfSparta · 07/09/2022 16:18

Also, Truss's message that Sturgeon is an attention seeker who should be ignored resonates with a lot of people who would rather cut their own arms off rather than go through another divisive referendum. We're still not over the last one. The COnservatives have been very very clear that they will not authorise another referendum and that's appealing.

Labour and the Lib Dems are anti-independence, but haven't voiced that nearly as strongly.

This.

I like the Scottish Labour leader but he's not anti- independence enough for me. Plus his kids go to private school!!

Not even sure who the Lib dem leader is at the moment...either in Holyrood or Westminster. I never hear about them anymore.

I genuinely do not know who I will vote for in the next general election.

mansviewpoint · 07/09/2022 16:34

So there are many reasons why people vote the way they do, but a lot of people will vote with "what they know" until it immediately adversly affects them. Be it Labour / green / lib dem / tory / bnp there is a level of logic that is clinged onto. I challenge most people to even look up any particular parties' policies. Look at the "New Labour", people didn't vote for Tony Blair because they agreed with the policies, it's because of the high rate of inflation, the housing market etc. of the early nineties. People voted for Maggie, time and time again because it didn't affect them. Essentially voting for a parties' policies doesn't exist. It's gut feel and well they've not screwed up the last 5 years.
You only have to look at Brexit (not the outcome, but the lies that both sides sold) to realise that over 90% of the british public didn't vote with any real understanding of what the impact of Brexit (or not Brexit'ing) would do. (not that Brexit is the reason why we are currently screwed. (It's a part reason at best).

Unfortunately the best outcomes of votes have been either A) Coalitions (Because the loonies on either side can't get their policies in) or B) Wartime. Because a politician won't survive if they don't support the war effort.

Crumpleton · 07/09/2022 16:33

AngelinaFibres · 07/09/2022 16:16

This.

Agree...
I'd have thought that COVID would have been the perfect time for Starmer and his party to show their worth by saying not only to the Tory party but the whole country...'Never have we had a situation like this in our times we need to pull together on this one.
But no he bickered day I day out with nothing positive to offer.

Gettingbythanks · 07/09/2022 16:33

Blossomtoes · 07/09/2022 16:22

What makes you think the Tories give a shit about women’s rights?

I didn’t say they do. But until I have a party I want to vote for again, I won’t be voting 🤷‍♀️

Skatewing · 07/09/2022 16:31

Just bear in mind that if you strip people of all they have worked hard for in some misguided attempt to rob the rich and give to the poor. The tax payers working to try and get somewhere in life will just leave the Country and take their cash with them.
They are all millionaire leaders that have no idea of how the regular people live - Labour leaders included.

Of course there needs to be help and opportunities but people also need to do a bit for themselves.
I say this as someone with experience of missing meals and sitting in the dark due to having no money.

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 16:31

WifeMotherWorker · 07/09/2022 15:45

There is no credible opposition!! Also the Conservatives seem to be the only party that know what a woman is.

Do they though @WifeMotherWorker?

PM Theresa May didn't seem to know or care when she set women's rights back a generation with her Self ID policy.

Caroline Nokes, who when chair of Women's and Equalities proposed Self ID and who remains disappointed that her GRA Reforms were not taken far enough.

Penny Mordaunt, a chief architect of Self ID who stood at the Despatch Box and declared TWAW and TMAM, is our new Leader of the Commons.

Crispin Blunt has reported women for retweeting JKR.

Jamie Wallis MP believes he can become a woman.

Some Tories know what a woman is. Some really don't. They don't give a fuck about us either way.🤷‍♀️

Meseekslookatme · 07/09/2022 16:27

KassandraOfSparta · 07/09/2022 16:22

Oh and also, why are there never threads about how Labour voters are brain-dead idiots who sit on their arses never working yet expecting the state to pay everything? How that are poorly educated, scum of the earth people who can;t understand basic economics and just breed endless numbers of children.

Offensive, yes? But OK for the lefties to be as equally offensive about people they disagree with? It's like the playground. Really thought MN was better than that. Clearly not.

This post describes why Tory voters are generally quiet.

83DanishMum · 07/09/2022 16:27

You're just going to get a load of posts saying that Labour don't know what a women is. It's tedious given how conservatives have and are stripping away women's rights.

And the new health Secretary and Deputy PM is anti-abortion!

Plus Liz Truss's views on abortion and women's bodily autonomy are unclear...
" When the new PM, Liz Truss, was foreign secretary, the UK government organised a multinational statement committing to the rights of women and girls as part of an intergovernmental conference it hosted in London in early July.

It was later amended to remove references to "sexual and reproductive health and rights" and "bodily autonomy". (Source BBC)