Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my children to pay for tax cuts for the middle-class?

334 replies

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 12:46

A new policy proposal to increase the ceiling for higher rate tax for individuals has been proposed so that it will only apply once you earn £80k plus. But there seems zero idea of how this will be funded.
Realistically the only way it will be funded is by increased government debt. Debt that my children and others will be working to pay off in the future.
Why should my children and others have to work in the future for tax cuts for the middle class?

Government borrowing should be for investment in the future. Building sources of cheap future energy for the future for example. It should not be used for short term political gains.

OP posts:
Doingprettywellthanks · 07/09/2022 15:04

What “class” do you regard yourself to occupy OP?

Badbadbunny · 07/09/2022 15:04

@antelopevalley

Instead there has been a push for the UK to have a service economy without understanding that this strategy leads to lower productivity.

It was Blair/Brown who were obsessed with the service economy!

Badbadbunny · 07/09/2022 15:02

@ChristinaXYZ

I like Truss' idea that government should do less and do it better. I'd give her a chance.

I fully agree. Far too much unnecessary/meaningless/pointless bureaucracy and form filling, box ticking, etc for no benefit. As you say, H&S is the one area that needs to stay, but we need that to be better too, as it's still lots of box-ticking and meaningless platitudes in policy statements etc that are ignored in real practice.

Like cafes/restaurants who can get poor food hygiene ratings or even closed down if they don't have comprehensive work instructions and policy documents (even if the food prepared is perfectly safe because the people doing it know what they're doing and don't need it written down in front of them). Contrast that with other cafes who DO have 5 star ratings because they have files of paperwork, but who employ incompetent staff who never read the instructions/policies and then serve dangerous food!

That's the problem - lots of paperwork which the regulators/inspectors check, but they don't check the paperwork is actually followed!

That's the same in lots of industries, trades and professions. In my profession (tax) our regulators mark us down if we havn't cross-referenced or files or if we havn't updated an expired client passport copy on file. They NEVER check that we've prepared the tax return correctly which is what really matters. They're obsessed with systems and procedures that aren't actually relevant to the actual work we do! We could prepare a tax return that was a work of fiction but as long as we'd ticked our checklist boxes we'd pass with flying colours.

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 15:02

Winceybincey · 07/09/2022 15:00

Why are you assuming your children won’t be middle class and benefit from this? Are you encouraging them to be low earners?

i’m so confused by this post

You are very naive if you think tax will stay low. Government debt is spiralling. Everyone will pay for it in the future. My children will pay high tax whatever they earn.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 15:00

ChristinaXYZ · 07/09/2022 14:54

That's a more interesting point than your original one. I think part of it is underinvestment but companies need incentives to invest. Windfall taxes for example are a disincentive. Companies are better at investing than government because they better understand what their industry needs. To invest, they need to keep more of their money. They also need to be a bit leaner - clearing out a lot of unproductive middle management (same is true for schools and hospitals) - or using consultancy firms that do little (media advisers, PR, advertising people, and other creatives plus all the diversity industry).

Businesses used to do all that in house and as a much lower portion of the investments they made. Or even when they bought is in, it was a much simpler product (art for newspaper ad, etc., not some creative's 'vision'). Health and safety, though much maligned, is however a part of middle management worth keeping. It is easy to forget how many people suffered industrial accidents.

I run a business: my biggest barrier to growth is all the various things I have to sign up to, to export - instead of saying small businesses of less than 100K turn-over can just pay a flat fee to contribute to whatever bit of social engineering is current (VAT in country of sale, green packaging levies etc - nothing to do with Brexit which in my industry has been no problem) they want me to pay lots of small sums with lots of attached paperwork - keeping track of every bit of packing I use and its content for example - I don't have time, should I employ someone? How is that productive? I like Truss' idea that government should do less and do it better. I'd give her a chance.

Investing in broadband, energy infrastructure, high tech batteries, transport and ports is needed. The Tories are committed to two of those already. I'd like to see what they do with the railways/smart motorways, etc. And the problems of lots of electric cars when when so many people live in terraced houses of flats. And problem of increased plastic pollution from heavier electric cars (plastic particles from tyres/roads/road paint is huge generator of plastic micro waste in the sea).

And btw just because people don't agree with you, does not mean they do not understand economics.

The poster did not understand what productivity meant so my comment was fair.

It is a nice idea that companies invest more if they get to keep more money, but that has not happened. There has been very little investment in energy production in spite of high incomes. The car industry has made virtually no investment in battery factories and the high performance car industry spent money lobbying government to be an exception to no more new petrol cars in 2030, rather than investing in new products.
And sorry, but what we need is large companies to invest and government, small firms can help but do not have the resources to make the impact really needed.

The government has pretty much ignored manufacturing which has contributed to our low productivity. While governments in Germany and Singapore have understand the importance of manufacturing. Instead there has been a push for the UK to have a service economy without understanding that this strategy leads to lower productivity.

OP posts:
Winceybincey · 07/09/2022 15:00

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 13:05

So my children should pay the costs of incentivising middle-class people to earn more money?

Why are you assuming your children won’t be middle class and benefit from this? Are you encouraging them to be low earners?

i’m so confused by this post

Arou · 07/09/2022 15:00

Well the first page of this thread is incredibly depressing. I won’t be reading more but I just thought I’d say I agree. Given the current climate and with everything going on it’s shockingly tone deaf.

BaggaChip · 07/09/2022 14:59

What would be a better policy OP?

Miajk · 07/09/2022 14:58

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 14:54

@Badbadbunny Except that is not what will happen. An economic crisis is right on the horizon.
This measure will add to government debt and have no real impact economically. It is the worst of all worlds.

Well I would certainly spend more if the government took less of my money, and what the economy needs is for people to spend.

Have you also considered that since our government is great at pissing money away some people would rather it was theirs than given out in another bogus contract for tory pals?

MarshaBradyo · 07/09/2022 14:57

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 14:50

@MarshaBradyo It does not surprise me at all that you are against government debt except for tax cuts for the middle class.

Can you stop going on about middle class?

you are muddling two separate things

As for the dig it’s very tiresome. I forgot what some posters are like. No discussion

IndigoC · 07/09/2022 14:55

I come from another country and am always staggered by the lack of aspiration here, the lack of social mobility, and poor productivity (because a lot of people have no incentive to work harder). Such a policy would be good news IMO. Your children deserve better than this.

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 14:54

@Badbadbunny Except that is not what will happen. An economic crisis is right on the horizon.
This measure will add to government debt and have no real impact economically. It is the worst of all worlds.

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 07/09/2022 14:54

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 14:50

@MarshaBradyo It does not surprise me at all that you are against government debt except for tax cuts for the middle class.

Your obsessed with class. Lots of "working class" earn more than £50k such as train/tube drivers! Lots of "middle class" such as teachers/nurses etc earn less than £50k. Class is an out-dated concept and it does you cause no benefit to keep harping on about it!

ChristinaXYZ · 07/09/2022 14:54

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 13:58

You do not understand productivity. The UK economy productivity is shit. That is not because people need to work more hours, they do not.
Our productivity is shit because of a lack of investment by companies and government.

That's a more interesting point than your original one. I think part of it is underinvestment but companies need incentives to invest. Windfall taxes for example are a disincentive. Companies are better at investing than government because they better understand what their industry needs. To invest, they need to keep more of their money. They also need to be a bit leaner - clearing out a lot of unproductive middle management (same is true for schools and hospitals) - or using consultancy firms that do little (media advisers, PR, advertising people, and other creatives plus all the diversity industry).

Businesses used to do all that in house and as a much lower portion of the investments they made. Or even when they bought is in, it was a much simpler product (art for newspaper ad, etc., not some creative's 'vision'). Health and safety, though much maligned, is however a part of middle management worth keeping. It is easy to forget how many people suffered industrial accidents.

I run a business: my biggest barrier to growth is all the various things I have to sign up to, to export - instead of saying small businesses of less than 100K turn-over can just pay a flat fee to contribute to whatever bit of social engineering is current (VAT in country of sale, green packaging levies etc - nothing to do with Brexit which in my industry has been no problem) they want me to pay lots of small sums with lots of attached paperwork - keeping track of every bit of packing I use and its content for example - I don't have time, should I employ someone? How is that productive? I like Truss' idea that government should do less and do it better. I'd give her a chance.

Investing in broadband, energy infrastructure, high tech batteries, transport and ports is needed. The Tories are committed to two of those already. I'd like to see what they do with the railways/smart motorways, etc. And the problems of lots of electric cars when when so many people live in terraced houses of flats. And problem of increased plastic pollution from heavier electric cars (plastic particles from tyres/roads/road paint is huge generator of plastic micro waste in the sea).

And btw just because people don't agree with you, does not mean they do not understand economics.

Badbadbunny · 07/09/2022 14:52

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 14:44

@Wibbly1008 You are extremely naive if you think taxes will not be much higher in the future. How do you think all this borrowing is going to be funded?

More people earning more and more businesses making more profits means more tax revenue, even at lower rates.

Better to have someone earning £60k and paying 20% basic rate tax on £60k than having someone paying £10k of their £60k earnings (to avoid HR tax) and paying 20% on just £50k. (Ignoring personal allowance for simplicity to illustrate).

Same with businesses. Better to have a big firm with it's head office based in the UK paying 19% corporation tax on it's profits rather than it moving abroad and the UK treasury getting much less (if anything).

Ncvisitor · 07/09/2022 14:51

@VestaTilley £80k for a whole family in London won’t go far for a lot of households.

Do you perhaps realise that if people are paying less tax, they might eat out more? Or visit a nail salon? Help the economy.

’My DH is a high earner and I’m happy for him to pay more tax’. I’d love it if more posts on here were I’M a high earner and not just my DH.

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 14:50

@MarshaBradyo It does not surprise me at all that you are against government debt except for tax cuts for the middle class.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 14:49

@mia What I want is a decent economy. The UK economy has major structural weaknesses that nobody is doing anything to address.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 07/09/2022 14:49

These debates re tax burdens seem to have come very late

I would have preferred this type of response re massive pandemic debt and impact on dc rather than just spend / debt more and more

I’m fine with these decisions now but wouldn’t have strained the system so much earlier on

VoiceaFromUranus · 07/09/2022 14:49

VestaTilley · 07/09/2022 14:46

YANBU. It’s not progressive.

My DH is a higher rate payer. He earns very well. We do not need a government hand out; I’d far rather it went to the poorest households.

Letting you keep your own money isn't a handout.

Miajk · 07/09/2022 14:48

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 14:43

Okay so most of you are fine for the government to borrow yet more money to pay for tax cuts.
While the economy goes to shit.
I guess we get the government we deserve.

Most of us are able to comprehend that it's a reasonable solution for a group of people who don't benefit from any help from the government, yet pay more into the system, while also facing a cost of living crisis.

One person on 50k somewhere like London with a partner making minimum wage is hardly a millionaire. You don't think they also deserve to have some kind of quality of life? You think they should keep paying more? Tax is already proportional anyway. Even at 20% they already put in more towards you, your kids, everybody who benefits from public services.

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 14:48

@ClottedCreamAndStrawberries It will not matter how much they earn. Taxes will be much higher in the future. All this borrowing costs money.

OP posts:
VestaTilley · 07/09/2022 14:46

YANBU. It’s not progressive.

My DH is a higher rate payer. He earns very well. We do not need a government hand out; I’d far rather it went to the poorest households.

ClottedCreamAndStrawberries · 07/09/2022 14:45

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 13:05

So my children should pay the costs of incentivising middle-class people to earn more money?

Why can’t your children be the ones earning more money? You seem to think very little of them.

Miajk · 07/09/2022 14:44

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 07/09/2022 14:41

Oh right so you don't care if they are educated do you? You want doctors and nurses to care for you but not to have gone to school? got you ok?

And you honestly won't ever use a public resource? ever?

I will, but that's why I pay taxes which I'm happy to do.

The point I was making is that higher earners already contribute more while taking less. And now OP feels like it's an outrageous idea somehow to for once also help them since there's a cost of living crisis.

I don't have children and won't. I wasn't educated in this country. I moved here and this country has given me frankly nothing while I've been paying taxes, including at the higher rate.

But that's how life works. You don't get to pick and choose where your taxes go. OP seems to want to benefit from this (as these taxes fund her children's education) but she doesn't like anyone else benefitting from it unless they make less money?