Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my children to pay for tax cuts for the middle-class?

334 replies

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 12:46

A new policy proposal to increase the ceiling for higher rate tax for individuals has been proposed so that it will only apply once you earn £80k plus. But there seems zero idea of how this will be funded.
Realistically the only way it will be funded is by increased government debt. Debt that my children and others will be working to pay off in the future.
Why should my children and others have to work in the future for tax cuts for the middle class?

Government borrowing should be for investment in the future. Building sources of cheap future energy for the future for example. It should not be used for short term political gains.

OP posts:
Doingprettywellthanks · 07/09/2022 16:49

TheBoots · 07/09/2022 15:13

God the replies here are depressing!!! For what it's worth OP, I am in the higher tax bracket and I agree with you. I would happily pay higher taxes in order to have excellent services that benefit everyone.

Since 2000 there have been 204 voluntary payments to HMRC

put your money where your mouth is @TheBoots !!

Doingprettywellthanks · 07/09/2022 16:47

Everanewbie · 07/09/2022 15:12

Can we have some balance on this thread? Half seem to think that good earners should pay zero and low earners should be grateful for scraps, and the other half seem to think that well paying jobs are the preserve of some mysterious middle class that is closed to new members, and therefore no one can possibly aspire top it and that anyone with moderate success should be taxed until the pips squeak.

Pretty much the definition of “balance” @Everanewbie !

SlickShady · 07/09/2022 16:43

Blossomtoes · 07/09/2022 16:16

You have a very odd perception of fairness @SlickShady.

Really odd to think everyone should pull their weight equally.

superplumb · 07/09/2022 16:43

Ohdearthatwasntgreatwasit · 07/09/2022 13:01

We have to incentivise people to do better for themselves.

If you want to benefit from this kind of tax cut, be a higher earner. Admittedly for most adults the ship will have sailed by the time they become parents, but the idea is that you drum it into your DC that they need to do better at school, get better jobs etc to be earning at this level.

Then where is the incentive to be a carer, a nurse, a hospital porter, all of which are vital and arguably more important than a banker wanker. They will never earn more so its not about being incentivised is it. Some people do roles because they like helping people and these roles never pay well.

PollyEsther · 07/09/2022 16:23

Higher rate tax actually pummels income in many cases, and those on lower salaries just don't realise: we certainly didn't when we were lower income! We've been the poorest of poor, surviving solely on benefits, we truly understand poverty. There were years when the only times we were warm were when charities had provided our oil for us, we literally couldn't pay it ourselves. That winter (2010) was the coldest I've experienced in my entire life. We used to think those on £40-50k were absolutely loaded. They're (we're) obviously not poor, but we're far from loaded now either. We can't afford foreign holidays, we don't have shiny new cars, we rent because we can't save a deposit whilst paying all our bills.

It still smarts to see my husband work his socks off and, when tax and NI are combined, lose 50% of what he's earned. He pays an entire person's net salary in tax most years. It's a huge amount of money to pay for an NHS we can't access, schools that are failing, police that don't actually have the funding to solve crimes, and bins that aren't collected (amongst other issues). We don't have any more take home money now than we did when he earned £13k part time and was topped up with Housing Benefit and Tax Credits... the system is drastically wrong and has failed to keep up with the reality of working and living in this country.

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 07/09/2022 16:20

Travis1 · 07/09/2022 16:06

More's the pity, she should have aborted me when she had the chance to be honest.

So I can't use the services that I pay for? Okie dokie then. The audacity of parents never fails to astound me.

You said you didn't like paying for children in education. My point is that you will benfit from their education whenever you use the public services in the future as they will be mostly paid for by the taxes of people who are children now and will be propping up the system then, it will also be todays children staffing them.

So my point is if no one pays for education now then no one benefits in the future.

You seem very bitter towards parents, I'm sure it would help if they only taxed us for our own childrens educations but then of course, since we paid we should only be able to benefit so if that were to be the case and in the future you were to be turned away from anywhere that provided any sort of medical assistance (or anywhere really, supermarket, police station anywhere with people working in it) on the basis that only those who funded the education of the doctors/nurses/clerks/cleaners etc. can benefit from it I am sure you would be just fine with that.

Miajk · 07/09/2022 16:18

Beachcomber · 07/09/2022 15:36

So let me get my head around this.

The new PM wants to use borrowed money to give tax cuts to high and higher earners.
During a cost of living crisis / energy / NHS crisis.

The idea being that these comfortable and well off people will spend this money on stuff they can already afford without these tax cuts and that that in turn will somehow boost the UK economy and help everyone (despite the context being that of a global crisis).

Meanwhile lower and low earners are sharing tips on how to heat homes with candles in flower pots and feed families on veg from allotments and packets of dried lentils (that they better try to buy and stock up on before the inevitable price increases really kick in).

And surprise, surprise, the haves think this is an excellent policy. After all we live in a fair, meritocratic society!

The gap between rich and poor just continues to increase in the UK. Not only is is shameful but I honestly don't think it is sustainable. There will be protests if not riots this winter. You can't expect some people to put up with being poor, hungry and cold in a rich country with plenty of money to go round whilst others sit comfortably contemplating which luxury to spend their tax break on.

And all this whilst the energy companies (and their shareholders) sit counting their record booming profits.

It's fucked up people.

I'm a high earner. My partner is not.

We're a generation affected by worst house prices in the history of the country. I wasn't eligible for free education so had to pay for it myself.

We're not millionaires living a lavish lifestyle. We don't have kids. We don't get and never had any government support, not even while paying extorionate rents on minimum wage years ago.

Yes I should be paying tax. Yes I'm happy to do so. No it's not unreasonable to suggest that someone on my position could use some help with cost of living too.

Blossomtoes · 07/09/2022 16:16

You have a very odd perception of fairness @SlickShady.

SlickShady · 07/09/2022 16:13

Jiminycricket10 · 07/09/2022 16:06

Scrapping progressive taxation is only fair from a starting point of everyone have the opportunity and ability to earn a decent amount and to progress in line with effort.
We’re a long way off of that...

No it's not. Proportional taxation is fair because the rich don't benefit proportionally more than the poor.

There should be a liveable tax-free allowance, maybe something like 20k, and then every £ should be taxed equally.

Jiminycricket10 · 07/09/2022 16:06

Scrapping progressive taxation is only fair from a starting point of everyone have the opportunity and ability to earn a decent amount and to progress in line with effort.
We’re a long way off of that...

Travis1 · 07/09/2022 16:06

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 07/09/2022 14:31

you are someones crotch goblin are you not? did you not go to school? see a doctor? no? you're parents must have been incredibly wealthy.

My parents/grandparents taxes paid for you.

and you have no intentions of ever seeing a doctor (who was once a child at school) or using any other public service ever? I applaud your utter selflessness. You will be one less burden on my DC when they are adults.

More's the pity, she should have aborted me when she had the chance to be honest.

So I can't use the services that I pay for? Okie dokie then. The audacity of parents never fails to astound me.

Blossomtoes · 07/09/2022 15:59

The aim should be to get away from progressive taxation altogether.

Absolutely not. Fortunately no party with any genuine hope of getting elected will ever put that in its manifesto.

SlickShady · 07/09/2022 15:56

Tangled123 · 07/09/2022 15:50

@SlickShady You can’t fund anything if you don’t have any money in the first place. If the rich don’t fund it, who will? Do you want roads full of potholes, full bins everywhere, no emergency services or schools? Or do you not care because you’re ok?

We should all fund it equally (percentage-wise), after a reasonable tax free allowance. The aim should be to get away from progressive taxation altogether.

Jiminycricket10 · 07/09/2022 15:53

Also, arguments that the vast majority of tax is paid by the wealthy should surely raise the question of income disparity...
Should people be able to earn hundreds of thousands into millions while those who do the actual work (remember those we clapped for back in the day) barely see their wages raised in line with inflation...?
I think Australia/New Zealand put a cap on the highest wages related to lowest wage (something like 10x the lowest wage??)

Tangled123 · 07/09/2022 15:50

@SlickShady You can’t fund anything if you don’t have any money in the first place. If the rich don’t fund it, who will? Do you want roads full of potholes, full bins everywhere, no emergency services or schools? Or do you not care because you’re ok?

MissFranKubelik · 07/09/2022 15:50

PAFMO · 07/09/2022 13:17

I didn't much want to pay for your kids to go to school and get medical care, but hey, that's democracy for you.

Dear god. We've sunk THAT low have we?

Jiminycricket10 · 07/09/2022 15:47

Not rtft if I’m repeating anything...
I’m not against incentivising working hard, but I do have grave concerns with the current leader and some people’s attitudes about ‘unproductivity’/‘need to work harder’.
Quotes of only keeping between 30p-37p in a pound for high earners doing overtime include student loan debt, child tax benefits being reduced and pension, which is different to the current thread on tax bands (money for pension isn’t lost to tax and includes an employer contribution?/claiming child tax credits over 50k shouldn’t be necessary so is rightfully reclaimed on a sliding scale/student loan debt is a separate issue)
Any arguments on making it pay to work should include those at the lower end, as even though 33% tax is percentage-wise less, people in this bracket can actually be working full time, and have not very much to show for it. I have student debt, not sure how I’m supposed to save for a house deposit/mortgage and pension, given that I lose around 50% of income over 21k (student loan plan 1 = 9% over 21k, plus masters loan = 6% over 21k, plus tax plus national insurance) - this does not even including putting towards a pension...
So yeah, I’m in agreement with working hard paying, but it shouldn’t just apply to those earning over 40k (jobs like that are few and far between in my region!).
Oh, and speaking from experience, there isn’t an issue with productivity, there’s an issue with working conditions - those in the NHS and education as well as those doing minimum wage jobs for very little respect or job security have been saying this on various threads - it’s not the money.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 07/09/2022 15:44

can I ask what you think comprises those not respectful working class?

It does rather smack of the Victorian concept of deserving and undeserving poor, doesn't it? still, makes a change from OP blethering on about the royal family, I suppose.

AStar98 · 07/09/2022 15:43

Assuming you currently pay tax OP. What do you think your taxes have been funding? Aside from when you lived abroad and, presumably didn't pay UK tax.
When you have paid tax, your contributions have most likely been part funding an overspend from previous generations when, shock of horrors, the government of the day racked up debt to fund 2 World wars! And the following economic chaos that would have ensued afterwards.
My point is, there is ALWAYS going to be government borrowing - you cannot realistically get away from it. It's like a Housing market where no one needs a mortgage, it's not going to happen. Not all debt is 'bad debt'.
The energy market is also in disarray. Demand is beyond outstripping supply at a rate of knots. Freezing prices & price caps are about curtailing that spiralling price, because like any other market it has it's limits. That said, how would you propose of stimulating growth and reducing borrowings without businesses being able to function on massively reduced energy? You want investment but I don't see the UK as a particularly attractive country.
Something has got to give!

SlickShady · 07/09/2022 15:43

A tax cut is just that, government taking away less of the people's hard-earned money. It is not 'giving' away anything.

What you really mean is that you don't want your children to shoulder a more equal share of the country's budget. Instead you want 'the rich' to be forced to fund everything.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 07/09/2022 15:42

Some of the pandemic debt was unavoidable, although competency and a lack of corruption would have kept the debt much lower

We're dealing with the debt we have, not the debt we should have had if things had been better run.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 07/09/2022 15:41

The policy in itself isn't a bad one, though I don't know if I'd go as high as 80k. The tax burden on income rather than wealth in this country is very skewed and there is only so far the working age population can be burdened with tax. Sooner or later we are going to have to address the reality that it's a shit idea to tax income, much of which is earned through work, in a way we don't tax wealth and assets. It's just going that way, for good or for bad, because of the balance of things. This is a more important point than whether people are further incentivised to work more via tax cuts: as I understand it, the answer to that is usually 'it depends' anyway. Additionally, with inflation raging as it is, 50k is liable to become rather closer to the median full time salary than it is now.

The problem is that Truss can't be trusted to fund this in a sensible way rather than simply kick the can down the road.

zzzexhaustedzzz · 07/09/2022 15:37

Has this thread been hijacked by rentaTories?
Aside from the complete BS idea that there is any genuine social mobility in this country…
Who is paying for this price freeze? When we should renationalise.
What plan is there to actually help the poorest, shortly to be even poorer?
Minimum wage increase? No?
Abolish zero hours contracts (no sick pay etc) No?
There is a level of human decency when you make choices about the lives of the poorest in society that this government have been sinking beneath for a long while.
Billionaires should not exist.

Beachcomber · 07/09/2022 15:36

So let me get my head around this.

The new PM wants to use borrowed money to give tax cuts to high and higher earners.
During a cost of living crisis / energy / NHS crisis.

The idea being that these comfortable and well off people will spend this money on stuff they can already afford without these tax cuts and that that in turn will somehow boost the UK economy and help everyone (despite the context being that of a global crisis).

Meanwhile lower and low earners are sharing tips on how to heat homes with candles in flower pots and feed families on veg from allotments and packets of dried lentils (that they better try to buy and stock up on before the inevitable price increases really kick in).

And surprise, surprise, the haves think this is an excellent policy. After all we live in a fair, meritocratic society!

The gap between rich and poor just continues to increase in the UK. Not only is is shameful but I honestly don't think it is sustainable. There will be protests if not riots this winter. You can't expect some people to put up with being poor, hungry and cold in a rich country with plenty of money to go round whilst others sit comfortably contemplating which luxury to spend their tax break on.

And all this whilst the energy companies (and their shareholders) sit counting their record booming profits.

It's fucked up people.

Blossomtoes · 07/09/2022 15:33

LittleMissUnreasonable · 07/09/2022 15:30

Personally I think there should be a flat rate rax of 33.3% regardless of earnings. Only the threshold at which you start to pay rate should change to £25k and education for salaries over 100k.

@saleorbouy Bloody hell, I'm glad you have no say in the financial sector....I earn 25k, not a penny more. I am entitled to no benefits at all. If I was to be taxed 33%, I'd be on my knees and would probably loose my home.

Under those arrangements you wouldn’t pay any tax at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread