Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my children to pay for tax cuts for the middle-class?

334 replies

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 12:46

A new policy proposal to increase the ceiling for higher rate tax for individuals has been proposed so that it will only apply once you earn £80k plus. But there seems zero idea of how this will be funded.
Realistically the only way it will be funded is by increased government debt. Debt that my children and others will be working to pay off in the future.
Why should my children and others have to work in the future for tax cuts for the middle class?

Government borrowing should be for investment in the future. Building sources of cheap future energy for the future for example. It should not be used for short term political gains.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 17:39

@Hawkins001 But deregulation led to the crisis. Financial institutions said deregulate us, we need to be competitive and can regulate ourselves. And then promptly fucked up the whole economy.

OP posts:
Hawkins001 · 07/09/2022 17:36

The same with tax, the tax system needs to be a competitive system, rather than top weighted for the high earners.

Hawkins001 · 07/09/2022 17:33

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 17:24

The financial crash was not about people taking out mortgages. It was about the deregulation of the market. This led to the offer of mortgages that were at a high risk of defaulting. But the real issue is how this debt was sold on in a way that reclassified the debt as medium risk. Investors paid far more for the debt than it was worth. They did not realise they were investing in a high-risk proposition. When people defaulted on their mortgages, the investments plummeted.
Deregulation tends to give the economy a temporary boost so is liked by governments looking at the short-term, but it inevitably leads to collapses and scandals.
It is normal for each generation to pay the previous generations' debt. And debt can be a good thing. But debt should be accrued for the benefit of the economy or in response to a crisis, not as a political bribe to some voters.
We have the worst of both worlds. Spiralling debt and a lack of investment. The lack of investment almost inevitably means productivity will continue to fall.

Deregulation, itself was not the main problem, even when Glass-Steagall Act 1933, was in place, their were still financial crisis, etc, deregulation is only a part of the issue, but then on the flip side, suddenly having more rules, would mean banks being able to be less competitive and as jamie diamon of jp morgan and chase, said, if the rules were tighter and more restrictive, they would then look at trading out of London more if the us, tightened the rules etc. Obviously that's just my basic understanding so far.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 07/09/2022 17:31

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 17:26

And giving money to the well-off in an economic crisis does not help the economy. When this has happened the well-off tend to save or invest it rather than spend it. Giving money to poorer people does help the economy as they tend to spend it almost immediately in local shops.
The tax cut is a voter's bribe, there is no economic justification for it.

This has been shown to be true in the past. But the idea that people on say 60 or 70k are going to behave like the super rich if given a few hundred extra a month in an environment of spiralling living costs is rather speculative. They may very well use it to maintain their discretionary spending rather than cutting their belts.

Blossomtoes · 07/09/2022 17:31

worldeater · 07/09/2022 17:26

But it's ok for middle class high earners to pay shit loads of tax to provide benefits for people who don't work and have loads of kids!!??

Impossible. Benefits cover a maximum of two children.

steppon · 07/09/2022 17:29

But it's ok for middle class high earners to pay shit loads of tax to provide benefits for people who don't work and have loads of kids!!??

tbf the stereotype of someone not working & having loads of kids is not really true.

steppon · 07/09/2022 17:27

Spiralling debt and a lack of investment. The lack of investment almost inevitably means productivity will continue to fall.

spot on

worldeater · 07/09/2022 17:26

But it's ok for middle class high earners to pay shit loads of tax to provide benefits for people who don't work and have loads of kids!!??

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 17:26

And giving money to the well-off in an economic crisis does not help the economy. When this has happened the well-off tend to save or invest it rather than spend it. Giving money to poorer people does help the economy as they tend to spend it almost immediately in local shops.
The tax cut is a voter's bribe, there is no economic justification for it.

OP posts:
PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 07/09/2022 17:25

Doingprettywellthanks · 07/09/2022 16:49

Since 2000 there have been 204 voluntary payments to HMRC

put your money where your mouth is @TheBoots !!

Being happy to pay more tax in order to have excellent services and being happy to pay more tax per se are clearly not the same thing though, because the former requires trust that the money will be used appropriately and the latter doesn't. Perhaps people don't trust the current corrupt shower not to funnel more of our tax money to their dodgy mates.

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 17:24

The financial crash was not about people taking out mortgages. It was about the deregulation of the market. This led to the offer of mortgages that were at a high risk of defaulting. But the real issue is how this debt was sold on in a way that reclassified the debt as medium risk. Investors paid far more for the debt than it was worth. They did not realise they were investing in a high-risk proposition. When people defaulted on their mortgages, the investments plummeted.
Deregulation tends to give the economy a temporary boost so is liked by governments looking at the short-term, but it inevitably leads to collapses and scandals.
It is normal for each generation to pay the previous generations' debt. And debt can be a good thing. But debt should be accrued for the benefit of the economy or in response to a crisis, not as a political bribe to some voters.
We have the worst of both worlds. Spiralling debt and a lack of investment. The lack of investment almost inevitably means productivity will continue to fall.

OP posts:
PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 07/09/2022 17:22

Mila1234567 · 07/09/2022 16:54

Yeah, the trickle down. Which has been proven not to work at all. We need EVERYONE to have more money, so imo it's better to raise personal allowance than to raise tax threshold for middle class only.

Is it possible this might be done as well? I only ask because the Tories have been in support of this in the recent past. Much of what the Cameron government did was very damaging, but them hiking the personal allowance was one good policy.

SandieCollins · 07/09/2022 17:17

NCforsafety · 07/09/2022 13:34

And I don't want to pay for your children's education, health care, or many of the things my tax payments contribute towards but I have been so for over 30 years as I don't get to have a choice in that. I'm also not a high earner but pay highest tax rate. It sucks. I'd love the tax rate lowered.

Someone else may already have asked this, if you’re not a high earner, why are you paying highest rate tax?

Hawkins001 · 07/09/2022 17:11

Wouldloveanother · 07/09/2022 17:03

Does it? To be fair you don’t even seem to understand that the current generation paying off the previous generation’s debts is actually a normal thing that has always happened. The reason we’re poor now is because of people living the high life 30 years ago and taking out mortgages they couldn’t afford to repay resulting in the economy going KAPUT in 2008 and it’s never recovered since.

I've been watching documentaries on the 2008 crash, I came across the film the big short, and margin call, and wanted to learn more about the reality of what happened rather than just the fictional version of the films.

Jiminycricket10 · 07/09/2022 17:10

Mila1234567 · 07/09/2022 16:54

Yeah, the trickle down. Which has been proven not to work at all. We need EVERYONE to have more money, so imo it's better to raise personal allowance than to raise tax threshold for middle class only.

Agree. I do fear that this incentive is noting more than a self-serving MP pay rise - given that many MPs earn 80k+...

Hawkins001 · 07/09/2022 17:07

superplumb · 07/09/2022 16:43

Then where is the incentive to be a carer, a nurse, a hospital porter, all of which are vital and arguably more important than a banker wanker. They will never earn more so its not about being incentivised is it. Some people do roles because they like helping people and these roles never pay well.

I Understand how essential a carer, nurse, hospital porter are for their duties and responsibility etc, but I'd argue that for the economy as a whole, a banker is more useful.

Biker47 · 07/09/2022 17:06

Hope it goes up and I'll be dropped out of 40% tax altogether, I'd rather half the money I currently pay into that bracket goes back to me to spend, rather than just be squandered by the government.

I'm also working class, not middle class ;)

Wouldloveanother · 07/09/2022 17:03

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 13:59

And this thread depressingly confirms how little most people understand about basic economics.
I guess this is the reason governments can get away with telling the electorate things that make zero sense.

Does it? To be fair you don’t even seem to understand that the current generation paying off the previous generation’s debts is actually a normal thing that has always happened. The reason we’re poor now is because of people living the high life 30 years ago and taking out mortgages they couldn’t afford to repay resulting in the economy going KAPUT in 2008 and it’s never recovered since.

Weightlossanne · 07/09/2022 17:00

You cannot just measure people’s worth in monetary terms. There are certain jobs that require high levels of education and commitment but will never be highly paid - should we not encourage people to be teachers, lecturers or nurses.

nopenotplaying · 07/09/2022 16:59

I pay the higher rate of tax. I'm certainly not middle class.

Hawkins001 · 07/09/2022 16:59

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 13:05

So my children should pay the costs of incentivising middle-class people to earn more money?

The government debt is unlikely to ever be paid off,

Pua · 07/09/2022 16:58

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 13:26

And if they have SEN and will struggle to do any job, tough luck.

My nephew is a labourer on a farm. We are all delighted as he has autism and there were serious concerns he would never get a job. He only has a job because the farmer accepts that he is a hard worker, but needs more detailed explanations and support than other employees.

My husband’s autistic and earns £85k. We’d love a tax cut to help pay for our autistic daughters private education as the state schools in our area are poor.

Wouldloveanother · 07/09/2022 16:57

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 13:05

So my children should pay the costs of incentivising middle-class people to earn more money?

Middle class people are shouldering the burden of everything else. And they get zero relief - no top ups, no subsidies, and most of the time even child benefit is taxed so highly as to be not worth claiming. So no, I’m not at all bothered if they get a bit of a break. They’ll go back to being squeezed somehow anyway

Ncvisitor · 07/09/2022 16:56

What is the obsession with hating the elusive ‘middle class’? Which btw, your salary does not dictate that you are or are not. Middle earners might be more accurate, but less emotive.

Surely these posters should be advocating for the higher taxation of the really rich? Not the people that are ‘doing ok’?

Mila1234567 · 07/09/2022 16:54

sundayvibeswig22 · 07/09/2022 13:48

But we all can't be doctors, etc. We need cleaners, shop staff, etc.

No we can't all be doctors, but the more money people have in their pocket the more they will spend, helping to keep people in their cleaning and shop jobs.

I work part time paye and run my own business. I keep my overall salary at 50k due to not wanting to lose my CB and the higher tax band threshold. I make more through my business but keep it in my business account. Obvs I still pay corporation tax on my profits.

50k in real terms is less than what it was 10 years ago so I agree it should be increased (though maybe not to 80k).

Yeah, the trickle down. Which has been proven not to work at all. We need EVERYONE to have more money, so imo it's better to raise personal allowance than to raise tax threshold for middle class only.

Swipe left for the next trending thread