Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my children to pay for tax cuts for the middle-class?

334 replies

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 12:46

A new policy proposal to increase the ceiling for higher rate tax for individuals has been proposed so that it will only apply once you earn £80k plus. But there seems zero idea of how this will be funded.
Realistically the only way it will be funded is by increased government debt. Debt that my children and others will be working to pay off in the future.
Why should my children and others have to work in the future for tax cuts for the middle class?

Government borrowing should be for investment in the future. Building sources of cheap future energy for the future for example. It should not be used for short term political gains.

OP posts:
PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 07/09/2022 21:51

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 21:16

Except lots of people will be earning that and not be in that situation.

Yes, that's true. Lots won't, but you clearly get that some will. There is significant diversity in the 50 to 80k cohort, which aids my point.

So where is your proof that people who are on 50k and may very well be below the ONS median depending on their household size are going to behave in the same way as the super rich if given a tax cut? Bear in mind there are more people earning 50k than 80k too, and higher rate taxpayers are disproportionately found in or near areas with the best job markets, which of course are more expensive. All you've done so far is use what we know about tax cut consequences in people with much more income and assets to claim that people not in this group will do the same thing.

XingMing · 07/09/2022 21:50

The price of her nice retirement bungalow, bought 25 years ago, in a sought after post code, fetched a decent price, settled an equity release mortgage, and is paying care home fees -- at £975 weekly, I am just waiting for the care home to ask for more to pay for heating bills,

Alexandra2001 · 07/09/2022 21:43

sst1234 · 07/09/2022 21:19

No We don’t. People are employed into those jobs where humans are cheaper to pay for than automation. Isn’t it strange how as soon as labour cost gets high, businesses start to invest in automation.

Cue posters falling over with examples to refute this point by bringing up jobs that they think could never be automated.

Of course posters will because you re incorrect, though judging by Truss's performance and the fact we've had 4 in the last 6 years, maybe our next PM should be a robot?

There are a whole host of jobs that cannot & will never (as in foreseeable future) be done by a machine/automation & those that can, attract a huge amount of complaints, esp when they involve human interaction.

Booklover3 · 07/09/2022 21:42

Capri3 · 07/09/2022 20:19

No, not at all. I live in a London commuter-belt town. Loads of top percent earners keep nannies, gardeners, cleaners, hairdressers, manicurists, beauticians, car valeters, private dentists/doctors and tree surgeons in work. Local takeaways and restaurants are always busy. Lots of extensions and house renovations employing architects, brick layers, tilers, electricians, kitchen fitters, plumbers, floor fitters, carpet fitters. Several private schools, academic tutoring services, tennis coaches, dance schools, swimming instructors etc….

Where do you think that the money comes from to employ all of these people?

And where would you prefer to be in that triangle? The one at the top with all the money to employee these people… or at the bottom with the nanny or the cleaner?

XingMing · 07/09/2022 21:28

in our case, IHT won't be relevant. DMIL's care home fees at £975 per week will soak up any surplus. Self funded. It's easy to burn through the value of a normal house when you are fairly healthy with dementia.

sst1234 · 07/09/2022 21:19

TigerRag · 07/09/2022 13:10

But we all can't be doctors, etc. We need cleaners, shop staff, etc.

No We don’t. People are employed into those jobs where humans are cheaper to pay for than automation. Isn’t it strange how as soon as labour cost gets high, businesses start to invest in automation.

Cue posters falling over with examples to refute this point by bringing up jobs that they think could never be automated.

sst1234 · 07/09/2022 21:16

Like others said OP, instead of assuming your children will never earn that amount, perhaps focus on instilling in them the value of skills, education, entrepreneurship so they can take advantage of this.

High tax advocates are usually just wanting anybody but them to pay more tax.

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 21:16

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 07/09/2022 18:31

Actually, it isn't an argument that they'll behave differently this time, because the evidence that tax cuts to people in this specific income bracket only results in saving or investing isn't there.

What you're talking about is the demonstrated previous behaviour of people who in many cases will have a lot more, and then assuming it applies to what will in many cases be middle income households (our household income is low 60s, though between two earners so no higher rate here, and we came out between the 50th and 60th centiles on that ONS where do you fit thingy, so there would be scope for someone in the 50-80k bracket if a sole income household to be lower). You aren't wrong about what happens with people who have a lot of money and assets, but you're filling in the gaps assuming a single parent privately renting on 60k in London is going to behave in the same way.

Except lots of people will be earning that and not be in that situation.

OP posts:
rainbowmilk · 07/09/2022 21:11

I’m a higher rate taxpayer who’d benefit from this proposal, and I agree with you OP. I am not one of the people that needs help. I may complain about my lot but I’m doing OK.

I do find it hypocritical to be going on about what your kids will have to pay for, though, given that every childless person who complains about paying tax for other people’s kids is told that they should be glad to do so as part of the social contract and the need for babies. Your kids will just have to hear the same!

Fraine · 07/09/2022 21:04

Why should my children and others have to work in the future for tax cuts for the middle class?

Well, why are my taxes paying for your children?

spuddy56 · 07/09/2022 21:02

Surely the threshold has been too low for a long time? Where we live a higher rate tax payer would only just be able to buy a 2 bed basic flat. That seems insane.

steppon · 07/09/2022 20:53

Ime generally those that are liable do everything in their power to reduce their liability.

steppon · 07/09/2022 20:50

I know pensions aren't included but surely lots of the 1 in 5 have big property wealth as that age group tend to have the houses that has seen huge gains eg my inlaws London home cost about 70k in the 80s & sold for 1.7m.

Blossomtoes · 07/09/2022 20:42

Pension pots don’t count for IHT because they can’t form part of an inheritance. Basically it’s property, investments, savings, etc. The one in five figure includes pension pots so it doesn’t extrapolate to IHT liability.

steppon · 07/09/2022 20:35

No, it’s because the threshold is £1 million per couple and very few people have that much money.

I know loads of people who have circumnavigated it. Obviously that's anecdotal but i'm sure I read 1 in 5 over 65s was a millionaire (house, investments, pension).

Blossomtoes · 07/09/2022 20:34

Capri3 · 07/09/2022 20:32

Some do. Our elderly neighbours gifted their house to their kids 10 years ago. I doubt that the rest of their estate will be over the taxable rate.

The £1 million only applies if a house is included. Otherwise it’s £650k per couple.

Capri3 · 07/09/2022 20:32

steppon · 07/09/2022 19:38

Is that because people have circumnavigated it though?

Some do. Our elderly neighbours gifted their house to their kids 10 years ago. I doubt that the rest of their estate will be over the taxable rate.

Jiminycricket10 · 07/09/2022 20:28

Oh wait I’m not a manager or part of a leadership team, so we ‘can’t afford’ to increase THOSE wages, can we?!
(Btw for the odd poster who thinks the 40k+ bracket includes most essential workers like teacher, nurses and many other important jobs need to take a look at current payscales)

Jiminycricket10 · 07/09/2022 20:21

5128gap · 07/09/2022 19:50

Excellent. Let's all just tell our children that then! And in the future there will be millions of £80k+ jobs suddenly created out of thin air for everyone who was sufficiently incenticised to want one.
And we won't need any teachers, or carers, or nurses, or social workers, police officers or cleaners or shop workers....Oh yeah, we might actually...but I know! They can earn £80k too! (as long as they worked hard at school, obvs.)
Everyone can be senior, no need for lower paid workers at all, ever again.
It'll be BRILLIANT!

This ^ totally agree @5128gap

My mum did drill it into us to work hard at school, get a degree, value education.

I’m still waiting for the plethora of Yorkshire based companies offering even 40k+ never mind 80k+ that are apparently waiting to reward my hard work as promised...

Capri3 · 07/09/2022 20:19

Booklover3 · 07/09/2022 18:25

The theory that wealth trickles down is all well and good if you are near the top right? A bit like a pyramid scheme…

No, not at all. I live in a London commuter-belt town. Loads of top percent earners keep nannies, gardeners, cleaners, hairdressers, manicurists, beauticians, car valeters, private dentists/doctors and tree surgeons in work. Local takeaways and restaurants are always busy. Lots of extensions and house renovations employing architects, brick layers, tilers, electricians, kitchen fitters, plumbers, floor fitters, carpet fitters. Several private schools, academic tutoring services, tennis coaches, dance schools, swimming instructors etc….

Where do you think that the money comes from to employ all of these people?

AprilRae91 · 07/09/2022 20:14

*this

Badbadbunny · 07/09/2022 20:13

steppon · 07/09/2022 19:38

Is that because people have circumnavigated it though?

More likely that most couples don't leave assets totalling a million pounds or more, which is the threshold for a couple if they leave their estate to each other and then to their children if that includes their family home. No need for fancy planning for those people.

Blossomtoes · 07/09/2022 20:12

steppon · 07/09/2022 19:38

Is that because people have circumnavigated it though?

No, it’s because the threshold is £1 million per couple and very few people have that much money.

AprilRae91 · 07/09/2022 20:11

It’s disgraceful that LT’s first priority is tax cuts. We need reform not cuts for the well off, and that his government is too corrupt to do it.

WulyJmpr · 07/09/2022 20:00

I for one have no financial incentive to take a more stressful, probably longer hours, supposedly better remunerated job.

So I think this would definitely help my career trajectory and probably wider economic growth.

Also I will need more cash to pay for my private healthcare, private dental, private schools...🙄