Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my children to pay for tax cuts for the middle-class?

334 replies

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 12:46

A new policy proposal to increase the ceiling for higher rate tax for individuals has been proposed so that it will only apply once you earn £80k plus. But there seems zero idea of how this will be funded.
Realistically the only way it will be funded is by increased government debt. Debt that my children and others will be working to pay off in the future.
Why should my children and others have to work in the future for tax cuts for the middle class?

Government borrowing should be for investment in the future. Building sources of cheap future energy for the future for example. It should not be used for short term political gains.

OP posts:
luckylavender · 08/09/2022 10:54

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 12:46

A new policy proposal to increase the ceiling for higher rate tax for individuals has been proposed so that it will only apply once you earn £80k plus. But there seems zero idea of how this will be funded.
Realistically the only way it will be funded is by increased government debt. Debt that my children and others will be working to pay off in the future.
Why should my children and others have to work in the future for tax cuts for the middle class?

Government borrowing should be for investment in the future. Building sources of cheap future energy for the future for example. It should not be used for short term political gains.

Stop voting Tory

antelopevalley · 08/09/2022 10:52

I understand that. But I also understand how someone looking at a low average local wage, not knowing anyone personally who is a higher rate taxpayer and not seeing any jobs advertised with higher wages, concludes there is a lack of those types of jobs where they live.

OP posts:
Labraradabrador · 08/09/2022 10:49

antelopevalley · 08/09/2022 10:36

@FarFromHome2 Well off people tend to know other well off people.
But I know if I look at the jobs advertised where I live in Scotland, it is very rare to see a job advertised at £40k up. I know there are some people with jobs earning that much such as headmasters and GPs, but the job vacancies page gives the impression it is extremely rare. The average official wage is also way below the national average wage.

Higher wage jobs aren’t typically advertised in the same way, so you won’t find them in the help wanted section(or whatever people use these days). Usually you would engage a recruiter who sources applicants that fit a particular profile, but if you do advertise you would say ‘competitive salary’ and leave it at that. I am contacted about job openings 2-3 times per month on average, all well into six figures and many now flexible about location. I also don’t have any particular qualifications beyond university degree - just lots of experience in my sector.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/09/2022 10:41

Jobs that are £ 80k and up probably won't be in the vacancies page of the local paper. They'll be handled by a recruitment agency, and probably one that specialises in the industry.

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 10:41

antelopevalley · 08/09/2022 10:36

@FarFromHome2 Well off people tend to know other well off people.
But I know if I look at the jobs advertised where I live in Scotland, it is very rare to see a job advertised at £40k up. I know there are some people with jobs earning that much such as headmasters and GPs, but the job vacancies page gives the impression it is extremely rare. The average official wage is also way below the national average wage.

I can see where you are going wrong. These jobs are simply not advertised where you are looking. You are doing the equivalent of going down to the job centre looking for a job as a cardiac surgeon and being surprised that most adverts are for being a chef in a pub or a security guard in a factory.

What is your degree in, and what sort of career are you looking for?

If you want to earn £100k plus then yes, you may need additional skills, and may need to work for a lot of years to get there, but that doesn’t mean that it’s not possible.

antelopevalley · 08/09/2022 10:36

@FarFromHome2 Well off people tend to know other well off people.
But I know if I look at the jobs advertised where I live in Scotland, it is very rare to see a job advertised at £40k up. I know there are some people with jobs earning that much such as headmasters and GPs, but the job vacancies page gives the impression it is extremely rare. The average official wage is also way below the national average wage.

OP posts:
FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 10:28

Off the top of my head I can think of six people to whom I’m close who live in Yorkshire.

Their jobs are;

Barrister
Judge
Midwife
Draftsman
Accountant
Fashion Designer.

Half of them will (each) be on over £80,000 per year.

The accountant is retired now, and just does some consultancy work, as he sold his shares in his small company when they were taken over by Sage, so now has quite a few million pounds in the bank.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/09/2022 10:23

Yorkshire is a very large County, so it does depend where you live.

Doesn't it have roads people can drive on and public transport to get them from one place to another, then?

antelopevalley · 08/09/2022 10:22

Yorkshire is a very large County, so it does depend where you live.

OP posts:
Hoppinggreen · 08/09/2022 10:10

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 09:47

Yorkshire has barristers, headmasters, accountants, surgeons, dentists, architects, senior police officers and so-on earning that sort of money. Is there any reason that these jobs aren’t achievable for you?

Leeds is a Financial centre and now had Channel 4, there are also lots of top law firms and other National and Multinationals there. Sheffield has similar.
There are well paying jobs in Yorkshire (if you are qualified of course)

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 09:49

Booklover3 · 07/09/2022 21:42

And where would you prefer to be in that triangle? The one at the top with all the money to employee these people… or at the bottom with the nanny or the cleaner?

Our nanny gets £18 per hour, our cleaner gets £17. I don’t think that that can be considered “ at the bottom.”

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 09:47

Jiminycricket10 · 07/09/2022 20:21

This ^ totally agree @5128gap

My mum did drill it into us to work hard at school, get a degree, value education.

I’m still waiting for the plethora of Yorkshire based companies offering even 40k+ never mind 80k+ that are apparently waiting to reward my hard work as promised...

Yorkshire has barristers, headmasters, accountants, surgeons, dentists, architects, senior police officers and so-on earning that sort of money. Is there any reason that these jobs aren’t achievable for you?

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 09:44

5128gap · 07/09/2022 19:50

Excellent. Let's all just tell our children that then! And in the future there will be millions of £80k+ jobs suddenly created out of thin air for everyone who was sufficiently incenticised to want one.
And we won't need any teachers, or carers, or nurses, or social workers, police officers or cleaners or shop workers....Oh yeah, we might actually...but I know! They can earn £80k too! (as long as they worked hard at school, obvs.)
Everyone can be senior, no need for lower paid workers at all, ever again.
It'll be BRILLIANT!

Your view is analogous to telling an athlete that there is no point training, as not everyone can win, and someone always must come last.

It’s not a sensible argument. If your children work hard at school, learn discipline, and the benefits of delayed gratification then they will have a much improved chance of getting a better career and of earning a higher wage.

I’m never going to win the Olympic 5,000m final, but if I train properly I can break the 20m barrier.

Similarly the people I employ are never going to be as wealthy as Elon Musk, but through the efforts that they have put in through school and university, and those that they put in now, they are able to earn a decent six-figure salary.

antelopevalley · 08/09/2022 09:37

@Pottedpalm An extra £4k is not going to make a difference to that. Nurses, GPs, and teachers leave because of the working conditions. But there is no political will to sort that out.

OP posts:
Everanewbie · 08/09/2022 09:01

Doingprettywellthanks · 07/09/2022 16:49

Since 2000 there have been 204 voluntary payments to HMRC

put your money where your mouth is @TheBoots !!

Perhaps nuance is a better word than balance. There only seems to be extreme arguing with extreme.

Pottedpalm · 08/09/2022 08:54

MintJulia · 07/09/2022 13:47

OP, think about which people it will impact most - those earning between £45k and £100k.

Who are all those people who are retiring in the middle of a skills shortage? Who are the 'Great Resignees'?

They are experienced teachers, nurses, doctors, dentists etc in their 50s and early sixties. The ones we need to hang on to and encourage to go on working.

We have a chronic shortage of teachers, doctors, dentists. Creating a tax regime that encourages them to carry on working an extra 5 or 10 years sounds like a good idea to me. Better value too, because the NHS trained them and we should encourage them to work as long as possible.

Sorry if that offends you, but working class people need doctors and teachers just as much as anyone else.

Well said

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 08/09/2022 08:36

It's true, there are various bottlenecks in the UK tax system and sometimes people respond accordingly. This isn't limited to higher earners by any means, low earners who need to take into account the impact on top up benefits are one of the cohorts affected.

sst1234 · 08/09/2022 08:27

Badbadbunny · 08/09/2022 08:14

I fully agree and see it constantly in my business (accountancy). I have self employed and small business clients at lots of different tax thresholds who are deliberately holding back their potential and deliberately working less than they could, to avoid breaching tax thresholds.

Right from the lowest level, i.e. part time ebayers, mobile hairdressers, office cleaners, market traders who are just working "enough" hours to qualify for UC or tax credits, free prescriptions, rent allowances, council tax discounts, etc - they won't work more because the benefit of a few extra working hours doesn't make up for the loss of benefits.

At the other end of the scale, I have a dentist who has a hard time keeping his income under £100k as he doesn't want to lose free childcare and doesn't want to pay a marginal tax rate of 63.25% on his extra earnings over £100k, so he's actually cutting down his working hours and doing less work to keep his income under the £100k.

Numerous different types of small businesses who keep their profits under £50k so they don't lose their child benefits at the same time as going over the higher rate threshold - they could work harder and grow their business more, but make a conscious effort not to.

But the worse tax cliff edge is the £85k VAT threshold where you can often be worse off by thousands of pounds by letting your sales/turnover (not profit) go over the £85k by a small amount, i.e. they could be £10k worse off if their sales grow from £85k to £86k if they are in retail, hospitality, a small garage or in fact any small business dealing directly with the general public. It's completely immoral and stupid to have that kind of "brake" on a small business that could otherwise grow! I've just had such a case, a small guest house who have had to reduce the number of letting bedrooms as they were too close for comfort to the £85k, so couldn't take the risk and the only safe way is to reduce their capacity, i.e. hold back a business that otherwise could have grown! It's madness.

The marginal tax rate graph (i.e. how much extra tax you pay on an extra pound of income) is like a mountain range with peaks and troughs, whereas common sense says it should either be a straight line or a gentle upward sloping curve. Our current crazy system has marginal tax rates at certain income levels of 60-70-80% which is a massive disincentive to push yourself and earn a bit more. Worse still, in several circumstances, it can be over 100%, in fact in some cases, can be hundreds or thousands of percent (such as the VAT threshold breach).

We desperately need a radical reform of the tax/benefits system to end this stupidly damaging system which has been created by a couple of decades of politicians tinkering with the tax system and being incapable of understanding the effects of their constant meddling.

Working harder/working more should always be worthwhile, wherever you are on the income scale. Quite simply any point on that scale where you end up "taking home" less than half of the extra you earn (i.e. marginal rate of over 50%) needs to be corrected and it's a massive disincentive to work harder/more if you know you're going to end up with less than half of your extra earnings in your pocket.

Proof, even if anecdotal, from a professional that high tax keeps productivity low and our economy suppressed.

MooseBreath · 08/09/2022 08:17

I think the higher tax bracket should be based on household income. 2 people bringing in £49k each are doing a hell of a lot better than a sole provider at £98k.

Badbadbunny · 08/09/2022 08:14

Labraradabrador · 07/09/2022 23:41

Also I think you undervalue the effect of taxes as a disincentive to work more and generate more income.

I do wonder the net effect of raising the threshold- I suspect there would be less of a decline in tax revenue than you might think as many people would work more.

I am one of the many self employed who actively manage workload around tax thresholds. I max out pension but then don’t take on any more than £50k as it just isn’t worth my time. I’m only working 1-2 days a week,but would easily double that if I felt it would be worth it. If the tax rates lower I would instantly increase work, meaning more taxes paid by me in total.

I fully agree and see it constantly in my business (accountancy). I have self employed and small business clients at lots of different tax thresholds who are deliberately holding back their potential and deliberately working less than they could, to avoid breaching tax thresholds.

Right from the lowest level, i.e. part time ebayers, mobile hairdressers, office cleaners, market traders who are just working "enough" hours to qualify for UC or tax credits, free prescriptions, rent allowances, council tax discounts, etc - they won't work more because the benefit of a few extra working hours doesn't make up for the loss of benefits.

At the other end of the scale, I have a dentist who has a hard time keeping his income under £100k as he doesn't want to lose free childcare and doesn't want to pay a marginal tax rate of 63.25% on his extra earnings over £100k, so he's actually cutting down his working hours and doing less work to keep his income under the £100k.

Numerous different types of small businesses who keep their profits under £50k so they don't lose their child benefits at the same time as going over the higher rate threshold - they could work harder and grow their business more, but make a conscious effort not to.

But the worse tax cliff edge is the £85k VAT threshold where you can often be worse off by thousands of pounds by letting your sales/turnover (not profit) go over the £85k by a small amount, i.e. they could be £10k worse off if their sales grow from £85k to £86k if they are in retail, hospitality, a small garage or in fact any small business dealing directly with the general public. It's completely immoral and stupid to have that kind of "brake" on a small business that could otherwise grow! I've just had such a case, a small guest house who have had to reduce the number of letting bedrooms as they were too close for comfort to the £85k, so couldn't take the risk and the only safe way is to reduce their capacity, i.e. hold back a business that otherwise could have grown! It's madness.

The marginal tax rate graph (i.e. how much extra tax you pay on an extra pound of income) is like a mountain range with peaks and troughs, whereas common sense says it should either be a straight line or a gentle upward sloping curve. Our current crazy system has marginal tax rates at certain income levels of 60-70-80% which is a massive disincentive to push yourself and earn a bit more. Worse still, in several circumstances, it can be over 100%, in fact in some cases, can be hundreds or thousands of percent (such as the VAT threshold breach).

We desperately need a radical reform of the tax/benefits system to end this stupidly damaging system which has been created by a couple of decades of politicians tinkering with the tax system and being incapable of understanding the effects of their constant meddling.

Working harder/working more should always be worthwhile, wherever you are on the income scale. Quite simply any point on that scale where you end up "taking home" less than half of the extra you earn (i.e. marginal rate of over 50%) needs to be corrected and it's a massive disincentive to work harder/more if you know you're going to end up with less than half of your extra earnings in your pocket.

AprilRae91 · 08/09/2022 05:00

Stamp duty takes the piss now and needs updating. We’re paying 7k stamp for out ordinary 3 bed terraced in the NW.

Labraradabrador · 07/09/2022 23:41

Also I think you undervalue the effect of taxes as a disincentive to work more and generate more income.

I do wonder the net effect of raising the threshold- I suspect there would be less of a decline in tax revenue than you might think as many people would work more.

I am one of the many self employed who actively manage workload around tax thresholds. I max out pension but then don’t take on any more than £50k as it just isn’t worth my time. I’m only working 1-2 days a week,but would easily double that if I felt it would be worth it. If the tax rates lower I would instantly increase work, meaning more taxes paid by me in total.

Labraradabrador · 07/09/2022 22:53

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 15:16

@Winceybincey Except I have not. I am just not naive. Higher taxes will happen in the future to pay for all of this.

OR we could be more proactive about managing our expenditure? Just like any families budgets, debt is a consequence of income not aligning with expenditures.

Privatisation of healthcare is inevitable at this point, for example. We can manage it proactively to make it work for the common good and ensure everyone has the basics (using private fees to supplement free services), or we can let it crumble and people vote with their feet and those with resources exit the system and create their own private bubble. You could tax everything over 50k at 100% and it still wouldn’t be enough to fix the nhs.

I also object to the idea that your children are owed my income. I’m all for safety nets that ensure basic health, education and well being for all, but I object to the idea that it rests on less than 50% of the population (net contributors) to fund the entirety of society’s well being.

TheBoots · 07/09/2022 22:07

Doingprettywellthanks · 07/09/2022 16:49

Since 2000 there have been 204 voluntary payments to HMRC

put your money where your mouth is @TheBoots !!

Thanks @doingprettywellthanks, I do, in fact put my money where my mouth is and give as much as I can to people who aren't as lucky as I am. And what, pray, do you do to make life better for your fellow humans?

Janesdufflecoat · 07/09/2022 21:58

I hate the current Govt with a passion but the tax bands have been set at the same level for too long!

I worked for HMRC 20 years ago & the bands are pretty much the same!

One example would be redundancy pay £30,000 tax free that's probably been the same for 30 years! At the time it was a lot of money but now not so much!

I'm more cross about paying a 'heating mortgage' for the next 20 years while the big companies make billions in profits than I am about the tax bands! That really is taking the piss!

Swipe left for the next trending thread