Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my children to pay for tax cuts for the middle-class?

334 replies

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 12:46

A new policy proposal to increase the ceiling for higher rate tax for individuals has been proposed so that it will only apply once you earn £80k plus. But there seems zero idea of how this will be funded.
Realistically the only way it will be funded is by increased government debt. Debt that my children and others will be working to pay off in the future.
Why should my children and others have to work in the future for tax cuts for the middle class?

Government borrowing should be for investment in the future. Building sources of cheap future energy for the future for example. It should not be used for short term political gains.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 14:44

@Wibbly1008 You are extremely naive if you think taxes will not be much higher in the future. How do you think all this borrowing is going to be funded?

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 14:43

Okay so most of you are fine for the government to borrow yet more money to pay for tax cuts.
While the economy goes to shit.
I guess we get the government we deserve.

OP posts:
Wibbly1008 · 07/09/2022 14:42

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 13:05

So my children should pay the costs of incentivising middle-class people to earn more money?

One day your kids will earn good money and be successful hopefully, they shouldn’t be penalised for doing well and working hard

Swingsarefun · 07/09/2022 14:41

Come to Scotland where the higher rate tax is 41% not 40% and kicks in when you earn a lofty £43k. Got to fund the illegitimate indypondering somehow.

I disagree with tax cuts as public services need to be funded but would like to see England go to a higher rate starting at £80k just to see what the SNP do next.

Fupoffyagrasshole · 07/09/2022 14:41

with climate change and everything else that's coming for us this will be the least of their worries.

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 07/09/2022 14:41

Miajk · 07/09/2022 14:38

Not sure how it's relevant what age they'll be, the point is it won't be their taxes funding it, since it's going to be paid for by me privately.

Surely that's fairly simple to understand.

Oh right so you don't care if they are educated do you? You want doctors and nurses to care for you but not to have gone to school? got you ok?

And you honestly won't ever use a public resource? ever?

Badbadbunny · 07/09/2022 14:39

@SweatyAndGrumpy

The current basic tax rate is about the lowest it ever has been.

NIC rates are the highest they've ever been.

In terms of average wages, the HR threshold is the lowest it's ever been.

VAT is just about the highest it's ever been.

Other indirect taxes (Fuel, alcohol, tobacco) etc are the highest they've ever been.

When talking about taxes, you have to look at the whole picture, not just cherry pick one particular tax.

caringcarer · 07/09/2022 14:38

The band starting at about £50k paying 40p in pound has been frozen for years. It is about time it was raised. Paying 20 percent tax up to £80k is a great idea. Many middle earners will benefit. Including police, civil servants, teachers with responsibility points, fire people, some nurses, accountants, ICT coders, a lot of trades people. These are people who likely don't claim benefits so are net contributers. Why should all the perks and handouts be for people who don't work or only work few (16) hours? Higher earners pay more tax. Why should your kids be any different to anyone else?

Miajk · 07/09/2022 14:38

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 07/09/2022 14:25

And the people you are paying for these services will be the same age as you will they?

Not sure how it's relevant what age they'll be, the point is it won't be their taxes funding it, since it's going to be paid for by me privately.

Surely that's fairly simple to understand.

Ncvisitor · 07/09/2022 14:37

@ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler I no longer live in the UK, so no. Your children will not be directly funding anything for me, despite me paying tax all my working life and that really doesn’t bother me.

The OP has limited understanding of the economy and came across as having a serious chip on their shoulder about the ‘middle classes’. And other posters were trying to point out ways that everyone has contributed tax to things that they can’t directly see the benefit of.

Badbadbunny · 07/09/2022 14:36

At the moment, people take actions to avoid paying higher rate tax (and of course losing child benefit). They increase their pension contributions (so HMRC get less tax). Or they refuse to do extra shifts, or take promotions, or reduce their working hours (so HMRC get less tax). There are literally hundreds of threads on various web forums from people asking how they can avoid HR tax and how to avoid losing child benefit when their wages go over £50k - the evidence is there in black and white that people take action to avoid it. The result is that HMRC get less tax because people either take steps to earn less or take steps to put more into pensions, so overall HMRC loses out and gets less tax than they would if people could earn more without the higher rate tax kicking in or losing child benefit.

For years, the HR tax threshold and the £50k child benefit claw back threshold hasn;t changed, so people have been hit by "fiscal drag" i.e. pay inflation etc not being matched by increases in these thresholds.

Maybe £80k is too high, but it needs to be increased to reflect pay inflation since it was last changed!

Zilla1 · 07/09/2022 14:33

I believe that children are our future ... and those children will inherit a share of a nation with a rather complex mix of liabilities and hard and soft assets, a workforce with a skills base and an economy formed of an ecosystem of companies. If someone thinks they can judge one year's tax policy and understand its effects on the future national debt taking into account how the additional untaxed income will be spent and saved and possibly keep firm afloat that would otherwise go under and then they think they have enough of a view of the consequences of the counterfactual of not making that tax cut then perhaps they might want to consider the limits of their knowledge.

ChristinaXYZ · 07/09/2022 14:32

PAFMO · 07/09/2022 13:17

I didn't much want to pay for your kids to go to school and get medical care, but hey, that's democracy for you.

In fact 'hey that tax systems for you'! If your kids don't pay tax they are not funding anyone. If they do pay tax they are for the most part funding schools, NHS, police, armed forces etc., all things most people thing are jolly useful. If you are a lower earner with kids you are probably close to being a net receiver of benefit from the tax/spend system. If you're a higher earner then you are benefiting from the tax cut you are talking about. You seem to be making yourself angry without thinking this through OP.

Incentivisation and aspiration is a good thing. Grumbling about different classes of people is a bit 20th century.

Truss and co want to pay the 'credit card bill' by growing the economy and growing tax receipts that way. You may disagree with that or think it won't work, (fair enough); you may think raising taxes on the rich and windfall taxes on companies will benefit the poorest in the economy and would rather have that system (not much international evidence that that works, but fair enough, vote Labour) but class based grumbling is just a bit weird.

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 07/09/2022 14:32

Ncvisitor · 07/09/2022 14:28

@ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler you can hold a grudge or you can begrudge someone.

I don’t know why you’ve assumed I don’t have children? Or that yours will be funding my retirement? (They won’t.)

I didn’t say the country doesn’t need children or that I don’t understand how tax works, I was bemused at the OPs annoyance that her children might be paying tax for something they don’t directly benefit from, and the assumption that the ‘middle classes’ are the ones to benefit.

But the younger generation will fund all of our elderly years how can anyone honestly not see that?

VioletInsolence · 07/09/2022 14:32

Ohdearthatwasntgreatwasit · 07/09/2022 13:01

We have to incentivise people to do better for themselves.

If you want to benefit from this kind of tax cut, be a higher earner. Admittedly for most adults the ship will have sailed by the time they become parents, but the idea is that you drum it into your DC that they need to do better at school, get better jobs etc to be earning at this level.

Oh ok, we’ll all just do that then🙄

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 07/09/2022 14:31

Travis1 · 07/09/2022 14:18

Actually no, the reality is that I'll have to keep working past retirement age so in my retirement I will still be paying taxes and once again funding a shit load for kids and services that I have never and will never be able to use.

Add to that the fact that I have to be accepting of all the little darlings and 'oh aren't they just soooo cute and adorable' and 'won't someone think of the children' fucksake people were even getting taken out of the queue at passport control and moved to the front because of their crotch goblins. So you'll forgive me for not giving two shiny shits about little timmys future taxes after I've carked it. 💁😂

you are someones crotch goblin are you not? did you not go to school? see a doctor? no? you're parents must have been incredibly wealthy.

My parents/grandparents taxes paid for you.

and you have no intentions of ever seeing a doctor (who was once a child at school) or using any other public service ever? I applaud your utter selflessness. You will be one less burden on my DC when they are adults.

Ncvisitor · 07/09/2022 14:28

@ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler you can hold a grudge or you can begrudge someone.

I don’t know why you’ve assumed I don’t have children? Or that yours will be funding my retirement? (They won’t.)

I didn’t say the country doesn’t need children or that I don’t understand how tax works, I was bemused at the OPs annoyance that her children might be paying tax for something they don’t directly benefit from, and the assumption that the ‘middle classes’ are the ones to benefit.

SweatyAndGrumpy · 07/09/2022 14:27

All generations pay the debts of the generation before them.

Personally I don't think the threshold should be raised because I think there are bigger priorities.

But I also don't agree that to do so, 'saddles' the next generation in ways that previous generations haven't been.

The current basic tax rate is about the lowest it ever has been. It could get a lot higher yet before we're asking more of tomorrow's earners than we asked of yesterday's - iysim.

What DOES need to happen is to keep wages rises in line with inflation. They have stagnated for the last decade or so and that leaves people trying to stretch their money futher each month. The answer isn't to lower tax, it's to keep wages moving in line with the cost of living.

To not want my children to pay for tax cuts for the middle-class?
Georgeskitchen · 07/09/2022 14:27

Tax people till the pips squeak and those that can will take their money elsewhere.

I wasn't born in world war 2 but I have been contributing to pay off the debt we owed for WW2 which was only settled about 15 or so years ago . Nobody asked me and all the rest but we didn't have a choice. You are very naive OP and need to do some research before you post your shit . Your kids will pay tax for a lot of stuff they don't pick and choose!!

Fiwere25again · 07/09/2022 14:27

@Travis1 Crotch goblin! The people on the train are now wondering why there is a lone traveller laughing uncontrollably!

BorgQueen · 07/09/2022 14:27

Most tradesmen can easily earn £750-£1000 a day when they are self employed, £70 an hour is low, that’s why I don’t understand the push for everyone to have a degree.
If they raise the 40% tax limit to £80k, surely they need to raise the VAT registration threshold to £100k as well.

DH could theoretically earn £80K by working 20 hours a week servicing peoples’ boilers at £80 a time, it takes 45 mins. His day rate for, say fitting a new boiler will be £750 and that will be cheap.

FreddyHG · 07/09/2022 14:26

I agree with only borrowing for long term investment. It is why I hate the new energy policy this is blatantly borrowing for short term gain with no investment.

I would also support increasing the lifetime allowance for pensions. We need to encourage people to save for their retirement.

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 07/09/2022 14:25

Miajk · 07/09/2022 14:17

My generation probably won't see a state pension. I'm also setting money aside for my care in the future so again, maybe everyone should stop digging into my pockets for what else I can sponsor you for.

And the people you are paying for these services will be the same age as you will they?

AntlerRose · 07/09/2022 14:25

Health is a public issue so you do use health services indirectly. If TB is spreadiny for instances it doesnt really care you didnt want to pay for someone else not to get TB, only yourself because to stop yourself getting TB you kinda have to stop others getting it too.

Ditto education, we all 'use' state education whether or not we have children as we all benefit from an educated workforce. There are millions of things i benefit from such as the person who undestands chemistry that makes all the drinking water safe. It just does get set up once and left ticking over. The list of things i need done for me, most of which i'm not even aware of is endless.

BuildersTeaMaker · 07/09/2022 14:24

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 13:05

So my children should pay the costs of incentivising middle-class people to earn more money?

I don’t disagree with you, but the threshold for higher rate has not changed to keep up with wage increases in a long time. When I was first working in 1980sonly director level type people in my industry would reach higher and, by 2000 I’d say 25% of workforce had been caught into the band.
id agree that I’d rather see nil band increase further…but the Tory view is to incentivise people to higher wages…