Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want my children to pay for tax cuts for the middle-class?

334 replies

antelopevalley · 07/09/2022 12:46

A new policy proposal to increase the ceiling for higher rate tax for individuals has been proposed so that it will only apply once you earn £80k plus. But there seems zero idea of how this will be funded.
Realistically the only way it will be funded is by increased government debt. Debt that my children and others will be working to pay off in the future.
Why should my children and others have to work in the future for tax cuts for the middle class?

Government borrowing should be for investment in the future. Building sources of cheap future energy for the future for example. It should not be used for short term political gains.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Endlesssummer2022 · 18/09/2022 20:37

‘Unless the thought is to effectively buy votes from the working middle-class?’

Well I will love it if the government has suddenly remembered who’s paying the bills in this country. Working middle-class people have had fuck all representation for some time.

We’ve watched as the Retired wealthy Telegraph readers, aspirational working class Daily Mail readers and working class Sun readers gave us Brexit which we knew was stupid and would trash the economy. The working middle classes have had enough of being rinsed for cash whilst being insulted for not beLeaving hard enough.

Many working middle class people have skills that can be taken elsewhere and the government now realise this and have clearly seen the Venn diagram which shows this group are the net contributors. It’s about time we saw something from this shit show.

Zilla1 · 18/09/2022 19:38

tbf to Scotland (and Wales), the general understanding is that they have a pot and prioritise differently, such as for prescriptions. There are costs and benefits, such as the burdens on HE institutions. They run things differently to England such as a single police force. Not sure the notion of the 'UK paying for benefits not available in the England' stand up to scrutiny though happy to see the evidence of preferential funding once demographics and geography are taken into account. The statement regarding 'UK paying for benefits not as available in England' seems odd.

XingMing · 18/09/2022 19:30

The UK will/can not going on paying for bnbefits in Scotand that are not as available in England.

RJnomore1 · 18/09/2022 18:09

The free uni has the HE sector on its knees.

happyfishcoco · 17/09/2022 21:38

Swingsarefun · 07/09/2022 14:41

Come to Scotland where the higher rate tax is 41% not 40% and kicks in when you earn a lofty £43k. Got to fund the illegitimate indypondering somehow.

I disagree with tax cuts as public services need to be funded but would like to see England go to a higher rate starting at £80k just to see what the SNP do next.

but at the same time, Scotland provides the most benefit to all Scots, like free 30 hours of nursery for all 3 years old, free medication, free dental, free UNI!!! correct me if I am wrong. now I wonder who pays the bill for free UNI....

happyfishcoco · 17/09/2022 18:55

MintJulia · 07/09/2022 13:47

OP, think about which people it will impact most - those earning between £45k and £100k.

Who are all those people who are retiring in the middle of a skills shortage? Who are the 'Great Resignees'?

They are experienced teachers, nurses, doctors, dentists etc in their 50s and early sixties. The ones we need to hang on to and encourage to go on working.

We have a chronic shortage of teachers, doctors, dentists. Creating a tax regime that encourages them to carry on working an extra 5 or 10 years sounds like a good idea to me. Better value too, because the NHS trained them and we should encourage them to work as long as possible.

Sorry if that offends you, but working class people need doctors and teachers just as much as anyone else.

well said!!
thank you for saying that! very good point and that I have not to think of!!

happyfishcoco · 17/09/2022 18:36

yes, YABU
how come your children working to pay for the "middle class"?
are your children paying 45% tax?? if so, they should, as they earn 150K.
if your children are paying 20% tax, which means the “middle class” is funding plenty for your children.

SofiaSoFar · 10/09/2022 08:05

@Jiminycricket10

Plus addressing issues like misogyny in pay scales, with many traditionally ‘male’ roles often considered more ‘valuable’... (trades, high level managers on millions vs carers, admin staff, etc.).

You're comparing skilled with unskilled work there.

Jiminycricket10 · 09/09/2022 13:52

Mybestyear · 09/09/2022 12:38

This. I’m a nurse (34 years qualified) and have undertaken around 10 years of additional study and training to get to where I am. I’m from a traditional working class background (coal mining) and have absolutely worked my socks off to earn £60k. Although this is a good salary, it’s not comparable to what 60k was when I was growing up. I’m now considering taking a less demanding role at a lower salary as it’s just not worth the stress as such a huge chunk of my pay goes on tax. It would effectively mean a loss of my skills in the NHS but I’m doing a high risk job (risk as in patient- related interventions) and the stress just doesn’t seem worth it.

I see your point. I don’t disagree with it. However, nor are most wages worth even a fraction of what they were, and for those in the lower tax threshold the impact of price rises is proportionally greater.
Also from a coal mining region so understand how hard you’ve worked to get where you are - I really do.
Also understand how hard those in lower paid jobs work too - granted some without the additional responsibilities.
There’s a massive issue with wealth distribution and the value placed on some jobs as opposed to others, and I feel we should all be lobbying for each other (e.g. carers have a paltry wage considering they care for some of the most vulnerable members of society, compare with banking where ‘responsibility’ in a male oriented environment comes with a huge pay check). There have been some convincing arguments on here regarding both the 50k and 100k tax bands - that’s why I like Mumsnet to challenge my perspective.
Having said that the effects of recent rises have been so severe that I have to say that changes to tax bands must also be for those lower down the scale too - as opposed to this potential divide and conquer/Tory vote winning/unofficial MP pay rise tactic currently proposed...

Jiminycricket10 · 09/09/2022 12:55

I actually found many points on this thread very interesting - particularly the accountant who explained how going over 100k works out at high tax on extra earnings due to the combination of losing the tax free threshold and high tax rates... Sounds like the tax system needs updating so it’s fair to everyone and it pays to work... Plus addressing issues like misogyny in pay scales, with many traditionally ‘male’ roles often considered more ‘valuable’... (trades, high level managers on millions vs carers, admin staff, etc.).
I’m not against hard work paying but I think many claims are misguided - that just because Yorkshire has the standard managerial level jobs like doctors, judges, headteachers, etc. that there are a wealth of well paying opportunities and raising only the 40% tax threshold will encourage people to get there. Home/hybrid working have improved the situation somewhat, and there are some fabulous initiatives around encouraging and supporting entrepreneurs, but there’s a long way to go.

Mybestyear · 09/09/2022 12:38

shedwithivy · 07/09/2022 13:12

The higher rate tax band was introduced to take more tax off high earners, as the threshold hasn't changed while inflation has continued, it brings ordinary middle income jobs into this bracket (including police officers, firefighters, senior teachers) I do think it would be fairer to stagger tax around this threshold rather than it being a sudden jump which also deters people from promotions or overtime if it tips them into the higher band.

This. I’m a nurse (34 years qualified) and have undertaken around 10 years of additional study and training to get to where I am. I’m from a traditional working class background (coal mining) and have absolutely worked my socks off to earn £60k. Although this is a good salary, it’s not comparable to what 60k was when I was growing up. I’m now considering taking a less demanding role at a lower salary as it’s just not worth the stress as such a huge chunk of my pay goes on tax. It would effectively mean a loss of my skills in the NHS but I’m doing a high risk job (risk as in patient- related interventions) and the stress just doesn’t seem worth it.

Jiminycricket10 · 09/09/2022 12:30

I think I was making the point - relating to the thread - that I agree with people saying the lower tax threshold should be raised so everyone benefits, but kind of lost my way... 🤪

Jiminycricket10 · 09/09/2022 12:28

*you’re

Jiminycricket10 · 09/09/2022 12:27

😂😂 you right @FarFromHome2 it’s not the best reply (my phone battery cut out and posted my reply without me pressing send).
I think I’d answered your question and then was more replying to the thread in general.

FarFromHome2 · 09/09/2022 07:38

Jiminycricket10 · 08/09/2022 14:14

I have to go back to my point about working conditions. I’m qualified in education, but honestly, the education system is severely broken if not actually damaging for some children and staff... (I got out due to this as have many others who are voting with their feet). So, I object to the argument that tax breaks should be given to encourage ppl to stay (you’ll actually find many experienced teachers - even under 50k - being forced out because they’re ‘too expensive’).
At no point in my ‘work hard to get a good job and earn well’ mantra was the crap that goes off in schools/the NHS/social care and many other core systems part of the deal. Nor do I agree that the professions you list (all senior) are the only ones of value deserving tax breaks. I guess I object to the school of thought that only being higher up in a profession brings enough value for a decent wage...

You are responding to points I didn’t make, my post was in response to the false claim that there were none or only very few high-paying jobs in Yorkshire.

I’m not sure what your dissatisfaction with teaching has to do with it.

Badbadbunny · 09/09/2022 07:24

A thread on another forum today highlighting a typical case of the impact of stupid tax rules where trying to get more tax off "higher" earners ends up with HMRC getting less!

forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/6385864/reducing-income-to-receive-child-benefit

Jiminycricket10 · 08/09/2022 14:14

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 09:47

Yorkshire has barristers, headmasters, accountants, surgeons, dentists, architects, senior police officers and so-on earning that sort of money. Is there any reason that these jobs aren’t achievable for you?

I have to go back to my point about working conditions. I’m qualified in education, but honestly, the education system is severely broken if not actually damaging for some children and staff... (I got out due to this as have many others who are voting with their feet). So, I object to the argument that tax breaks should be given to encourage ppl to stay (you’ll actually find many experienced teachers - even under 50k - being forced out because they’re ‘too expensive’).
At no point in my ‘work hard to get a good job and earn well’ mantra was the crap that goes off in schools/the NHS/social care and many other core systems part of the deal. Nor do I agree that the professions you list (all senior) are the only ones of value deserving tax breaks. I guess I object to the school of thought that only being higher up in a profession brings enough value for a decent wage...

Doingprettywellthanks · 08/09/2022 13:13

Bet you didn’t expect that response! 😂

Doingprettywellthanks · 08/09/2022 13:07

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 12:57

No, that’s their gross pay.

Why do you ask, are you dodging tax with yours?

Yep. I pay cash

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 12:57

Doingprettywellthanks · 08/09/2022 12:53

Is that cash in hand to your cleaner out of interest?

No, that’s their gross pay.

Why do you ask, are you dodging tax with yours?

Doingprettywellthanks · 08/09/2022 12:53

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 09:49

Our nanny gets £18 per hour, our cleaner gets £17. I don’t think that that can be considered “ at the bottom.”

Is that cash in hand to your cleaner out of interest?

FarFromHome2 · 08/09/2022 12:05

antelopevalley · 08/09/2022 11:29

@Wouldloveanother I look at actual research.

And yet you seem to ignore facts that don’t suit your preferred narrative.

Those higher earners that you don’t want your children to pay for, they are the ones actually paying in the most tax, so are paying for your children, not the other way round.

Higher earners have been paying more tax under this government for years than they did under Labour. Trying to claim that reducing this increase is “making my children pay” isn’t tenable.

antelopevalley · 08/09/2022 11:29

@Wouldloveanother I look at actual research.

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 08/09/2022 11:12

Your personal experience does not always reflect the average reality.

But neither does yours. And while people living in more expensive parts of the country may earn more, that’s reflected in the astronomical house prices/rent that they pay.

You seem to have almost a Dickensian view of poverty, that a lower salary = poor and average or above average salary = wealthy.

The cookie simply doesn’t crumble like that.

antelopevalley · 08/09/2022 10:55

I know trades people earning low wages, people working in jobs as cleaners and childcare workers on low wages, etc. Whereas in MN people only seem to know people working in trades earning very high wages and cleaners and nannies all on £30k plus. In reality the average trades wages are in the low £30ks - differs depending on the trade, and cleaners and childcare workers tend to be low paid.
Your personal experience does not always reflect the average reality.

OP posts: