Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's my money and I'll spend it ...

387 replies

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 10:50

I'd really like to get your opinions on my slightly odd marriage set up. I don't know how I've ended up here and think I'm pretty conventional but this situation is far from the norm. I'll try to keep it short but with all relevant info.

We're married and mid-40s. Second time for both he has young adult children and I don't. We've been together about 10 years in total. Married for five. We earn roughly around the same and I helped him with some of the costs for his children when they were with us but I never paid any of his child maintenance (by that I mean I paid half towards days out, birthday presents, holidays that sort of thing) . I had no part in his first marriage break-up.

He's inherited a substantial sum from an unmarried great aunt - somewhere in the region of 5 x years worth of our joint salaries. Not life changing or enough to retire on but still a nice and slightly unexpected bonus. He was not close to the aunt and didn't see her regularly so this sad occasion doesn't have a huge emotional toll (sorry if that sounds harsh I think it would be different if it were a closer family member).

We have a small mortgage which we've always overpaid to protect us in old age as neither or us thought there would be any inheritance from anywhere and too much fun in our 20s (and children in his case) meant little pension provisions until much too late.

This money is his and he's made this very clear. (I know we're married so I think it's both if we split). I have no intention of splitting with him though. He's buying a fancy new car. He's paying off some small credit card debt and going on a boys holiday! I have no problem with the holiday this was planned but I also have a small debt (£5.5k) and for him to pay this off for me wouldn't make a big dent in his money. My car is fine so I don't need a new car. We don't have joint accounts and never have. We always earned almost the same so apart from his child costs we were equal. I now feel he's punishing me for not contributing to his child maintenance when he was paying. Both kids are now working full time (no Uni).

AIBU to think he's being incredibly selfish or is he right and the money is his to do what he likes with? I don't think he has plans to give his kids any of it at this point but they are looked after in his will (as they should be).

OP posts:
SavBbunny · 07/09/2022 13:58

@OldAgeWorries I am sorry you are in this difficult situation.
Your husband is mean and it doesn't bode well. My sister has been in a similar marriage. She signed a prenup over some £50k savings. She has to pay half of all meals out. Same transfer s*it. The husband earns twice her salary. It is not a happy home.
I am lucky as my husband would give me his last penny. I earn five times his salary and when it is bonus time I pay off any debt. We pay for housing and food equally but no one is counting. I have been ill in the past and couldn't work. He paid everything working 80 hour weeks.
I think the problem is communication. My husband inherited and he bought me a lovely gift and paid all debts. He even bought my father a gift (our last surving parent). The rest went towards our home.
I would be saying right what are your plans for the windfall? Are you intending to reduce the mortgage and debts? If he isn't I would seriously be thinking of not spending my old age with him. Would he pay for nursing care if you needed it? Love should be all encompassing.

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 07/09/2022 13:57

@IDidntKnowItWasAParty

She shouldn't feel entitled to it though, if his aunt wanted them both to have it she would have willed it to both.
If op has a problem with that then she should leave.
Money seems to bring out the greed in people.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 07/09/2022 13:56

I don't think he is wrong necessarily. My dh inherited £90k from his parents and that is his money. He did buy me a car, but I didn't expect it. 10 years later, he still has half of it. It gives him peace of mind.

MiniCooperLover · 07/09/2022 13:56

My DH's mum sadly passed away a few years ago, he straight away on receiving his inheritance paid the maximum allowed off our mortgage and has put the rest aside to clear our mortgage come December when we can (without incurring a penalty charge). I did say to him it's your money, is that what you want to do with it and he insisted yes, not an issue. That's what married couples do, they take care of each other not just themselves.

3peassuit · 07/09/2022 13:50

When I inherited money, I saw it as family money and used it to pay down the mortgage. It meant the whole mortgage was paid off more quickly and we could put cash away to help the DDs with their own housing costs when the time came. I wouldn’t have dreamt it was meant for my own personal use. DH and I have always seen any money coming into the household as a joint pot, perhaps as your household has always viewed income as separate, he sees no reason to change that view.

LAMPS1 · 07/09/2022 13:49

I know plenty of married couples organise their financial affairs the way you do it, but I don’t understand it. seems to me that you get married and become one family unit so all money goes into one pot and bills come out and whatever is left is saved for emergencies and the future.
YANBU expecting this windfall from your DH’s relative to go into a family pot for all of you to benefit.
I would hate this situation you are in and would feel very excluded as if there’s no point at all being married if I wasn’t in his heart and mind as he celebrates his good fortune.
He’s mean OP !
But you knew that already the first time he didn’t pay for your birthday meal.

ThanksItHasPockets · 07/09/2022 13:48

See what he says when you ask him directly but honestly, OP, it sounds like this is part of a very long-term pattern of meanness. I would not want to grow old with a selfish man.

IDidntKnowItWasAParty · 07/09/2022 13:47

@NotMyselfWithoutCoffee aren't you a joy lol - of course he can do with it what he LIKES, no one is saying otherwise - it's the fact that he clearly doesn't LIKE to share any portion of it with his DW, whom he is supposed to love and who is supposed to be his life partner, that is the problem.

RandomMess · 07/09/2022 13:47

Meh he's miserly.

I would reduce going out and state you can't afford to go 50:50 with all the price increases so you need to stay home as you still have debt to repay.

Sadly I think you may find out he's actually miserly unless he's spending on himself. Not an attractive quality Sad

Sunnysideup999 · 07/09/2022 13:45

I think if his aunt wanted it to go to both of you then she would have specified that in the will?
I always think it’s odd to lay claim to inheritance money left to someone just because you’re married to them.

Hopeislost · 07/09/2022 13:45

Is he always this selfish? I had a small inheritance recently (a few months pay) and although we keep our finances separate, DH was part of the discussion of what I should do with it. I ended up spending half on a family holiday and half clearing some of my debts.

Yes it is technically his money but I just can't get my head round how he doesn't even consider you. Does he ever do nice things for you?

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 07/09/2022 13:42

Yabu it was his money, willed to him by his family.
He can do what he likes with it.

Montymorency · 07/09/2022 13:40

very selfish of him, it would eat away at me that his spontaneous reaction wasnt to share this with you. i unexpectedly inherited a large amount from a family friend a couple of years ago and it gave me huge pleasure to give my husband half. we had struggled month to month and now the lack of financial pressure is amazing.

Cailin66 · 07/09/2022 13:38

If I inherited this amount of money I would pay off all debt. All credit cards, all bank loans, all car loans and the mortgage. I would pay for a nice family holiday. I'd probably give the children between 5 and 10 thousand each. Then I'd do any major house renovation that had been on the long finger (bathroom conversion/patio/garden). After that I'd think about a new car (only if needed) for both of us. In our marriage (first) it's always been 50/50. Men are idiots about cars so I wouldn't have an issue with him getting a flash car (even if I think it's stupid)

In your case I think your husband, who is now going to be your life long partner is exceedingly selfish. You shouldn't have to ask. But if I were you and he didn't pay off the miserly 5 thousand debt you have and the mortgage I would question whether it was worth staying with someone so selfish. Has he suggested even one thing out of his inheritance for you?

mcmooberry · 07/09/2022 13:37

He sounds extremely ungenerous in general if he makes you pay half for your birthday meal. Maybe this situation has crept up on you, but it certainly isn't right or normal.
No, you are not BU but he now would only be doing it under sufferance if he didn't think to offer in the first place/take you both away for a fabulous holiday.
I personally couldn't be married to someone so tight.

emeraldcity2000 · 07/09/2022 13:37

How did you come to the current arrangement? I have a few friends who have much more separate finances second time around - because they felt unfairly treated through their divorces and preferred to be self sufficient. I'd still expect him to do something nice for you though. And to use the money to help his kids out.

Crazykatie · 07/09/2022 13:37

My mums estate is about to be distributed and I have no intention of sharing mine, it would not be expected either, if finances are separate they are separate. My OH would not even know how much is in my account unless I choose to tell him, I don’t know how much is in his.

Clarinet1 · 07/09/2022 13:36

I think that, in a loving relationship, if one person has some good fortune it’s right to share it. In this case the car might be ?20% of the inheritance, the boy’s holiday, say 5-10% and to pay of the debt for the OP would be maybe 1-2%. Hardly unreasonable. However, the OP doesn’t seem to have really discussed this with her H which she should. If he really nitpicks about contributions the DC’s expenses that is unfair as they are his DC and it sounds as if the OP did more than her fair share. And as for going halves on her birthday meal......

user1498572889 · 07/09/2022 13:34

My husband received some money and i said to him that we had to make it last. He said it was his and it was up to him. It went into our joint account so i spent it when i wanted to He never said anything

Iloveacurry · 07/09/2022 13:33

You say it’s a 6 figure amount, so 5k isn’t really that much really. Yes he is being tight.

Do you still treat his kids when you go out for meals? Pay half with your DH? If so, perhaps just pay for yourself next time.

Peridot1 · 07/09/2022 13:33

I can’t get past you paying half for your birthday meals. How on Earth did that start? And then you pay in full for his?

What was your loan for initially? Something for the house/household?

I do think you have an odd set up. And I also think he is quite mean for not offering you a lump sum and/or paying for a nice holiday.

SeaRabbit · 07/09/2022 13:32

What's in your wills and is the house held as joint tenants or as tenants in common? Is his life insurance written for you?

silverbubbles · 07/09/2022 13:29

So although you have always split things 50/50 he didn't really do this did he? You were always paying more as you supported his kids as well? If you went on holiday as a family you would still split the bill 50/50? You would pay half cost of their birthday day gifts?

He is a tight, greedy, miserly bastard. I wouldn't bother going out for dinner with a bloke like this.

Datafan55 · 07/09/2022 13:26

I think having separate money is sensible, surely? - if you needed to leave for any reason....
No expectation here that it would/should be yours 50/50.

However if you inherit money, surely the first thing you do is help those you care about - eg a loved one's debt paid off, something to any kids for their future house deposits etc ...

SilentHedges · 07/09/2022 13:25

user1471457751 · 07/09/2022 13:10

It would be really nice if all those accusing the OP of trying to have it both ways would actually bother to read the OPs posts. She has made it very clear from the start that, while she didn't pay toward cms, she did pay half toward birthdays, Christmasss, days out etc. So no, their finances haven't always been completely separate and the OP has spent a lot on subsidising her husband with his children.

THIS. I feel quite frustrated for the OP that people don't read her posts and look at the facts presented before making comments. It's also worth bearing in mind that the OP will have spent considerably more on housing than she would have had to, because there needs to be additional space for his kids. She's made a significant contribution.