Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's my money and I'll spend it ...

387 replies

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 10:50

I'd really like to get your opinions on my slightly odd marriage set up. I don't know how I've ended up here and think I'm pretty conventional but this situation is far from the norm. I'll try to keep it short but with all relevant info.

We're married and mid-40s. Second time for both he has young adult children and I don't. We've been together about 10 years in total. Married for five. We earn roughly around the same and I helped him with some of the costs for his children when they were with us but I never paid any of his child maintenance (by that I mean I paid half towards days out, birthday presents, holidays that sort of thing) . I had no part in his first marriage break-up.

He's inherited a substantial sum from an unmarried great aunt - somewhere in the region of 5 x years worth of our joint salaries. Not life changing or enough to retire on but still a nice and slightly unexpected bonus. He was not close to the aunt and didn't see her regularly so this sad occasion doesn't have a huge emotional toll (sorry if that sounds harsh I think it would be different if it were a closer family member).

We have a small mortgage which we've always overpaid to protect us in old age as neither or us thought there would be any inheritance from anywhere and too much fun in our 20s (and children in his case) meant little pension provisions until much too late.

This money is his and he's made this very clear. (I know we're married so I think it's both if we split). I have no intention of splitting with him though. He's buying a fancy new car. He's paying off some small credit card debt and going on a boys holiday! I have no problem with the holiday this was planned but I also have a small debt (£5.5k) and for him to pay this off for me wouldn't make a big dent in his money. My car is fine so I don't need a new car. We don't have joint accounts and never have. We always earned almost the same so apart from his child costs we were equal. I now feel he's punishing me for not contributing to his child maintenance when he was paying. Both kids are now working full time (no Uni).

AIBU to think he's being incredibly selfish or is he right and the money is his to do what he likes with? I don't think he has plans to give his kids any of it at this point but they are looked after in his will (as they should be).

OP posts:
Weirdlynormal · 07/09/2022 12:11

I even pay half towards my birthday meals

Fuck that then. He's a tight arsehole...but you knew that already.

Tinkity · 07/09/2022 12:10

This money is his and he's made this very clear. (I know we're married so I think it's both if we split).

No you are wrong about this, inheritance is NOT automatically considered a marital asset as long as it is kept entirely separate from joint / family finances.

Inheritances can be considered a marital asset if:

  1. It’s been mixed / pooled with family finances, so if for example he deposits it into a joint bank account or he pays off your joint mortgage etc.
  2. There are not enough marital assets to adequately provide for everyone’s needs post divorce & using it is the only way to provide everyone with housing etc.

Courts always try to preserve inheritances where possible though.

Weirdlynormal · 07/09/2022 12:10

I can understand why a second marriage keeps their finances separate. I can also understand why you haven't paid maintenance for his kids, but that must mean you've had more money than him until now, right?

Surely you can't have it both ways?

All that said, my husband inherited a huge sum and we have it held in both our names, invested it in both our pensions and it's very much shared money. We are a first marriage so I think that does influence things, but I can't see why I wouldn't share something with the person I love.

Motnight · 07/09/2022 12:09

My dh and I both put money into a pot and then have our own spending money.

We have had 2 inheritances, one each. Each time we have spent around half of it on family stuff - ie paying a lump sum of the mortgage off, house improvements.

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 12:08

No he has an older sister.

It is six figures but he is really splashing out on a new car which is great as he's always wanted one and never thought he would have one. I don't resent him that one bit. Nor the boys holiday.

He is a bit tight, I even pay half towards my birthday meals but I thought he was just careful. The £5.5k for my loan really wouldn't make much of a dent.

OP posts:
SunshineLoving · 07/09/2022 12:07

I can never get my head around a married couple not sharing finances anyway but I find going 50-50 on a meal with your husband is very wrong.

Re the inheritance, in my opinion, the inheritance is a shared thing. You are married! Yes it may be in his name but you are a couple and should discuss and agree together how best to use the money or whether to save it. I would struggle very much if I was you to move past this.

Christmasiscominghohoho · 07/09/2022 12:07

I couldn’t imagine not giving my partner any or not treating him/ giving him any money if I inherited such an amount.

Pollydon · 07/09/2022 12:07

YANBU, my DH also received an inheritance, large enough to buy a house outright. He immediately put the moneys into a joint account, he also bought a new car , but he cleared off both of our credit cards first and we had a big holiday. It was always seen by him as joint Money. Funnily enough some of his relatives saw this as his money alone and are pretty aghast that I am joint owner of the house we then bought and have full access to the funds . Married 30 years.

Christmasiscominghohoho · 07/09/2022 12:06

I think he should pay of your debt.
Pay off the mortgage
and put some in the joint account/pay for a holiday.

SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 07/09/2022 12:05

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 11:11

We don't have a marriage pot or family money. We each have our own account. If we go out for a meal we'll split it 50/50. We both pay equal amounts into a bills account and that pays mortgage, bills, food. We each pay to run our own vehicles.
My loan is paid from my own money and not the bills account.
He's not usually selfish like this but then we've never had a situation like this before.

Normally I’d say YANBU as I think that if you’re married or in a committed relationship you should share in each other’s good fortune and also help each other out in tough times.

However, the fact that your money is all separate and that you even go halves on a meal out says to me that this is not how your marriage works.

I used to earn a LOT less than XP and he subsidised me by paying for holidays and meals out for us both and for my DCs. If we’d moved in together I would have wanted a more shared arrangement - and tbh this was one of the things that ended it for me.

When we talked about pensions he told me that his was looking surprisingly good (only a few years contributions but on a 6 figure salary!). He asked me what my retirement plan was and I pointed out that after 10+ years as a single mum on a low income, funnily enough I didn’t have a huge pension pot - or even a small one! He then replied that it would be on my kids to take care of me. This solidified to me that he didn’t see me as a partner at all, that even in old age he expected to live a life of luxury but I’d have to fend for myself. I can’t imagine ever thinking like that about someone I’d loved for 10 years!

Your marriage sounds a lot like this, so if you’ve been ok with it up until now, YABU to expect him to share his windfall with you when he won’t even share a meal without expecting you to pay for your half.

Bearsan · 07/09/2022 12:03

I would share it with DH but I do think you're being unreasonable to expect him to pay off your debts.
If it's 5x household income and 5.5k won't make a dent in it, then it is life changing to most people and he should at least pay off the mortgage.

IAmNotHoratio · 07/09/2022 12:03

I don’t know if I’m conventional but I think in a marriage it should be a what’s yours is mine situation if at all possible. So yes, I think he’s being very selfish.

ancientgran · 07/09/2022 12:03

I think it is mean, I assume this is well into six figures so paying of your loan is tiny. I've been married before and so has DH and we keep our money separate and both pay our share but if one of us has some extra e.g. got a lump sum due to an accident, then we would certainly at least treat the each other but probably just share it after paying off or reducing mortgage.

VatofTea · 07/09/2022 12:02

Is he an only child? Did he never learn to share?

inmyslippers · 07/09/2022 12:01

He sounds very mean spirited

thing47 · 07/09/2022 12:00

roarfeckingroarr · 07/09/2022 11:55

@thing47 what a lovely man. Does he have any brothers / friends Grin

Really? I just thought was normal behaviour… We're a team (most of the time!)

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 07/09/2022 11:59

I think given that you've financially supported the children then he should acknowledge that contribution and factor that in to the inheritance.

ParvuliThankYouDebbie · 07/09/2022 11:59

He's not usually selfish like this but then we've never had a situation like this before

Well, he’s not been selfish before because he’s only benefited before has t he, if you helped out with costs for his children. Still, at least you what he’s really like now, up to you what you do with that information of course.

stepparentbingo · 07/09/2022 11:58

Firstly, this idea that you haven't helped pay any of his child maintenance - if you did any of the following then you directly contributed towards that:

  • pay half the mortgage on a property that included bedrooms for his children that you did not need or use
  • pay half of food / gas / electric / water / council tax on a larger property (see above point) for times his children used these when with you
  • did any cooking, cleaning, washing, child-minding, transporting, meal planning, shopping, buying toiletries, for his children during times they spent with you
  • paid half of holidays cost when he should have been paying 3/4
  • paid half of birthday and meals/days out costs when he should have paid either all or 3/4 of those costs.

It sounds to me like he has had you believe that you haven't contributed to maintenance, but I'm willing to bet from what you have described that you very much have by doing some or all of the things on the list.

If this is how he values you and your marriage, maybe bear in mind that if you were to divorce, all of this inheritance would go into the pot to be divided up - and the starting point would be divided equally. This is completely regardless of your current account arrangements (which btw would also be in the same pot regardless of whose name it is in).

I would be very hurt not to be included in some discussions as to how this money is spent, and would like you to realise that you have very much been subsidising his life and his children's maintenance payments over the years by taking on financial responsibilities.

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 11:58

I can have a conversation with him I just wanted the opinions of strangers to see if my opinion was wildly out of order.

OP posts:
MachineBee · 07/09/2022 11:58

Me and DH are on second time around too, although we both have DCs. If I had a big windfall I’d want to have some treats for me, DH and the family, but also not fritter it away. So would definitely use some of it to pay off all or part of the mortgage and other household debts.

This way it frees money up now, provides greater future financial security and could even be there for inheritances for children (assuming it doesn’t all go n elderly care fees).

Perhaps you need to decline a few meals out on the grounds that you are trying to pay off your debt (citing CoL crisis or somesuch reason) and he may offer to pay for the meals out (in which case he helps you indirectly pay off your debts). Or the penny might drop that it would be a nice thing for him to do for you and life will continue as before.

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 11:57

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 07/09/2022 11:45

How did the set up of you paying half his children's costs come up? Did he ask or did you offer?

I think I offered at the start. It just became a thing.

OP posts:
Confusion101 · 07/09/2022 11:56

I wouldn't jump to any conclusions without even having a conversation with him. What are you scared of - after 10 years, and all else being well, why not just ask?

This!!!! As usual Mumsnet would have you signing the divorce papers without even having a conversation!

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 11:56

I'm not overly happy with the judgements but this is AIBU so I suppose I have to take the rough with the smooth.

I have never expected anything from him and won't start now. I just think it's mean of him. To the poster who suggested I should have to pay half his childcare I disagree strongly. I contributed more than enough to days out - they are his kids and his responsibility.

No, not a student loan, just a standard bank loan.

OP posts:
YellowTreeHouse · 07/09/2022 11:56

You have chosen not to share finances, so of course he shouldn’t have to offer to share with you.

You can’t have it both ways.

Swipe left for the next trending thread