Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's my money and I'll spend it ...

387 replies

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 10:50

I'd really like to get your opinions on my slightly odd marriage set up. I don't know how I've ended up here and think I'm pretty conventional but this situation is far from the norm. I'll try to keep it short but with all relevant info.

We're married and mid-40s. Second time for both he has young adult children and I don't. We've been together about 10 years in total. Married for five. We earn roughly around the same and I helped him with some of the costs for his children when they were with us but I never paid any of his child maintenance (by that I mean I paid half towards days out, birthday presents, holidays that sort of thing) . I had no part in his first marriage break-up.

He's inherited a substantial sum from an unmarried great aunt - somewhere in the region of 5 x years worth of our joint salaries. Not life changing or enough to retire on but still a nice and slightly unexpected bonus. He was not close to the aunt and didn't see her regularly so this sad occasion doesn't have a huge emotional toll (sorry if that sounds harsh I think it would be different if it were a closer family member).

We have a small mortgage which we've always overpaid to protect us in old age as neither or us thought there would be any inheritance from anywhere and too much fun in our 20s (and children in his case) meant little pension provisions until much too late.

This money is his and he's made this very clear. (I know we're married so I think it's both if we split). I have no intention of splitting with him though. He's buying a fancy new car. He's paying off some small credit card debt and going on a boys holiday! I have no problem with the holiday this was planned but I also have a small debt (£5.5k) and for him to pay this off for me wouldn't make a big dent in his money. My car is fine so I don't need a new car. We don't have joint accounts and never have. We always earned almost the same so apart from his child costs we were equal. I now feel he's punishing me for not contributing to his child maintenance when he was paying. Both kids are now working full time (no Uni).

AIBU to think he's being incredibly selfish or is he right and the money is his to do what he likes with? I don't think he has plans to give his kids any of it at this point but they are looked after in his will (as they should be).

OP posts:
Mamma80 · 07/09/2022 12:27

VatofTea · 07/09/2022 11:16

I'm probably in the minority - but if you didn't share any of the financial responsibilities of his family life (even a tiny amount) in your earlier years together, then I don't think you are entitled to any of the inheritance booty.

I think it would be a kind gesture from him to pay off your debt (decision to be made by him alone with no guilting or pressure), but if he did that, would your sense of entitlement grow or would you be satiated with your cut of rich old auntie's estate?

I agree with this, I would be livid with my husband, but then we have always pooled our money, youve made it really clear all along that you seperate your funds (paying 50/50 for dinner ect)
Theres another reply on here saying you were never responsible for the child maintenance but actually if your saying all money should be shared because your married and together then so should financial responsibilities, in that you should have been supporting the maintenance of the children.

It sounds like you've been happy to keep everythibg seperate until you were the party that was worst off.

Saying that he could of course offer which would be the nicer thing to do. In a court of law yes youd get half but its up to you if your marriage is worth more as I think you'll have to agree how you'll work your finances moving forward as you've created this situation out of how youve handled finances previously.

KettrickenSmiled · 07/09/2022 12:27

I don't want it both ways? Yes my disposable income was marginally higher than his because I didn't have maintenance to pay,

Of course you bloody didn't. Because YOU DO NOT HAVE KIDS.

Any PP giving you stick for that & gleefully ignoring that you paid 50% of DC food/presents/trips out costs whenever they were in your home, is just wilfully using the maintenance thing as a red herring to beat you up with.
But this is AIBU, where second wives/stepmums always take a bashing, so ...

SleepingStandingUp · 07/09/2022 12:26

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 11:22

@Ragwort either he pays or I pay and we transfer the money over to each other. I know it sounds weird it's just what we've always done.

Just to be clear I haven't asked and he hasn't said no. It just hasn't been suggested by him and I don't want or feel I should have to ask.

Meh, you need to mention it to him. Not suggested evading on bended knee or anything but perhaps it hasn't occurred to him, perhaps he doesn't want to offend you, perhaps he is unwilling. Who knows.

You want money from him, there's no reason you shouldn't have to ask.

Jack, now you've inherited 200k, I wondered if you'd consider paying off my bank loan so we're both finally debt free?

elfin79 · 07/09/2022 12:26

I think YABVVVU. Your money is separate until your DH inherits a large sum of money and then you want a share?

I say this as someone in a very similar situation to you - DP of 13 years (civil partnership for 3), 1 adult DSD (who's holidays and birthday presents I have also contributed to), roughly the same incomes (although I have had periods where I have earned less and still contributed 50/50), both have loans outstanding which are paid from our own accounts. "House account" covers bills, mortgage, house expenses and holiday.

DP is about to inherit approximately twice our yearly salary from his aunt (who he also wasn't close to, so not a huge emotional upheaval).

It's HIS money. He wants to pay off his loan, fine, the rest he will invest for his retirement. I am actively encouraging him to do this. I don't think he should pay off my loan or make an overpayment on the mortgage (if he did I would ensure that that was ring-fenced in his share of the house - we have a deed of trust and wills that reflect our respective contributions to the deposit we put down).

What people are missing is that when one or both partners/spouses have children that are not of the relationship, then all preconceptions about family money go out of the window. My DSD will inherit from DP when he dies, as such, anything that he has now is not mine and neither should it be.

How would you feel if the tables were turned and he wanted a chunk of your money?

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 12:25

No practicalities. I've suggested he puts the max into Premium Bonds and ISAs so it doesn't all get chipped away as he's a bit of a spender and always has been. The new car is quite extravagant but he's always wanted it.

We're fortunate and I'm grateful I'm not on the breadline but it makes me wonder when we're older what the situation will be. We'll be mortgage free by then but will he be retired at 60, have a wardrobe full of designer gear and the newest car while I'm still working til 75?? God I hope not. This is what I'm genuinely worried doubt hence the user name.

OP posts:
AllMyExesWearRolexes · 07/09/2022 12:24

I didn't have an inheritance but I did have a medical insurance payout when I was ill. When we got the money we agreed that I got a Rolex, DW got a new Ford Focus, DD got driving lessons and a new laptop and the rest went in the bank.
Technically it was "my money" as I had the heart attack to get it but it's going to be used for the family's benefit.

Fadeout83 · 07/09/2022 12:23

I feel like you two need to have a discussion about money and finances now. I mean you’re married. Surely you can say hey how about that debt of mine? Just so odd you can’t just talk about it. Also can’t you toss a bit of extra money into the bills account so you don’t have to split dinners every time you go out? Just pay out of that?

Anyway I digress. I don’t think you’re being unreasonable to expect this but I do think you’re being unreasonable not communicating with him. And your set up is a bit odd but who am I to judge.

KettrickenSmiled · 07/09/2022 12:23

I now feel he's punishing me for not contributing to his child maintenance when he was paying.

This bloody inheritance aside - at that time, when you always paid 50% of days out for the kids (& I imagine 50% of eg food costs etc too ...) - did he make his displeasure about the child maintenance clear to you?
And how did that manifest?

How did/do you feel about the fact that he is pissed off about the maintenance, instead of grateful for your unswerving financial support of his DC's activities (& presumably day-to-day costs when in your home)?

SummerWhisper · 07/09/2022 12:22

He sounds awful. Tight doesn't cover it. Selfish doesn't cover it. Cruel is the word I would use. He is indulging his inflated ego by buying himself a flash car when you have shown generosity towards him and his children, you have a debt and his children won't even be on the property ladder but no, old big head wants a flash car. He will be getting Turkey teeth next.

MrKlaw · 07/09/2022 12:20

I wouldn't bedrudge 'spending money' - eg 10% of total or perhaps the holiday he's planned. But I'd give that to both sides so you can both have some disposable. If he had eg 10k for the holiday and debts and gave the same to you, you could choose to pay off your credit cards and/or buy something nice.

The Car feels like a big purchase and may be valid if its about time to replace, but would be at least a discussion - the inheritance is a good way to avoid finance and interest but 'fancy car' sounds like you think he's stretching things a bit - or he may think its an opportunity to have something nice that he maybe hasn't had (although 'fun 20s' sounds like you've not been wanting too much?)

Whats left after that we'd definitely be having a long talk about - 5x your yearly income sounds like whack it in a savings account/trickle into a couple of ISAs for retirement/pay off a chunk of the mortgage to save interest and also help towards retirement.

Has he made any noises about anything practical like that?

Somethingneedstochange · 07/09/2022 12:19

This

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 12:19

@gingertoast I'm only bringing up the food thing in response to those saying I didn't pay his child maintenance.

I haven't asked and don't feel I should have to but I can and will. I wanted the opinions of Mumsnet to check I wasn't being unfair.

OP posts:
mountainsunsets · 07/09/2022 12:18

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 12:13

I don't want it both ways? Yes my disposable income was marginally higher than his because I didn't have maintenance to pay, but I did contribute towards half of all food costs when the kids were with us every second weekend plus a couple of nights in the week, plus much more so I didn't entirely wash my hands of his extra costs. I pay half the mortgage for the house they stay in, half the bills, half the holiday costs.

I'm not asking for half of his inheritance just a small contribution that would make life a bit easier.

It reads like you've been a bit passive financially tbh.

Why did you accept paying half his kids food bill when he won't even buy you a birthday dinner?

Somethingneedstochange · 07/09/2022 12:18

He's being very selfish what about paying off the mortgage and putting some into savings? The least he could help his kids out by helping them get on the property ladder. Everyone is struggling to get by at the moment and just wanting to spend it all on himself is careless. You didn't have to contribute anything towards his children but you did.

10HailMarys · 07/09/2022 12:17

Just to be clear I haven't asked and he hasn't said no. It just hasn't been suggested by him and I don't want or feel I should have to ask.

Oh FFS. Just bloody ask him then! Then you'll know if he's being deliberately selfish or has just forgotten that you have that debt. If your finances are entirely separate, then there's a good chance he hasn't even thought about it.

He's not a mind-reader. If you want him to pay off the debt, ask him.

I haven't got a clue what DP's credit card balance is. He hasn't got a clue what I owe on my loan. If he wanted me to pay off his card out of a windfall I'd received, I'd be more than happy to do that, but he would have to ask because I've no idea if he has owes anything, and if he does owe anything, I wouldn't know how much it was.

mamabear715 · 07/09/2022 12:16

Marriages are odd these days.. I was married three times (am widowed now) and it was always OUR money, think I must just be out of date!
I do think it's selfish behaviour though.
My mum inherited some money from a neighbour that she'd looked after. My (lovely, open handed) Dad said ooh, what shall we spend it on? Mum said 'But it's MY money..' Dad ended up telling her to shove it up her arse.. ;-)

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 12:16

Tinkity · 07/09/2022 12:15

He is a bit tight, I even pay half towards my birthday meals but I thought he was just careful.

Does he pay half of his own birthday meals too though?

No I used to take him to a posher restaurant than we would normally go and pay for his birthday meal. Until this year ...

OP posts:
gingertoast · 07/09/2022 12:16

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 12:13

I don't want it both ways? Yes my disposable income was marginally higher than his because I didn't have maintenance to pay, but I did contribute towards half of all food costs when the kids were with us every second weekend plus a couple of nights in the week, plus much more so I didn't entirely wash my hands of his extra costs. I pay half the mortgage for the house they stay in, half the bills, half the holiday costs.

I'm not asking for half of his inheritance just a small contribution that would make life a bit easier.

But you haven't asked and he hadn't said no. You need to actually ask him as your financial set up has been so separate for the duration of your relationship.

Bringing up paying for kids food etc seems pretty churlish at this late stage

eggsandbaconeveryday · 07/09/2022 12:15

Firstly you are not nor ever have been responsible for paying maintenance for his children. Secondly, why was his first thought not to take you both away on a fabulous holiday and pay some money off the mortgage?. Your are partners in life ( married) so surely he should look at this as an opportunity for you both to benefit from not just himself ? I know that I couldn't behave that way and not lose sleep over it

Tootyfilou · 07/09/2022 12:15

Half towards your birthday meal?! If that is the case you can hardly be surprised by his behaviour. What would happen if you lost your job or became ill and could not work? Quite frankly he sounds awful.

Tinkity · 07/09/2022 12:15

He is a bit tight, I even pay half towards my birthday meals but I thought he was just careful.

Does he pay half of his own birthday meals too though?

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 12:13

I don't want it both ways? Yes my disposable income was marginally higher than his because I didn't have maintenance to pay, but I did contribute towards half of all food costs when the kids were with us every second weekend plus a couple of nights in the week, plus much more so I didn't entirely wash my hands of his extra costs. I pay half the mortgage for the house they stay in, half the bills, half the holiday costs.

I'm not asking for half of his inheritance just a small contribution that would make life a bit easier.

OP posts:
WitTanks · 07/09/2022 12:12

Seems like an incredibly weird set up; paying half each if you go for a meal.

He sounds like a selfish arsehole though.

LookItsMeAgain · 07/09/2022 12:12

Could you ask him for a contribution towards paying back the loan sooner? So if your loan is for 5K, perhaps 1k of that meaning the interest will be less and the repayments made smaller???
It makes financial sense, he's not giving you all of the money to repay your loan but he is easing the burden of the loan on everyone involved.

As for you paying 50% of your own birthday meals, I think that one should be made into 100% of the other party paying, so long as it's just the two of you eating out. There should be an agreement that you will only eat in restaurants where the bill doesn't require you to name your first born after the Maitre D' so that you're not going into hock for a single night out but then it should be up to the other to pay the bill for that one meal out.

mountainsunsets · 07/09/2022 12:11

But you actively chose not to share finances so why would you automatically get a share of his inheritance? It goes against how you've always operated as a couple.

The time to discuss all this was before you got married, not now he's come into some money.

IMO can't refuse to share money for over a decade and then expect to share his inheritance, especially as you always had more disposable income (that you didn't share while he paid his child maintenance.