Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's my money and I'll spend it ...

387 replies

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 10:50

I'd really like to get your opinions on my slightly odd marriage set up. I don't know how I've ended up here and think I'm pretty conventional but this situation is far from the norm. I'll try to keep it short but with all relevant info.

We're married and mid-40s. Second time for both he has young adult children and I don't. We've been together about 10 years in total. Married for five. We earn roughly around the same and I helped him with some of the costs for his children when they were with us but I never paid any of his child maintenance (by that I mean I paid half towards days out, birthday presents, holidays that sort of thing) . I had no part in his first marriage break-up.

He's inherited a substantial sum from an unmarried great aunt - somewhere in the region of 5 x years worth of our joint salaries. Not life changing or enough to retire on but still a nice and slightly unexpected bonus. He was not close to the aunt and didn't see her regularly so this sad occasion doesn't have a huge emotional toll (sorry if that sounds harsh I think it would be different if it were a closer family member).

We have a small mortgage which we've always overpaid to protect us in old age as neither or us thought there would be any inheritance from anywhere and too much fun in our 20s (and children in his case) meant little pension provisions until much too late.

This money is his and he's made this very clear. (I know we're married so I think it's both if we split). I have no intention of splitting with him though. He's buying a fancy new car. He's paying off some small credit card debt and going on a boys holiday! I have no problem with the holiday this was planned but I also have a small debt (£5.5k) and for him to pay this off for me wouldn't make a big dent in his money. My car is fine so I don't need a new car. We don't have joint accounts and never have. We always earned almost the same so apart from his child costs we were equal. I now feel he's punishing me for not contributing to his child maintenance when he was paying. Both kids are now working full time (no Uni).

AIBU to think he's being incredibly selfish or is he right and the money is his to do what he likes with? I don't think he has plans to give his kids any of it at this point but they are looked after in his will (as they should be).

OP posts:
BatteryPoweredMammy · 07/09/2022 12:41

In your opening posts, you sound like a carefree single twenty something, not a mature adult. But the fact he’s tight with money (going halves on your birthday meals FFS!), suggests that your relationship isn’t necessarily based on shared ideals. Does he look after you when when you’re sick, for instance?

Do you not regularly sit down and have sensible discussions about money, savings and debts. Especially with regards to the current financial climate and soaring inflation rates?

To be honest, I think you’re being very short sighted and simply hoping for the best. You’re already in your mid-40’s. You’ll be mid-50’s before you can blink.

What plans have you agreed if ;

one of you is made redundant? Will you be expected to use up any savings/get into debt to continue to pay 50% of the bills?

one of you gets sick and has to give up working and live on sickness benefits. Hopefully, you realise that most benefits are determined on your joint incomes, not expenditure, and if you’re sick you could be left with zero income.

what ages are you hoping to retire at and how will you fund it?

I’m in my late 50’s and already 4 of my good friends are dead. All had been in relationships and working full time in good jobs. You cannot assume that you’re going to stay healthy and still be happily working till you’re 70.

As you’re married, you really ought to be able to discuss this inheritance in terms of your joint financial future proofing. The fact he wants to blow significant sums on himself and hasn’t offered to pay off your small-ish debt speaks volumes as to how quickly he might ditch you if your financial circumstances change for the worse.

Honestly, you need to get your head out of the sand and think about your future with this man who appears not to care as much about you as you do about him. Think about that!

NoMichaelNo · 07/09/2022 12:40

nutellachurro · 07/09/2022 12:35

When women post on here in reverse they're told it's their money and to do what they want with it

So I'll hold the same view for your husband

Agreed.

Pyewhacket · 07/09/2022 12:40

Of course you’re being unfair. You want separate finances until he gets a windfall and then you want him to share it 🙄

Yep, agree with this.

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 12:40

Yes the money has hit his account, about two weeks ago I believe. Im not raging.

OP posts:
Aroundthetwist · 07/09/2022 12:39

My marriage is like this, we run entirely separate finances. We always have done and it’s worked fine, but we are quite independent from each other. We have children and have been married for 18 years. We would split a meal out as you describe.

I’m likely to be in your dh’s position in a few years as my father is ill. I may inherit a similar sum.

I would not share my inheritance 50:50 with dh. However, I would likely share a small portion, and then invest the rest and use the income to treat us both. I wouldn’t share the capital though because I’m not sure how our marriage will pan out once the children leave home - it isn’t the most secure. Ultimately, I would prefer our children to benefit from any inheritance rather than my dh. That sounds harsh, but it’s important to me to ring fence it so it wouldn’t be a marital asset, and to retain control over it. As long as we are together though, I would share the income to reduce bills or pay for treats. So perhaps a halfway house, sharing a small amount, sharing the income, but keeping the capital ring fenced would be a sensible solution. I certainly wouldn’t spend it on flash items for myself and leave dh in the cold - despite our slightly odd set-up.

My conclusion is that my marriage isn’t the most secure hence the need to protect myself in the long-term whilst hopefully sharing in an easier life in the short term. Perhaps your dh was burnt through the break up of his first marriage and is protecting himself here - although it doesn’t sound ideal for you if you wanted more security.

theresnouseingrumpin · 07/09/2022 12:38

Ask him

Ryder68 · 07/09/2022 12:38

He'll be doing the Billy Big Balls act around town and may consider being married a drag soon.

porkmarkets · 07/09/2022 12:38

Has the money hit his account yet? Maybe he'll transfer a portion to you when it does?

derxa · 07/09/2022 12:37

nutellachurro · 07/09/2022 12:35

When women post on here in reverse they're told it's their money and to do what they want with it

So I'll hold the same view for your husband

I agree

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 12:37

nutellachurro · 07/09/2022 12:35

When women post on here in reverse they're told it's their money and to do what they want with it

So I'll hold the same view for your husband

OK thanks, that's fair.

OP posts:
sweeneytoddsrazor · 07/09/2022 12:37

How long has he had the inheritance. You said the holiday was already booked so he has purchased a car he has always wanted and paid off his debt. Maybe he is considering what the best option is to do with the rest, pay off mortgage or invest for example? He hasn't exactly blown it all on himself despite all the selfish wanker posts. Just have a conversation with him like couples irl do.

Pinkdelight3 · 07/09/2022 12:36

I'm not asking for half of his inheritance just a small contribution that would make life a bit easier.

You're not actually asking him for anything. You haven't asked so until you do, it's all in your head. Even feeling like he's punishing you for not contributing to his kids seems groundless unless he brings that up as as reason for not helping you out now. Glad that you are going to ask, but try not to overthink it in advance and definitely don't be bringing the past DC financing into it as that may be irrelevant.

Interesting that PPs said inheritances are not actually seen as shared money and it is seen as "his" money not as marital funds, esp in a second marriage with no DC. So after going along with separate finances and splitting everything 50/50 for 10 years - even your birthday meals - it is a shift from your side to want his contribution. Not saying he's right - am all for shared finances/family pots personally - but this is how you've set it up together so you need to initiate the change rather than raging in advance.

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 12:35

Not life changing as in we couldn't retire on it. I think that's what I mean. It is a lot of money and if it were both of ours the mortgage would be cleared, the debts cleared, nice holiday, decent car for him (mine is ok), rest in investments. Still working.

OP posts:
nutellachurro · 07/09/2022 12:35

When women post on here in reverse they're told it's their money and to do what they want with it

So I'll hold the same view for your husband

Andromachehadabadday · 07/09/2022 12:35

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 12:25

No practicalities. I've suggested he puts the max into Premium Bonds and ISAs so it doesn't all get chipped away as he's a bit of a spender and always has been. The new car is quite extravagant but he's always wanted it.

We're fortunate and I'm grateful I'm not on the breadline but it makes me wonder when we're older what the situation will be. We'll be mortgage free by then but will he be retired at 60, have a wardrobe full of designer gear and the newest car while I'm still working til 75?? God I hope not. This is what I'm genuinely worried doubt hence the user name.

To be honest this all sounds a bit strange.

I won’t marry dp because I don’t want to combine finances, legally or other wiseZ when I got my dividend money, which is a fair amount, but not as much as your dh got. I gave dp 10K. Not for anything in particular but because we are a couple and I don’t want to sit with 100k and him just his wage. I also want him to spend it as he wants. So your dh not giving you anything is weird for.

That said, I think it’s really strange when married couples keep their finances so separate, even down to paying 50:50 for every meal. While me and dp don’t share finances, we are far more generous with eachother than this. And we don’t keep score of who paid for what. but I suppose if he has the view that you don’t share money and you have have accepted that, he probably views things completely differently.

I assume he feels that there’s been times where you have had spare money and you haven’t subsided him, so he doesn’t have to pay things for you now.

I can’t say who is unreasonable because I think you would need to know a lot of detail from both sides in regards to money during the marriage as a whole.

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 12:34

YellowTreeHouse · 07/09/2022 12:31

Of course you’re being unfair. You want separate finances until he gets a windfall and then you want him to share it 🙄

I'm just thinking what I would do if tables were turned. If I had inherited I would have already given him money to pay off his debt and booked a nice holiday.

OP posts:
StoppinBy · 07/09/2022 12:33

I'm still stuck on how an amount of money equal to 5 x's your combined yearly wages wouldn't be life changing. It sounds like a huge amount of money.

Sorry to say but I am not sure I could stay with a man who did this. Spending on himself and no thought of you or his kids, selfish man.

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 12:32

Paigeworkerx · 07/09/2022 12:28

Surely you could ask if he’d like to pay off the mortgage?

Then you’re saving your mortgage repayments and can pay off the loan quicker

Paying off the mortgage would be wonderful but that would be a much bigger chunk and I would understand his reluctance as effectively he's handing me half of that mortgage money.

The loan is a much smaller amount, more of a kind gesture/gift.

OP posts:
YellowTreeHouse · 07/09/2022 12:31

Of course you’re being unfair. You want separate finances until he gets a windfall and then you want him to share it 🙄

KettrickenSmiled · 07/09/2022 12:31

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 12:16

No I used to take him to a posher restaurant than we would normally go and pay for his birthday meal. Until this year ...

Then I think @Tinkity has just answered the next question for you:

We're fortunate and I'm grateful I'm not on the breadline but it makes me wonder when we're older what the situation will be. We'll be mortgage free by then but will he be retired at 60, have a wardrobe full of designer gear and the newest car while I'm still working til 75?? God I hope not. This is what I'm genuinely worried doubt hence the user name.

Yes, your fears will come true.
Because this man has a hugely entitled & hypocritical approach to money.
And as they are in the small things (a meal) so will they be in the big things (you working an extra 15 years because he is a tightwad.)

You are also misaligned in the way you handle money.
You want to pay down debt & save into a pension.
He wants flash cars, a flash wardrobe, 'boys holidays' & a wife who pays half his costs.

Ryder68 · 07/09/2022 12:31

He is a bit tight, I even pay half towards my birthday meals but I thought he was just careful.

Well he's not being careful with his inheritance is he? Pissing it up the wall on fancy cars and lads holidays!

He's only 'careful' when it comes to paying anything for YOU.

MrKlaw · 07/09/2022 12:30

OldAgeWorries · 07/09/2022 12:25

No practicalities. I've suggested he puts the max into Premium Bonds and ISAs so it doesn't all get chipped away as he's a bit of a spender and always has been. The new car is quite extravagant but he's always wanted it.

We're fortunate and I'm grateful I'm not on the breadline but it makes me wonder when we're older what the situation will be. We'll be mortgage free by then but will he be retired at 60, have a wardrobe full of designer gear and the newest car while I'm still working til 75?? God I hope not. This is what I'm genuinely worried doubt hence the user name.

practically it would make sense for you both to max out ISAs (potentially stocks and shares if you have time to let them mature but thats a separate topic) and depending how much is left do the same the next few years too. That may be one way to gently determine how ringfenced he really feels about it as techically that other ISA would be in your name (but is practical from a family finances perspective)

mellicauli · 07/09/2022 12:29

This sounds like a loveless marriage. I'd want out.

Paigeworkerx · 07/09/2022 12:28

Surely you could ask if he’d like to pay off the mortgage?

Then you’re saving your mortgage repayments and can pay off the loan quicker

MouseRoar · 07/09/2022 12:27

God that is monumentally selfish of him. And the boy's holiday! Really awful and I'd be very hurt in your shoes