Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents not upsetting people who can’t have kids

238 replies

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 10:40

Read this article in the Guardian with interest, about the need for people with kids to be very conscious of the pain people without kids around them might be feeling, and how friendships can break up when one person is able to have kids and the other can’t.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/sep/06/new-parent-friend-children-baby-grief?CMP=fb_cif#comment-158514602

As someone with one kid and a second on the way, and some old friends / a sibling around me who don’t have kids (some who want them but haven’t found a partner, one who is struggling to conceive), I do try to be careful not to constantly talk about mine or say things like “gosh you went to the theatre then had a lie in the next day, I’m so jealous.” Even though I am very jealous. Also try to not always suggest meet ups with them at the park with baby in tow (though most meet ups do have to be like this as it’s just when I have more time to meet and gives partner valuable alone time to cook, read, be a person rather than a parent.

However, it is also legitimately hard not to sometimes talk about your kids or bring your baby along to a meet up, because when they are young, they consume your life in a way that is sometimes good and sometimes bad : exhausting!! I’d love to be able to chat to friends about the books I’m reading, the day trips I’ve been on, the exhibitions I’m going to visit, what’s going on in politics at the moment but since having a baby the time I have to do any of those things has literally shrunk by about 85%. You also do start spending a bit more time with other parents because they also care about objectively boring stuff like sleep schedules and catchment areas, and they also don’t mind hanging out in awful kid friendly cafes and soft plays.

Curious to hear views about what parents and those who want to be parents can do to accommodate each other’s lives without causing hurt.

OP posts:
PauliesWalnuts · 07/09/2022 13:29

It’s a good article. As a childless by circumstance woman I’m guilty of phasing out some friends with children although I have kept in touch with others. I’ve also made a point of building friendships with other child-free and childless women and couples.

I think most people can be sensitive to other people’s situations but I think there is a small section of society that almost beatify motherhood. We have a baby coming in our family and at the moment nothing else is important - not my promotion, not the baby’s aunt’s new job, not a cousin’s career change and massive sports achievement. Even my landmark birthday lunch was over in 3 mins before the scan pictures and links to travel systems came out.

I think it’s a subconscious thing. My boyfriend sometimes talks about how he “can’t wait to be a grandparent”. His kids are 12 and 15. But he’s already feeding them this “when you’re a parent…” thing like it’s a done deal - he’s assuming they will want to have children and will get to have them. So right from their teens those kids are being told subconsciously that this is the path they’ll go down, and if it doesn’t happen for whatever reason, that can make the alienation or feeling left out, or left behind, even more pronounced.

RagingWoke · 07/09/2022 13:28

It's a hard one, and everyone is different so a conversation from either side is the best way to handle it.
I have been on both sides, struggled to conceive and had a few friends who were always telling me how amazing kids were, how life without dc must be so sad and unfulfilling or just constantly complaining about how hard their life was. And my favourite 'when are you going to have a baby then? Oh I didn't know you'd been trying so long, I got pregnant first time!'. But I was always happy for friends and family having dc, enjoyed spending time with their dc for the most part or helping out when they had newborns and were exhausted.

Then after i did conceive and had a healthy baby had a friend who was struggling to conceive and because I knew what it was like I was very conscious of not making every meet up or conversation about my baby. It was difficult because I always had the baby with me for the first year or so but while she was small it was easy enough to arrange meet ups around nap time so I could have a grown up conversation.

It's possible to be a parent and maintain friendships and interests outside of that. Admittedly in the early years it's harder to be physically away from dc (especially when BFing) and tricky if a friends or family feel they can't be around a baby but again, a conversation about their feelings, acknowledging them and agreeing or finding a compromise that's suits both.

Macaroni1924 · 07/09/2022 13:28

@PlumPudd everyone is different and for me it’s about friends/family being upfront an honest about what makes them feel happy or uncomfortable. I went through 7 years of ivf for my dd. Life felt it was on hold, so we make plans and possibly cancel if it works? Need to stay in this job in case I need maternity leave and so on. In that time one colleague had 3 children, from her 2nd and 3rd she took me aside privately to tell me which I thought was so kind and really appreciated. I honestly hand on heart can say I got that giddy excited feeling for her each time. I cried afterwards, not out of jealousy or bad feeling for her but I suppose mourning that again it wasn’t me. She was the very first person I told when it happened and she was an amazing support throughout. During this time another colleague was on her 2nd year of ivf and I felt that I should tell her before it was announced. When I took her aside and told her, her response was congratulations you don’t need to tell me I’m fine. I honestly felt like I had pissed her off so just shows that one person can feel one way and another differently.
The things that piss me off the most are people telling me to stand on my head or lie on my side. By this point I think I’ve literally done cartwheels down the street naked just in case it worked so stop with the shitty advice. People saying oh no we are definitely not having any more (and all the variations) - I would love that choice but don’t think it’s something you say to someone who has again been trying for nearly 6 years (desperately want a 2nd!) My cousin said this repeatedly and I once caught his wife giving him a sharp dig in the ribs🤣I left behind a friend many years ago who was in a same sex relationship and one night said to me she wanted children. I told her that can still happen for you and her response was no that’s unnatural! She was supporting me through ivf but felt it was unnatural, why was it ok for me and not her.
I am one of the lucky ones who has had a positive outcome and a precious gift. I wouldn’t wish infertility on my worst enemy but it has never made me not want to celebrate my friend/families children. Children are such a special part of our lives whether we want, or have, our own.

CavernousScream · 07/09/2022 13:23

ChagSameachDoreen · 07/09/2022 11:52

I can't say I'm a fan of this recent tendency to "include" everyone in everything. On Mother's Day, we're told we have to "make space for" those who aren't mothers for whatever reason. Same on Father's Day. It's exhausting. Victim culture.

Must be so tough for you that my kids get to make a Father’s Day card for other male figures in their life because their dad is dead. <hugs>, hope you’re managing ok after after to make a tiny bit of space so people less fortunate than you feel a bit less shit. I can see it’s challenging.

DysonSphere · 07/09/2022 13:22

Arbesque · 07/09/2022 12:52

I think the world has learnt to be a lot more sensitive and inclusive towards disabled people and has stopped looking down on unmarried women. That is surely a good thing?

That's not quite on the topic of the conversation imo. We all accept inclusivity and awareness of others is good. But that doesn't mean certain aspects of life and conversation are not exclusionary by nature of the situation. I'm disabled myself. I used to love jogging and exercise. I can't now and am piling on weight.

I don't expect my friends not celebrate reaching a 10k running milestone with me.

I'm happy for them and revel in their success. I appreciate that their joy isn't a deliberate infliction of pain to me.

Other times they listen to me bemoaning my circumstances and I return the favour by giving a listening ear in their joys/angst.

grlwhowrites · 07/09/2022 13:20

MsRosley · 07/09/2022 13:07

We seem to have tiptoed into a culture where instead of being reasonably mindful of other people's sensitivities, we're now expected to feel ashamed of anything that has gone well in our lives, while legitimising other people feeling offended if we do not perform our shame well enough. It's ridiculous. I don't expect everyone around me to kowtow around my sensitivities like they're navigating some kind of minefield. I expect myself to get over things to the extent where I can allow other people to live their own lives without forcing them into constant self scrutiny and self-imposed silence.

THIS. You basically said everything I wanted to but a lot more succinctly while I rambled on haha.

grlwhowrites · 07/09/2022 13:18

I think it's impossible to live life constantly thinking about other people's situations and potential pain, we aren't built that way. If you know people in your life are trying to conceive then obviously, be mindful and don't ask intrusive questions if months pass by with no pregnancy, but it's unfair to expect people to change their behaviours and lifestyles, or not celebrate certain milestones, to always suit others. There's got to be middle ground.
I'm childfree by choice (so subject to constant questioning and judgement) and don't want to always sit in child-friendly spaces - noisy cafes or soft play areas are my personal hell - but I'm well aware children take over people's lives and, while adults-only events and meet-ups are preferable, it's just not always possible. At least meeting friends in child-friendly spaces means I still get to see them.
Invite your friends to things, or mention they're welcome to attend if it's a child-led activity but there's no pressure etc. Don't expect people to come to child-focused events, but make sure they know they're welcome if they want to be there. Personally, I don't want to go to a five-year-old's party and though I'd appreciate the invite, I certainly wouldn't expect one and I'd understand why I might not get one, too.
I can't imagine the pain of not being able to conceive, but people with kids are often a package deal and they should be allowed to speak about their children or share happy moments from their lives as parents without fear of judgement or being branded insensitive.
I'm about to donate my eggs for the second time to try and help those struggling to conceive, so it's not like I'm a callous cow not wanting to try and help or consider the feelings of those without children. It's important to have adult-only time with friends, but it's not fair to expect your pain or struggles to be your friends' main priority. Life is shit and hard a lot of the time, we all have stuff going on. It's just not possible to constantly take on board other people's pain on top of your own. Don't be a dick but everyone should bear in mind that we've all got to put own lifejackets on first.

SheeWeee · 07/09/2022 13:16

I'm still not seeing anything that isn't covered by "don't be a dick".

Some people are insensitive assholes. But they are insensitive assholes in general, the topic doesn't matter, and they aren't going to change anyway.

Electricstar · 07/09/2022 13:12

I’m childless and suffered a loss in April this year. I’m not sure what the future holds and so not sure if I can answer this fully but having a loss whilst being around pregnant friends or those with children can be very hard

I do not think until you have experienced loss or unable to have children you can fully understand.

That being said I do fully understand it must be hard to feel unable to discuss your pregnancies or children with friends who are struggling or who have lost. One of my friends was talking to me yesterday about her morning sickness and admittedly I felt jealous - of course she’s allowed to be upset she’s got bad sickness but I’d do anything to have that and have a healthy baby.

You should never feel bad for having children or healthy pregnancies - and no one should make you feel guilty.

What helped me the most is being open and honest with friends and them doing the same with me. Sometimes I’m happy to chat about it and sometimes I’m not. Maybe they feel like on egg shells on sometimes and then they’d tell me etc

Although the comment about having to make space on Mother’s Day did get me a bit. You’re allowed your opinions but personally I think it’s nice on Mother’s Day to acknowledge my babies I lost and my friends who are desperate to be mums.

KimberleyClark · 07/09/2022 13:07

PurpleDaisies · 07/09/2022 12:45

But sometimes I feel pissed off that mums have to be quiet and make way for others’ feelings.

Don’t you think we all do that?

Absolutely.

MsRosley · 07/09/2022 13:07

We seem to have tiptoed into a culture where instead of being reasonably mindful of other people's sensitivities, we're now expected to feel ashamed of anything that has gone well in our lives, while legitimising other people feeling offended if we do not perform our shame well enough. It's ridiculous. I don't expect everyone around me to kowtow around my sensitivities like they're navigating some kind of minefield. I expect myself to get over things to the extent where I can allow other people to live their own lives without forcing them into constant self scrutiny and self-imposed silence.

wibblywobblybits · 07/09/2022 13:04

The thing to avoid is telling people how incredible it is to have kids, life would not be complete without them, etc,

@DoodlePug You've hit the nail on the head for me. I have various friends who have chosen to remain childless, and a sibling who is struggling to conceive, and I can't think of a situation or conversation where it's even necessary to say things like this, yet people do. Either you've chosen to have kids, in which case you (hopefully) already know incredible kids are. And if you don't, why do you need someone telling you how you should feel? Either that, or you don't have them (for whatever reason) - in which case, why do you need to be told how much better life is with kids? It's just inconsiderate and thoughtless either way.

MagpiePi · 07/09/2022 13:02

fallguys2 · 07/09/2022 12:49

We are struggling to conceive.

Personally, we love spending time with friends/ family's children and hearing all about them.

Our lack of success conceiving doesn't make us uninterested in the lives of people/ children we care about.

I really don't like it when people pussyfoot around as if I'm going to be upset if they talk about their kids.

The best thing you can do if you know someone who is struggling to conceive, is actually ask them if it bothers them or not, and then be sensitive to their reply. Everyone is different. We would be really sad if our loved ones felt like they had to filter themselves on our behalf - we love their kids!

This is why it is virtually impossible to get it right!

Some people will get upset if you talk about a subject, and others will get upset if you avoid the subject, but you are supposed to know how they feel without asking or being told. Especially if it is a random work colleague where you don't know anything about their life outside work.

I hope things work out for you @fallguys2

CarmenBizet · 07/09/2022 12:59

A genuine, strong friendship should be able to withstand conversations about this tbf.

Talk about the joys and tribulations of parenting with friends who also have kids. It comes across a bit tone deaf to complain to a non parent about how jealous you are that you can't have a lie in when you chose to have a child and won the lottery in being able to actually have one. Unless your friend is known to be happily childfree, that is.

It's a bit dull when you haven't got kids to just listen to someone bang on about them for a whole meetup. Just be a bit more socially aware, make sure you ask questions about them and their life too.

You also do start spending a bit more time with other parents because they also care about objectively boring stuff like sleep schedules and catchment areas, and they also don’t mind hanging out in awful kid friendly cafes and soft plays.

I've not found this really. Yes I've made new parent friends and some pre-existing friends now have kids too but I haven't changed my social group much and don't hang out less with former friends that don't have kids just cos I have one. My friendships with childfree/childless friends are just as close. Some take an active role in my kid's life which is nice, others it's lovely to have a friendship that's based on other things.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 07/09/2022 12:58

I've been engaged and had a few relationships in my life but due to a chequered family history (grandparents divorces etc), people being single mothers, I always knew from a young age that I'd never be a single mum. I have 2 best friends, one a single mum at 18, the other single mum at 27 after having DC at 24. Both their lives were hard - the latter easier as she waited a few years. I've always been on the fence so 50/50 re having kids, when my biological clock ticked in 30s/40s I got more pressure but even then in late 30s/40s I still ensured I took MAP to ensure not getting pregnant.

I did have a few events in 30s - friends parties with kids at houses/parks where sometimes I felt wistful especially if not in a relationship, but I made my peace with that.

I'm now happily single (but trying to date) and am a doting aunt/aunt-in-law to DB and his DW's DS and to SIL's BD and his DW's two kids. Fell out with half siblings a few years ago so no relationships there with their DC.

I've also mixed and made very good friends with NDNs who have DC and have seen their struggles with childcare and family life. Hasn't stopped them inviting me over/to family parties etc. You make your peace with life!

Good interesting article though, food for thought.

NKFell · 07/09/2022 12:58

I do try and be mindful, I'm not really a 'woke' type but I definitely try to be kind.

We can be sensitive to others feelings without being censored. I don't see it as black or white.

drpet49 · 07/09/2022 12:54

Chiwi · 07/09/2022 10:59

Sometimes you can't win. And I don't mean that in a nasty way, the pain must be unbearable but every person is different, one friend who struggled to concieve resented being left out of chat about my kids, trips with them and only invited on 'grown up' outings, shes become a wonderful addition to my childrens life (now pregnant!). The other couldn't bare to hear mention of my youngest and didn't even acknowledge his birth. It was just too painful for her, we've lost touch but with no resentment from me, she just couldn't cope with friends with small kids. If she wants to be friends later, I'm still here. I can't imagine the pain of wanting a child desperately and not being able to have one.
I think suggesting any uniform approach isn't helpful, everyone deals differently. You can try to be sensitive but it's best just to ask them and be honest that you don't know how best to manage the situation.

This

Arbesque · 07/09/2022 12:52

DysonSphere · 07/09/2022 12:48

Agree.

It is further demonstration of this victim culture.

So what now? Should those who have never been proposed to or married or are divorced start insisting their engaged and married friends 'tone down' their exuberant conversations about their weddings or anniversaries?

Those who have health problems start asking those who are well to not talk about the great sporting or travelling opportunities they can take part in as healthy people?

I mean tell me what part of life doesn't include some sort of exclusion-by-proxy?

And if you've actively chosen not to have children as a positive choice, why be derisory about those who haven't talking about their children. Surely you're neutral about it?

I think the world has learnt to be a lot more sensitive and inclusive towards disabled people and has stopped looking down on unmarried women. That is surely a good thing?

PurpleDaisies · 07/09/2022 12:51

DysonSphere · 07/09/2022 12:48

Agree.

It is further demonstration of this victim culture.

So what now? Should those who have never been proposed to or married or are divorced start insisting their engaged and married friends 'tone down' their exuberant conversations about their weddings or anniversaries?

Those who have health problems start asking those who are well to not talk about the great sporting or travelling opportunities they can take part in as healthy people?

I mean tell me what part of life doesn't include some sort of exclusion-by-proxy?

And if you've actively chosen not to have children as a positive choice, why be derisory about those who haven't talking about their children. Surely you're neutral about it?

If you knew someone was really struggling with not being married, or feeling down about their health etc, don’t you think it would just be nice not to go on and on about it? That’s just common courtesy. Save it for other friends.

Musti · 07/09/2022 12:49

Your life is your life. Everyone has different struggles - some are finding someone, or having kids, or having no money worries etc. you can’t shut every part of your life off for fear of offending or hurting people. Obviously don’t go on about you falling pregnant on the first go to your friend who is struggling to conceive but otherwise, your life is your life.

If they have issues then they may need to hand around other friends.

When I was single, I tended to meet up with another single mum at weekends. We’d go out together when we didn’t have the kids and with the kids when we did. But sometimes we also went out with couples etc.

fallguys2 · 07/09/2022 12:49

We are struggling to conceive.

Personally, we love spending time with friends/ family's children and hearing all about them.

Our lack of success conceiving doesn't make us uninterested in the lives of people/ children we care about.

I really don't like it when people pussyfoot around as if I'm going to be upset if they talk about their kids.

The best thing you can do if you know someone who is struggling to conceive, is actually ask them if it bothers them or not, and then be sensitive to their reply. Everyone is different. We would be really sad if our loved ones felt like they had to filter themselves on our behalf - we love their kids!

DysonSphere · 07/09/2022 12:48

Ylvamoon · 07/09/2022 12:37

I don't know...
I have children and they are a huge part of my life- same as DH and to a lesser extent my dogs.

Hiding them away and not including them or making out that they don't have much meaning to me is so wrong.

Why shouldn't I share what is most important to me with my friends?
Friendships move and evolve and sometimes we outgrow friends... that's life.

We all have struggles and unfortunately there isn't such a thing as a "bubble" to protect us from things that can/ will/ might upset us.
I think it's far more important to learn to deal with our emotions, sometimes acept the crappy bits in life and look at the things we have rather than what we don't have.

Agree.

It is further demonstration of this victim culture.

So what now? Should those who have never been proposed to or married or are divorced start insisting their engaged and married friends 'tone down' their exuberant conversations about their weddings or anniversaries?

Those who have health problems start asking those who are well to not talk about the great sporting or travelling opportunities they can take part in as healthy people?

I mean tell me what part of life doesn't include some sort of exclusion-by-proxy?

And if you've actively chosen not to have children as a positive choice, why be derisory about those who haven't talking about their children. Surely you're neutral about it?

Libelula21 · 07/09/2022 12:47

I have no idea!

PurpleDaisies · 07/09/2022 12:45

But sometimes I feel pissed off that mums have to be quiet and make way for others’ feelings.

Don’t you think we all do that?

Arbesque · 07/09/2022 12:44

Changingnames20 · 07/09/2022 12:36

I do think that women like myself who have children easily, are given a golden place in society and it’s easy to forget that.

Not so much me as I was a single parent, and have a child with disabilities (ones that are not so in vogue to talk about). Going out to work or staying at home though comes judgement… how we bring them up… And that has reminded me that we really do prop up married mothers and give them a bit of red carpet - I guess it is as old as time.

So it’s good just to be mindful that although children might be our whole world, and society loves us for that, but it’s really horrible if you feel outside of that, particularly if you want that, either by trying to conceive or just not finding a partner. So tough. We need sisterhood for all women whatever they are going through!

I think some mothers give themselves a golden place in society.