Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents not upsetting people who can’t have kids

238 replies

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 10:40

Read this article in the Guardian with interest, about the need for people with kids to be very conscious of the pain people without kids around them might be feeling, and how friendships can break up when one person is able to have kids and the other can’t.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/sep/06/new-parent-friend-children-baby-grief?CMP=fb_cif#comment-158514602

As someone with one kid and a second on the way, and some old friends / a sibling around me who don’t have kids (some who want them but haven’t found a partner, one who is struggling to conceive), I do try to be careful not to constantly talk about mine or say things like “gosh you went to the theatre then had a lie in the next day, I’m so jealous.” Even though I am very jealous. Also try to not always suggest meet ups with them at the park with baby in tow (though most meet ups do have to be like this as it’s just when I have more time to meet and gives partner valuable alone time to cook, read, be a person rather than a parent.

However, it is also legitimately hard not to sometimes talk about your kids or bring your baby along to a meet up, because when they are young, they consume your life in a way that is sometimes good and sometimes bad : exhausting!! I’d love to be able to chat to friends about the books I’m reading, the day trips I’ve been on, the exhibitions I’m going to visit, what’s going on in politics at the moment but since having a baby the time I have to do any of those things has literally shrunk by about 85%. You also do start spending a bit more time with other parents because they also care about objectively boring stuff like sleep schedules and catchment areas, and they also don’t mind hanging out in awful kid friendly cafes and soft plays.

Curious to hear views about what parents and those who want to be parents can do to accommodate each other’s lives without causing hurt.

OP posts:
Fivemoreminutesinbed · 07/09/2022 14:43

Following.

SheeWeee · 07/09/2022 14:42

Jan6755 · 07/09/2022 14:33

That's not what I meant at all.

That is what you said though, so perhaps you should rephrase

PunchyAnts · 07/09/2022 14:42

mam0918 · 07/09/2022 14:33

I had primary infertility for 3 years and secondary infertility for 10 years, which included a loss and IVF.

Basic consideration is fair (like dont make a huge deal of your pregnancy to someones face if you dont know their curcumstances) but also life doesnt magically stop people have kids and they will cross your path at some point.

I personally found secondary infertility FAR harder because having 1 child means you are forced to do all the things people with primary infertility can actively avoid.

With primary I barely ever was around kids and could avoid all that and distract myself with other stuff like holiday and nights out but with secondary I had:

  • my child asking constantly for a sibling
  • people giving opinions on my family (your too young to have more, you need to have another quick so they are close, you dont want an only child, think of the enviroment and stick to one etc...)
  • I had to take my kid to school and child friendly places and be surrounded by families/babies/pregnant women
  • the world is set for 2 kid families which is insult to injury (my DS was regularly left out of stuff for not having a sibling to join in)
  • pregnant women suddenly dont think twice about telling you (a pracrical stranger) it was an unplanned oopsie baby they hadnt wanted
  • Medical professional and random strangers call you selfish (litrally an IVF radiologist told me IVF should only be availible to those with primary, she had an attitude like we where stealing someone elses chance which is batshit) and say stupid shit like 'just adopt'

^ non of those things ever happened with primary, now granted I was younger (I assume older childless women may face more spontanious questioning about why they dont have kids) but most are very specific to secondary where as with primary no one ever really mentioned kids or assumed anything.

You've put into words a fair bit of what I found really difficult about TTC number 2. It's a different beast.

PunchyAnts · 07/09/2022 14:40

@Jan6755 A new parent who is sleep deprived, recovering from birth and struggling is not an "arsehole" for seeking support to a childless friend or relative. If your friend or relative has asked you not to because they don't feel able to support you for whatever reason and you persist, perhaps you have a point.

Baggingarea · 07/09/2022 14:39

Me and my husband struggling and I'm kind of over feeling depressed about it. I like to think I listen to friends if they are having a tough time with kids I even like spending time with baby relatives because you can have a lot of fun!

But things to avoid doing please (light-hearted):

  1. making infertility an issue. The amount of times ppl have gone "I was taking little Timmy to school and... Oh sorry!" while looking at me. Like thanks for the infertility reminder. Stop being awkward!

  2. the fake/patronising "oooh I so wish I could go do all the cool things you get to do because you are child-free". Of course parents will miss their old free lives but us non parents can tell when it's put on for our "benefit"

  3. Don't assume we want what you have or covet your life. If I could have kids they'd be well nicer than ur sprogs (joke... Ish)

  4. Don't assume we can't understand your issues. Yes having a child is life changing - but so is infertility for a lot of ppl. It makes you entirely re-evaluate life and have a deeper empathy for others.

  5. Bonus point: Yes, being a new parent is very hard but remember to be considerate of others. I walk with a stick and it's shocking the amount of ppl who make me dive out of the way with their buggies. If I can move for disabled ppl while pushing nieces & nephews, so can you!!

FirewomanSam · 07/09/2022 14:37

I can’t speak for all childless women but for me, the things that upset me most are:

  • The snarky ‘oh, that must be nice!’ comments, as you say, when I’ve done something that wouldn’t be possible if I had kids. A spontaneous meal out, trip to the cinema, mini-break or whatever. Yes, I have more time than you to do those things. I don’t feel guilty about it. Sorry. (Obviously it works both ways, though, and I would also be sensitive about talking about lots of fun evenings out with a mum-friend who was struggling with the loss of some of her own free time and social life).
  • Minimising any difficult or tiring things happening in my life by saying ‘you don’t know the meaning of tired, you don’t have kids!’ or similar. Thankfully most of my friends are lovely and usually if I’ve said ‘sorry, I know I shouldn’t complain about being tired because you have it so much worse’ they’ll reply with ‘don’t be silly, you’re allowed to be tired’.
  • Conversely (and this might well be very different for other childless women) I personally find it really upsetting when parents talk amongst themselves about their kids and then say ‘sorry Sam this must be really boring for you’. I’m your friend, your kids are the most important thing going on in your life right now. Of course I want to hear about them. Similarly, if a friend was struggling with parenthood and wanted to talk, I’d want them to feel they could talk to me. If I did find it too hard to hear about, then I’d hope I could have an honest conversation with a close friend about that.
  • People making assumptions about my situation, either that I’m not planning on having kids or that I AM planning at some point but haven’t thought to start TTC yet. No one ever seems to consider that I might actively have tried already.
  • There are also the generally thoughtless comments like the pregnant friend who’s slightly younger than me, who kept going on about how worried she was about being an ‘old’ mum and how her pregnancy was risky because she had just turned 35. She wasn’t to know that I was TTC at the time or hoping to have kids at some point, but she also had no reason to assume I wasn’t, so a little sensitivity around the subject wouldn’t have hurt.

Basically, just recognise it’s a potentially sensitive subject, have some awareness of who you’re talking to and that there can be all sorts going on that you might not be aware of, so don’t make assumptions. Communicate honestly with your friends as much as you can, and, as someone else succinctly put it, just don’t be a dick.

2000lightyearsaway123 · 07/09/2022 14:37

@Macaroni1924 no I appreciate the advice. I think that those closest to me know that this is something that makes me sad but not to the all consuming extent that it does. And to he honest these people now don't have the time to listen my problems. I generally try to work on the assumption that when they say and do insensitive things or even things that aren't really insensitive but they hurt me for whatever reason I file It away under "no bad intention". And I try my best to go to the events when I am invited or to be the most enthusiastic auntie I can be.

I still have time and I do hope to have a child on my own if needs be and that is something I'll be seriously looking into the logistics of next year.

I hope your friend finds success with her new partner 😊

mam0918 · 07/09/2022 14:33

I had primary infertility for 3 years and secondary infertility for 10 years, which included a loss and IVF.

Basic consideration is fair (like dont make a huge deal of your pregnancy to someones face if you dont know their curcumstances) but also life doesnt magically stop people have kids and they will cross your path at some point.

I personally found secondary infertility FAR harder because having 1 child means you are forced to do all the things people with primary infertility can actively avoid.

With primary I barely ever was around kids and could avoid all that and distract myself with other stuff like holiday and nights out but with secondary I had:

  • my child asking constantly for a sibling
  • people giving opinions on my family (your too young to have more, you need to have another quick so they are close, you dont want an only child, think of the enviroment and stick to one etc...)
  • I had to take my kid to school and child friendly places and be surrounded by families/babies/pregnant women
  • the world is set for 2 kid families which is insult to injury (my DS was regularly left out of stuff for not having a sibling to join in)
  • pregnant women suddenly dont think twice about telling you (a pracrical stranger) it was an unplanned oopsie baby they hadnt wanted
  • Medical professional and random strangers call you selfish (litrally an IVF radiologist told me IVF should only be availible to those with primary, she had an attitude like we where stealing someone elses chance which is batshit) and say stupid shit like 'just adopt'

^ non of those things ever happened with primary, now granted I was younger (I assume older childless women may face more spontanious questioning about why they dont have kids) but most are very specific to secondary where as with primary no one ever really mentioned kids or assumed anything.

Jan6755 · 07/09/2022 14:33

SheeWeee · 07/09/2022 14:30

It can be really hard to remember all the different ways you can be an arsehole when you are miserable and exhausted?

Excuse me? An exhausted, ill, in pain new parent is an "arsehole" for talking about it?

That's not what I meant at all.

KimberleyClark · 07/09/2022 14:33

Electricstar · 07/09/2022 14:24

AGREE!
The misconception that grief fades is not true.
Losing a pregnancy or never being a mother isn’t something you eventually get over and the grief never ends. I am speaking for most, but understand some may disagree which is 100% valid

When you are childless not by choice you do not just miss out on a baby or pregnancy, you miss out on first birthday, second birthdays etc, you miss out on doing mum things that you always thought you’d be doing, you mourn the life you thought you’d have. There is always another date that is coming up wether it’s Christmas, Mother’s Day etc which brings back memories of not having your child or not being able to have children to be with you.

I know most woman who I’ve spoken to who are childless not by choice who have accepted their new path will fully agree you never get over it - there will always be reminders

When you get beyond childbearing age you het to the stage when friends are becoming grandparents and that can be tough too.

Electricstar · 07/09/2022 14:31

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 14:16

One example I can think of that possibly isn’t covered by the “not being a dick” advice (which I agree with), is talking about how hard motherhood / parenthood is. Particularly with a new baby.

We we’re so so happy about our baby, but my wife (who had him, I’m having the second) really struggled in the first few months with the birth recovery, the cracked nipples, the night feeds, the exhaustion, the hormones etc. Similarly we’ve also had real low low points whenever we and the baby have been ill (try looking after a toddler when you both have gastro or covid and can barely stand but they have bounced right back to high energy mode). I’m pretty sure that at those times she / I will have said to friends and siblings, some of whom would like kids but haven’t got them yet and worry they never will, about how this is the hardest thing you’ve ever done or how low or exhausted you feel in that moment.

To people desperate to have kids that could seem really hurtful aka I wish I had what you had and here you are telling me how tough it is. But on the other hand - it is really tough and parents can also get vulnerable and desperately need to be able to say what a hard time they’re having to their friends and loved ones.

OP you and your wife’s feelings are completely valid too. I am sorry you have struggled, I know a lot of people struggle with a new baby and have traumatic births, illnesses etc. Your feelings matter. I mentioned this in an above post but sometimes as someone who hasn’t got children yet (hopefully one day I have a healthy pregnancy) you do feel a bit jealous when people talk of their children struggles. I feel guilty for feeling this way but I do feel pangs of jealousy when friends who are pregnant complain of morning sickness or complain of sleepless nights and tough times with their new babies. These friends are completely able to feel this way. I think it’s just after losing your babies or being childless you’d do anything to have these problems sometimes x

SheeWeee · 07/09/2022 14:30

It can be really hard to remember all the different ways you can be an arsehole when you are miserable and exhausted?

Excuse me? An exhausted, ill, in pain new parent is an "arsehole" for talking about it?

Jan6755 · 07/09/2022 14:26

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 14:16

One example I can think of that possibly isn’t covered by the “not being a dick” advice (which I agree with), is talking about how hard motherhood / parenthood is. Particularly with a new baby.

We we’re so so happy about our baby, but my wife (who had him, I’m having the second) really struggled in the first few months with the birth recovery, the cracked nipples, the night feeds, the exhaustion, the hormones etc. Similarly we’ve also had real low low points whenever we and the baby have been ill (try looking after a toddler when you both have gastro or covid and can barely stand but they have bounced right back to high energy mode). I’m pretty sure that at those times she / I will have said to friends and siblings, some of whom would like kids but haven’t got them yet and worry they never will, about how this is the hardest thing you’ve ever done or how low or exhausted you feel in that moment.

To people desperate to have kids that could seem really hurtful aka I wish I had what you had and here you are telling me how tough it is. But on the other hand - it is really tough and parents can also get vulnerable and desperately need to be able to say what a hard time they’re having to their friends and loved ones.

I mean I get this advice too, but sometimes you do say things like this, particularly when you are in the midst of it all. It can be really hard to remember all the different ways you can be an arsehole when you are miserable and exhausted?

Surely there has to be some balance of "That person isn't hurtful or vindictive, so I need not to take everything personally as well." It's about being sensitive, but it's also got to be about being accepted when you have inadvertently said something hurtful as well. Intention has to matter doesn't it?

Electricstar · 07/09/2022 14:24

Arbesque · 07/09/2022 14:12

If you lose a parent the intense grief eventually subsides onto a low level of grief that is bearable but sometimes ramps up eg on significant dates or during occasions when parents would normally be there.

I think that's what the article means. Not having a child isn't something you mourn for a couple of years and then get over. It is always a gap in your life.

AGREE!
The misconception that grief fades is not true.
Losing a pregnancy or never being a mother isn’t something you eventually get over and the grief never ends. I am speaking for most, but understand some may disagree which is 100% valid

When you are childless not by choice you do not just miss out on a baby or pregnancy, you miss out on first birthday, second birthdays etc, you miss out on doing mum things that you always thought you’d be doing, you mourn the life you thought you’d have. There is always another date that is coming up wether it’s Christmas, Mother’s Day etc which brings back memories of not having your child or not being able to have children to be with you.

I know most woman who I’ve spoken to who are childless not by choice who have accepted their new path will fully agree you never get over it - there will always be reminders

KimberleyClark · 07/09/2022 14:21

@PlumPudd it was only in the initial very raw stage of coming to terms with my childless that I couldn’t bear to hear how hard being a parent was. I had a very rose tinted view of it. I am a lot more circumspect now.

PauliesWalnuts · 07/09/2022 14:18

Spot on @Arbesque . It also makes me feel like that because I’ve not had a child that I’ve somehow failed at life.

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 14:16

SheeWeee · 07/09/2022 13:16

I'm still not seeing anything that isn't covered by "don't be a dick".

Some people are insensitive assholes. But they are insensitive assholes in general, the topic doesn't matter, and they aren't going to change anyway.

One example I can think of that possibly isn’t covered by the “not being a dick” advice (which I agree with), is talking about how hard motherhood / parenthood is. Particularly with a new baby.

We we’re so so happy about our baby, but my wife (who had him, I’m having the second) really struggled in the first few months with the birth recovery, the cracked nipples, the night feeds, the exhaustion, the hormones etc. Similarly we’ve also had real low low points whenever we and the baby have been ill (try looking after a toddler when you both have gastro or covid and can barely stand but they have bounced right back to high energy mode). I’m pretty sure that at those times she / I will have said to friends and siblings, some of whom would like kids but haven’t got them yet and worry they never will, about how this is the hardest thing you’ve ever done or how low or exhausted you feel in that moment.

To people desperate to have kids that could seem really hurtful aka I wish I had what you had and here you are telling me how tough it is. But on the other hand - it is really tough and parents can also get vulnerable and desperately need to be able to say what a hard time they’re having to their friends and loved ones.

OP posts:
SheeWeee · 07/09/2022 14:15

PurpleDaisies · 07/09/2022 14:04

I think this is why it is best for friends to be able to tell each other how they are feeling inside

Which is exactly what the article says. I wonder if many posters actually read it before assuming this was some campaign from the Barrens trying to get a taboo put on all mention of children.

Is there really any need for that?

People talking about their feelings with their friends is hardly novel or somehting we need to be told to do, is it?

Arbesque · 07/09/2022 14:12

Jan6755 · 07/09/2022 14:09

So I read the article again, and I am trying to understand this, and it sounds very, very hard. I understand that it is a form of grief, to understand and recognise that you will not be able to have child for whatever reason. I completely get that, I do. But the article kind of hints that this grief lasts a very long time? I am really trying not to be like an elephant in a china shop here, but I suppose I believe any type of grief that goes on too long can be problematic to the person experiencing it. Is that healthy to be treated as though you are in a period of grief for decades?

I can understand about being sensitive for decades, I am asking specifically about this feeling of grief.

If you lose a parent the intense grief eventually subsides onto a low level of grief that is bearable but sometimes ramps up eg on significant dates or during occasions when parents would normally be there.

I think that's what the article means. Not having a child isn't something you mourn for a couple of years and then get over. It is always a gap in your life.

Jan6755 · 07/09/2022 14:09

So I read the article again, and I am trying to understand this, and it sounds very, very hard. I understand that it is a form of grief, to understand and recognise that you will not be able to have child for whatever reason. I completely get that, I do. But the article kind of hints that this grief lasts a very long time? I am really trying not to be like an elephant in a china shop here, but I suppose I believe any type of grief that goes on too long can be problematic to the person experiencing it. Is that healthy to be treated as though you are in a period of grief for decades?

I can understand about being sensitive for decades, I am asking specifically about this feeling of grief.

PurpleDaisies · 07/09/2022 14:04

I think this is why it is best for friends to be able to tell each other how they are feeling inside

Which is exactly what the article says. I wonder if many posters actually read it before assuming this was some campaign from the Barrens trying to get a taboo put on all mention of children.

Electricstar · 07/09/2022 14:02

SheeWeee · 07/09/2022 13:57

You're not getting it. Highlighting it to WHO? The people who will listen to you are not the ones making the comments.

But there is the point of who decides a comment is stupid or insensitive? Of course, some are obvious. But a women commenting about what she did on Mothers day to a good friend, is that stupid/insensitive to a childless/free friend? Or is just normal conversation between friends?
It's not so simple, is it?

@SheeWeee I think this is why it is best for friends to be able to tell each other how they are feeling inside. My friends are early years teachers and after my miscarriage I asked them if it was OK if we didn’t talk about their jobs too much when we met (they go on for ages about it - obviously, understandable it’s their jobs and they all do the same thing) some people don’t mean to me insensitive at all which is why I think it’s best to just say “I can’t talk about this today”

Arbesque · 07/09/2022 14:02

SheeWeee · 07/09/2022 13:57

You're not getting it. Highlighting it to WHO? The people who will listen to you are not the ones making the comments.

But there is the point of who decides a comment is stupid or insensitive? Of course, some are obvious. But a women commenting about what she did on Mothers day to a good friend, is that stupid/insensitive to a childless/free friend? Or is just normal conversation between friends?
It's not so simple, is it?

You're not getting it. I am highlighting it to people on here who may have made thoughtless comments across the years, unaware of the affect it was having, and willing to change their behaviour.
Or are you saying such people don't exist?

Coastalcreeksider · 07/09/2022 14:00

I meet up with my three oldest friends from time to time, they are all grandparents now and mid 60s. I can't contribute to a lot of the conversation as I don't have kids but I always find it quite funny when they want to know how my cat is. 😂

KimberleyClark · 07/09/2022 13:57

Stopandlook · 07/09/2022 13:50

www.anniekirby.com/blog/grief-comes-in-different-colours

This gives a glimpse into how your friend may feel at times. I don’t know the answer, but understanding the pain that childless not through choice women may help 💐

Thanks for sharing this, it is spot on.