Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents not upsetting people who can’t have kids

238 replies

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 10:40

Read this article in the Guardian with interest, about the need for people with kids to be very conscious of the pain people without kids around them might be feeling, and how friendships can break up when one person is able to have kids and the other can’t.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/sep/06/new-parent-friend-children-baby-grief?CMP=fb_cif#comment-158514602

As someone with one kid and a second on the way, and some old friends / a sibling around me who don’t have kids (some who want them but haven’t found a partner, one who is struggling to conceive), I do try to be careful not to constantly talk about mine or say things like “gosh you went to the theatre then had a lie in the next day, I’m so jealous.” Even though I am very jealous. Also try to not always suggest meet ups with them at the park with baby in tow (though most meet ups do have to be like this as it’s just when I have more time to meet and gives partner valuable alone time to cook, read, be a person rather than a parent.

However, it is also legitimately hard not to sometimes talk about your kids or bring your baby along to a meet up, because when they are young, they consume your life in a way that is sometimes good and sometimes bad : exhausting!! I’d love to be able to chat to friends about the books I’m reading, the day trips I’ve been on, the exhibitions I’m going to visit, what’s going on in politics at the moment but since having a baby the time I have to do any of those things has literally shrunk by about 85%. You also do start spending a bit more time with other parents because they also care about objectively boring stuff like sleep schedules and catchment areas, and they also don’t mind hanging out in awful kid friendly cafes and soft plays.

Curious to hear views about what parents and those who want to be parents can do to accommodate each other’s lives without causing hurt.

OP posts:
DobbyHasASock · 07/09/2022 16:52

I am not the same person.

I am saying both are a loss and you don't get to minimise someone else's grief.

SheeWeee · 07/09/2022 16:51

PurplePansy05 · 07/09/2022 16:49

And here is the thing. This deeply offends me because you have a child - and three of mine are dead. You cannot compare this. These situations aren't comparable, it's literally life or death.

I walked in these shoes for a long time before having my child and believe me, I would have died to be a mother to a living child, even if this came with challenges you are describing.

I don't walk in your shoes, but you clearly don't walk in mine either. Your post is the insensitive one here. It may well come across ungrateful that you have a child to those who can't, to be blunt. And accusatory in tone as if I was minimising your experience and difficulties. I am not, but do not ever compare this to having your child die because you're tone deaf and beyond offensive.

I find your post pretty offensive as well. It's not top trumps, you don't get to tell others that your pain is worse than theirs, that's not how life works.

PurplePansy05 · 07/09/2022 16:49

DobbyHasASock · 07/09/2022 16:32

What an insensitive thing to say to a parent of a child with a disability. A parent, if they have a life altering difference may have had to make huge sacrifices and had their life changed forever.
Maybe practise what you preach. A lifetime of dealing with disability is a form of grief and a lonely path.

And here is the thing. This deeply offends me because you have a child - and three of mine are dead. You cannot compare this. These situations aren't comparable, it's literally life or death.

I walked in these shoes for a long time before having my child and believe me, I would have died to be a mother to a living child, even if this came with challenges you are describing.

I don't walk in your shoes, but you clearly don't walk in mine either. Your post is the insensitive one here. It may well come across ungrateful that you have a child to those who can't, to be blunt. And accusatory in tone as if I was minimising your experience and difficulties. I am not, but do not ever compare this to having your child die because you're tone deaf and beyond offensive.

mumofgirl1 · 07/09/2022 16:42

I struggled to conceive for 10yrs couldn't have ivf as partner has a daughter to a previously relationship. My friend popped kids out for fun (6 kids) it never bothered me being around her and the kids what bothered me the most was the questions of when are you going to have kids, your getting older now your body clock is ticking , my kids are the best thing that ever happened to me. I'd brush it off with well I don't want kids, because I could be doing with the pitty party that would come after I'd told them we was trying but with no success. These are the things that people need to stop saying. Luckily for me after giving up trying and coming to terms with the fact I wasn't meant to be a mum we managed to naturally conceive are beautiful daughter at the age of 36. But if someone's not got kids by a certain age don't feel the need to lecture them how they should start thinking about having kids. That stuff cuts with a knife when you've been trying for years.

DobbyHasASock · 07/09/2022 16:32

PurplePansy05 · 07/09/2022 16:12

It's the same for anyone with a difference.

Respectfully, there is no way you can compare having a child with a disability to someone having a child dying in pregnancy or at/post-birth. There is just no way. Life and death is not that kind of difference, ever. And this doesn't take away from your hardship and struggle. You can't compare your situation to a long struggle to have a child in the first place and being left with empty arms either. These things do not belong to the same category of "people with a difference", no.

What an insensitive thing to say to a parent of a child with a disability. A parent, if they have a life altering difference may have had to make huge sacrifices and had their life changed forever.
Maybe practise what you preach. A lifetime of dealing with disability is a form of grief and a lonely path.

PurplePansy05 · 07/09/2022 16:12

It's the same for anyone with a difference.

Respectfully, there is no way you can compare having a child with a disability to someone having a child dying in pregnancy or at/post-birth. There is just no way. Life and death is not that kind of difference, ever. And this doesn't take away from your hardship and struggle. You can't compare your situation to a long struggle to have a child in the first place and being left with empty arms either. These things do not belong to the same category of "people with a difference", no.

PurpleDaisies · 07/09/2022 16:10

I give up.

Johnnysgirl · 07/09/2022 16:09

PurpleDaisies · 07/09/2022 16:09

You really can’t see it from my posts and the op’s responses?

Honestly this place sometimes drives me mad.

No.

PurpleDaisies · 07/09/2022 16:09

Johnnysgirl · 07/09/2022 16:05

Why do you feel you're due an apology?

You really can’t see it from my posts and the op’s responses?

Honestly this place sometimes drives me mad.

KimberleyClark · 07/09/2022 16:07

I also had many moments of silently resenting friends who were able to just have sex and get pregnant, and who didn’t have to save, then go though invasive medical procedures many of which failed.

so did I. I so envied people who could go to bed with their nice warm partners, have a lovely time and just let nature take its majestic course while I was having to have loads of injections and blood tests and invasive internal scans. Seemed so unfair.

Johnnysgirl · 07/09/2022 16:05

PurpleDaisies · 07/09/2022 16:02

Fair enough, sorry if it hurt, perhaps any kind of lighthearted remark isn’t right for this topic. I’m not trying at argue that you are wrong, just that I didn’t mean what you were saying I meant aka “you’re lucky not to have to have gastro”. It was just meant as a comment about the awfulness of gastro, nothing more.

When I called you out on it, you didn’t apologise. You continued to explain what having had to meant for you with no hint that what you’d said was wrong.

I hope you’re sincere in realising lighthearted wasn’t right. This reads like a non apology apology though .

Why do you feel you're due an apology?

Chloefairydust · 07/09/2022 16:03

This is such a good thread, and it’s so nice that your thinking of ways to be sensitive to your friends feelings OP.

As a childfree person I would say don’t feel you have to avoid your friends/ family without children. When my brother and his ex had theirs I loved being around them and still do. Your friends may like to interact with your children as a sort of ‘auntie’ figure in their lives too. The only thing I would say is just avoid insensitive comments (which I’m sure you would anyway) . Things like “when are you having your babies?” Ect can be really awkward questions. Or not validating their feelings, like if they say they are feeling tired, saying “you don’t know what it is to be tired till you have kids” or assuming that your childfree friend and their spouse isn’t a family because they don’t have children. But don’t feel like you can’t talk about your children to them, or have to shield them from your children.

PurpleDaisies · 07/09/2022 16:02

Fair enough, sorry if it hurt, perhaps any kind of lighthearted remark isn’t right for this topic. I’m not trying at argue that you are wrong, just that I didn’t mean what you were saying I meant aka “you’re lucky not to have to have gastro”. It was just meant as a comment about the awfulness of gastro, nothing more.

When I called you out on it, you didn’t apologise. You continued to explain what having had to meant for you with no hint that what you’d said was wrong.

I hope you’re sincere in realising lighthearted wasn’t right. This reads like a non apology apology though .

tootiredtoocare · 07/09/2022 15:54

It's the same for anyone with a difference. I have a disabled child, and as anyone else who has will tell you, we quickly grow a thick skin. If I got hurt at every comment my friends make celebrating the achievements of their non-disabled children (achievements my child won't ever get close to) I'd spend my whole life crying. My child being disabled doesn't mean I can't be happy for people with normal kids who are doing really well, or even who just aren't doing badly. I can't expect every parent, or every person, to understand what it's like to raise a disabled child, so nor can I expect them never to unwittingly say something that might sting.

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 15:48

Ylvamoon · 07/09/2022 15:27

This thread is an other example where women (especially mothers) have to give up their own identity and be ever so careful, mindful sensitive and walk on tip toes in order to please others.

No it’s not @Ylvamoon. I started this thread because I was interested in hearing people’s views from all perspectives about coping with an issue that is very hard to understand unless you’ve experienced it. There are umpteen million threads about motherhood elsewhere on mumsnet. This one is about how people with kids and people who want them can relate to and support each other. If you feel silenced by people on here sharing what upsets them and what doesn’t (clearly it’s often highly personal as there have been plenty of people here saying they struggle with infertility and either love or hate to hear about other peoples children). Then you can start a different thread

OP posts:
megosaurusrex · 07/09/2022 15:46

We struggled for years to conceive, then DH was diagnosed with azoospermia. He literally had a 0% sperm count, and had to have a sperm retrieval, which we were told he had a 50% chance of them finding any. Luckily they did.
We were then left in this sort of limbo for what felt like an eternity, waiting for NHS appointments, dealing with cancellations due to Covid, etc. I don't have the words to describe how upsetting and anxiety provoking all this was. I was crying at pregnancy announcements, crying myself to sleep some nights, that sort of thing.
We decided to do IVF privately and were lucky enough to be successful first time round, DS is 15 months now. We also have a spare embryo we will try again with in future.
It's easy to forget the horrendous emotional strain of it all now. My heart goes out to anyone struggling in this way.

Arbesque · 07/09/2022 15:44

Ylvamoon · 07/09/2022 15:27

This thread is an other example where women (especially mothers) have to give up their own identity and be ever so careful, mindful sensitive and walk on tip toes in order to please others.

I am actually lost for words 😮

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 15:43

BadNomad · 07/09/2022 15:29

Yes, but you still said it...you made a joke...in front of women who are struggling with infertility, on a thread specifically about people needing to show more sensitivity around childlessness.

Fair enough, sorry if it hurt, perhaps any kind of lighthearted remark isn’t right for this topic. I’m not trying at argue that you are wrong, just that I didn’t mean what you were saying I meant aka “you’re lucky not to have to have gastro”. It was just meant as a comment about the awfulness of gastro, nothing more.

I did actually start this thread, specifically to ask what people’s views were, and I did struggle with infertility before getting pregnant myself, as well as my wife and I having to save for years to be able to afford to pay for fertility treatment, because we’re gay and the NHS didn’t (until about a month ago) fund anything for female female couples, until you had already paid for six rounds of IUI at a private clinic yourself, and bought your own sperm. Something which costs about twelve grand all together. I also had many moments of silently resenting friends who were able to just have sex and get pregnant, and who didn’t have to save, then go though invasive medical procedures many of which failed.

OP posts:
PurplePansy05 · 07/09/2022 15:38

Ylvamoon · 07/09/2022 15:27

This thread is an other example where women (especially mothers) have to give up their own identity and be ever so careful, mindful sensitive and walk on tip toes in order to please others.

Slow clap.

No. This thread is to show people like you that others can be empathetic. I say this as a mother. A mother to a living child and those that I lost. Nothing to fucking do with being a mother and losing identity. I wish you could at least pretend to be polite, if kind is too much, instead of posting this.

LadybirdsAreNeverHappy · 07/09/2022 15:33

“It’s as if you are pressing your nose against the sweet-shop window of life, and you’re never ever going to be on the other side.”
**
“How do you say to someone “I desperately want what you have” without making them feel uncomfortable?”

Every adult with half a brain knows that parenthood is not like a sweet shop whether they have kids or not.
And nobody says I desperately want what you have to a woman in a psychiatric ward, suicidal with PND or parents struggling with a child with severe disabilities.
This is somebody with a very immature, idealised notion of parenthood who probably spends way too much time looking at photos on SM and ignoring the reality of parenthood IRL.
This is a grown woman who uses a phrase like “friendship apocalypse “ seriously.
She sounds like a fourteen year old.
I don’t have a social group of female friends who are all becoming mothers all at the one time but my sister and her dh have been struggling to conceive for a long time and I try my best to be sensitive to them.
I’ve had a hard time adjusting to motherhood and I’m unlikely to be making it seem like a trip to the sweet shop anyway. The same sister once said to me when I was struggling with mh problems and a newborn “thanks a lot. You have put me right off having kids with all your crying and moaning about it “.
Insensitivity goes both ways. It is also insensitive to compare an idealised version of hypothetical motherhood to somebody else’s reality and make them feel like shit about themselves.
It is generally not deliberately insensitive to simply talk about your kids or complain that your tired or whatever.
Most people who want kids and can’t have them would not take this attitude and I hope most people with kids would be sensitive to anyone they knew who’s struggling to conceive or had to accept childlessness because it is the non-dickhead thing to do. They shouldn’t need reminding.
Infertility is hard. Parenthood can also be very hard. There’s no point in comparing the two.

PurplePansy05 · 07/09/2022 15:33

OP, you're right, parenting is hard. BUT one only understands this perception when ones becomes a parent. So the thing is, any (completely justified) moans about it to people who are struggling openly or in silence may well be hurtful to them. I moan to fellow mums who are not TTC or done with kids, or on here, on suitable threads. It IS hard and there's no point in minimising.

But looking back, when I was dying to become a parent, the pain and grief of that was of a very different kind and incomparably harder to carry every day. Again, this is why I'm selective about who I talk to.

In fact, the grief never went away and it's often the case rainbow parents deal with a double whammy of grief and the usual parenting struggles, not easy to navigate either.

FirewomanSam · 07/09/2022 15:32

Be reasonable. Everyone has their own shit. Everyone is dealing with something. Of course some people are going to say things to you that you find offensive or insensitive, but I guarantee you have said things that others find offensive or insensitive.

That we can both agree on! No arguments here on any of those points.

The thread was asking what kinds of things childless people might find hurtful or upsetting so I answered honestly. I didn’t say my friend was awful for her comments or that I’ve cut her off as a friend because of it or that she should walk on eggshells around me forever more or that I’ll never forgive her. I also didn’t say I’ve never said anything that’s ever offended her or anyone else. I just gave an example of a comment that irked me. If that makes me unreasonable then so be it.

APoll16 · 07/09/2022 15:32

I have 2 children but also struggled with infertility for many years. From my perspective, I can say with absolutely clarity that parenting young children is exhausting, overwhelming and at times all-consuming but that it doesn’t compare with the heartbreak, pain and utter loneliness of not being able to conceive. I mean this in a kind way - if you can’t imagine what it’s like not to be able to have children that you desperately want, you are ever so lucky.

It is entirely possible for people who can’t conceive to love your children, want to see them and be part of their lives etc. while also feeling sad for themselves. If they’re friendships you really value, you should (IMO) make time to spend with those people, without your children, without making them feel bad about it - not every time, but sometimes.

Electricstar · 07/09/2022 15:32

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 14:46

And I can also completely understand how, if you don’t have kids but want them, you probably will be sat there as your friend talks about how hard it is, with a little bit of you thinking “I’d take your cracked nipples and exhaustion if I got a baby along with them and be happy about it.” Expect for the gastro, nobody would willingly take the gastro!!

I guess as another poster said, some of it has got to come down to trying to remember that even if someone may occasionally say something that is hurting your feelings (and this could go either way, because if a childless friend asked you ti stop gushing about your new baby, or never asked a question about them that could also feel hurtful) they probably don’t know they are doing it or mean it that way, and if the hurt is too much you can always just say it’s a bit of a sensitive topic and ask if you talk about something else for a while. And if they don’t take the hint or continue after this has been said, you can chalk it up to them being a dick and back away from the friendship for a bit.

@PlumPudd Yes definitely myself and my best friend were pregnant at the same time and I lost my pregnancy and she’s due on my twins due date. Let’s be honest she’s got the better deal, her baby is healthy and she’s getting the nursery ready whilst I’m grieving. But you are right, I know she misses me and hurts not being able to talk to me.

Its good to understand that everyone has valid feelings. Of course I’d rather go through the sickness etc to have a baby but that doesn’t mean my friends have to love their sickness because I lost my pregnancy if that makes sense. It works for everything, I’m married and live with DH and my best friend is single and wishes she had someone. She’d probably rather the wedding stress I had and the odd arguments with DH than be single when it’s something she wants desperately. But my own stresses are still valid x

PurpleDaisies · 07/09/2022 15:31

BadNomad · 07/09/2022 15:12

But it's that kind of comment people are saying is insensitive. It's implying the childless person is lucky because they didn't have to go through that. Whereas someone who wants a child would give anything to go through that hell. It's like saying to someone after a miscarriage, "at least you won't have to go through the pain of childbirth".

Somebody has told me that.

Any sentence that starts with “at least” needs to end before it gets said out loud.

@PlumPudd you have absolute no idea what women struggling with infertility would put themselves through to end up with a living baby. I am really surprised you’re continuing to argue your point. I’m sure your pregnancy was awful. I genuinely mean it that I would swap places with you without a second thought.

Swipe left for the next trending thread