Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents not upsetting people who can’t have kids

238 replies

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 10:40

Read this article in the Guardian with interest, about the need for people with kids to be very conscious of the pain people without kids around them might be feeling, and how friendships can break up when one person is able to have kids and the other can’t.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/sep/06/new-parent-friend-children-baby-grief?CMP=fb_cif#comment-158514602

As someone with one kid and a second on the way, and some old friends / a sibling around me who don’t have kids (some who want them but haven’t found a partner, one who is struggling to conceive), I do try to be careful not to constantly talk about mine or say things like “gosh you went to the theatre then had a lie in the next day, I’m so jealous.” Even though I am very jealous. Also try to not always suggest meet ups with them at the park with baby in tow (though most meet ups do have to be like this as it’s just when I have more time to meet and gives partner valuable alone time to cook, read, be a person rather than a parent.

However, it is also legitimately hard not to sometimes talk about your kids or bring your baby along to a meet up, because when they are young, they consume your life in a way that is sometimes good and sometimes bad : exhausting!! I’d love to be able to chat to friends about the books I’m reading, the day trips I’ve been on, the exhibitions I’m going to visit, what’s going on in politics at the moment but since having a baby the time I have to do any of those things has literally shrunk by about 85%. You also do start spending a bit more time with other parents because they also care about objectively boring stuff like sleep schedules and catchment areas, and they also don’t mind hanging out in awful kid friendly cafes and soft plays.

Curious to hear views about what parents and those who want to be parents can do to accommodate each other’s lives without causing hurt.

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 08/09/2022 08:17

I didn’t begrudge people having children either. I was happy for them but sad for myself. It was also difficult when friends and family got pregnant for the second, third, even fourth time when I had not managed to conceive once.

Starlightstarbright1 · 08/09/2022 08:09

Underanothersky · 07/09/2022 11:27

I think this is ridiculous. I thought I was infertile for twenty years, and yes I grieved that but I didn't begrudge other people having children or spending time around children.

This was me..i actively tried for 7 years before conceiving..

I talked about my child a lot as a Lp from when my ds was 10 months old.. i had virtually nothing else going on in my world

Arbesque · 08/09/2022 07:55

rainbowmilk · 07/09/2022 22:40

I had ti give up my chance of having children to save my life - and then nearly died after the surgery. I was 32. I went back to work and apparently my colleagues had all been gossiping about this, but when I confirmed that yes I had really nearly died and children were not part of my future now, one colleague blurred out, “I’d rather have died than be unable to have my three.”

She was mortified - but she was supported in what she’d said by a room full of other mums, who said that she’d only said what any mother would choose.

I’ve lost so many friends over the years to low-level thoughtlessness, once they became parents and entered into the cult of motherhood. I didn’t blame any of them in particular but I do think being a mum confers a special status, and it was like all of these previously fab, interesting people became obsessed with the minutiae of domestic tedium whilst telling me it was the best thing in the world, that I didn’t understand, and that they couldn’t see how they’d ever cared about the silly things that occupied their childless life.

I also haven’t had a single Christmas off in seven years. I’m currently lobbying to get this one off and the parents I work with are acting like I’m King fucking Herod.

I know it’s not a war, it’s not us vs them, and that not every mum is like this, but all I can say is that my life has been infinitely improved by cutting every single mum out of it (including my own, but that’s another story). And I don’t apologise for that.

I can understand someone blurting out something stupid and being mortified. But for your colleagues to back her up. That's pretty shocking.
Are they the same ones hogging the Christmas leave every year?

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 22:56

rainbowmilk · 07/09/2022 22:40

I had ti give up my chance of having children to save my life - and then nearly died after the surgery. I was 32. I went back to work and apparently my colleagues had all been gossiping about this, but when I confirmed that yes I had really nearly died and children were not part of my future now, one colleague blurred out, “I’d rather have died than be unable to have my three.”

She was mortified - but she was supported in what she’d said by a room full of other mums, who said that she’d only said what any mother would choose.

I’ve lost so many friends over the years to low-level thoughtlessness, once they became parents and entered into the cult of motherhood. I didn’t blame any of them in particular but I do think being a mum confers a special status, and it was like all of these previously fab, interesting people became obsessed with the minutiae of domestic tedium whilst telling me it was the best thing in the world, that I didn’t understand, and that they couldn’t see how they’d ever cared about the silly things that occupied their childless life.

I also haven’t had a single Christmas off in seven years. I’m currently lobbying to get this one off and the parents I work with are acting like I’m King fucking Herod.

I know it’s not a war, it’s not us vs them, and that not every mum is like this, but all I can say is that my life has been infinitely improved by cutting every single mum out of it (including my own, but that’s another story). And I don’t apologise for that.

I’d rather have died than be unable to have my three.”

Wow what a see you next Tuesday! She should have got some sort of disciplinary for that, what a cow.

The cutting out thing is a difficult one. I had a friend who more or less cut contact with me right after we told her my wife was pregnant. We’d been really close for a good seven years and suddenly nothing, no replies to texts or hellos for months. Eventually one message after I left her a couple of missed calls asking if she was safe and okay and had I done something to upset her, where she more or less denied anything had changed between us and just said of course she was fine and why was I being weird. After that I took the hint and just left it in her court, but I was pretty hurt that someone I’d regarded as a very close friend just cut me out without any explanation. I think if she’d said, it’s the child thing, I just can’t be around people who have them, I’d have been upset still to lose her but would have understood. But going from really close to nothing with no explanation did hurt and made me feel like a fool, as though I was this keen idiot who had spent years thinking she was my good friend and she’d never much cared about me - probably not the case but that was the feeling. It might not have been the kid announcement but based on a few things she’d said before I think it probably was. I hope it helped her, but I still miss her.

OP posts:
rainbowmilk · 07/09/2022 22:40

I had ti give up my chance of having children to save my life - and then nearly died after the surgery. I was 32. I went back to work and apparently my colleagues had all been gossiping about this, but when I confirmed that yes I had really nearly died and children were not part of my future now, one colleague blurred out, “I’d rather have died than be unable to have my three.”

She was mortified - but she was supported in what she’d said by a room full of other mums, who said that she’d only said what any mother would choose.

I’ve lost so many friends over the years to low-level thoughtlessness, once they became parents and entered into the cult of motherhood. I didn’t blame any of them in particular but I do think being a mum confers a special status, and it was like all of these previously fab, interesting people became obsessed with the minutiae of domestic tedium whilst telling me it was the best thing in the world, that I didn’t understand, and that they couldn’t see how they’d ever cared about the silly things that occupied their childless life.

I also haven’t had a single Christmas off in seven years. I’m currently lobbying to get this one off and the parents I work with are acting like I’m King fucking Herod.

I know it’s not a war, it’s not us vs them, and that not every mum is like this, but all I can say is that my life has been infinitely improved by cutting every single mum out of it (including my own, but that’s another story). And I don’t apologise for that.

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 22:09

Seasprayandsunshine · 07/09/2022 21:01

with all respect - it is impossible for you to understand the feeling of desperately wanting a life with children in it and having to attempt to come to terms with you may never have it.
so the annoying and frustrating parts of parenthood to you are the biggest desires of someone who can’t have children.
it hurts to the core when you casually moan about lack of sleep, some childless people would kill for it.
I speak on behalf of the previously infertile, 6 years I suffered before I had my miracle baby. For 6 years it consumed me, my body was broken, my life path had to be re thought - who was this person without children? I abandoned some of my best friends as it physically hurt me to see her living the life I would never have. Would my husband leave me, would I die alone? My friends wouldn’t include me anymore. The disappointment that my parents would never have grandchildren. know this all sounds dramatic - but it’s accurate.

so, from my perspective. Just understand and show that you are grateful for what you have. It’s not guaranteed for anybody. You are extremely fortunate to have your children and to have a body that allows you to easily make a family.
Complaining about your children/pregnancy/birth is a no go (I know you likely have valid reasons but know your audience) and mix it up. Yes, suffer the pain for 20 minutes to do an adult cafe. Choose a child activity that you can maybe take one eye off for at least 10 minutes. Get a babysitter for a meal/drinks out - and don’t talk about your kids.
I know it’s hard, but just trying to give a little of the non mum version of you occasionally will be appreciated more than you could imagine.

Which I completely get and if I knew I was with someone who was actively battling infertility and / or desperately desperately wanted children but couldn’t have them I would do most of the things you’re suggesting @Seasprayandsunshine and would hope most people would too.

I suppose the friends I was more thinking of in my original post are probably more in the - I’d like kids but haven’t found someone yet and worry sometimes that I might not - camp. Or in the, we’ve been trying to conceive for a bit and I’m slightly worried we might have to try alternative routes if something doesn’t happen soon, camp. And with them, I’d probably go for something a bit more mixed. Like sometimes inviting them to hang out at the park with the kid, but sometimes leaving the kid at home and doing something just with them. Having a bit of a grumble about the tough times when you’re just over your third awful cold / teething episode of the month and can barely keep your eyes open, and sometimes not talking about kids at all. And probably also trusting them to tell me if they were feeling worse than I thought and needed me to change the subject. Because they are dear friends / family.

I know splitting people into those categories is an oversimplification because I’m sure there will be people who are childless through lack of opportunity, who feel just as heartbroken as people who are medically infertile and have gone through years of IVF or similar. I know one friend who would have loved kids but didn’t find someone in time, finds it quite a struggle to be around her boss who has a husband and is going through IVF, talks a lot about how bereft she is and asks my friend to pick up her work whenever she has to go off for treatment or if she’s having a sad day, and just assumes my friend will be fine with it and work overtime or cancel her plans. Think my friend finds this woman’s big display of emotion and assumption that everyone will understand and grant her leeway / support her because she’s going through treatment a bit galling, when she doesn’t get any similar understanding or support.

OP posts:
Seasprayandsunshine · 07/09/2022 21:01

with all respect - it is impossible for you to understand the feeling of desperately wanting a life with children in it and having to attempt to come to terms with you may never have it.
so the annoying and frustrating parts of parenthood to you are the biggest desires of someone who can’t have children.
it hurts to the core when you casually moan about lack of sleep, some childless people would kill for it.
I speak on behalf of the previously infertile, 6 years I suffered before I had my miracle baby. For 6 years it consumed me, my body was broken, my life path had to be re thought - who was this person without children? I abandoned some of my best friends as it physically hurt me to see her living the life I would never have. Would my husband leave me, would I die alone? My friends wouldn’t include me anymore. The disappointment that my parents would never have grandchildren. know this all sounds dramatic - but it’s accurate.

so, from my perspective. Just understand and show that you are grateful for what you have. It’s not guaranteed for anybody. You are extremely fortunate to have your children and to have a body that allows you to easily make a family.
Complaining about your children/pregnancy/birth is a no go (I know you likely have valid reasons but know your audience) and mix it up. Yes, suffer the pain for 20 minutes to do an adult cafe. Choose a child activity that you can maybe take one eye off for at least 10 minutes. Get a babysitter for a meal/drinks out - and don’t talk about your kids.
I know it’s hard, but just trying to give a little of the non mum version of you occasionally will be appreciated more than you could imagine.

notanothertakeaway · 07/09/2022 20:34

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 07/09/2022 11:22

I can't have children and would love them. My sister gave birth two weeks ago to her first child and I'm struggling. I've bought my nephew presents, sent flowers, done everything I can possibly do but all my Mum now talks about is my nephew. My sister keeps on telling me I can't possibly understand how tired she is and I'm so lucky not to be able to go through it.

I don't avoid activities with children, I won't avoid my nephew and I love him and will spoil him but it still hurts. It hurts to be told I'll never understand a love between a child and his mother and it does hurt to be told that I can take my nephew out to places when he's older so I get to experience these things.

I get that they consume your life OP and you're jealous sometimes of your childless friends who can just go to the theatre and have a lie in the next day but it was your choice to have children, it's not always someones choice not to have children.

@WhenISnappedAndFarted That sounds tough. I hope it gets easier for you

Speedweed · 07/09/2022 20:15

verbalinfusion.wordpress.com/2017/06/02/lifting-the-crushing-weight-of-infertility-with-a-little-help-from-sisyphus/

This cartoon sets out what it feels like.

I found the worst thing was not people talking about their children, but when they made patronising comparisons - usually statements which begin 'You're so lucky you can...' or 'I wish I could...', usually followed by something insignificant like read a book, lie in etc.

VestaTilley · 07/09/2022 19:35

I think people need to grow up, stop being so over sensitive and stop thinking the whole world revolves around themselves. It’s just common sense - if you know a friend is having IVF or has had miscarriages, don’t talk about your baby lots or invite them to coffee at a soft play cafe.

Likewise, if you are struggling try to remember your friend who is a mother might be going through PND, relationship problems or insanity inducing sleep deprivation, and not to take personally any minor comment about how hard parenting is.

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 07/09/2022 19:35

Even those getting pregnant through IVF are allowed to complain without comments of implied ungratefulness.

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 07/09/2022 19:08

BadNomad · 07/09/2022 15:04

Are you saying your baby wasn't worth it?

Would you say this to expectant mums who experience HG (severe morning sickness)?

What an odd comment to say and this from someone who has two IVF children.

RedWingBoots · 07/09/2022 18:30

@HotWashCycle your SILs would have stronger relationships with their own siblings so it was up to your brothers to ensure that their children spent time with you. The fact your brothers didn't do that e.g. ensure their sibling had a good relationship with their children shows what kind of brothers you have.

I had my child late, and my brothers who are older had absolutely no problem inviting me over to spend time with their children when I was childless.

Anyway if you have any assets make sure you write a will to leave it to people - whether they are friends or other less close relations - who have treated you with dignity over the years. This means don't leave it to your brothers and their children.

Ticksallboxes · 07/09/2022 18:29

My sister can't conceive for medical reasons, but she's very lucky as she seems to have a London tribe of women friends who chose not to have children.

She and they all work in the film and music industry - it's so competitive and London is so expensive, but so alluring, that these women just weren't prepared to risk giving it up, and decided they'd rather keep going and be the best they could.

She's an amazing auntie and we and our teens love her visits and hearing about her international lifestyle and experiencing her ridiculous energy and enthusiasm.

She's also beautifully dressed and groomed (and a size 8). I feel about 70 in comparison!

HotWashCycle · 07/09/2022 18:19

I don't have DC but my brothers both do. They don't know the reasons why I don't. I so wanted to be an aunt to their DC but in both cases their wives held me at arms length because I don't have DC for their kids to be cousins with. The two SILs both had plenty of siblings who also had children, and I was more or less ignored. So it was doubly painful - no DC of my own, and made to feel outside their kid-centred worlds. I did not really get to have a close relationship with my nephews and niece as they grew up. On one occasion I was told quite bluntly by SIL that her DC would prefer not to come to me for an outing but to her sister and sister's DC. Maybe my SILs just assumed I would not be interested in their DC, or perhaps they just didn't bother with me as I could not contribute anything child-related. Either way it was and is really painful.

I don't think it is even personal, just completely thoughtless and insensitive.

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 17:42

Chloefairydust · 07/09/2022 16:03

This is such a good thread, and it’s so nice that your thinking of ways to be sensitive to your friends feelings OP.

As a childfree person I would say don’t feel you have to avoid your friends/ family without children. When my brother and his ex had theirs I loved being around them and still do. Your friends may like to interact with your children as a sort of ‘auntie’ figure in their lives too. The only thing I would say is just avoid insensitive comments (which I’m sure you would anyway) . Things like “when are you having your babies?” Ect can be really awkward questions. Or not validating their feelings, like if they say they are feeling tired, saying “you don’t know what it is to be tired till you have kids” or assuming that your childfree friend and their spouse isn’t a family because they don’t have children. But don’t feel like you can’t talk about your children to them, or have to shield them from your children.

@Chloefairydust, just thought it was an interesting article and wondered what others thought about the topic. Despite the fact that it hasn’t been straightforward for me and partner to have our kid or get pregnant, the fact that we have has made me doubly conscious of the people around me who don’t have kids and might want them and how they might be feeling.

So much of life seems to be down to blind randomly assigned luck. Like whether you find a partner or not, which has wide ranging impacts outside of the obvious. Lots of single friends for example feel they will never be able to afford a flat or house of their own without a partner to share a mortgage with and will forever feel without a secure home, no matter how hard they work or what they do.

Life is random and unfair.

OP posts:
XjustagirlX · 07/09/2022 17:37

I have suffered with infertility for over 3 years and I am finally pregnant on my 6th go at ivf.

i didn’t really get the rude comments of when are you having a baby as I was very upfront about ivf with people. It is an effective way to stop the questions.

What annoyed me most was when I was passed a family baby and the parent explained to me how to hold a baby 🤨 and then when I got it to sleep I was told well done.

i had more experience with babies than the parents! So patronising.

also I wasn’t allowed to babysit as I didn’t have my own children.

Jan6755 · 07/09/2022 17:35

Cognacsoft · 07/09/2022 17:10

I think the thread is getting derailed somewhat.
@SheeWeee and @PurplePansy05 you both feel very strongly about your different situations and that's to be expected.
However I think you're both trying to compare apples with pears here.
I've not been in either situation and I think they both sound very difficult.

My df had lost both his parents by the time he was 21, I can't imagine that either.
What i do know is my df never felt the need to trump someone else with his grief and perhaps you two shouldn't either.

Oh, come on @SheeWeee was just responding to a particularly tone-deaf post, particularly lacking in empathy. I was glad she did tbh (alongside another poster) And it wasn't comparing apples and pears, not to my view anyway. This isn't top trumps and no-one should be telling others their grief is worse.

SheeWeee · 07/09/2022 17:33

Cognacsoft · 07/09/2022 17:10

I think the thread is getting derailed somewhat.
@SheeWeee and @PurplePansy05 you both feel very strongly about your different situations and that's to be expected.
However I think you're both trying to compare apples with pears here.
I've not been in either situation and I think they both sound very difficult.

My df had lost both his parents by the time he was 21, I can't imagine that either.
What i do know is my df never felt the need to trump someone else with his grief and perhaps you two shouldn't either.

I'm literally saying that comparison is ridiculous and its not ok to compare yours with anyone elses and tell them you win in your sick game, so no, I am not comparing anything at all.

Baggingarea · 07/09/2022 17:13

Pp is misunderstanding the woman with a disabled child. She was saying that she experiences a similar relationship as child-free with people who have non-disabled children - not that it's harder.

You can choose to live your life in misery and being the worst off out of everyone. Or you can choose to work through trauma, accept it and be happy.

Cognacsoft · 07/09/2022 17:10

I think the thread is getting derailed somewhat.
@SheeWeee and @PurplePansy05 you both feel very strongly about your different situations and that's to be expected.
However I think you're both trying to compare apples with pears here.
I've not been in either situation and I think they both sound very difficult.

My df had lost both his parents by the time he was 21, I can't imagine that either.
What i do know is my df never felt the need to trump someone else with his grief and perhaps you two shouldn't either.

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 17:07

PurpleDaisies · 07/09/2022 16:02

Fair enough, sorry if it hurt, perhaps any kind of lighthearted remark isn’t right for this topic. I’m not trying at argue that you are wrong, just that I didn’t mean what you were saying I meant aka “you’re lucky not to have to have gastro”. It was just meant as a comment about the awfulness of gastro, nothing more.

When I called you out on it, you didn’t apologise. You continued to explain what having had to meant for you with no hint that what you’d said was wrong.

I hope you’re sincere in realising lighthearted wasn’t right. This reads like a non apology apology though .

Okay but I am saying sorry now for making a remark that was lighthearted, and you’re saying I’m being insincere. Perhaps the fact that I started this thread as a way to hear other peoples experiences, and that I’ve explained that I have struggled, firstly to even be able to try to get pregnant and then secondly to get pregnant, means you could give me a little bit of the benefit of the doubt and take my word instead of assuming I’m lying?

I still think that the meaning of my broader comment - aka that people with kids can have low moments and talk about that and that people who want kids can envy even those low moments and that that’s also fine and that it’s hard to understand each other’s perspectives - was okay. I’m not apologising for that, but I am saying sorry for including the lighthearted remark about the awfulness of gastro, and that you being so upset by it has made me realise that I shouldn’t have said it, even though it wasn’t intended to be upsetting.

For me, having gastro is pretty bloody scary because if I can’t keep my medication in my system, I have seizures, and the last two times I’ve had a seizure I’ve severely injured myself, been unable to speak properly or understand language for weeks (which feels like being an animal) and had to be off work for months. Also if I have a seizure while in the later stages of being pregnant there is a good chance I will injure or loose the baby. Making a joke of it is my way of trying to cope with the fear and the horrible reality.

OP posts:
PurplePansy05 · 07/09/2022 17:00

SheeWeee · 07/09/2022 16:57

You don't get to decide what is comparable, you don't get to decide what other people feel or should feel. You have no idea about their life.
Stop playing such a sick game of one-up manship

You can disagree with me, but that won't change my view in the slightest. It's absolutely not a game or a competition to me, the topic is way too serious for this. And I can only guess it's a sensitive one for you too, for a different reason, hence the response.

SheeWeee · 07/09/2022 16:57

PurplePansy05 · 07/09/2022 16:55

Well then, practice what you preach too and don't compare the incomparable.

I don't deny your life is hard or that you grieve what should have been, but this is hard in a very different way.

It's not a grief comparison or a competition. Life and death aren't comparable, that is literally the only binary thing seemingly left in this world. And it is not offensive or minimising to say that.

You don't get to decide what is comparable, you don't get to decide what other people feel or should feel. You have no idea about their life.
Stop playing such a sick game of one-up manship

PurplePansy05 · 07/09/2022 16:55

Well then, practice what you preach too and don't compare the incomparable.

I don't deny your life is hard or that you grieve what should have been, but this is hard in a very different way.

It's not a grief comparison or a competition. Life and death aren't comparable, that is literally the only binary thing seemingly left in this world. And it is not offensive or minimising to say that.