Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents not upsetting people who can’t have kids

238 replies

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 10:40

Read this article in the Guardian with interest, about the need for people with kids to be very conscious of the pain people without kids around them might be feeling, and how friendships can break up when one person is able to have kids and the other can’t.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/sep/06/new-parent-friend-children-baby-grief?CMP=fb_cif#comment-158514602

As someone with one kid and a second on the way, and some old friends / a sibling around me who don’t have kids (some who want them but haven’t found a partner, one who is struggling to conceive), I do try to be careful not to constantly talk about mine or say things like “gosh you went to the theatre then had a lie in the next day, I’m so jealous.” Even though I am very jealous. Also try to not always suggest meet ups with them at the park with baby in tow (though most meet ups do have to be like this as it’s just when I have more time to meet and gives partner valuable alone time to cook, read, be a person rather than a parent.

However, it is also legitimately hard not to sometimes talk about your kids or bring your baby along to a meet up, because when they are young, they consume your life in a way that is sometimes good and sometimes bad : exhausting!! I’d love to be able to chat to friends about the books I’m reading, the day trips I’ve been on, the exhibitions I’m going to visit, what’s going on in politics at the moment but since having a baby the time I have to do any of those things has literally shrunk by about 85%. You also do start spending a bit more time with other parents because they also care about objectively boring stuff like sleep schedules and catchment areas, and they also don’t mind hanging out in awful kid friendly cafes and soft plays.

Curious to hear views about what parents and those who want to be parents can do to accommodate each other’s lives without causing hurt.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RagingWoke · 09/09/2022 15:23

Do people lose their minds over pregnancy?

Yes. Both ways.
The expectant parents can become completely consumed by it and people struggling with their own fertility or circumstances can get upset by it. Then there's the middle ground who just don't really care and get a bit sick of having a pregnancy/baby/child thrust on them.

I have an acquaintance who from the minute she peed on the stick was rubbing her belly, sighing, waddling and talked about nothing but her pregnancy. Swore she could feel kicks at 6 weeks and made people 'feel' it by putting their hands on her upper stomach and didn't believe anyone telling her it wasn't possible to feel it yet and the fetus was nowhere near where she was touching and it was probably farts. Since having the baby she lost any form of identity outside of the baby, will not talk about anything else or do anything without the baby... I can completely see why anyone would want to distance from that kind of person.

I've also known people completely cut off anyone with kids because it was just too painful for them. To me, this response is understandable (if extreme).

Googlecanthelpme · 09/09/2022 15:10

massively over complicating quite a simple thing.

Just be a normal person who appreciates that people have more than one element to their lives. Kids / family is just ONE side of us. I am far more than a parent and when I see friends we talk about lots of things regardless of whether we have children or not.

if I’m talking about my house / home then of course kids come up but if I’m talking about work, hobbies, art, politics, travel, food, music or lots of other things then kids are rarely mentioned.

I am a mum but I’m loads of other things and I ensure that the time I spent with my child free friends isn’t just me wanging on about what my kids have been up to.

Baggingarea · 09/09/2022 15:03

It's weird. I had something similar from a friend. A big weird elaborate picture announcement for their second over text accompanied by a "just wanted you to know so you are not upset". Do people lose their minds over pregnancy?

Ylvamoon · 09/09/2022 13:31

@Poppchipps that's truly awful. Honestly, I would have found the calendar cringe worthy.... unless you are a doting grandparent, godparent or aunt.

Poppchipps · 09/09/2022 07:25

Wow. How utterly thoughtless. I'm sorry, that is awful.

Me "not being nice" to my friend re her baby/the calendar caused issues for years. I'm still friends with her sister and it was brought up fairly recently.

I was very very blunt and just told her how much it hurt me and how I couldn't imagine how she possibly thought I'd want a new born baby calendar.

She finally got the point and it hasn't been mentioned again.

But I still feel hurt and angry all these years later.

rainbowmilk · 08/09/2022 22:35

Poppchipps · 08/09/2022 22:24

I went NC with a friend I had been very close to. My DH and I had been TTC for years, we were on the waiting list for IVF and having tests to try to find the reason for the infertility.

My friend had her second baby, couldn't understand why I didn't want to meet the baby right at that time (surprise visit) and then gave me a calendar customised with photos of her baby and toddler.

That is fucking dreadful, I’m really sorry.

I had a friend go through a phase of writing my birthday and Christmas cards in baby/child speak from her daughter. We’re not friends anymore, oddly…

Poppchipps · 08/09/2022 22:24

I went NC with a friend I had been very close to. My DH and I had been TTC for years, we were on the waiting list for IVF and having tests to try to find the reason for the infertility.

My friend had her second baby, couldn't understand why I didn't want to meet the baby right at that time (surprise visit) and then gave me a calendar customised with photos of her baby and toddler.

Baggingarea · 08/09/2022 21:35

Seasprayandsunshine · 08/09/2022 16:31

I don’t actually have a BMW 🤣

🤣🤣🤣

PlumPudd · 08/09/2022 17:45

SashaPearce · 08/09/2022 16:39

Is it possible that she just had other stuff going on in her life at the time she stopped answering messages, like work busyness or personal drama, and the timing was coincidental? I’m not totally clear from your post whether the cutting out was temporary or permanent on her part, but if permanent could it partly be that she got the impression you’d distanced yourself, if you just never contacted her again after she said that things were fine between you?

It was permanent. The timing could well have been coincidental, but based on a few things she’d said in the past, and something she’s said since to a mutual friend who asked her if she’d seen me lately, it felt like it was probably linked.

The reason I found her texting to say everything was fine and why was I asking if she was okay, odd, was because we’d gone from texting a few times a week and meeting up every few weeks, to me still texting and suggesting meet ups and her not replying ever. I had good reason to ask if she was okay, as it was very out of character/ out of friendship context behaviour and was worried something had happened to her or she was going through something. So for her to act as if everything was fine and why was I asking if it wasn’t, seemed a bit disingenuous. I didn’t back off completely after that, sent something for her birthday, a few Facebook likes etc but I stopped asking to meet up or if everything was okay as it had been a good eight months by then.

If it was the news about the pregnancy that led to her cutting contact I hope it helped her, but I still miss her and felt our prior friendship justified a text just to say, I’m sorry I can’t handle being around people with kids, I wish you well or something like that. I don’t know, it’s hard to ever fully understand someone else’s reality or what they can or can’t do.

OP posts:
PlumPudd · 08/09/2022 17:28

rainbowmilk · 08/09/2022 14:12

This would almost be like not driving my BMW to pick up a friend as they may want one in the future..

Yes, it’s exactly like that. Except that you’d need to live in a society that tells you that owning a BMW is the greatest achievement a woman can make, that non-BMW-owning people are immature/selfish/superficial and don’t know what true love is, and that you should be treated differently at work because you have a BMW. Oh, and it would need to be impossible for some women to obtain a BMW no matter how hard they tried or how much money they earned.

So not really at all like that.

To be fair we do also live in a society that tells women that once they’ve had a kid they should then be able to hold down a job full time, keep a clean house, feed a family, and raise well behaved, socially conscious, academically high achieving children with minimal reliance on TV or childcare - all that and smile at the same time. And if you don’t manage to do all that you’re told you’re either a feckless state dependent single mother who is probably raising future criminals, or an unmaternal cold hearted career woman who is probably raising future sociopaths.

Also in the UK 54,000 mothers every year report being forced to leave their jobs because of how they are treated during their pregnancy, maternity leave or after they return to work and over three quarters of women with kids reported experiencing some form of pregnancy or maternity discrimination at work every year.

I completely agree that we live in a society that fetishises motherhood and implies it’s the “greatest achievement a woman can achieve” that women who don’t want children or can’t have them are somehow unwomen. And that this is awful and wrong.

But once you’ve achieved that great achievement, society doesn’t reward you, usually it pulls the carpet right from under your feet, shoves a hundred new responsibilities onto your plate, doesn’t adequately fund your healthcare and demotes you in favour of a guy called Chris with four years less experience than you.

Not saying wanting a kid and not having one isn’t worse than wanting a kid and having one - it is worse. Just that the lovely vision of motherhood as ultimate female goal society holds up, is a vision that screws everyone over, whether you’ve not met the goal and are taunted by it, or have met it and discovered it was largely an illusion.

OP posts:
Electricstar · 08/09/2022 17:01

Nonews · 08/09/2022 16:56

Realistically. there's not much you can do, is there? If you have kids they are a part of your life, and if that is, understandably, too painful for that person to bear there is not much that the parent can do about that.

I have other things going on in my life that makes ordinary things in other people's incredibly painful for me. I rather see it as for me to manage those feelings. But ultimately, if something going on in someone's life is too painful for you to manage, then you have to decide whether to let that friendship go ( which is painful for the ejected person).

I do get your point too. Sometimes I try and tell myself that my triggers aren’t anyone else’s problem. I do expect my friends to be mindful of my situation though, which mostly they are and will communicate with them if I feel uneasy.

I don’t really expect strangers to be mindful or know what I’m going through, although the “you’ve just got married, when are the kids coming?” 3 weeks after my miscarriage from strangers is just unneeded imo

Nonews · 08/09/2022 16:56

Realistically. there's not much you can do, is there? If you have kids they are a part of your life, and if that is, understandably, too painful for that person to bear there is not much that the parent can do about that.

I have other things going on in my life that makes ordinary things in other people's incredibly painful for me. I rather see it as for me to manage those feelings. But ultimately, if something going on in someone's life is too painful for you to manage, then you have to decide whether to let that friendship go ( which is painful for the ejected person).

SashaPearce · 08/09/2022 16:39

PlumPudd · 07/09/2022 22:56

I’d rather have died than be unable to have my three.”

Wow what a see you next Tuesday! She should have got some sort of disciplinary for that, what a cow.

The cutting out thing is a difficult one. I had a friend who more or less cut contact with me right after we told her my wife was pregnant. We’d been really close for a good seven years and suddenly nothing, no replies to texts or hellos for months. Eventually one message after I left her a couple of missed calls asking if she was safe and okay and had I done something to upset her, where she more or less denied anything had changed between us and just said of course she was fine and why was I being weird. After that I took the hint and just left it in her court, but I was pretty hurt that someone I’d regarded as a very close friend just cut me out without any explanation. I think if she’d said, it’s the child thing, I just can’t be around people who have them, I’d have been upset still to lose her but would have understood. But going from really close to nothing with no explanation did hurt and made me feel like a fool, as though I was this keen idiot who had spent years thinking she was my good friend and she’d never much cared about me - probably not the case but that was the feeling. It might not have been the kid announcement but based on a few things she’d said before I think it probably was. I hope it helped her, but I still miss her.

Is it possible that she just had other stuff going on in her life at the time she stopped answering messages, like work busyness or personal drama, and the timing was coincidental? I’m not totally clear from your post whether the cutting out was temporary or permanent on her part, but if permanent could it partly be that she got the impression you’d distanced yourself, if you just never contacted her again after she said that things were fine between you?

Seasprayandsunshine · 08/09/2022 16:31

I don’t actually have a BMW 🤣

Baggingarea · 08/09/2022 16:10

Seasprayandsunshine · 08/09/2022 14:04

I see this as completely different, I’m sorry if I misunderstood your question.

This would almost be like not driving my BMW to pick up a friend as they may want one in the future. Or not celebrating a promotion as a friend was scared that they couldn’t get one when they tried. I have had friends like this in the past - we aren’t friends anymore. I would never flaunt anything if I thought it would hurt a friend genuinely, but I would be upset if I felt I couldn’t share proud moments with them. Don’t get me wrong - if a friend was struggling to pay rent I would not gloat about my purchase of a fantastic new house etc.

And this also changes the thought processes of the childless person, rather than sadness - is it resentment that you aren’t the same friend that you were childless? So they aren’t mourning for the child they can’t have - they are mourning for their childless friend? If this is the case - I do understand - but life moves on. Kids or no kids, we are all different people than what we were when we 18, change is inevitable and if they can’t cope with that, are they someone you can still be friends with.
We can forget about the kids for a little bit, have a little break - but being a parent is a full time job and it does impact every area of our lives. We will never be the same person - and to expect that is unreasonable.

Any excuse to mention the BMW 😂

Electricstar · 08/09/2022 15:43

@Seasprayandsunshine I do not think you can compare being childless due to losses or infertility with wanting a BMW. Whilst I understand what you are trying to say - they are not comparable

Exactly what @rainbowmilk said is correct

For me I wouldn’t personally say I resent friends who are having children whilst I’m struggling to stay pregnant but I do feel jealous of them. I wouldn’t say I could resent anyone for having a child, but I do feel jealous of those who see a positive test and go onto have a healthy baby. It isn’t anyone’s fault that losses and infertility happen, it is unfortunately life and my friends are not to blame for my problems. It has been hard for me watching my friend’s bump grow and grow and get bits for the nursery whilst I’m grieving over my losses and just about coping. Of course I feel jealous. It isn’t about my friends no longer being childless and changing and not being the same friend at all.

rainbowmilk · 08/09/2022 14:12

This would almost be like not driving my BMW to pick up a friend as they may want one in the future..

Yes, it’s exactly like that. Except that you’d need to live in a society that tells you that owning a BMW is the greatest achievement a woman can make, that non-BMW-owning people are immature/selfish/superficial and don’t know what true love is, and that you should be treated differently at work because you have a BMW. Oh, and it would need to be impossible for some women to obtain a BMW no matter how hard they tried or how much money they earned.

So not really at all like that.

Seasprayandsunshine · 08/09/2022 14:04

I see this as completely different, I’m sorry if I misunderstood your question.

This would almost be like not driving my BMW to pick up a friend as they may want one in the future. Or not celebrating a promotion as a friend was scared that they couldn’t get one when they tried. I have had friends like this in the past - we aren’t friends anymore. I would never flaunt anything if I thought it would hurt a friend genuinely, but I would be upset if I felt I couldn’t share proud moments with them. Don’t get me wrong - if a friend was struggling to pay rent I would not gloat about my purchase of a fantastic new house etc.

And this also changes the thought processes of the childless person, rather than sadness - is it resentment that you aren’t the same friend that you were childless? So they aren’t mourning for the child they can’t have - they are mourning for their childless friend? If this is the case - I do understand - but life moves on. Kids or no kids, we are all different people than what we were when we 18, change is inevitable and if they can’t cope with that, are they someone you can still be friends with.
We can forget about the kids for a little bit, have a little break - but being a parent is a full time job and it does impact every area of our lives. We will never be the same person - and to expect that is unreasonable.

PlumPudd · 08/09/2022 12:23

FarmGirl78 · 08/09/2022 08:25

Having been in the position of desperately wanting children but not having them I've been in the position of being heartbroken over insensitive friends and their big feet.

Without a shadow of doubt the BIGGEST by far hurt was caused by bloomin Facebook and it's mindless "Mummy challenge...Tag 6 friends you think are wonderful mummies. We don't celebrate being mummies enough....Ladies, get tagging!!" drivel and gradually everybody I knew would be appearing on my timeline. And while it was obviously done without any malice it was just cruel and wildly unthinking. I felt my nose was rubbed in it and completely excluded.

I also used to get very very upset about friends who, in small gatherings, would be slagging their children off. I get that its difficult being a parent, emotionally exhausting, draining etc. Eg. Round at a friend's house and few others turning up for cosy chatty night in, and one launched into a rant about her Daughter wanting comforting, saying she wasn't maternal and didn't know why she'd ever had a child. This wasn't a heartfelt 'I'm struggling and need to confide' chat, but a dismissive rant like Jimmy Carr might have. There was only about 5 of us and I'm just astounded she didn't realise I was sat there with tears in my eyes thinking "I'd give my right arm for that".

I also held a gathering at mine once for a different group of friends for a tv event (think Eurovision/World cup/Friends finale type event) and one girl had a 6 month old and all the woman discussed nothing but labour and giving birth ALL NIGHT. Not only spoiled the event for all the men who couldn't listen to the TV properly (and were feeling a bit queazy at some of the details! 🤣) but I had to keep leaving the room as I was so upset IN MY OWN HOME.

Theres also the times where it hurt just passing happy families walking past the park, or seeing babies in pushchairs, but of course that's life and can't be helped or avoided. I can't resent those instances, but I can scream about my ranty friend, and insensitive oaf friend leading a conversation about giving birth.

Just be aware, be sensitive, and realise there's a time and a place, and that comments like "I can't understand why anyone would want kids!" is something you shouldn't really say in front of the Woman who desperately does want them and isn't in a situation where she can have them.

I find all the Facebook parenting celebration, look and my lovely kiddywinks stuff a bit sick making and I have one. Completely different of course if you’re desperate for kids and it’s reminding you of that sadness.

Though I know some people love it. I guess there is always going to be stuff on these platforms that is triggering, a relative who had struggled with alcohol finds all the gin o clock, wine time, look at us all raising a toast, Facebook stuff quite difficult as it makes them want to drink / reminds them that a lot of people see drink as essential to having a good time.

On a practical note there are privacy / content settings on Facebook and Instagram where you can say you want to see less adds about certain topics, and I’m pretty sure they include categories for kids and parenting as well as things like alcohol or pets - basically anything that could be triggering for people. I don’t think it hides content your friends are posting, but you can also hide people’s posts (without them knowing and while still staying friends with them) or put a 30 day pause on seeing their content.

OP posts:
Johnnysgirl · 08/09/2022 11:58

Baggingarea · 08/09/2022 11:54

Don't be so judgey. If it hurt her feelings then it hurt her feelings. It's not for you to determine.

I'm totally on board with the fact that it hurt her feelings Confused
I think it's bloody awful. It wasn't the poster I was judging.

SallyWD · 08/09/2022 11:56

FarmGirl78 · 08/09/2022 08:25

Having been in the position of desperately wanting children but not having them I've been in the position of being heartbroken over insensitive friends and their big feet.

Without a shadow of doubt the BIGGEST by far hurt was caused by bloomin Facebook and it's mindless "Mummy challenge...Tag 6 friends you think are wonderful mummies. We don't celebrate being mummies enough....Ladies, get tagging!!" drivel and gradually everybody I knew would be appearing on my timeline. And while it was obviously done without any malice it was just cruel and wildly unthinking. I felt my nose was rubbed in it and completely excluded.

I also used to get very very upset about friends who, in small gatherings, would be slagging their children off. I get that its difficult being a parent, emotionally exhausting, draining etc. Eg. Round at a friend's house and few others turning up for cosy chatty night in, and one launched into a rant about her Daughter wanting comforting, saying she wasn't maternal and didn't know why she'd ever had a child. This wasn't a heartfelt 'I'm struggling and need to confide' chat, but a dismissive rant like Jimmy Carr might have. There was only about 5 of us and I'm just astounded she didn't realise I was sat there with tears in my eyes thinking "I'd give my right arm for that".

I also held a gathering at mine once for a different group of friends for a tv event (think Eurovision/World cup/Friends finale type event) and one girl had a 6 month old and all the woman discussed nothing but labour and giving birth ALL NIGHT. Not only spoiled the event for all the men who couldn't listen to the TV properly (and were feeling a bit queazy at some of the details! 🤣) but I had to keep leaving the room as I was so upset IN MY OWN HOME.

Theres also the times where it hurt just passing happy families walking past the park, or seeing babies in pushchairs, but of course that's life and can't be helped or avoided. I can't resent those instances, but I can scream about my ranty friend, and insensitive oaf friend leading a conversation about giving birth.

Just be aware, be sensitive, and realise there's a time and a place, and that comments like "I can't understand why anyone would want kids!" is something you shouldn't really say in front of the Woman who desperately does want them and isn't in a situation where she can have them.

I was tagged several times on Facebook by friends inviting me to do the mummy challenge. I felt sooo uncomfortable about it. I thought of my friends who desperately wanted children and couldn't and how painful it must be to see all that. I also thought of my friends who had no children by choice and how utterly boring, sentimental and tacky they would find it! I thought of my friends with children who would have absolutely no interest in seeing my pictures of motherhood! So I declined the invitation.
I don't like all this "motherhood" stuff on social media. Of course being a mother is very important to me (the most important thing in my life) and of course I'll chat to other mums about the trials and tribulations of motherhood. We all need to vent sometimes. However, I don't like it when people are constantly advertising the fact they're a mother, talking of little else, like they're members of some elite club. I feel it creates division with the women who aren't mothers (whether they want to be or not).

Baggingarea · 08/09/2022 11:54

Johnnysgirl · 08/09/2022 11:17

Without a shadow of doubt the BIGGEST by far hurt was caused by bloomin Facebook and it's mindless "Mummy challenge...Tag 6 friends you think are wonderful mummies. We don't celebrate being mummies enough....Ladies, get tagging!!" drivel and gradually everybody I knew would be appearing on my timeline. And while it was obviously done without any malice it was just cruel and wildly unthinking. I felt my nose was rubbed in it and completely excluded.
Jesus Christ...
You need to stop associating with halfwitted bimbos like this. Most moderately intelligent people don't behave this way 🤢
Sorry, I totally get why you felt your nose was rubbed in it, but honestly, who does this shit? Bin them.

Don't be so judgey. If it hurt her feelings then it hurt her feelings. It's not for you to determine.

Johnnysgirl · 08/09/2022 11:17

Without a shadow of doubt the BIGGEST by far hurt was caused by bloomin Facebook and it's mindless "Mummy challenge...Tag 6 friends you think are wonderful mummies. We don't celebrate being mummies enough....Ladies, get tagging!!" drivel and gradually everybody I knew would be appearing on my timeline. And while it was obviously done without any malice it was just cruel and wildly unthinking. I felt my nose was rubbed in it and completely excluded.
Jesus Christ...
You need to stop associating with halfwitted bimbos like this. Most moderately intelligent people don't behave this way 🤢
Sorry, I totally get why you felt your nose was rubbed in it, but honestly, who does this shit? Bin them.

FarmGirl78 · 08/09/2022 08:25

Having been in the position of desperately wanting children but not having them I've been in the position of being heartbroken over insensitive friends and their big feet.

Without a shadow of doubt the BIGGEST by far hurt was caused by bloomin Facebook and it's mindless "Mummy challenge...Tag 6 friends you think are wonderful mummies. We don't celebrate being mummies enough....Ladies, get tagging!!" drivel and gradually everybody I knew would be appearing on my timeline. And while it was obviously done without any malice it was just cruel and wildly unthinking. I felt my nose was rubbed in it and completely excluded.

I also used to get very very upset about friends who, in small gatherings, would be slagging their children off. I get that its difficult being a parent, emotionally exhausting, draining etc. Eg. Round at a friend's house and few others turning up for cosy chatty night in, and one launched into a rant about her Daughter wanting comforting, saying she wasn't maternal and didn't know why she'd ever had a child. This wasn't a heartfelt 'I'm struggling and need to confide' chat, but a dismissive rant like Jimmy Carr might have. There was only about 5 of us and I'm just astounded she didn't realise I was sat there with tears in my eyes thinking "I'd give my right arm for that".

I also held a gathering at mine once for a different group of friends for a tv event (think Eurovision/World cup/Friends finale type event) and one girl had a 6 month old and all the woman discussed nothing but labour and giving birth ALL NIGHT. Not only spoiled the event for all the men who couldn't listen to the TV properly (and were feeling a bit queazy at some of the details! 🤣) but I had to keep leaving the room as I was so upset IN MY OWN HOME.

Theres also the times where it hurt just passing happy families walking past the park, or seeing babies in pushchairs, but of course that's life and can't be helped or avoided. I can't resent those instances, but I can scream about my ranty friend, and insensitive oaf friend leading a conversation about giving birth.

Just be aware, be sensitive, and realise there's a time and a place, and that comments like "I can't understand why anyone would want kids!" is something you shouldn't really say in front of the Woman who desperately does want them and isn't in a situation where she can have them.

Arbesque · 08/09/2022 08:21

I don't think many childless people 'begrudge' others having children, they just feel sad everytime someone announces a pregnancy because it's another reminder that they can't have the thing they want most on the world.

Do you think bereaved daughters, who feel sad on Mothers Day, begrudge other people having Mothers?

Swipe left for the next trending thread