Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this info on register shouldn't be displayed to all pupils.

112 replies

Kerrrmieee · 07/09/2022 10:31

DD 13 asked me what the blue flag underneath her name stood for when her name and picture is displayed during the morning and afternoon registers.

My first reply was huh? In our day it was a tick with a pen on a paper sheet.

Has a quick Google and it turns out they are using Bromcom and register displays their photo and a symbol.

The blue flag happens to mean Pupil Premium child.
We had a laugh about it saying it means you are disadvantaged by being stuck with only me, and I'm poor! (Tongue in cheek)

Seriously though, there a flags for looked after children, children entitled to free school meals, bad behaviour, gifted talented, special needs.

AIBU to think this info shouldn't be privy to her classmates? I can't honestly say I'm over bothered but some people might be.

I've attached the image from Bromcom.

Waffle over!

To think this info on register shouldn't be displayed to all pupils.
OP posts:
Malbecfan · 07/09/2022 20:37

I'm also a teacher and like @Haudyourwheesht , we use a different system and are told categorically NOT to project the register. I set up my screen before a class comes in with a task, then freeze the screen so the kids can see the task but I can look at the register. Once I've taken the register, I close it and unfreeze the screen.

This is a data breach and as such, it should be reported to the data manager. I like the way that the OP is remaining calm about it, but the school needs to know about it, not to apportion blame, but to ensure that something potentially more serious is not displayed.

spongedog · 07/09/2022 20:37

Rhythmisadancer · 07/09/2022 10:40

that has to be a teacher mistake, allowing the register to be displayed -presumably because the OHP is on and showing the computer screen. Tell the school asap and get them to make sure teachers know that there are data protection and safeguarding issues all over this!

Please do this. This is a data breach and is important. However any school tries to portray it. So eg it was an accident - doesnt matter it is a data breach. etc.

I am a school data manager with very good GDPR knowledge. I bang on to anyone who listens about this potential risk. SLT always say no teacher would do this. But they do and it is not OK. At all. It really isnt. There are other sensitive data fields that we need to record. There needs to be total discretion as to how that data is stored and communicated. My DPO is less qualified than me. She doesnt understand at all some of the intricacies of Data Protection legislation because her training is so superficial.

Haudyourwheesht · 07/09/2022 20:32

I am a teacher, albeit using a different register system and we've been told categorically that registers are not to be projected. It's a breach of the pupils privacy.

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 20:31

LittleScottieDog · 07/09/2022 20:26

I hate it when teachers show the register on the whiteboard. Why? There's no need!

There is often a lack of training for staff about how to use a whiteboard to the best of its ability, so I've met plenty of teachers who've never known you can freeze a screen or use a dual screen. In this kind of situation, it means a GDPR breach. Definitely right to email, OP. I'll be interested in what their response is.

Oh please. It's down to human error. Of course there is no need to show private info on a smart board, but in most cases, it is inadvertent. Have you ever gone out the house without your purse? Forgetfulness and mistakes are not sins. This is different to a teacher, who has ignored training and wants to do things the lazy way.

cansu · 07/09/2022 20:31

Hello OP
I wasn't actually aiming my comment at you at all. I can read and saw that you had indeed emailed! There are however many messages on here talking about the school being sued and teachers being disciplined which I was referring to.

LittleScottieDog · 07/09/2022 20:26

I hate it when teachers show the register on the whiteboard. Why? There's no need!

There is often a lack of training for staff about how to use a whiteboard to the best of its ability, so I've met plenty of teachers who've never known you can freeze a screen or use a dual screen. In this kind of situation, it means a GDPR breach. Definitely right to email, OP. I'll be interested in what their response is.

Kerrrmieee · 07/09/2022 20:21

*argument

OP posts:
Kerrrmieee · 07/09/2022 20:21

cansu · 07/09/2022 20:18

A simple call or email to say that a child has queried the flags and should they be hidden would be the proportionate response.

Emailed before 11am this morning 🙄 very calmly outlining the situation.

The only one OTT here is you @cansu

Settle down. There was never any argton this thread. Don't try and start one.

OP posts:
Kerrrmieee · 07/09/2022 20:19

cansu · 07/09/2022 20:17

The amount of outrage and OTT talk of suing and being disciplined is ridiculous. It is an error. I hardly think the teacher is thinking of causing a terrible data breach or upsetting a student . A s

Who has mentioned suing? Apart from me as a joke and in reference to something I'd read 10 mins previously.

I've seen no outrage at all nor displayed any.

OP posts:
cansu · 07/09/2022 20:18

A simple call or email to say that a child has queried the flags and should they be hidden would be the proportionate response.

cansu · 07/09/2022 20:17

The amount of outrage and OTT talk of suing and being disciplined is ridiculous. It is an error. I hardly think the teacher is thinking of causing a terrible data breach or upsetting a student . A s

Kerrrmieee · 07/09/2022 20:16

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 20:11

Surely your only gripe, and rightly so, should be with the blatant negligence in displaying students' private info on a smart screen. I don't quite get the need to analyse the different markers attributed to each student. They are there for a reason and it isn't to the detriment of learners.

Yes that was my only gripe and I emailed (well thought I had) before 11am this morning. There's no more gripe from me other than phone not having enough storage to send said email.

I haven't been rude about it, I'm not sure why PP is saying they don't want to lose Bromcom - just got in - again.

My gripe wasn't even a massive gripe for our situation, however others could potentially be seriously pissed off with it and take it further - hence trying to let school know at my earliest opportunity.

OP posts:
Culldesack · 07/09/2022 20:11

Kerrrmieee · 07/09/2022 19:13

I just wanted to add that DD didn't come home with updates on who has what symbol. As mentioned in OP whether it be SEN, FSM, PP it really doesn't worry us. What did worry me is that it is a data breach, especially for LAC, and nobody in the flag categories should be flagged at all!

Surely your only gripe, and rightly so, should be with the blatant negligence in displaying students' private info on a smart screen. I don't quite get the need to analyse the different markers attributed to each student. They are there for a reason and it isn't to the detriment of learners.

Brigante9 · 07/09/2022 19:57

Magnanimouse · 07/09/2022 19:42

Across many 1000s of classes who are using Bromcom, this is going to happen, even if your school realises and asks teachers to do the registers differently.

I'd be emailing Bromcom also - that info doesn't need to appear on the page where the register is marked. Try to get it fixed across the system!

We don’t want Bromcom to remove the flags, thanks. Currently, it’s the only way I can see who is SEND/PP etc which we use to create seating plans. It’s not yet up on the system elsewhere. It’s a lot quicker to find out info on new kids than to find the SEND register. Teachers should freeze boards when completing the register. Ours may also have an absence reason on there, so big data breach.

Magnanimouse · 07/09/2022 19:42

Across many 1000s of classes who are using Bromcom, this is going to happen, even if your school realises and asks teachers to do the registers differently.

I'd be emailing Bromcom also - that info doesn't need to appear on the page where the register is marked. Try to get it fixed across the system!

Kerrrmieee · 07/09/2022 19:13

I just wanted to add that DD didn't come home with updates on who has what symbol. As mentioned in OP whether it be SEN, FSM, PP it really doesn't worry us. What did worry me is that it is a data breach, especially for LAC, and nobody in the flag categories should be flagged at all!

OP posts:
TheNefariousOrange · 07/09/2022 19:12

This would be (quite rightly) a disciplinary at our school. An accident is understandable once, if you haven't realise the board isn't frozen, but this sounds like it's being done in purpose.

Kerrrmieee · 07/09/2022 18:52

I've just asked DD if anybody had nothing against their name. She said no it's either a heart or a flag.

Therefore @hopeishere as said previously upthread a heart is one of the houses and a flag is just that - singling out, even if it's gifted and talented.

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 07/09/2022 18:17

Definitely should not be available to anyone without a need to know. Even without a key, these things are easy to figure out.

they did this kind of thing 40 years ago with paperwork and leveled textbooks. The kids weren’t supposed to know the symbols, but we weren’t stupid, we were able to translate them almost immediately. People have to remember that the children and parents who might inadvertently view this information don’t do so in a vacuum. They have pieces of knowledge about various students just from day to day interactions. If you put that together with observing coded symbols, even without intending to interpret the symbols, your brain might do it anyway.

Goldenbear · 07/09/2022 18:07

Even if the school use different symbols for different categories, which is likely, it still sets a child apart from others in the class who may have nothing against their name. The symbols stand out if they equate to the less common categories and others will be able to determine that they fall in to one of the categories that they may not want other people to know. It will be pretty obvious if it is something innocuous like 'house' as all children will have a symbol and they would be able to deduce this.

HipsterCoffeeShop · 07/09/2022 17:48

Bromcom has a projector mode for registers - so teachers can display the register with just the kids names and no other identifying or personal info

Agree though it is poor form - hopefully it's a one off and the teacher just forgot to stop sharing her screen.

beautifulfreak1985 · 07/09/2022 17:47

thats totally not on!! you're right to complain

hopeishere · 07/09/2022 17:38

So there's a blue flag and you've assumed it's for PP because that's what they use in the example?

Kerrrmieee · 07/09/2022 17:16

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 07/09/2022 16:34

What does queued in outbox mean? Do your emails not get sent automatically, that sounds very annoying

Yes normally they do and I've been sending emails all day.

My phone is warning of lack of storage, so I forwarded to same address, no joy.
However I'd attached the Bromcom pic (because the admin staff will have no clue what I am taking about IME).
Deleted pic and it sent no problems.

My email was pretty self explanatory, however, experience tells me different.

OP posts:
AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 07/09/2022 16:34

Kerrrmieee · 07/09/2022 16:23

DD home, symbols still being displayed - email still queued in outbox.

What does queued in outbox mean? Do your emails not get sent automatically, that sounds very annoying