Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think leaving the ECHR (European Court of Human Rights) is a cause for concern?

217 replies

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 10:25

On paper, the new Home Secretary, Suella Braverman, looks well qualified to understand the rule of law and flex her legal arm. She seems to be a competent lawyer (but being a good lawyer does not mean someone is also a ‘good person’).

I get that it’s easier for the government to win legal cases if they withdraw from the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). Change the rules of the games to make it easier to win the game. I get it. But I don’t agree in principle because it’s not in the spirit of the game or rule of law. Some rules put players at a disadvantage, but they’re rules for a reason (reasons that need consideration).

Why do the plans to take the UK out the ECHR sound worrying?

To me, it’s because human right laws were hard won (do people who support getting rid of human rights laws realise that or care?). Once lost it’ll be even harder to win back human rights laws (and they may never be re-won again). Losing human rights protections under the ECHR is a slippery slope imo. We’re all humans with vulnerabilities, so we all benefit from the enforcement of human rights laws under ECHR.

OP posts:
BewareTheLibrarians · 07/09/2022 12:31

(To be very clear, the murderer was NOT an asylum seeker. Can see someone reading that without context and jumping all over that.)

UnnecessaryFennel · 07/09/2022 12:29

izimbra · 07/09/2022 11:47

I think when you have a government that can't enact its planned legislative agenda without breaching people's human rights, and so plans to withdraw from the decades long convention that protects them, then the direction of travel is extremely concerning.

Indeed.

BewareTheLibrarians · 07/09/2022 12:28

@Culldesack Can you articulate why you’ve brought up that case in particular? You’re seem to be alluding to something but unable to say it clearly.

Do you think the murderer was an asylum seeker (thus relevant to comments above)? Do you think the fact that the murderer was not British means he will be treated better? Do you think his deportation will be blocked because of some kind of human rights? Do you think he will not be charged with murder? What is the relevance to this thread that necessitates a family’s tragedy to be brought out in public again?

KrisAkabusi · 07/09/2022 12:28

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 12:16

I think you don't know which direction this was going in. How do you think the victim's killer's UK rights are going to be administered? It is no good insulting people's intelligence, when you're not coming from a position of strength.

But what rights do you want removed? Because the UK isn't leaving the ECHR to give people more rights. They arrest someone for that murder. Do you want to remove his right to a fair trial? How about his right not to be tortured? Should he face the death penalty? And what if they've arrested the wrong person?

Human rights should be universal and not at the whim of whatever PM is in power at the time.

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 12:16

PestorPeston · 07/09/2022 12:13

I think your degree may have been a poor investment. ECHR upholds the right to life.

Stop trying to score cheap points off someone's personal tragedy.

I think you don't know which direction this was going in. How do you think the victim's killer's UK rights are going to be administered? It is no good insulting people's intelligence, when you're not coming from a position of strength.

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 12:14

Oh and because PM Johnson passed a nifty wee law that said if the government believe that you could be entitled to citizenship elsewhere they can strip you of your UK citizenship without telling you. So you could go on holiday and then discover you are stateless when you try to get home. So if you are black, brown, Jewish, had a foreign grandparent or have a foreign spouse or are from NI, the government can make you homeless and stateless.

PestorPeston · 07/09/2022 12:13

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 12:07

When thinking about children's rights, how many were thinking of the rights of the 9 year old girl, murdered in Boston? Who killed her?

I think your degree may have been a poor investment. ECHR upholds the right to life.

Stop trying to score cheap points off someone's personal tragedy.

Farahilda · 07/09/2022 12:11

It's not worrying because we shall continue to be bound by our obligations under the UN

Which are higher (in international terms) than the EU ones.

It's just taking out the middle management. It's not removing human rights, or abrogating from our UN treaty obligations. There should be no change.

But I can see how the presentational issue is being leapt on, either by those who do not know about or understand the role of the UN. Or by those who wish to misrepresent by omission.

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 12:07

Tierne · 07/09/2022 12:00

Dont see the issue. We wrote the rules. We basically invented the modern court system. Some shakier states might need the ECHR to keep them in check but we dont. We have our own system in place

Because things change. And can change very fast for women.

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 12:07

When thinking about children's rights, how many were thinking of the rights of the 9 year old girl, murdered in Boston? Who killed her?

familyofworms · 07/09/2022 12:05

I will insult anyone who supports reducing mine and my children’s rights. I’m sick to the fucking back teeth of supporters of this pseudo Tory party pushing for my life to be harder.

The attacks on our democracy and rights by the Tory government is fucking terrifying. It looks like their plan is to spend the next 2 years destroying the rights of UK citizens.

This, and this!!

It is extremely concerning, and I say this as a very close family member of a murder victim. I cannot believe anyone would think that it's a good idea.

PestorPeston · 07/09/2022 12:04

Tierne · 07/09/2022 12:00

Dont see the issue. We wrote the rules. We basically invented the modern court system. Some shakier states might need the ECHR to keep them in check but we dont. We have our own system in place

ECHR keep us accountable. Without them we could change the rules. We could change how the courts work, we could become like Belarus or Russia.

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 12:02

Tierne · 07/09/2022 12:00

Dont see the issue. We wrote the rules. We basically invented the modern court system. Some shakier states might need the ECHR to keep them in check but we dont. We have our own system in place

🙌 hallelujah.

Tierne · 07/09/2022 12:00

Dont see the issue. We wrote the rules. We basically invented the modern court system. Some shakier states might need the ECHR to keep them in check but we dont. We have our own system in place

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 11:59

Oops, don't know why there's a quote there.

PestorPeston · 07/09/2022 11:59

The only reason to leave is to get rid of some of the rights, which ones do the Tories not like?

the right to life (Article 2)
freedom from torture (Article 3)
freedom from slavery (Article 4)
the right to liberty (Article 5)
the right to a fair trial (Article 6)
the right not to be punished for something that wasn’t against the law at the time (Article 7)
the right to respect for family and private life (Article 8)
freedom of thought, conscience and religion (Article 9)
freedom of expression (Article 10)
freedom of assembly (Article 11)
the right to marry and start a family (Article 12)
the right not to be discriminated against in respect of these rights (Article 14)
the right to protection of property (Protocol 1, Article 1)
the right to education (Protocol 1, Article 2)
the right to participate in free elections (Protocol 1, Article 3)
the abolition of the death penalty (Protocol 13)

Could be an idea to read up before ripping up www.equalityhumanrights.com/en/human-rights/what-are-human-rights

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 11:59

Kendodd · 07/09/2022 11:57

I agree, its chilling OP.
Doesn't mean this policy won't be cheered to the rafters by the public though.

I remember I happened across a pro Brexit street stall protesting against May's Brexit deal. I asked a person on the stall why he objected, he said because it wasn't Brexit. I asked if he'd read it, he said 'no' . I asked his colleague if she'd read it, answer 'no'. Turned out that not one of them, about 12 people, had actually read it. I suspect it will be the same with those cheering our exit from ECHR, they'll just get their information from tabloid headlines.

A bit like those, on here, not understanding how domestic courts work.

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 11:57

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 10:41

Human rights aren't ever afforded to victims of murder, for instance, so I couldn't care less about it.

YANBU @WakeUpAndBeAwesome. The attacks on our democracy and rights by the Tory government is fucking terrifying. It looks like their plan is to spend the next 2 years destroying the rights of UK citizens.

Kendodd · 07/09/2022 11:57

I agree, its chilling OP.
Doesn't mean this policy won't be cheered to the rafters by the public though.

I remember I happened across a pro Brexit street stall protesting against May's Brexit deal. I asked a person on the stall why he objected, he said because it wasn't Brexit. I asked if he'd read it, he said 'no' . I asked his colleague if she'd read it, answer 'no'. Turned out that not one of them, about 12 people, had actually read it. I suspect it will be the same with those cheering our exit from ECHR, they'll just get their information from tabloid headlines.

BewareTheLibrarians · 07/09/2022 11:53

@justaladyLOL but people who enter the UK illegally can’t be housed. Unless you count being detained/imprisoned as housed?

Of course, this means understanding that asylum seekers entering the UK aren’t entering illegally. (And that by definition illegal immigrants and asylum seekers are very different things.) In fact, the government’s own requirement is that in order to claim asylum, you have to first enter the UK.

Not that many people who don’t look into things will know that though, given that even many conservative mps refer to asylum seekers as illegal immigrants. Which is incorrect, and they know is incorrect, but they rely on people not understanding the difference. And I wonder if part of that is to hide that fact that uncontrolled boat crossings have increased under the current government due to inept policy.

DiDonk · 07/09/2022 11:53

RudsyFarmer · 07/09/2022 10:45

I think the constant red tape costs a bloody fortune and I’m absolutely sick of individuals playing the system. So actually I’m all for it. I know it’s an unpopular opinion but we’re in a time where unpopular decisions are going to be made.

What red tape does the ehcr bring?

Oh is it literally nothing?

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 11:52

AchatAVendre · 07/09/2022 11:51

So you're presumably aware of Kamino, Danske Slagterier, etc and why not having even administrative decisions made against individuals without due process isn't a good idea? Do you welcome your local authority making a wrong decision which devastates you financially without holding some form of hearing first where you can have legal representation?

Is judicial review going as well then?

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 11:51

izimbra · 07/09/2022 11:49

No point trying to take the moral high ground when you're arguing for the removal of my and my children's human rights.

How will your rights, and those of your children be removed? Are you saying we will be living in a tyranny?

AchatAVendre · 07/09/2022 11:51

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 11:48

Unfortunately, European Law, was part of my first degree. I am aware of its mechanism. I remember the laborious task of learning each Article.

So you're presumably aware of Kamino, Danske Slagterier, etc and why not having even administrative decisions made against individuals without due process isn't a good idea? Do you welcome your local authority making a wrong decision which devastates you financially without holding some form of hearing first where you can have legal representation?

izimbra · 07/09/2022 11:49

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 11:38

Swearing and insults, always the same from the left. I'm not going to bother addressing anybody, from hereonin, who cannot rationally debate.

No point trying to take the moral high ground when you're arguing for the removal of my and my children's human rights.

Swipe left for the next trending thread