Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think leaving the ECHR (European Court of Human Rights) is a cause for concern?

217 replies

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 10:25

On paper, the new Home Secretary, Suella Braverman, looks well qualified to understand the rule of law and flex her legal arm. She seems to be a competent lawyer (but being a good lawyer does not mean someone is also a ‘good person’).

I get that it’s easier for the government to win legal cases if they withdraw from the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). Change the rules of the games to make it easier to win the game. I get it. But I don’t agree in principle because it’s not in the spirit of the game or rule of law. Some rules put players at a disadvantage, but they’re rules for a reason (reasons that need consideration).

Why do the plans to take the UK out the ECHR sound worrying?

To me, it’s because human right laws were hard won (do people who support getting rid of human rights laws realise that or care?). Once lost it’ll be even harder to win back human rights laws (and they may never be re-won again). Losing human rights protections under the ECHR is a slippery slope imo. We’re all humans with vulnerabilities, so we all benefit from the enforcement of human rights laws under ECHR.

OP posts:
Culldesack · 07/09/2022 13:13

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 07/09/2022 13:06

It is very concerning but, at the same time I am looking forward to the likes of @Culldesack and @RudsyFarmer falling foul of any removal of rights somewhere down the line.

Will be hilarious see them back on here moaning about how outrageous it is that X,Y, or Z happened to them and that's not what they expected when they were happy to wave goodbye to an assortment of fundamental rights.

I will be perfectly fine, because 1) I am not so bitterly obsessed with a political party, to the point of self combustion.

  1. I understand the relationship between domestic and EU law, which you don't.

  2. My rights, as a citizen won't be going anywhere.

In yet another breeding ground thread for the Tory bashers, I'm only amazed the insults and swearing have only occurred several times. Give it till the later shift come on. The same old insults, profanities and lack of reasoning, will surface. Same old, rinse and repeat.

Another thread to wipe your feet on the way out.

Fladdermus · 07/09/2022 13:11

PestorPeston · 07/09/2022 13:03

Blinking heck@Fladdermus that could trigger Special Procedures.

Why the great race to go from we wrote this to 'watch out Syria, Afghanistan and the rest

Article 2 is also a bit of pain. Not killing people upsets tories, as made clear by Patel a while back.

www.indy100.com/news/priti-patel-resurfaced-clip-death-penalty-ian-hislop-question-time-video-home-secretary-9020006

bibliomania · 07/09/2022 13:10

The European Court of HR issues legally binding judgements; the UN treaty bodies (Committee against Torture etc) do not. Anyone who thinks domestic or UN mechanisms are equivalent does not fully understand the law.

Leafy3 · 07/09/2022 13:07

Fladdermus · 07/09/2022 12:58

Suella Braverman has been pretty clear. She wants to start with getting rid of our right to not be tortured.

www.independent.co.uk/independentpremium/uk-news/tory-leadership-candidate-suella-braverman-torture-human-rights-b2124323.html

So what are we going to do about it?

Just sit back, roll over and let them get on with it?

The incumbent government does not have a democratic mandate.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 07/09/2022 13:06

It is very concerning but, at the same time I am looking forward to the likes of @Culldesack and @RudsyFarmer falling foul of any removal of rights somewhere down the line.

Will be hilarious see them back on here moaning about how outrageous it is that X,Y, or Z happened to them and that's not what they expected when they were happy to wave goodbye to an assortment of fundamental rights.

Leafy3 · 07/09/2022 13:05

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 12:51

Sorry @Leafy3, misread there.BlushThanks

😄

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 13:05

undermilkjug · 07/09/2022 12:59

The convention on human rights isn't European (EU) law. It is a convention led by Britain who agreed on certain fundamental rights at the end of WW2 and codified them as a means of upholding them.

ukandeu.ac.uk/the-facts/whats-the-difference-between-the-european-convention-on-human-rights-the-european-court-of-human-rights-and-the-european-court-of-justice/#:~:text=The%20ECHR%20and%20its%20court,EU%20law%20within%20the%20EU.

You better have a word with the Associate Dean then, who led that module ! Pretty sure he knew what he was talking about when discussing the EU and its origins. Keyword: origins.

PestorPeston · 07/09/2022 13:03

Blinking heck@Fladdermus that could trigger Special Procedures.

Why the great race to go from we wrote this to 'watch out Syria, Afghanistan and the rest

undermilkjug · 07/09/2022 12:59

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 11:48

Unfortunately, European Law, was part of my first degree. I am aware of its mechanism. I remember the laborious task of learning each Article.

The convention on human rights isn't European (EU) law. It is a convention led by Britain who agreed on certain fundamental rights at the end of WW2 and codified them as a means of upholding them.

ukandeu.ac.uk/the-facts/whats-the-difference-between-the-european-convention-on-human-rights-the-european-court-of-human-rights-and-the-european-court-of-justice/#:~:text=The%20ECHR%20and%20its%20court,EU%20law%20within%20the%20EU.

Fladdermus · 07/09/2022 12:58

PestorPeston · 07/09/2022 11:59

The only reason to leave is to get rid of some of the rights, which ones do the Tories not like?

the right to life (Article 2)
freedom from torture (Article 3)
freedom from slavery (Article 4)
the right to liberty (Article 5)
the right to a fair trial (Article 6)
the right not to be punished for something that wasn’t against the law at the time (Article 7)
the right to respect for family and private life (Article 8)
freedom of thought, conscience and religion (Article 9)
freedom of expression (Article 10)
freedom of assembly (Article 11)
the right to marry and start a family (Article 12)
the right not to be discriminated against in respect of these rights (Article 14)
the right to protection of property (Protocol 1, Article 1)
the right to education (Protocol 1, Article 2)
the right to participate in free elections (Protocol 1, Article 3)
the abolition of the death penalty (Protocol 13)

Could be an idea to read up before ripping up www.equalityhumanrights.com/en/human-rights/what-are-human-rights

Suella Braverman has been pretty clear. She wants to start with getting rid of our right to not be tortured.

www.independent.co.uk/independentpremium/uk-news/tory-leadership-candidate-suella-braverman-torture-human-rights-b2124323.html

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 12:57

Dogtooth · 07/09/2022 12:53

Bloody hell @Tierne. You are saying: the UK made a system to uphold human rights. But we are so good at human rights we don't need the human rights system we created. We can just kind of wing it and we'll be fine because we're so human-rightsy we don't even need laws about it.

Jaw dropping

Well according to most on here, the UK would be devoid of any rights, if we depart from ECHR

Even more jaw dropping

meditrina · 07/09/2022 12:57

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 12:38

The ECHR is not an EU offshoot. It existed long before the EU.

My bad. Lazy typing. Sorry

It is however the European (not EU) offshoot of the UN convention from which it flows.

So unless the government is also planning on abrogating the treaty obligations to the UN, this isn't a bonfire of human rights

Dogtooth · 07/09/2022 12:53

Tierne · 07/09/2022 12:00

Dont see the issue. We wrote the rules. We basically invented the modern court system. Some shakier states might need the ECHR to keep them in check but we dont. We have our own system in place

Bloody hell @Tierne. You are saying: the UK made a system to uphold human rights. But we are so good at human rights we don't need the human rights system we created. We can just kind of wing it and we'll be fine because we're so human-rightsy we don't even need laws about it.

Jaw dropping

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 12:51

Sorry @Leafy3, misread there.BlushThanks

Anotherdopeytaxpayer · 07/09/2022 12:49

Certainly the Court can bind the hands of parliament, adds nothing to our prosperity and makes us less secure by preventing the deportation of dangerous foreign nationals. It does nothing to change the attitudes of governments in countries such as Russia when it comes to human rights.

Remember the cases of clerics such as Abu Hamza and Abu Qatada, who were charged with terrorism offenses abroad but avoided extradition from the UK for long periods due to legal battles with the ECHR ?

Whilst severing ties with Strasbourg would give British courts greater powers to deport foreign criminals, it almost certainly won’t happen.

Leaving the ECHR would require another huge legislative programme which would take up a lot of a parliamentary session.

JuliaDomna · 07/09/2022 12:47

I might be wrong but I was listening to Brenda Hale, she of the spider brooch fame, but she said that individuals would still have recourse to the EHCR. What would change is the automatic imposition of its decisions into UK law. The UK was a founding member of the EHCR in 1951. It's got nothing to do with the EU, even though the Conservative Party and Daily Mail would like us to believe.

I see this as another prong in their aim to reduce our legal rights. They have already tinkered with the right to protest, next up is a curb on the right to challenge Government Policy through Judicial Review. The Police have been instructed to look upon journalists are terrorist groups. I think it is very concerning. These are rights fundamental to a functioning democracy.

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 12:47

Endlesssummer2022 · 07/09/2022 12:35

‘Swearing and insults, always the same from the left’

Where did I say I was from the left? I’m actually dead centre and would be considered a ‘Blairite’ or ‘One Nation Tory’ when they still existed. I can say for certain that you are not or the ‘normal’ right though.

I think me swearing is nothing compared to mine and my kids rights being threatened though so off your fuck.

So mature.

BewareTheLibrarians · 07/09/2022 12:46

Oh. Oh dear. 🫢

“EXC: Cabinet agreed to shelve Raab’s British Bill of Rights designed to protect against meddling ECHR in Strasbourg, The Sun can reveal. It was due back in Commons next week.

New PM risks major blowback after delaying the second reading of the legislation - which was due on 12 September. A senior govt source: "The bill is a mess and its not going to come back in anything like its current form."

But much vaunted plan to make the Supreme Court in London ultimate decision-maker on human rights issues – not the ECHR in Strasbourg - now risks running out of time now before the end of the Parliament. Officially it will be “reviewed” but opponents say “it’s dead”.”

mobile.twitter.com/MrHarryCole/status/1567471503884648448

(don’t know how seriously I can take The Sun, but interesting if true.)

Leafy3 · 07/09/2022 12:44

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 12:42

You were had @Leafy3. Did you not check out what the ECHR is before voting Leave?🤦‍♀️

Did you misread my post there @TooBigForMyBoots ? 🤦

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 12:42

Leafy3 · 07/09/2022 12:38

I know people are going to hate hearing this, but this was the biggest reason I voted against brexit.

Brexiteers were vocal about this from the start, it shouldn't be coming as a surprise now

You were had @Leafy3. Did you not check out what the ECHR is before voting Leave?🤦‍♀️

KrisAkabusi · 07/09/2022 12:39

Because we are, and will remain, signatories to the UN convention - which is a much more important one than the EU offshoot modelled on it.

It's got nothing to do with the EU.

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 12:38

The ECHR is not an EU offshoot. It existed long before the EU.

Leafy3 · 07/09/2022 12:38

I know people are going to hate hearing this, but this was the biggest reason I voted against brexit.

Brexiteers were vocal about this from the start, it shouldn't be coming as a surprise now

Endlesssummer2022 · 07/09/2022 12:35

‘Swearing and insults, always the same from the left’

Where did I say I was from the left? I’m actually dead centre and would be considered a ‘Blairite’ or ‘One Nation Tory’ when they still existed. I can say for certain that you are not or the ‘normal’ right though.

I think me swearing is nothing compared to mine and my kids rights being threatened though so off your fuck.

meditrina · 07/09/2022 12:31

KrisAkabusi · 07/09/2022 12:28

But what rights do you want removed? Because the UK isn't leaving the ECHR to give people more rights. They arrest someone for that murder. Do you want to remove his right to a fair trial? How about his right not to be tortured? Should he face the death penalty? And what if they've arrested the wrong person?

Human rights should be universal and not at the whim of whatever PM is in power at the time.

They are and will remain universal.

Because we are, and will remain, signatories to the UN convention - which is a much more important one than the EU offshoot modelled on it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread