Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think leaving the ECHR (European Court of Human Rights) is a cause for concern?

217 replies

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 10:25

On paper, the new Home Secretary, Suella Braverman, looks well qualified to understand the rule of law and flex her legal arm. She seems to be a competent lawyer (but being a good lawyer does not mean someone is also a ‘good person’).

I get that it’s easier for the government to win legal cases if they withdraw from the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). Change the rules of the games to make it easier to win the game. I get it. But I don’t agree in principle because it’s not in the spirit of the game or rule of law. Some rules put players at a disadvantage, but they’re rules for a reason (reasons that need consideration).

Why do the plans to take the UK out the ECHR sound worrying?

To me, it’s because human right laws were hard won (do people who support getting rid of human rights laws realise that or care?). Once lost it’ll be even harder to win back human rights laws (and they may never be re-won again). Losing human rights protections under the ECHR is a slippery slope imo. We’re all humans with vulnerabilities, so we all benefit from the enforcement of human rights laws under ECHR.

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 13:51

What do you mean by autonomy @hattie43? The right to torture? The right of male bodied folk to access women's single sex spaces? The ability to strip women of their right to abortion/contraception? The right to lock people up for wrong think?

Leafy3 · 07/09/2022 13:51

@hattie43 they won't be 'our' decisions though.
They will be - and are - the decisions of the super rich who fund the Conservative party. People who are completely out of touch with society and who are unaffected by the laws which determine every aspect of our lives.

These are the people who've cut legal aid to rhe point v few even have a hope of pursuing justice. They are the same people who want you to pay for every aspect of your health care (and even a short ambulance ride can cost hundreds of pounds), the people who wish to remove your rights at work, remove your rights to an unbiased fair trial, monitor your every movement...etc etc.

This isn't scare mongering, it's already happening now.

TeaKlaxon · 07/09/2022 13:51

hattie43 · 07/09/2022 13:46

This country is going to the dogs , yes if leaving gives us more autonomy to make our own decisions then we should go

And just scrap the Good Friday Agreement too?

BewareTheLibrarians · 07/09/2022 13:51

hattie43 · 07/09/2022 13:46

This country is going to the dogs , yes if leaving gives us more autonomy to make our own decisions then we should go

But it’s been sent “to the dogs” by the very people who you’re trusting to take us out. If everything’s got so much worse over the years that the conservative have been in charge, why would you trust them to make anything better for you?

KrisAkabusi · 07/09/2022 13:50

Grumpybutfunny · 07/09/2022 13:29

As much as I would love to so we can reinstate the death penalty it doesn't make economic or security sense whilst we are at war with Russia. I don't necessarily oppose us leaving and forming a closer alliance with the USA etc but not right now

So you're happy with killing innocent people? Because unless you can have 100% confidence in the police, the government(!) and the justice system, that will happen if you have the death penalty. And lets be honest, the UK does not have a good track record with convicting innocent people.

izimbra · 07/09/2022 13:48

"3) My rights, as a citizen won't be going anywhere."

I think this is instructive.

The reason the government wants to do this is so that they can enact policies which under current arrangements would breach the human rights of asylum seekers and migrants.

And that's going to be ok with Conservatives, who, judging from what I see every day on social media, don't see these people as fully human anyway.

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 07/09/2022 13:48

I haven't read the full thread apologies but I think, as is evidenced in the few responses that I have read, that most people don't actually understand what human rights actually are and should perhaps read up on the subject before commenting.

For instance what right is being contravened by someone being released from prison?

The right to life is most often understood as is the fact that human rights relate to treatment by the state not by other individuals.

People do not realise how much they benefit from having 'human rights' and that is because they have them. When they are taken away and the state can act as it wants, how it wants, when it wants it will eventually come for everyone in some way, but people think they are so perfect that they don't 'need' that protection.

hattie43 · 07/09/2022 13:46

This country is going to the dogs , yes if leaving gives us more autonomy to make our own decisions then we should go

TeaKlaxon · 07/09/2022 13:42

Incidentally, not a single person advocating leaving the ECHR seems to be aware that it would also mean tearing up the Good Friday Agreement.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 07/09/2022 13:41

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 13:13

I will be perfectly fine, because 1) I am not so bitterly obsessed with a political party, to the point of self combustion.

  1. I understand the relationship between domestic and EU law, which you don't.

  2. My rights, as a citizen won't be going anywhere.

In yet another breeding ground thread for the Tory bashers, I'm only amazed the insults and swearing have only occurred several times. Give it till the later shift come on. The same old insults, profanities and lack of reasoning, will surface. Same old, rinse and repeat.

Another thread to wipe your feet on the way out.

  1. You sure? You seem to incredibly invested in defending the tories at every turn.

2 & 3) Ah sorry, I forgot you were the preeminent authority on the subject. I shouldn't listen to the concerns about withdrawing from the ECHR that have been raised by politicians, organisations, and commentators of all political hues.

Culldesack says it will all be fine so that's that. Oh, and this iteration of the Tories deserve every bashing they get.

Endlesssummer2022 · 07/09/2022 13:40

What I can’t understand is why supporters of removing the ECHR don’t just move to the sort of countries who kick people out without a fair trial or commit state sanctioned murder like Saudi Arabia?

Why try to turn our county into Saudi Arabia instead? I’m more than ok for people to move to these places and potentially fuck up their own lives if that’s how they feel but why try and drag the rest of us down with them?

If they are opposed to gay marriage or be fired at will by their employer, there are multiple countries to choose from.

TeaKlaxon · 07/09/2022 13:36

meditrina · 07/09/2022 12:31

They are and will remain universal.

Because we are, and will remain, signatories to the UN convention - which is a much more important one than the EU offshoot modelled on it.

  1. That is not true. The ECHR is much more important to the protection of human rights in member states than the UN, not least because there is a right to take cases to the European Court of Human Rights, which does not exist for individuals through the UN system. For the same reason, there is an extensive body of ECHR case law that does not exist for UN instruments which are much more aspirational than enforceable.
  2. The ECHR is not an EU institution 🙄
lollipoprainbow · 07/09/2022 13:31

Good idea it's abused at every turn.

TeaKlaxon · 07/09/2022 13:30

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 11:39

No, but we will be called all sorts to point that out. The UK has many domestic rights that will remain. How did we manage before 1998? 🙄

Do you think the UK joined the ECHR in 1998?

You're wrong - the UK joined the ECHR in the 1950 (it came into force in 1953). I presume your reference to 1998 relates to the incorporation of ECHR rights into domestic law via the Human Rights Act, but that's not what is at issue in this thread. The suggestion from Braverman was not just to change the Human Rights Act but to leave the Convention itself.

Grumpybutfunny · 07/09/2022 13:29

As much as I would love to so we can reinstate the death penalty it doesn't make economic or security sense whilst we are at war with Russia. I don't necessarily oppose us leaving and forming a closer alliance with the USA etc but not right now

54isanopendoor · 07/09/2022 13:26

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 11:02

“Why is counter-terrorism a human rights issue?

“Both terrorism and counter-terrorism are human rights issues.

“Terrorism is a human rights issue because it involves deliberate attacks on civilians causing death and serious injury – and so engages the right to life and the right to physical integrity.

“Counter-terrorism is a human rights issue because the way that the state responds to the threat of terrorism may involve exceptional measures that depart from long-established legal principles, including fundamental rights.”

justice.org.uk/counter-terrorism-human-rights/

@WakeUpAndBeAwesome do you remember Priti Patel having trouble mixing up her terrorists & anti-terrroists (about 2 years ago?) it would have been funny if it weren't so scary that she was in power & so clueless (not comparing you btw!)

OF COURSE giving up any Human Rights is a bad idea. For all of us.
They are hard won & relatively recent in human history. We ALL have rights.
Yes, they can be temporarily suspended in cases of murder / terorrism but thats a slipperly slope as '1 mans terrorist is another mans freedom fighter' & all that.

Braverman is not a reassuring choice of post. She will be quietly working on @Fladdermus list whilst we are all scared silly about our energy bills this winter

Snugglemonkey · 07/09/2022 13:25

Endlesssummer2022 · 07/09/2022 11:25

People who support removal of the act are weapons grade dumb. The act covers key items from the right to marry who we want to the right to privacy.

Of course those in power who want to get rid of it will focus on terrorists in order to win support because they know the clapping seals won’t read what the act covers and believe they will be fine. They will support initiatives which will see their own children starve in order to spite foreigners.

They are. And they vote! They are the same morons who believed slogans on buses about Brexit saving the NHS etc. I do not believe in democracy any more sadly. There are too many utter imbeciles.

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 13:25

The ECHR was the target of a dirty protest by a group called Pissed Off Trannies yesterday. They were protesting against the EHRC's ruling on women's rights to single sex spaces. Do not open the link if you're eating lunch. www.vice.com/en/article/jgpj5y/pissed-off-trannies-ehrc-protest

ODFOx · 07/09/2022 13:23

Bill of Human Rights Bill has been pulled from second reading for a full review and rewrite.
Thank Goodness! A bill that allowed so many caveats was ripe for abuse.

TeaKlaxon · 07/09/2022 13:22

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 10:41

Human rights aren't ever afforded to victims of murder, for instance, so I couldn't care less about it.

That's not actually true though.

The right to life implies certain positive obligations on the State. These include obligations to conduct an investigation into an unlawful death, notify potential victims if the state becomes aware of threats to their life (Osman warnings). These rights derive from the ECHR.

Snugglemonkey · 07/09/2022 13:20

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 10:41

Human rights aren't ever afforded to victims of murder, for instance, so I couldn't care less about it.

You will when your rights are being violated and there is no recourse. There will always be individuals who commit horrible acts, but the removal of the human rights act will leave us open to violations by the state. Do you trust that the government will only use that for good?

meditrina · 07/09/2022 13:18

bibliomania · 07/09/2022 13:10

The European Court of HR issues legally binding judgements; the UN treaty bodies (Committee against Torture etc) do not. Anyone who thinks domestic or UN mechanisms are equivalent does not fully understand the law.

indeed. you need to look at how each country has ratified it and incorporated it into their laws.

Anyone who omits to mention the domestic law that flows from the treaty obligations is either ignorant of how treaty obligations are carried out, or is seeking to misrepresent

Twiggywinkle13 · 07/09/2022 13:18

Of course it’s concerning - it’s bloody terrifying.

Also, I don’t know why it’s quite so hard to grasp but the bottom line is we either all have human rights or none of us have - just because you don’t ‘want’ certain people to have human rights doesn’t mean you should scrap the whole thing and lose the rights yourself - talk about cutting your nose to spite your face.

rubbleonthedoub · 07/09/2022 13:16

What have the ECHR and ECtHR ever done for us?
There have been several important cases that have gone to the ECtHR which have protected and advanced human rights in the UK.
Freedom of expression for the press comes from a case known as Sunday Times from 1979.
The decriminalisation of homosexual acts in Northern Ireland came about thanks to a case called Dudgeon from 1981.
A case called Smith and Grady made clear that banning LGBT+ people from serving in the Armed Forces breaches human rights.

BewareTheLibrarians · 07/09/2022 13:15

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 12:57

Well according to most on here, the UK would be devoid of any rights, if we depart from ECHR

Even more jaw dropping

It is a worry when the incoming Bill of Rights is described like this, (from the link on my last post about the incoming Bill of Rights being shelved):

“A senior govt source: "The bill [of rights] is a mess and its not going to come back in anything like its current form."

It doesn’t really fill anyone with confidence about their overall competence.

Swipe left for the next trending thread