Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think leaving the ECHR (European Court of Human Rights) is a cause for concern?

217 replies

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 10:25

On paper, the new Home Secretary, Suella Braverman, looks well qualified to understand the rule of law and flex her legal arm. She seems to be a competent lawyer (but being a good lawyer does not mean someone is also a ‘good person’).

I get that it’s easier for the government to win legal cases if they withdraw from the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). Change the rules of the games to make it easier to win the game. I get it. But I don’t agree in principle because it’s not in the spirit of the game or rule of law. Some rules put players at a disadvantage, but they’re rules for a reason (reasons that need consideration).

Why do the plans to take the UK out the ECHR sound worrying?

To me, it’s because human right laws were hard won (do people who support getting rid of human rights laws realise that or care?). Once lost it’ll be even harder to win back human rights laws (and they may never be re-won again). Losing human rights protections under the ECHR is a slippery slope imo. We’re all humans with vulnerabilities, so we all benefit from the enforcement of human rights laws under ECHR.

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 07/09/2022 16:44

bibliomania · 07/09/2022 15:58

Interesting thoughts, RedToothBrush! Cynical but true that it's politically useful to have the ECHR to blame for things.

twitter.com/RajivShah90/status/1567493045532213249

I was a spad in MOJ under Robert Buckland and, until yesterday, in the No 10 Policy Unit where I worked on constitutional issues for the past three years.

Thread on this important announcement [axing of the Bill of Rights]

TL;DR: This is great news but would be a mistake to see it from a left v right pov 1/

The ECHR and the Strasbourg Court create a number of difficulties for the UK, particularly in the field of immigration. But for better or for worse we are in the ECHR and subject to the jurisdiction of the Strasbourg Court and so we are bound by the judgments of that Court 2/

There is nothing that we can do on the domestic level to change the fact that we are bound by Strasbourg. The proposed Bill of Rights cannot do that. The only way to do so is to leave the ECHR
3/

Ultimately, the Bill of Rights sought to provide a domestic solution to a problem that only had an international solution. When you look at it, it has a number of provisions that look like red meat, but actually, it is a vegan steak 4/

Sadly, in this polarised political environment, many people have an interest in portraying things as being far more consequential than they are. So, lots of the activist groups and much of legal twitter talked about the Bill as if it was the worst possible thing 5/

This might have led the right to think that there was actually something consequential in the Bill. Reading the debates when the Bill was introduced that seemed to be the view of many tory MPs who thought that this would solve the small boats issue 6/

For example much has been made of cl 24 in light of the Rule 39 order stopping the Rwanda flight. But all this clause does is confirm that interim orders of the Strasbourg court are not automatically enforceable in domestic law. That's not new 7/

But - crucially - they remain binding in international law and that's why the UK complied with it and stopped the Rwanda flight. If cl 24 had been law none of that would have changed. So people who think that the Bill is necessary to deliver Rwanda would be disappointed 8/

Ultimately, this Bill would have been a political nightmare for the govt. It would have overpromised and underdelivered, the parliamentary passage would have been hell, and it would lead to very few gains for the government. 9/

Furthermore, it would mean that we would own it. When the deportation of a foreign national offender gets blocked it would no longer have because of 'Labour's Human Rights Act' but instead it would be because of the 'Tories Bill of Rights' 10/

So the issue is not whether you are a eurosceptic ERGer or a One Nationer, it is about whether you care about focusing the govt's limited political capital on effective reforms or whether something more cosmetic appeals 11/

To Liz Truss's credit, it looks like she wants to focus on effective reforms and so has wisely chosen to drop this Bill even if it might cause a backlash from the right of the party 12/

Make of that, what you will.

gatehouseoffleet · 07/09/2022 16:37

Leaving the ECHR would be a huge concern (and a breach of the GFA) but it is not happening. The Bill of Rights Act has been called in for review by the new government and insiders say it's dead. While I don't believe everything I read on Twitter, the info has been tweeted by reputable sources.

One little bit of good news. I hope.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 07/09/2022 16:34

The Brits wrote the ECHR

Not quite; it was created by the Council of Europe, and while at the time that was chaired by a Brit (David Maxwell) they didn't exactly shove him in a corner and leave it all up to him

Leafy3 · 07/09/2022 16:19

@Bubblebubblebah the UK has already been downgraded to an "emerging" country :/

I don't care which side of the centre line you sit on, our human rights must be protected at all costs.

There's a reason people fought for them for so long and so hard. And there's a reason why a few very rich people want to get rid of them- that it's for the good of the country is well-used lie.

OneTC · 07/09/2022 16:13

Interesting to think there are people who think that you can have too many human rights. They're not the kind of thing to wish away really.

Also worth considering that anything you give away now it's gone forever and whilst you may think this lot are okay the next government could consist of Darth Starmer and an army of gender fluid shocktroopers who will be more than happy to send you for reeducation, and it'll be inline with your "rights" as a citizen Grin

RudsyFarmer · 07/09/2022 16:08

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 10:55

As I found out last night, you can't go against the grain, without inviting a pile on. I totally agree with you.

Most people do agree. They just keep those opinions to themselves.

Bubblebubblebah · 07/09/2022 16:02

Honestly, do schools here not work with pupils on some critical thinking?

Times like these are when I am happy to have another passport to be able to bugger off when this turns into rightless 3rd world country😳
And prople don't care cause someone they don't like also has human rights. Good luck when you are the someone who doesn't deserve them in others' eyes....

bibliomania · 07/09/2022 15:58

Interesting thoughts, RedToothBrush! Cynical but true that it's politically useful to have the ECHR to blame for things.

Thenose · 07/09/2022 15:57

*unnecessary

JumpingPiglets · 07/09/2022 15:54

Victims of murder and their families are entitled to, and receive, protection under the ECHR.

Article 2 provides a right to life, giving right to a duty to investigate and an operational duty regarding certain types of safeguarding in certain circumstances.

A number of inquests engage this issue, and families receive compensation based upon it.

Thenose · 07/09/2022 15:52

PestorPeston · 07/09/2022 12:13

I think your degree may have been a poor investment. ECHR upholds the right to life.

Stop trying to score cheap points off someone's personal tragedy.

A better investment may also have prevented the OP from punishing readers with a confetti of unecessary commas.

Tinytinseltown · 07/09/2022 15:24

There are a lot of complete fcking imbeciles on here complaining about the ECHR when what they are most concerned about falls under the jurisdiction of domestic statute and common law. I am so sick of people with no understanding of the legal framework bitching about things of which they know nothing.

It happened with Brexit, and we saw it coming with this. FFS if you want to live in a country ‘free’ from the ECHR you’re very welcome to move to Belarus, currently the sole European country that is not a signatory. Good luck, fuck off.

BewareTheLibrarians · 07/09/2022 15:19

@caringcarer Really interesting that you should raise all those points that have previously been debunked on the Rwanda threads. So you know they’re not true, and yet…

Also really interesting that you’ve missed that the Rwandan government has only committed to taking 200 asylum seekers.

“Rwanda only has the capacity to accommodate 200 Channel migrants, its government officials said as they admitted they were powerless to stop people from leaving in order to return to the UK.

Yolande Makolo, a spokesman for the Rwandan government, said the country only had one hostel with 200 spaces that was “ready” to receive migrants from the UK.”

www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2022/07/22/rwanda-can-hold-just-200-channel-migrants-cant-stop-returning/

And where’s your proof that they’re all economic migrants? How does that explain why the government’s own Home Office assess 70-something% of arrivals as genuine asylum cases? Are you saying this government is completely incompetent? Do you know the procedure for assessing torture and slavery claims? Do you know why asylum seekers have higher incidences of slavery and torture? If you arrive in a safe country but cannot access housing, health care and education, does that mean it’s safe for you/your children?

Don’t panic, I’m not expecting any answers 😁

HowManyWaysAreThereToSayThatEverythingSucks · 07/09/2022 15:18

Yabu to think you might be unreasonable. Of course, it's hugely concerning.

I trust the ECHR more than the (current) British government to uphold Human rights. I don't want a watered down bill of rights.

Human rights exist to protect us from the arbitrary powers of the state. All of us. it doesn't matter if you are a potential terrorist, criminal or just someone the government doesn't like. We have them by virtue of being human. Anything else and you are on a very slippery slope of only being protected based on what a populist government likes to do. You just need to have a passion grasp of history to understand how vital they are in protecting us.

KrisAkabusi · 07/09/2022 15:12

If they are slaves we should free them from slave masters and send them to safety in Rwanda.

And what if they're not safe in Rwanda? It hasn't got the greatest human rights record.

SheeWeee · 07/09/2022 15:08

lollipoprainbow · 07/09/2022 14:42

, ALL humans deserve human rights.

Some really really don't .

Yes, they do. That's why they are called HUMAN rights/

caringcarer · 07/09/2022 15:06

I'm with Suella in this one. Immigrants coming from France are not slaves. Yet they use Human Rights 4 Freedom from slavery to resist being sent back to Rwanda. They are economic migrants and once they reach a safe country they should stop as no longer in danger. Instead they claim they are slaves. If they are slaves we should free them from slave masters and send them to safely in Rwanda.

RedToothBrush · 07/09/2022 14:59

Harry Cole AT mrharrycole
EXC: Cabinet agreed to shelve Raab’s British Bill of Rights designed to protect against meddling ECHR in Strasbourg, The Sun can reveal.

It was due back in Commons next week.

New PM risks major blowback after delaying the second reading of the legislation - which was due on 12 September.

A senior govt source: "The bill is a mess and its not going to come back in anything like its current form ."

But much vaunted plan to make the Supreme Court in London ultimate decision-maker on human rights issues – not the ECHR in Strasbourg - now risks running out of time now before the end of the Parliament.

Officially it will be reviewed but opponents say its dead.

DH and I have had a long conversation about Truss's Cabinet over lunch. The people she has put into Cabinet are interesting as they are probably more competent than both May's and Johnson's. This doesn't mean I like them nor that I agree with their ideology but it's worth keeping an eye on. This COULD make them more worrying as a right wing government, or it could be a good sign

What I find fascinating is that whilst there may be the focus on the right wing nut jobs that are Mogg and Braverman you also have much more sane choices in Jake Berry and Tungendhat in there too. It's much more broad than Johnson’s Cabinet and I'd argue her choices seem much more thought out. If the Bill of Rights is killed off that's also the Rwanda plan dead.

This also opens up an interesting paradox. If you keep the ECHR you have something to blame at the election for immigration. Labour's ECHR. If you put in the bill of rights and its still a fucking farce over Rwanda you cannot blame someone else for the mess. It could be a political gambit for seeking reelection.

But in the short-term I have to say this action would kill off a lot of my immediate concerns about Braverman and the axing of the ECHR.

My first thought on Truss is she could prove more interesting and canny than I had anticipated. I shall reserve judgement but its a really interesting move if this is indeed true.

Keep your eyes on it for developments. It could be more revealing than you think.

lollipoprainbow · 07/09/2022 14:42

, ALL humans deserve human rights.

Some really really don't .

RedToothBrush · 07/09/2022 14:37

If what im reading is right Truss has put in Bauverman but axed the British Bill of Rights. If the latter is true, I'm a lot less concerned as that would suggest a commitment by the back door to the ECHR.

TeaKlaxon · 07/09/2022 14:24

ChimneyPot · 07/09/2022 14:01

I think you meant “seems to care” rather than “seems to be aware”

Those who seem certain that their rights as citizens won’t be at risk by leaving the ECHR don’t seem to be aware that it is often British citizens who have had to use the ECHR to vindicate their human rights against a government that would prefer to ignore them.

Probably both.

There does seem to be a significant overlap between people who want to leave the ECHR and those who either don't know or don't care about the risk of resuming what was essentially a civil war within the UK until 25 years ago.

balalake · 07/09/2022 14:19

Perhaps it would be easier for justice to be done if the courts were properly funded and there were not long delays. Ryan Giggs and those accusing him of coercive behaviour and other offences have to wait until next summer for justice to be done, for example.

The ECHR not only ensures justice, but also the number of cases which the government does not 'get its own way' are very few as a result.

Leafy3 · 07/09/2022 14:04

The point is that the way you can legitimately ensure a law abiding person has fair rights to justice, is to ensure all people have those rights.

It ensures that everyone has an unbiased trial.

It's absolutely essential to individual freedom and democracy.

ChimneyPot · 07/09/2022 14:01

TeaKlaxon · 07/09/2022 13:42

Incidentally, not a single person advocating leaving the ECHR seems to be aware that it would also mean tearing up the Good Friday Agreement.

I think you meant “seems to care” rather than “seems to be aware”

Those who seem certain that their rights as citizens won’t be at risk by leaving the ECHR don’t seem to be aware that it is often British citizens who have had to use the ECHR to vindicate their human rights against a government that would prefer to ignore them.

SheeWeee · 07/09/2022 13:53

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 10:54

I don't like the idea of terrorists having human rights, if that helps.

IT doesn't help at all.

What about people accused of terrorism, do you want them to have human rights?

Heres a hint, ALL humans deserve human rights.

Swipe left for the next trending thread