Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think leaving the ECHR (European Court of Human Rights) is a cause for concern?

217 replies

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 10:25

On paper, the new Home Secretary, Suella Braverman, looks well qualified to understand the rule of law and flex her legal arm. She seems to be a competent lawyer (but being a good lawyer does not mean someone is also a ‘good person’).

I get that it’s easier for the government to win legal cases if they withdraw from the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). Change the rules of the games to make it easier to win the game. I get it. But I don’t agree in principle because it’s not in the spirit of the game or rule of law. Some rules put players at a disadvantage, but they’re rules for a reason (reasons that need consideration).

Why do the plans to take the UK out the ECHR sound worrying?

To me, it’s because human right laws were hard won (do people who support getting rid of human rights laws realise that or care?). Once lost it’ll be even harder to win back human rights laws (and they may never be re-won again). Losing human rights protections under the ECHR is a slippery slope imo. We’re all humans with vulnerabilities, so we all benefit from the enforcement of human rights laws under ECHR.

OP posts:
LexMitior · 07/09/2022 19:50

PetraBP · 07/09/2022 18:55

It’s so the Tories can have a referendum on bringing back the death penalty.

You heard it here first.

Grow up. That is such a fringe attitude amongst politicians that no one would support it. General public like hanging, mind

LakieLady · 07/09/2022 19:48

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 10:54

I don't like the idea of terrorists having human rights, if that helps.

That would have been tough for the Guildford Four, the Birmingham Six, the Maguire Seven and Judith Ward, all of whom were wrongly convicted of terrorist offences and locked up for years.

Unless and until we have 100% foolproof legal system, imo it's wrong to deny basic rights to convicted criminals. Their loss of liberty is the punishment for their deeds.

BeenToldComputerSaysNo · 07/09/2022 19:43

Agree OP. I find it concerning. It fits with this govt's style of pushing for more power, whilst fighting against accountability for its actions.

LakieLady · 07/09/2022 19:39

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 10:41

Human rights aren't ever afforded to victims of murder, for instance, so I couldn't care less about it.

Wow, that's a weird take on this. Thankfully, very few people become victims of murder, but all of us should be entitled to fundamental human rights. It's a cornerstone of a civilised and democratic society.

How would a murder victim exercise their human rights if they had them?

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 19:31

@Bubblebubblebah “It is easier to escape the rules when you make them and to prosecution if your mates are still up there. Or at least that's what they think.....”

Easier to think they can escape the rule of law. Precarious position. Pride comes before the fall…

That complacency has a way of biting people on the bum.

Like that time the Prime Minister was fined for Partygate.

OP posts:
Bubblebubblebah · 07/09/2022 19:25

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 19:18

Except Suella Braverman and her part of society are still vulnerable as human beings and are not above the law (although they may feel like it). They may think they’re shielded but may need the ECHR just as much as an ordinary human.

Which human doesn’t need the right to protection from torture and inhuman treatment?

Which articles in the ECHR would Suella Braverman not want for herself and her part of society?

The golden rule would really help here. Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. Equality, fairness and justice. Basic principles…

It is easier to escape the rules when you make them and to prosecution if your mates are still up there. Or at least that's what they think.....

They shouldn't want rights erosion, no one should. Anyone with law degree (and tbh even without it because it is quite logical)should understand the basic of Rule of law and why rights are needed and NOT to be distributed sporadically based on "I don't think you deserve them atm babes"

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 19:23

Christmascaroll · 07/09/2022 19:20

Banned from practicing in America though

Why was she banned?

OP posts:
WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 19:22

*socio-economic

OP posts:
WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 19:22

Echobelly · 07/09/2022 19:04

YANBU - last year I read The Secret Barrister's first book where he makes the excellent point that it is never in the public's interest for people to have fewer rights. The government and the media like to frame these things are preventing some or other outrageous-sounding thing (eg 'Prisoner got legal aid to sue for uncomfortable blanket!') which is either totally untrue or massively distorted. This is great until you or your family or anyone with a totally legitimate grievance needs legal aid, or to launch a claim for racial discrimination or whatever thing the government has made harder or taken away as a right.

I don't doubt this government wants US-style 'Your employer owns you' style working arrangements - they'll frame it as because people are 'lazy' and 'unproductive' and somehow removing their rights is supposed to make them more motivated (IIRC, research shows workers with fewer rights are less motivated). Also the UK's productivity metrics, which they are always complaining are so low, are totally outdated because they are based on a 'producing widgets' economy, which we haven't been for years, and don't take account of digital productivity and the knowledge economy, that are actually pretty productive. But 'The party of business' apparently doesn't understand this.

The Secret Barrister books are brilliant. More people should read them to understand how the law works and the impact of politics and sociology-economic factors on the law.

The media has a lot to answer for turning people against their own interests.

OP posts:
PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 07/09/2022 19:20

YANBU - last year I read The Secret Barrister's first book where he makes the excellent point that it is never in the public's interest for people to have fewer rights.

Yep.

Christmascaroll · 07/09/2022 19:20

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 10:36

On paper she has good academics.

“Law at Queens’ College, Cambridge. She later gained a master’s degree in Law from the Panthéon-Sorbonne in Paris and then qualified as a New York attorney.

Banned from practicing in America though

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 19:18

Bubblebubblebah · 07/09/2022 19:03

Actually I take that.... But! Counterargument.
She doesn't care because it won't touch her part of society. It will be ordinary people, not shielded rich ones. The ordinary who are in here thinking that it's totes fine to not have secured human rights.

I kind of want to know how many of them moan about Qatar football....

Except Suella Braverman and her part of society are still vulnerable as human beings and are not above the law (although they may feel like it). They may think they’re shielded but may need the ECHR just as much as an ordinary human.

Which human doesn’t need the right to protection from torture and inhuman treatment?

Which articles in the ECHR would Suella Braverman not want for herself and her part of society?

The golden rule would really help here. Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. Equality, fairness and justice. Basic principles…

OP posts:
WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 19:05

isadoradancing123 · 07/09/2022 18:52

Not a concern at all, far too many people have abused the system,

Bold claim.

Did the newspaper tell you that or have you got some actual experience or evidence to back this up?

Newspapers are in the business of selling stories, not the whole truth.

OP posts:
Echobelly · 07/09/2022 19:04

YANBU - last year I read The Secret Barrister's first book where he makes the excellent point that it is never in the public's interest for people to have fewer rights. The government and the media like to frame these things are preventing some or other outrageous-sounding thing (eg 'Prisoner got legal aid to sue for uncomfortable blanket!') which is either totally untrue or massively distorted. This is great until you or your family or anyone with a totally legitimate grievance needs legal aid, or to launch a claim for racial discrimination or whatever thing the government has made harder or taken away as a right.

I don't doubt this government wants US-style 'Your employer owns you' style working arrangements - they'll frame it as because people are 'lazy' and 'unproductive' and somehow removing their rights is supposed to make them more motivated (IIRC, research shows workers with fewer rights are less motivated). Also the UK's productivity metrics, which they are always complaining are so low, are totally outdated because they are based on a 'producing widgets' economy, which we haven't been for years, and don't take account of digital productivity and the knowledge economy, that are actually pretty productive. But 'The party of business' apparently doesn't understand this.

Bubblebubblebah · 07/09/2022 19:03

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 19:00

Suella Braverman has a law degree from a prestigious institution. So… I no longer know what to expect tbh.

Actually I take that.... But! Counterargument.
She doesn't care because it won't touch her part of society. It will be ordinary people, not shielded rich ones. The ordinary who are in here thinking that it's totes fine to not have secured human rights.

I kind of want to know how many of them moan about Qatar football....

TeaKlaxon · 07/09/2022 19:01

isadoradancing123 · 07/09/2022 18:52

Not a concern at all, far too many people have abused the system,

You have no concern about ripping up the Good Friday Agreement?

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 19:00

Bubblebubblebah · 07/09/2022 18:48

Ha. As if anyone with law degree would produce arguments like here🙈

Suella Braverman has a law degree from a prestigious institution. So… I no longer know what to expect tbh.

OP posts:
PetraBP · 07/09/2022 18:55

It’s so the Tories can have a referendum on bringing back the death penalty.

You heard it here first.

isadoradancing123 · 07/09/2022 18:52

Not a concern at all, far too many people have abused the system,

LexMitior · 07/09/2022 18:50

RedToothBrush · 07/09/2022 16:44

twitter.com/RajivShah90/status/1567493045532213249

I was a spad in MOJ under Robert Buckland and, until yesterday, in the No 10 Policy Unit where I worked on constitutional issues for the past three years.

Thread on this important announcement [axing of the Bill of Rights]

TL;DR: This is great news but would be a mistake to see it from a left v right pov 1/

The ECHR and the Strasbourg Court create a number of difficulties for the UK, particularly in the field of immigration. But for better or for worse we are in the ECHR and subject to the jurisdiction of the Strasbourg Court and so we are bound by the judgments of that Court 2/

There is nothing that we can do on the domestic level to change the fact that we are bound by Strasbourg. The proposed Bill of Rights cannot do that. The only way to do so is to leave the ECHR
3/

Ultimately, the Bill of Rights sought to provide a domestic solution to a problem that only had an international solution. When you look at it, it has a number of provisions that look like red meat, but actually, it is a vegan steak 4/

Sadly, in this polarised political environment, many people have an interest in portraying things as being far more consequential than they are. So, lots of the activist groups and much of legal twitter talked about the Bill as if it was the worst possible thing 5/

This might have led the right to think that there was actually something consequential in the Bill. Reading the debates when the Bill was introduced that seemed to be the view of many tory MPs who thought that this would solve the small boats issue 6/

For example much has been made of cl 24 in light of the Rule 39 order stopping the Rwanda flight. But all this clause does is confirm that interim orders of the Strasbourg court are not automatically enforceable in domestic law. That's not new 7/

But - crucially - they remain binding in international law and that's why the UK complied with it and stopped the Rwanda flight. If cl 24 had been law none of that would have changed. So people who think that the Bill is necessary to deliver Rwanda would be disappointed 8/

Ultimately, this Bill would have been a political nightmare for the govt. It would have overpromised and underdelivered, the parliamentary passage would have been hell, and it would lead to very few gains for the government. 9/

Furthermore, it would mean that we would own it. When the deportation of a foreign national offender gets blocked it would no longer have because of 'Labour's Human Rights Act' but instead it would be because of the 'Tories Bill of Rights' 10/

So the issue is not whether you are a eurosceptic ERGer or a One Nationer, it is about whether you care about focusing the govt's limited political capital on effective reforms or whether something more cosmetic appeals 11/

To Liz Truss's credit, it looks like she wants to focus on effective reforms and so has wisely chosen to drop this Bill even if it might cause a backlash from the right of the party 12/

Make of that, what you will.

What this means is the "Bill of Rights" is deader than a dead thing. There are plenty of Tories who support no change and so don't expect Raab's "solution in search of a problem" (thanks Robert Buckland) to re-emerge.

Bubblebubblebah · 07/09/2022 18:48

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 18:36

What was your first degree? Law or International Law or (International) Politics?

Ha. As if anyone with law degree would produce arguments like here🙈

LexMitior · 07/09/2022 18:46

Puzzledandpissedoff · 07/09/2022 16:34

The Brits wrote the ECHR

Not quite; it was created by the Council of Europe, and while at the time that was chaired by a Brit (David Maxwell) they didn't exactly shove him in a corner and leave it all up to him

It was written by English government lawyers, not the Council of Europe. They certainly had some useful suggestions but they didn't draft the text. I find ironic the UK complains about it.

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 18:36

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 11:48

Unfortunately, European Law, was part of my first degree. I am aware of its mechanism. I remember the laborious task of learning each Article.

What was your first degree? Law or International Law or (International) Politics?

OP posts:
Sirius3030 · 07/09/2022 16:59

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 11:16

Of course all of our rights will be affected. However, I would rather see rights being protected on an individual or common sense basis. It sticks in my throat to see a monster, who has carried out a heinous crime, to use the ECHR to get pity, aka justice.

This isn’t how law works.

bibliomania · 07/09/2022 16:50

That makes sense.