Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think leaving the ECHR (European Court of Human Rights) is a cause for concern?

217 replies

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 10:25

On paper, the new Home Secretary, Suella Braverman, looks well qualified to understand the rule of law and flex her legal arm. She seems to be a competent lawyer (but being a good lawyer does not mean someone is also a ‘good person’).

I get that it’s easier for the government to win legal cases if they withdraw from the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). Change the rules of the games to make it easier to win the game. I get it. But I don’t agree in principle because it’s not in the spirit of the game or rule of law. Some rules put players at a disadvantage, but they’re rules for a reason (reasons that need consideration).

Why do the plans to take the UK out the ECHR sound worrying?

To me, it’s because human right laws were hard won (do people who support getting rid of human rights laws realise that or care?). Once lost it’ll be even harder to win back human rights laws (and they may never be re-won again). Losing human rights protections under the ECHR is a slippery slope imo. We’re all humans with vulnerabilities, so we all benefit from the enforcement of human rights laws under ECHR.

OP posts:
eastegg · 08/09/2022 09:36

Leafy3 · 07/09/2022 22:32

Well you know that's theory that cases don't get as far as court unless the criminal is actually guilty, so I imagine lots of people really wouldn't care!

Do you share that view, Leafy3? Don’t dignify it with the word ‘theory’. It’s a silly nonsense with no basis in legal reality.

TeaKlaxon · 08/09/2022 09:13

ProfessorSlocombe · 08/09/2022 08:46

NI would have had to be exempt from any changes as the Belfast Agreement explicitly requires the oversight of the ECHR.

www.dfa.ie/media/dfa/alldfawebsitemedia/ourrolesandpolicies/northernireland/good-friday-agreement.pdf

with the US pressure already piling on, it's hard to see how a move like this would have helped.

It’s telling that not a single person advocating leaving the ECHR has even tried to address the Northern Ireland issue.

ProfessorSlocombe · 08/09/2022 08:46

NI would have had to be exempt from any changes as the Belfast Agreement explicitly requires the oversight of the ECHR.

www.dfa.ie/media/dfa/alldfawebsitemedia/ourrolesandpolicies/northernireland/good-friday-agreement.pdf

with the US pressure already piling on, it's hard to see how a move like this would have helped.

Echobelly · 08/09/2022 08:23

I know of at least one 'TERRORIST'-headlined story about human rights where the man in question was actually totally innocent, but was arrested along with a family member who wasn't. But that didn't stop the DM claiming he was terrorist and misrepresenting what his claim was about - they focused on I think 36 hours of detention that was carried out against the letter of the law when his claim was also about weeks of sleep deprivation and other inhumane treatment.

I'm sure leaving ECHR will be trumpeted as a victory for Brexit (despite it being co-founded by the UK and being nothing to do with the EU) and 'Making our own laws', which we've always been able to do. What it is there for is a higher power to appeal to when our laws get it wrong. Slow handclap for the people who are cheering the removal of that.

Bubblebubblebah · 08/09/2022 08:00

Rights come with responsibilities. If people are irresponsible, they don't deserve the same rights as those that are.

I think the rights should be first stripped of the ones supporting it as a test trial. Then they should be forced back to school.

Just an fyi, you also have responsibilities that come without rights. Like i have to pay taxes, or i go to jail, but I am not allowed to vote. I have all responsibilities of british citizen, yet I don't have all thet rights.

If people think they can just decide when and what rights someone can loose, you couold also argue thfat people can then decide what laws apply to them and when.

Well you know that's theory that cases don't get as far as court unless the criminal is actually guilty, so I imagine lots of people really wouldn't care!
Here is a catch. It's also about due process. They could actually change it that the case doesn't have to go to trial and person goes straight to jail. It includes even bits like arrest when you have to be informed properly etc. Denying legal representation from the beginning would fall under as well. Lastly, another right is presumed innocent until found guilty, not until trial starts. You are not guilty at that point, there is just enough evidence to bring it to trial.

Looks like people are happy to give the rights up because they don't seem to know what they are.

SunscreenCentral · 07/09/2022 23:27

I would view the UK stepping away from the ECHR much the same way as I do the overturn of Roe v. Wade in the US.

Deeply concerning.
Doesn't affect me or mine thankfully but it is very worrying

Blossomtoes · 07/09/2022 23:24

Bubblebubblebah · 07/09/2022 21:43

First they came.... Springs to mind actually

It does. So does boiling a frog. I’m bloody glad I’m old and the effect on me will be minimal.

Devilishpyjamas · 07/09/2022 23:20

Human right are about protecting you / everyone - from the State. It’s not just the daily Mail crap about terrorists & prisoners. When my severely disabled son was carted off 380 miles from us with 2 hours notice (yes it did happen) - due to lack of resources locally it was the Human Rights Act that was his greatest protection. He’d never been away from me for more than 2 days before & the NHS ignored their own codes of practice. It was the HRA protections and the joint parliamentary committee for human rights using his case as an example of what not to do that meant the NHS changed (eventually) what they were doing.

So of course human rights are Important. The ERG who are now in charge have always been against the little people having too many rights. We’re in for a rocky ride for the next two years

eastegg · 07/09/2022 23:19

Sorry, just realised Stagg wasn’t actually convicted but lost a chunk of his life to a wrongful accusation. I could have used lots of other examples. The point stands.

TooBigForMyBoots · 07/09/2022 23:16

LexMitior · 07/09/2022 19:50

Grow up. That is such a fringe attitude amongst politicians that no one would support it. General public like hanging, mind

They said that about Brexit.🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

eastegg · 07/09/2022 23:14

Florenz · 07/09/2022 22:42

Too many criminals/terrorists etc have been able to hide behind/go running to the ECHR that it's given "human rights" a bad name.

Rights come with responsibilities. If people are irresponsible, they don't deserve the same rights as those that are.

How do you separate out the responsible from the irresponsible without having a fair system for doing so? Without, essentially, human rights? And if you say well, take them away at the point when it is proved, by due process and to a high standard, that they they are bad people, what about, as pps have mentioned, the Judith Wards, the Colin Staggs etc, who turned out to have been wrongfully convicted? Miscarriages of justice prove that human rights have to be for everyone at all times.

BewareTheLibrarians · 07/09/2022 23:09

@Florenz too many criminals and terrorists? Do you know how many, or is that Daily Mail headlines at work again?

This list on the ECHR’s impact on criminal cases is quite enlightening. Was this the kind of thing you mean? Abu Qatada makes the list. I assume people are aware he was deported to Jordan to face trial there. Abu Hamza isn’t on this list, but was extradited to the US (actually backed by the ECtHR) where he’s in prison.

files.justice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/06170745/Human-Rights-Act-and-criminal-justice-system.docx

PestorPeston · 07/09/2022 23:01

@Florenz only about a dozen cases a year make it to ECHR

They are available on-line, maybe you could reference the ones you disapprove of.

Florenz · 07/09/2022 22:42

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 22:11

Apt.

It is interesting how so many people buy into what the media feeds them without questioning what they’re consuming.

Does the media realise that with great power comes great responsibility?!

Too many criminals/terrorists etc have been able to hide behind/go running to the ECHR that it's given "human rights" a bad name.

Rights come with responsibilities. If people are irresponsible, they don't deserve the same rights as those that are.

BewareTheLibrarians · 07/09/2022 22:41

@WakeUpAndBeAwesome Certain sections of the media are utterly complicit - Emily Maitlis’s recents comments feel really relevant here.

“The former Newsnight presenter highlighted the role of Sir Robbie Gibb, who previously worked as Theresa May’s director of communications and helped to found the rightwing GB News channel.
Last year he was appointed to the BBC’s board by Boris Johnson’s government and has since influenced a series of ongoing reviews of the broadcaster’s editorial output.”
”Maitlis warned that the traditional media is becoming increasingly afraid to stand up for itself in an era where “facts are getting lost, constitutional norms trashed, claims frequently unchallenged”.”

amp.theguardian.com/media/2022/aug/24/emily-maitlis-says-active-tory-party-agent-shaping-bbc-news-output

I mean, it’s not surprising, but a worrying number of people won’t realise that they’re being spoonfed Tory-friendly news rather than an unbiased agenda.

Leafy3 · 07/09/2022 22:32

eastegg · 07/09/2022 21:50

What if you or someone you cared about was wrongly accused of murder? Would you care about the (human) right to a fair trial?

Well you know that's theory that cases don't get as far as court unless the criminal is actually guilty, so I imagine lots of people really wouldn't care!

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 22:11

Bubblebubblebah · 07/09/2022 21:43

First they came.... Springs to mind actually

Apt.

It is interesting how so many people buy into what the media feeds them without questioning what they’re consuming.

Does the media realise that with great power comes great responsibility?!

OP posts:
eastegg · 07/09/2022 21:50

Culldesack · 07/09/2022 10:41

Human rights aren't ever afforded to victims of murder, for instance, so I couldn't care less about it.

What if you or someone you cared about was wrongly accused of murder? Would you care about the (human) right to a fair trial?

Bubblebubblebah · 07/09/2022 21:43

First they came.... Springs to mind actually

Gilead · 07/09/2022 21:41

Jeez, the knee jerk reactions of people who don’t want to afford others human rights is terrifying.

TeaKlaxon · 07/09/2022 21:30

sst1234 · 07/09/2022 21:25

What protection are you worried about losing by exiting ECHR? What do you think will happen if we did? Locked in our homes? Oh, sorry that already happened even with the glorious ECHR.

How about the tearing up of the Good Friday Agreement? Is that a price worth paying?

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 21:29

sst1234 · 07/09/2022 21:25

What protection are you worried about losing by exiting ECHR? What do you think will happen if we did? Locked in our homes? Oh, sorry that already happened even with the glorious ECHR.

I ask you the same question. Take your pick from the list that @PestorPeston posted upthread:

the right to life (Article 2)
freedom from torture (Article 3)
freedom from slavery (Article 4)
the right to liberty (Article 5)
the right to a fair trial (Article 6)
the right not to be punished for something that wasn’t against the law at the time (Article 7)
the right to respect for family and private life (Article 8)
freedom of thought, conscience and religion (Article 9)
freedom of expression (Article 10)
freedom of assembly (Article 11)
the right to marry and start a family (Article 12)
the right not to be discriminated against in respect of these rights (Article 14)
the right to protection of property (Protocol 1, Article 1)
the right to education (Protocol 1, Article 2)
the right to participate in free elections (Protocol 1, Article 3)
the abolition of the death penalty (Protocol 13)

OP posts:
sst1234 · 07/09/2022 21:25

What protection are you worried about losing by exiting ECHR? What do you think will happen if we did? Locked in our homes? Oh, sorry that already happened even with the glorious ECHR.

eastegg · 07/09/2022 21:09

I strongly urge anybody, before coming to a conclusion about what Braverman or any other politician says about this subject, to read Fake Law by the Secret Barrister, or at least the section on human rights.

They explain it much better than I can, but basically people like Braverman, and before her Raab, are lawyers, arguably perfectly clever, competent ones, who deliberately and cynically misrepresent aspects of the law and the legal system, exploiting and encouraging misinformation and ignorance about it, to further their own ends, and those ends are to gain political support. They care not one jot about what is fair, right or makes legal sense. They just want to be popular.

In the process, there is invariably a scapegoat employed as part of the misinformation; in the case of human rights, a big one here is terrorists and other heinous criminals and we are encouraged to believe that HR help them and not us. All a load of atrocious bollocks.

WakeUpAndBeAwesome · 07/09/2022 20:25

@LakieLady Checks and balances are important… ECHR seems to serve this function. Without it then what do we have?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread