Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest DP gets a degree

62 replies

Hooploop · 07/09/2022 08:50

DP doesn't have A levels and didn't go to uni. But he's very intelligent and articulate, a bit of a geek actually, and just hated school/education system. He's done well in his career and made it to a senior job in an industry which usually requires a degree as standard. He has 10 years of experience in this industry and is genuinely good at what he does (I used to work with him, that's how we met).

Earlier this year he was made redundant, along with 5 colleagues, and is struggling to get another job. The job market seems to be great for most people at the moment - his laid off colleagues have all got great new jobs, some earning double their previous salary.

He's getting interviews for senior roles at some great organisations (possibly because his last company is a household name, very respected) but not progressing past final interviews. He was offered one role but for £15k a year less than what he was earning previously. I suspect part of it is because he doesn't have a degree.

AIBU to suggest he actually gets a qualification? He's been unemployed for 5 months now, is getting down about it, and his redundancy pay is running out. Just for background, I have a degree and have always been the higher earner.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sundayvibeswig22 · 07/09/2022 14:18

Why didn't he take the job at 15k less? Better to be in a job. How much of a drop was this if his other told was very senior?

redferrari · 07/09/2022 13:48

A few colleagues and myself were made redundant in 2011. The first person to find another job in that group was one without a degree. She had 12 years experience and is v knowledgeable despite no formal degrees. So it's possible. I think a pp's suggestion to ask feedback is the best idea. I did contracting for slightly lesser amount to get back into the industry and was able to network and my work itself was a testimony rather than interview process.

Testina · 07/09/2022 13:30

It’s not his lack of a degree if he’s getting to final interview. Better off with interview coaching I expect. Why did he turn down the other job? For how long is he planning to hold out for a higher paid one than that offer?

mondaytosunday · 07/09/2022 13:26

Who would care about a degree if he has ten years experience? And how would getting a degree help in the immediate future? And how would you pay for it?

Sparkletastic · 07/09/2022 13:13

Much more likely to be his interview skills than his lack of a degree.

KILM · 07/09/2022 12:33

Depends on sector but im in tech and past entry level degrees become irrelevant, i would be very surprised if this was the issue. Is he asking for feedback of interviews and when he's getting rejections? Is he doing any interview prep with contacts in the industry where he can get feedback on his aproach?

CanThisBe · 07/09/2022 11:36

If he's progressing in interviews it can't all be about the degree, but despite it being possible, theoretically, to do my job without a degree, I don't think I'd have got it without one.

Also, I know that the last company DH worked for doesn't recruit non graduates to that post anymore. DH did really well without a degree, but I think he'd struggle in the same industry now.

Call0fthecows · 07/09/2022 11:32

His friends that he used to work with, do any of their companies offer a " refer a friend scheme " to get him a job ?

Has he been networking with his past contacts ?

Is he on LinkedIn ?

I agree take a lower job to gain entry into a company & move jobs internally

Do all this before a degree

smileandsing · 07/09/2022 11:27

His experience will count for far more than a degree could now. Do you seriously want him to spend years out of the workplace achieving a qualification that won't make much difference to his employability? He's getting interviews, so it's not that which is holding him back. What feedback is he getting from these? Why didn't he try to negotiate the salary up and take the job that paid less than his previous role but far more than his current unemployment does?

edwinbear · 07/09/2022 11:17

He should really take the lower paid job. The longer he is out of work, the lower any potential offers will be, because employers know he's been out of work for a while so not in a strong negotiation position. Once he's back in work, he can decide whether to study part time, focus on promotions etc, but his priority needs to be getting back into his industry, even at a lower salary.

Jaxhog · 07/09/2022 11:13

He should ask for feedback from his interviews. That will give him better information about whether a degree is holding him back or not. Maybe he just needs better interview preparation.

Taking time out to do a degree is a very big financial commitment, and doing a degree through the OU is a massive commitment - I know, I've done it.

DarkShade · 07/09/2022 11:08

If you can afford it, he can start an online parttime degree (like those with the open university) and then under education he can list the degree and say '2022-present' or 'currently undergoing' or whatever. It will also help these months not be a waste. People will glance at it and see that he is capable of doing one, they might even think he has a degree if they don't look at the dates properly, if it comes up he can point out that his CV says clearly he's still doing it.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 07/09/2022 10:56

aftonwater · 07/09/2022 09:11

Absolutely do not lie about having a degree on a CV.

If you seriously beleive it is lack of degree...

Would he do an experiment...

  1. Send his usual CV...
  1. Send a usual CV BUT slightly disguised re school/prev job role...)so it's not evident its the same as #1, different name /dob /address..and ADD a degree...

Abd see if pretend person gets a better response?

Not for him to proceed with a faked CV.. As thus is fraud...!

But just so you know

Another thought... Is it anything to do with interview prep/performance...

Dobyou know the successful candidates..? Were they similar to your OH but with a degree?

If I were recruiting - if all other things were equal... I may well decide on someone with a degree... Hust it's a more 'even' background...

SalviaOfficinalis · 07/09/2022 10:49

AchatAVendre · 07/09/2022 10:23

Thats just not correct. He might be getting invited to interviews based on his experience on his cv but failing to impress because employers prefer candidates with degrees for a whole host of reasons. They are giving him a chance but not saying a degree isn't required simply by interviewing him. The jobs market can be really competitive at the moment, and not having a degree scores you lower than candidates with a degree. It depends far more heavily on what other candidates they have to choose from.

You don’t agree, that’s fine, it doesn’t mean my opinion is “not correct”.
Unless I was giving clearly false or dangerous advice there’s no need to mark my homework!

NovaDeltas · 07/09/2022 10:43

No, complete waste of money. Is he in tech? No one gives a shite about degrees and a lot of developers, including senior and lead, are self taught or have degrees in other subjects. Experience is all that matters.

He needs to keep at it and ensure his soft skills are decent. It's not just about coding or tech stuff, it's about coming across as a friendly person you can work with. That's usually where developers go awry.

larry4PM · 07/09/2022 10:42

I work in a senior role and have always had to prove any qualifications I claim to have - screening is typical of senior roles to make sure you're not a massive liar, like the previous poster recommended he try to be! Stupid idea.

If he's got 10 years of experience where he's moved up the ranks (i.e. he's not been in a junior role for 10 years with zero progression), he's probably reached the point in his career where he's deemed to have equivalent experience and a degree will add nothing.

You're not unreasonable to suggest he does something with his time after redundancy - a short course, volunteering, etc - but you are unreasonable to tell him to go to uni. Especially seeing as he doesn't even have A-Levels. Just because a degree worked for you doesn't mean it's relevant to his path.

He's getting the interviews, so he could do with some help with interview practice. I doubt he would want to do that from you - I do sense a slight undertone of judgement - but he must have professional contacts from his previous role who would be willing to help. I do interview practice with old colleagues all the time - I know them well enough to know which questions they'll hate, so I force them to practice those. Really good success rate in getting them new jobs!

Gently suggest he taps up his network for more support. And if it's relevant to his line of work, his LinkedIn needs to be up-to-date, with a professional photo, and plenty of activity from him on it.

FinallyHere · 07/09/2022 10:41

DenholmElliot1 · 07/09/2022 10:22

Yes, suggest he gets a degree. What's the worst that can happen?

If it isn't the degree holding him back, then taking a pointless degree will cost him three years (min) wages gore gone , £9k a year fees plus living expenses

Seems pretty convincing to me

Fleur405 · 07/09/2022 10:38

Difficult to say without knowing the role but I expect his interview skills might be the issue.

LollingAround · 07/09/2022 10:35

Why don't you tell us the industry?

Are there any other additional qualifications or short professional courses he could do rather than a degree?

thesandwich · 07/09/2022 10:33

Does he use LinkedIn? Does he have a wide industry network?

TooHotToTangoToo · 07/09/2022 10:29

I doubt it's the lack of degree, I've never had an issue with getting senior roles, and I've only just got GCSE's. Those types of roles are far more interested in experience

motherofthelittlescreamingone · 07/09/2022 10:27

He should take a lower paid job - better to be in work, can always keep looking!

SatinHeart · 07/09/2022 10:26

Agree with pp saying that if the degree was a barrier they would screen him out before the interview stage.

Doing a degree now would just put him in debt and also out of his industry for 3 years, making his experience less current.

If you can possibly afford it, he should probably accept a pay cut to get back into the workforce if one gets offered again.

AchatAVendre · 07/09/2022 10:23

SalviaOfficinalis · 07/09/2022 10:20

As others have said, if lack of a degree was the problem he wouldn’t be shortlisted for interview.

Maybe he needs to work on his interview skills? I wonder if there are any coaching/workshop type things… would be much cheaper than a degree.

Thats just not correct. He might be getting invited to interviews based on his experience on his cv but failing to impress because employers prefer candidates with degrees for a whole host of reasons. They are giving him a chance but not saying a degree isn't required simply by interviewing him. The jobs market can be really competitive at the moment, and not having a degree scores you lower than candidates with a degree. It depends far more heavily on what other candidates they have to choose from.

DenholmElliot1 · 07/09/2022 10:22

Yes, suggest he gets a degree. What's the worst that can happen?