Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the new health secretary should spend a day at an abortion clinic ?

132 replies

Goldencup · 07/09/2022 06:03

So apart from the fact that she is clearly clinically obese and smokes cigars ! Our new health secretary is also an anti abortionist, being a practicing Catholic. I was also raised as a Catholic to be believe abortion was wrong, but becoming a doctor and a mother has changed my mind 360 (or 180) on this. The pivitol moment for me was attending TOP lists as a medical student and talking to the women, realising that it is nearly always the least worst choice of a variety of pretty dire options. If this women (Coffe) is to stand in judgment on thousands of women than perhaps she should dip her toe into the reality. BTW I would also advocate a 12 hr shift on her feet on as an HCA on the dementia wards.

OP posts:
SavoirFlair · 07/09/2022 07:23

AuntieMarys · 07/09/2022 07:12

Shes like Ann Widdecombe. And that's not good

How is she comparable to Ann Widdicombe ….aside from being middle aged, shorter hair and technically overweight?

They are not at all comparable but this is where I think Mumsnet is absolutely hateful

Women who are middle aged and perhaps a little overweight become despised and invisible in public life - it’s like nothing they can say can be useful because they haven’t “sorted out” their hair and their appearance and weight.

As I said earlier in the thread, I’m a lifelong runner, fortunate to have this addiction in the sense few people judge me for being late forties , because I happen to be a 10 dress size. (Aside from the “have a biscuit love”) types in the office but that’s another post..

my point is, I’m not writing out of bitterness. I’m writing out of sheer frustration that of all the people appointed to cabinet yesterday , it’s the overweight middle aged woman that gets it.

I mean Suella Braverman’s personal affiliations need a quick check, but she’s thin so that’s ok.

loudlylikealion · 07/09/2022 07:20

Goldencup · 07/09/2022 07:17

It is part of one's declaration to the GMC that you will look after your own health. I would argue carrying the amount of weight she clearly is, isn't looking after your health. But she isn't a doctor and doesn't have to answer to the GMC.

It's not part of the selection criteria to be an MP though presumably, that's the point. It's who (some of) the country have chosen to represent them and then liz truss has given them extra jobs to do. If people thought she was good enough to be an MP and voted her in then that's all that matters. None of this discriminatory nonsense.

picklemewalnuts · 07/09/2022 07:20

Gosh what a lot to unpick.

Yes, she should have a better understanding of the pressures that lead to abortion.
Should vulnerable women have to educate her? Absolutely not.

Yes she should be a healthy weight. Does her obesity leave her ignorant of the health issues associated with obesity?
Absolutely not. Does it in fact make her hyper aware of them? Almost certainly.

SavoirFlair · 07/09/2022 07:19

Goldencup · 07/09/2022 07:17

It is part of one's declaration to the GMC that you will look after your own health. I would argue carrying the amount of weight she clearly is, isn't looking after your health. But she isn't a doctor and doesn't have to answer to the GMC.

It is part of one's declaration to the GMC that you will look after your own health

She is leading the health service, not the doctors body of practice

But she isn't a doctor and doesn't have to answer to the GMC.

you just corrected your own fallacy in the space of two sentences…? You do know you can edit before posting @Goldencup and this isn’t a stream-of-consciousness?

notdaddycool · 07/09/2022 07:18

I read her comment on abortion last night, it was something like “as a Catholic I’m against them, but I’m not going to stop anyone even if i wish they didn’t” this thread is bile for bile’s sake. I’ve also seen a lot of fat nurses and midwives, should they be banned from the NHS too?

loudlylikealion · 07/09/2022 07:17

So apart from the fact that she is clearly clinically obese and smokes cigars ! that's for her and her doctor.

Goldencup · 07/09/2022 07:17

Sarahconnor1 · 07/09/2022 07:12

This has nothing to do with her being female, I would say the same of a man. How can she really with a straight face talk about health promotion strategies?

So do you also think all doctors and nurses should be a healthy weight? They have to talk to the public face to face about issues surrounding obesity.

It is part of one's declaration to the GMC that you will look after your own health. I would argue carrying the amount of weight she clearly is, isn't looking after your health. But she isn't a doctor and doesn't have to answer to the GMC.

OP posts:
loudlylikealion · 07/09/2022 07:14

It might be an idea for her to visit one for a morning yes. I assume she would be doing lots of visiting places?

Goldencup · 07/09/2022 07:14

She has suggested a 12 week limit. Terminations after 12 weeks are usually the most needed and affect vulnerable women and girls disproportionately. There is a lot of speculation around abortion services presently as the telemedicine model introduced in the pandemic and largely welcomed by clients is being questioned. I am concerned that a significant tightening of access will affect women and girls in vulnerable situations and may lead to increased numbers of unintended pregnancies and births.

OP posts:
RoseAndRose · 07/09/2022 07:12

She's stated the law won't be changing.

I'm sure it'll be spotted if there is any sniff that she will change from her publicly stated position.

Sarahconnor1 · 07/09/2022 07:12

This has nothing to do with her being female, I would say the same of a man. How can she really with a straight face talk about health promotion strategies?

So do you also think all doctors and nurses should be a healthy weight? They have to talk to the public face to face about issues surrounding obesity.

AuntieMarys · 07/09/2022 07:12

Shes like Ann Widdecombe. And that's not good

Crocwok · 07/09/2022 07:11

Rinatinabina · 07/09/2022 07:02

I mean if you care about BMI as being a qualifying factor in being the health secretary rather than I don’t know actual ability to do the job we could ask Rees-Mogg to do it.

She is liz' best mate so allegedly had her pick of the jobs. Nothing to suggest she's particularly suited to the role specifically. Given that she votes against women's reproductive rights, equality for gay couples and always votes against benefit rises (even had a run in with Marcus Rashford) I'm curious in what abilities she seems to possess that make her better than someone randomly picked out from the cabinet. Her voting history doesn't seem to suggest she's bothered about people having access to healthcare despite their financial standing so rest in peace NHS.

Sunnysideup999 · 07/09/2022 07:10

I don’t care a jot about her size or how many cigar she smokes or what karaoke songs she likes to sing in her spare time - all I care about is whether she can sort out the mess that is healthcare in this country.

ThickCutSteakChips · 07/09/2022 07:09

She said only this year that she doesn't like abortions and wishes people didn't get them, but wouldn't condemn people that do. And that the law isn't going to change on abortion.

Which is perfectly acceptable stance really.

MintJulia · 07/09/2022 07:09

MissMaple82 · 07/09/2022 06:38

I find this woman to be utterly disgusting... in everyway!!!

This. She is fundamentally unfit to be health secretary in every way. Hopefully her tenure will be very short lived.

If this is Liz Truss's standard of common sense, we are all in for a miserable year or two.🙁

MoggyP · 07/09/2022 07:07

I don't see why there's a need

Abortion clinics are private sector concerns.

NHS TOP services take place within wider obs/gyn departments (in most of the country, I guess some places like London might be big enough to have some free-standing ones, even there it's not the main way)

Telling the new health secretary to spend time observing places for private provision of services seems an entire waste of time.

And would of course raise suspicions of a privatisation agenda

I think there are considerably more pressing issues that need to be tackled this autumn

(PS: I remember the lead public engagement official of the 1990 who used to accompany Virginia Bottomley around when she was Health Secretary - they were a heavy smoker. It's sometimes about the person in ways that outweigh, the habits and the appearances)

PermanentTemporary · 07/09/2022 07:05

When I read her personal MP page I was in fact a bit reassured, she sounded perfectly rational and at least seemed to be pro action on climate change.

It may be a shock to hear this but I encounter lots of obese people in the NHS - particularly on the wards of course given the effect of obesity on health, but also in the staff teams and including myself unfortunately. She may have a deeper understanding of health because she's bound to have had issues because of it, goodness knows I have.

Goldencup · 07/09/2022 07:04

animalprintfree · 07/09/2022 06:58

Can’t see why spending the day at an abortion clinic would change her views. It might even confirm them.

I think it is an uninformed opinion (I might be wrong) it is very easy to be theoretically opposed to something you have no personal experience of. Much harder to talk to real women and continue to hold those views. She has no experience of pregnancy or childbirth. As I said in my OP talking to the women seeking late term abortions was transformative for me.

OP posts:
SerenadeOfTheSchoolRun · 07/09/2022 07:03

*that might work

SerenadeOfTheSchoolRun · 07/09/2022 07:03

With regard to obesity - she will have probably spent a lot of time thinking about government policies what might work to tackle the obesity crisis and perhaps we will have some action on our obesogenic environment and less talk of ‘personal responsibility’ which has been a failing strategy for the last 40 years at least.

Rinatinabina · 07/09/2022 07:02

I mean if you care about BMI as being a qualifying factor in being the health secretary rather than I don’t know actual ability to do the job we could ask Rees-Mogg to do it.

Rinatinabina · 07/09/2022 07:00

I assumed she was hired to sort out the massive backlog in the NHS and avert a winter crisis not lead body pump. The NHS is a behemoth of an organisation that is going to require a lot of effort and brain power to improve. I saw so many comments about this in the times, trashing her for her appearance. I want the health secretary to be smart more than I want her to be a slim non smoker. It’s extraordinary to me anyone thinks this is a valid criticism of her. I don’t think I have ever looked at the health secretary and thought, thats my role model for fitness goals.

Her abortion stance is because she’s a practicing catholic (I think it’s awful personally) she’s apparently very much on the left of the party.

animalprintfree · 07/09/2022 06:58

Can’t see why spending the day at an abortion clinic would change her views. It might even confirm them.

Goldencup · 07/09/2022 06:53

This has nothing to do with her being female, I would say the same of a man. How can she really with a straight face talk about health promotion strategies?

Which health secretary was obese ?
The links between obesity, cancer and dementia has become clear in the last 10-15 yrs. Science is funny like that it makes progress and discovers new things.

What was acceptable in the 80's or 90's (casual sexism, heavy drinking, smoking in the work place) is hardly relevant in 2002.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread